I wrote another story. Its fantasy with magic and transformations. Its still on the front page. Probably won't be by the end of the day with how quickly stories get pushed off it these days. I'm looking for engagement because honestly, I'm tired of writing the same story over and over again. Authors can write different things you know. It doesn't have to be all the same shit over and over again *sighs*.
Maybe I should find someplace else to publish my stuff.
https://bigclosetr.us/topshelf/fiction/106362/scouts-guide-a...
Comments
I think you stated two parts (there are more) ...
of the problem "why are people not reading my stuff?"
"It's still on the front page" ... It's the shear number of stories here. Some authors seem to do a story a day (Angharad's "Bike" was one a day, but now is one a week),
Other authors are announcing Publication (e.g. on Amazon) of their stories, and some sales are 'feeding the Closet'. So prolific authors and Publication Announcements are making the Front Page scroll fast.
---
Everyone here has limited time to read, and different interests. I have scores of BCTS story tabs open; all for reading "someday". (I'm almost looking forward to a browser crash that loses all my tabs. Almost.)
Some stories are simply "not for me". For my own mental health, I need to take the Cautions and Warnings seriously. Stories tagged severe abuse, r-pe, suicide ... or if these show up in a story ,,, I'm out. And some things, like "boy ends up in girl band", or main character gets bullied in high school - I've seen too many already ... Or the Whateley stories, where the school has roughly equal good and evil students with Powers ... I just can't engage the with this premise.
===
On the whole, the above are "good things" - active authors, lots going on, I, and other readers, can avoid some amount of "getting bummed out" ...
---
"I'm tired of writing the same story over and over again." ... Well, this site is overwhelmingly MtF stories. So the problem of every such story is "how to get the boy into a dress".
I chose to ago against this with two of my very few stories I have here. Both are FtM. In https://bigclosetr.us/topshelf/fiction/101208/new-years-revo..., the main character is having nightmare-level stress telling their parents they are a boy, and https://bigclosetr.us/topshelf/fiction/97657/creepy-mansion wherein the Mad Scientist's daughter isn't.
-
This "same stuff" might be an "author problem", more than it is a reader problem.
Writing prompts are never-ending: Current events, tabloid headlines, the YouTube rabbit hole, somebody else's story, last night's dream(s) ... Add, as you have done, magic and fantasy =and your imagination=, and you have a story. Oh, and some authors here write non TG stuff (just label it). Example: my https://bigclosetr.us/topshelf/fiction/99037/bugs-my-garden
---
Now, it seems I have a story by Enemyoffun on the top of my to-read pile.
---
"how to get the boy into a dress"
Sorry to disagree with you. TBH, there are far too many stories like this on this (and other sites). They have been done to death many times over.
How many more "Prom, Cheerleader" stories do we have to suffer? Yes, suffer.
I try to be different in my writing. I hardly ever write about teenagers so that whole thing of getting a boy into a dress is irrelevant.
My last two stories (on my blog) have dealt with fame and social media and how two people escaped from that mire.
There are lots of mtf related topics that don't involve High School, Jocks, Proms and all that [redacted]. I hated my time at school beck in the 1960's. I have written a couple of stories about that time in my life and that is more than enough.
Widen your horizon. It will bring a lot of benefits believe me.
Samantha
{I only signed in so that I could respond to this post}
Account for the tide.
Dear EOF,
When I saw the last line of your post, I will confess I was surprised. I was under the distinct impression you were a very successful author here. Scratching my head a bit, I went and looked at the numbers on your recent stories and confirmed my intuition. Second Star to the Right, for example, has been up for less than a month, and has 2,882 hits, 204 kudos, and 16 non-author comments, several of which were pretty meaty. Those numbers don’t just look fine, they look good.
