Rules Are Rules: 7. Tiny Alice

Printer-friendly version

Alice asked, "How will you handle tomorrow? What are you going to do? How are you going to explain to everybody?"

They all looked at me, and I looked back at them. A slow smile came to my lips, and Alice said, "No! You're not! You... you can't! You're not going to pretend to be a girl, are you!?"

Rules Are Rules: A Marcie Donner Story, by Kaleigh Way

 
7. Tiny Alice

 

We followed Denise outside. She was across the street, talking to a girl who looked about my age. I froze for a moment, then quickly turned to go back in the house.

Aunt Jane frowned, puzzled, and stopped me by putting her hand on my arm. "What's wrong?"

"That girl!" I hissed. "I don't want her to see me!"

"What girl?" Jane's head swiveled, scanning the empty street. "Where? Someone you know?" Jane asked, puzzled.

"The girl Denise is talking to! I don't know her, but if she goes to my school, and she sees me, it's going to make it hard to change back to Mark."

Aunt Jane gave a small smile. "You've got it all wrong," she said. "That woman isn't your age. She's my age. That's Alice. She, Denise, and I went to high school together. We used to call her Tiny Alice because she was always the smallest girl in our class."

Jane glanced across the street. "You can see she hasn't grown any since then."

"She really went to school with you?" I asked, full of doubt. I was beginning to wonder whether I could believe a single word that my aunt said.

"Yes," Jane replied, surprised by my disbelief. "Why wouldn't she?"

"You might say that just to trick me, and get me stuck wearing a dress."

Aunt Jane scoffed and said, "No, I swear. And you're not going to be stuck wearing a dress. Alice is an old friend, and she needs some support right now. Come on, you'll like her. She's great."

As we crossed the street and got closer, I could see that Alice didn't exactly look like a girl. The way she dressed and acted was more adult, more like Denise.

But the thing that really struck me about her was how tired and sad she looked. Well... not sad exactly... but definitely not happy.

"Hi, Alice!" Aunt Jane called. "How are you holding up? How is Donny doing?"

Alice sighed and said, "I guess he's going to be all right. His doctor said it wasn't really a stroke. It was a transchemic something attack..."

"Transient Ischemic Attack," Jane offered. "It's like a mini-stroke. So his symptoms cleared up?"

"Yes," she said. "Pretty much. After a couple hours he kind of came to, and started talking and acting normally. Now he's worn out, and they want to keep him for a couple days to do some tests." She sighed again. "They said it was a warning sign."

"Will he be back at school?" I asked.

Alice gave me a kind of blank stare for a moment. "No, hon, I'm not going to let him. It's time for him to retire. Past time." She kept on looking at me, but there was no expression on her face. It was a little unnerving. She glanced back and forth between me and Jane, and said, "Who are you? Are you two related?"

"Yes," Jane said. "This is my niece, Marcie."

"I'm her nephew, Mark," I countered.

"Niece."

"Nephew."

"Stop," Denise said, gently but firmly. "Alice, we'll let you go. I guess you need to rest."

"No, no, don't go!" Alice cried. "Can't you come in the house with me? I don't want to be alone right now. It'll be too weird without Donny."

"All of us?" Denise asked.

"Yes," said Alice. "All of you! If you don't stay... if you don't come in, it'll just be me and my thoughts. I'll go crazy! Come on, I'll cook you dinner. Please?"

The three women went back and forth for a tiny while longer, but I tuned them out. Something else was happening, something more important... for me, anyway. I had a moment, an unusual, eye-opening moment, and it changed the course of the rest of my life.

As we stood there on that suburban street, the sun sank behind the houses. Everything — houses, cars, trees, people — took on a warm, liquid, golden glow. A soft wind unrolled itself and filled the street, its soft feathery fingers rustling my skirt and rippling its tiers and ruffles.

I'd been outside with bare legs plenty of times, but there was a world of difference between wearing shorts and wearing a skirt. A gentle wave of wind quietly slipped under and slid all the way up my legs, brushing my light cotton underwear, reminding me that every stitch and thread I wore said girl.

A thrill of gooseflesh rushed over my back and arms. Its electric tingle spread up my neck into my scalp.

I drew a deep, smiling breath and saw my little fake breasts rise, then fall.

In a strange and indescribable way I felt right and good. It was a new sensation for me. After a whole day of fighting and fearing what I was wearing, I suddenly relaxed, and when I relaxed, I saw that I belonged right there, that I was part and parcel of the whole scene, and something secret part inside of me said, Oh, God! It's good to be a girl! and then it said, I can do this. I want to do this. I want to be a girl!

And when that secret part of me said those things, the rest of me agreed.

I could have stood there longer, drinking in the magic of that transforming moment, but it ended abruptly when Aunt Jane shook my arm and called out, "Earth to Mark! Earth to Marcie! Come on, boy! Come on, girl! We're going to be with Alice. We can talk more inside."

The warm golden moment ended, but I knew what I'd felt and seen, and I knew what I wanted to do.

I followed the others. We trooped into Alice's house and sat down around her kitchen table.

I drank soda; the women drank white wine. Alice tied an apron around her waist, and got busy washing and chopping vegetables. She put water on to boil and poured some oil into a pan.

All of us offered to help, but she refused. "No," Alice said, "I need to be busy. What you can do is talk to me. Distract me. Tell me anything, everything." She looked me in the face, and said, "You — Tell me the niece/nephew story." Then she pointed at Jane and said, "You — Don't interrupt her."

Jane shrugged and sipped her wine.

I took a deep breath and began, "I might have been one of the last people to see Mr. Bruce before his stroke–"

Jane open her mouth to correct me, but Alice wagged her finger. "Go on," she said.

I told her the story of how I missed the first two days of school, and how I didn't have my gym suit. As I talked, her face betrayed a series of silent reactions. I didn't know what her reactions meant, but each time I paused, she said, "Go on."

When I got to the part where I was in the girls' gym class, Alice asked me to describe the outfit I had to wear. I had some trouble, so I ran across the street to Denise's house and pulled it out of my bag. Alice spread it on the table.

"Oh, my God. These ugly old things. I wonder where on earth he got them! No girl would ever be caught dead wearing one of these." She balled it up and shoved it into the kitchen trash.

"Donny is just insane about gym clothes," Alice went on. "He used to talk about it for hours. Literal hours. I asked him to stop, but I could see it was eating him up. I got tired of asking him to give up on it, to drop it. Once he got on it, he was like a runaway train."

"It's a big deal to him," I said.

She nodded. "I finally realized what it was. He felt that people looked down on him for being a gym teacher, and when the boys forgot their outfits he felt like they looked down on him too. He took it as an insult, like they didn't care, like it didn't matter." She paused. "Like he didn't matter." She looked at the floor and sighed.

I wasn't sure what to say.

After a moment, she collected herself and asked, "Okay: I understand how you ended up in gym class with the girls, but how on earth did you end up in those clothes you've got on? My husband didn't have anything to do with that, did he?"

"No," I said, and told her the rest of the story. Again, I carefully left Jerry out of it. A few times I had to pause because the three of them were laughing so much. Alice stopped me twice because her sides were hurting, and Denise jumped in at one point to paint a short, unflattering portrait of Mrs. Zeff, the woman who hauled me into the office.

"Okay. So that was today." Alice concluded. "How will you handle tomorrow? What are you going to do? How are you going to explain to everybody?"

They all looked at me, and I looked back at them. A slow smile came to my lips, and Alice said, "No! You're not! You... you can't! You're not going to pretend to be a girl, are you!?"

I kept smiling and looking at the three women, but I didn't answer right away.

Denise gently told me, "Come on now, Mark. You know we were only teasing you before, don't you? No one ever wanted you to wear a dress."

"Unless you want to...," Jane prompted, chuckling to herself. But I knew she didn't mean it.

Jane was busy laughing, but Denise and Alice gaped in surprise, because they saw what I wanted. It was written all over my face.

"I want to try it," I said. "I want to try it to be a girl. If I can, I mean. If that's okay."

© 2006, 2007 by Kaleigh Way

up
247 users have voted.
If you liked this post, you can leave a comment and/or a kudos! Click the "Thumbs Up!" button above to leave a Kudos

Comments

Trying isn't allowed

Does Mark realize there is no trying, that if he starts attending school as a girl he will have to do it convincingly for the entire 6 months? He can't start as Marcie and then decide a couple of weeks later to go back to being a boy. There is now no one at the school who saw Mark, but to be a girl he is going to have to satisfy the toughest critics in the world - teenage girls. As the new girl in school Marcie will be examined with a magnifying lens by the other girls, checking out the competition. Any flaw will be spotted and discussed at length. It's total immersion with a vengeance.

Teen girls are so judgmental. I read years ago in a Rolling Stone Magazine interview that Winona Ryder was harassed in high school because she was seen by her peers as an effeminate boy claiming to be a girl. It's a tough crowd.

Karen J.

"Being a girl is wonderful and to torture someone into that would be like the exact opposite of what it's like. I don’t know how anyone could act that way."

College Girl - poetheather


"Life is not measured by the breaths you take, but by the moments that take your breath away.”
George Carlin

Tsk

Don't be so serious! =)

This is supposed to be all fun - reality has no business butting in.

I for one love this story so far. It's so wonderfully crazy! (makes me feel right at home) XD

Edit:
Also, saying that he'd "like to try to be a girl, if that's okay" might just be a girly way to word it, (instead of saying "i'll be a girl, give me the dress!"), so there! *sticking out tongue* - just kidding! sorry! XD

Uh-h-h

You don't get it, do you?

KJT

"Being a girl is wonderful and to torture someone into that would be like the exact opposite of what it's like. I don’t know how anyone could act that way."

College Girl - poetheather


"Life is not measured by the breaths you take, but by the moments that take your breath away.”
George Carlin

Is there really any point to

Is there really any point to arguing about this? Besides, the story is already fully written, for better or for worse. Might as well just suspend your disbelief and go along for the ride.

Not arguing

Everbody seems a bit dense this morning. What I'm saying is that "Marcie" is going to have to be all girl, all the time, in order to avoid discovery. If that doesn't lend itself to a comedy of "oopsies" I don't know what would! Fake breasts, fake periods, fake (?) boyfriend, she is going to have to out-girl the girls!

How about a pierced navel? Or tongue? Multiple-pierced ears, lash extensions, nails, the list of possibilities goes on and on! What if Marcie's new girl friends all decide they should get a tattoo, and decide on a butterfly or a rose on the ankle or shoulder? Is there a fall formal dance at the school? And don't forget about Homecoming!

Some testosterone blockers to keep Mark's secondary male characteristics from developing too much? This could be a slippery slope Marcie is standing at the top of.

Karen J.

PS: And just because the story is already written doesn't mean that Kaleigh can't change something. Should one of us pitch an idea she likes, she can always rewrite the unpublished chapters and use it if she wants.

"Being a girl is wonderful and to torture someone into that would be like the exact opposite of what it's like. I don’t know how anyone could act that way."

College Girl - poetheather


"Life is not measured by the breaths you take, but by the moments that take your breath away.”
George Carlin

Right and right! Besides,

Right and right! Besides, if nobody could talk about it, what fun would it be?

And just fyi -- I have no qualms about changing things. Anything.

being girl

a boy trying to out girl the girls lol. sounds pretty awesome.

Re: Being Girl

Think of it this way: in a situation where there are two actions, one being essentially female and one essentially male, a GG might be comfortable enough with her perceived sex to do the essentially male action. Marcie, on the other hand, needs to always appear female so her secret isn't discovered. Take Halloween, for instance. A GG might wear a pirate costume with fake beard and mustache. Marcie would have to choose the princess costume with ball gown and tiara. Think of all the fun "she" would have negotiating bathroom stalls or getting in and out of a car in a full skirt with layers of petticoats.

Oopsie!

Karen J.

"Being a girl is wonderful and to torture someone into that would be like the exact opposite of what it's like. I don’t know how anyone could act that way."

College Girl - poetheather


"Life is not measured by the breaths you take, but by the moments that take your breath away.”
George Carlin

being girl

karen i dont think he can realistically. eventually and likely withen the week the girls wold notice something isnt right. he couldnt pretend he is a girl convincingly with no prior experience being a girl.
of course he could get friends to help him learn.

Hello?!

Fiction, right?


"Life is not measured by the breaths you take, but by the moments that take your breath away.”
George Carlin

I suppose you're right...

I suppose you're right... but I've read so many TG stories in which a boy dresses like a girl AND THEN

- he looks in the mirror and sees a girl looking at him
- putting on makeup comes naturally
- he learns how to walk and sit like a girl in five minutes
- he goes to school and all the girls accept him
- all the boys say "I always knew she was a girl. What was up with the baggy clothes?"
- he is not only a pretty girl, but the prettiest girl, and all the other girls are happy for her
- even the boys who *know* he's really a guy fall for him

Now, I don't think that kind of stuff could be written over and over if there wasn't some real-life experience behind it.

Also, on TV sitcoms, even a big burly guy can put on a an old granny dress and be instantly accepted as a girl by everyone.

I hope you're not going to tell me that those things aren't true!

But seriously, my idea was simply that Mark would keep a low profile, and people would take him for a girl since he dressed like one.

You'll see how it works out. (Maybe it doesn't!)

coool

well its fiction. we could always say he is a transgendered and being a girl comes naturally.
or the school has very nice people in it.

Well...

The thing is, people always reinterpret their memories, what they "know", in light of what they're currently experiencing. So I'd say it isn't so much that people would have always thought of the person as a girl, but since most guys don't run around wearing girl's clothes, other people would reinterpret their memories to justify the contradiction in their own minds.

Though, most TG stories are not what you would call "grounded in reality". But then again, what story is? Unless it's some kind of biography or a history tale, there's going to be fictional elements which either couldn't happen or would be unlikely to ever happen. The best stories mix the two up so that the reader can't tell.

You should be a character in

You should be a character in the story! Somebody does make this point to him... I think it's in the next chapter.

Would be an honor

Maybe next time, eh? :)

KJT

"Being a girl is wonderful and to torture someone into that would be like the exact opposite of what it's like. I don’t know how anyone could act that way."

College Girl - poetheather


"Life is not measured by the breaths you take, but by the moments that take your breath away.”
George Carlin

Rules

Karen is right, if it truly was based on reality. Yes there is no trying. there is only DO and if it gets tough, he can't stop.

I just wonder what he is going to tell his parents? "Hi Mom and Dad, I just wanted to tell you I have decided to go to school as a girl and live like one. My name is Marcie. I have made many girlfriends already. Oh and mom, I already have a boyfriend. He's cute."

The Doctor that Jane eluded too, may play an important job too. Mark may be taking feminising drugs soon, maybe unknown to him, since Jane is a nurse and can watch over him. It seems Jane knows something of Mark, that maybe he is a TS at heart and his mother knows and sort of set him up with Jane for that reason. Does his mother know that she really has a daughter in a male body?

I love the story, even though the drip feed is slow. I just hope the needle doesn't get clogged up, because of it's slow feed. You know how plateletts are when they sit to long in one place, they tend to congeil and sort of clog up everything, so you don't bleed to death. I just hope nothing happens to you Kaliegh, I would hate not seeing 'the rest of the story' as Paul Harvey would say, if something ever happened to you. Please make sure somone has the rest of the story to put up in case you couldn't. Just a bit of insurance is all. Whispering to you, I could be that person? Laughing and giggling at you. Pick me! Pick me!

Oh well, hugs anyway dear, good job really. I am definately enjoying the story.

Hugs
Joni w

Thanks for worrying about my

Thanks for worrying about my health!

He doesn't *tell* his parents. They find out. Remember, they are off in New Jersey, while Mark's in California.

Oh, and I promise: if it

Oh, and I promise: if it ever looks like I'm going to be hit by a bus, I'll dump the whole story in here first.

hit by a bus

ROTFLMAO!!!!!!!!!!

Good one Kaliegh. The telling of the parents is done by phone in my version I thought it was funny.

Yet you say they do find out. Hmmm is this a conspiracy? Interesting. This may not be so serendipitous as it may appear? Seems some thought was brought to bear after all.

OK! Where's the next chapter?

Hmmmm whole story at once? Where's that bus?

JUST KIDDING GEEES!!!!!!!! Can't a girl have any fun?

Giggles and hugs
Joni W

cool

i like it. so he willingly chooses to try to be agirl. that sounds risky but fun.

I noticed it was ...

Jezzi Stewart's picture

... Denise, not Jane, that said attending as a girl was a joke. Having him willing from the beginning sort of takes the suspense out of it. I wonder what Jane would have done had he said he didn't want to - particularly if this is a conspiracy. I doubt with Jerry as a BF Marci will be able to keep a low profile.

"All the world really is a stage, darlings, so strut your stuff, have fun, and give the public a good show!" Miss Jezzi Belle at the end of each show

BE a lady!

Jane never meant for him to

Jane never meant for him to go to school as a girl. Neither did Denise.

In their minds, it was impossible, and that's why they felt so free to tease him.

Very nice

This read is an excellent ride :D

Oh, Wow!

Nice segue from "Not Gonna Do It!" to "Wanna Try It for a While!"

Yours from the Great White North,

Jenny Grier (Mrs.)

x

Yours from the Great White North,

Jenny Grier (Mrs.)

"Transforming moment"

I hate to say this, but I just don't see this as being a real possibility at all. Up to this sudden "moment", Mark was trying constantly to get out of having to follow the female dress code, then out of nowhere, he gets this "eureka moment" and wants to do it.

It makes no sense at all, there is no history anywhere of Mark being a CD, TG or TS. If he had even a little history of anything like that, it would be quite plausible, but with none, it just feels like a way to get him to go along with it all, i.e., a forced capitulation.

I'll continue reading, but the story completely breaks the suspension of disbelief, turning it to a fantasy at best.

This falls in to the over used TG plot cliche of:

Hypatia Littlewings's picture

"Any boy who tries being a girl no mater how it happens will want to be a girl, because of course being a girl is better"(or some variation there of). Is it remotely possible a random boy might feel that way? I'd say, Maybe. Is it likely? I'd say, No. Is it just another interesting twist in an absurd fun story of train wreck of wild coincidences? It could be! It is fun read!

*grins*
~Hypatia >i< ..:::

Hmmm.

Emma Anne Tate's picture

Actually, the moment worked for me. I don’t think it’s a case of “put any boy in a skirt and he’ll want to be a girl.” But this character? The one who enjoyed being escorted to the principal’s office by a nice boy — until he was noticed and freaked out? Who enjoyed playing field hockey with the girls and found it fun and unstressful, except when he thought to remember his predicament? Who couldn’t bring himself to tell either the female gym teacher, the Queen of Hearts, the Principal, or even a secretary that he was a boy? Who meekly put on a padded bra and a dress? Who agreed to a kind-sorta double date?

This didn’t come out of the blue. He didn’t hate being a boy, so being a girl never occurred to him. But when he dipped a toe in the water, he had a “eureka” moment that isn’t wildly out of character for the person the author described.

And not for nothin’ — the moment was magic. Thanks, Kayleigh.

Emma

the key in the lock

when you realize you just feel RIGHT being a girl ...

DogSig.png