I guessed at that point that you had been posting here for a bit, so I nosed around and confirmed that this is so (Congratulations, by the way!!!). One of your first stories, The Kill Shot, has 10,723 hits, 277 kudos, and maybe 14 non-author comments for Chapter 1— but it’s been on the site 15 years. Mosts hits, kudos and comments come early, but some few do keep rolling in.
What I’ve found, though, is that authors were getting fantastic numbers around 2018 or so. Maybe there were more readers, or fewer stories were being posted. But regardless, the numbers were great. Like the first chapter of A Starlight Summer — 6,771 hits, 462 kudos, and 23 non-author comments.
I think authors who were active at that point must feel like their current stories aren’t being as well received. But you have to account for the tide, which in this case is the number of readers and the number of stories being posted. By more recent metrics, your stories remain among the most popular here. Hopefully that helps.
We all get discouraged, but this community and all of the authors here can lift each other up. We can read each other’s stories and provide the kind of feedback we all enjoy. You have great fans here and a community that loves your work. I have no doubt they will give any endeavors of yours a shot, even if your muse leads you in new directions.
— Emma
Frustration or discouragement
There are several possible reasons for stories getting fewer displays (a.k.a. reads). I will try to list some of them in no particular order.
I know that some authors post their weekly story chapters all on the same day, but they limit it to two of their three or four ongoing stories. This is what Su Shi and Amethyst are doing.
With a trice weekly posting of one story at a time, she could have reduced the overfilling of the new stories list on the front page, Thus allowing more authors to keep stories on the front page for longer. She would also have been able to give her readers more time to enjoy her stories. Now that all her finished stories are posted she is fading from readers memories, and it is unlikely that new readers/visitors will find her stories very easily.
Basically the relevant CSS code would be:
a:link { color: LinkText } /* unvisited links */
a:visited { color: VisitedText } /* visited links */
a:hover { color: yellow } /* user hovers */
a:active { color: lime } /* active links */
I was using the visual differentiation of unvisited from visited links as a reminder of authors I wanted to follow. As well as help me identify which chapter of a story I still need to read. I can still access those features, but only when I turn off the use of the site style-sheet by going to
View → Page Style → No Style
(in Firefox).This works for me:
This: I was using the visual differentiation of unvisited from visited links
Works for me. I don't know why it doesn't work for you.
Hugs,
Erin
= Give everyone the benefit of the doubt because certainty is a fragile thing that can be shattered by one overlooked fact.
visual differentiation of unvisited from visited links
I'm using Firefox 137.0.2 (64-bit) and I see no difference between visited and unvisited links. With multiple chapter stories, I have to use other clues to see if I've already read that chapter: is the number of comments greater than the number of unread comments, or opening the story. going to the end, and seeing if I gave it a kudo. This was not a problem before the system crash a while back.
I'm using Firefox Release April 15, 2025 Version 137.0.2,
I see no visual difference in visited and unvisited links. I have since the attack that took us off line for a while.
Hugs
Patricia
Happiness is being all dressed up and HAVING some place to go.
Semper in femineo gerunt
Ich bin ein femininer Mann
Doesn't Work...
...for me either. (MacBook v10.13, browser is Firefox 115.22 or Safari 13.1) The current chapter gets differentiated in the side listing while I'm reading it (which of course isn't of any use, except to indicate that the color function still exists). But it doesn't carry over even when I bring up the previous or next chapter of the story from there, or go to any other page.
I have to work around it the same ways already mentioned: look for additional comments, or a submission date later than my previous visit. Doesn't always work, of course.
Eric
CSS color for links
I just cleared my cache and then reloaded the website several times with no change in display.
When I disable the Page Style via the menu, it affects only the current tab that was active when I selected that menu option. But that also looses the page layout in header, multi-column and footer.
I can also configure Firefox in the Preferences to Always override the website color selections. But that also affects each and every website in any window or tab. Though the text layout on BCTS is preserved. Only all the organizing color blocks are gone.
I have also used the the “Web Developer Tools” of Firefox to inspect how the display of the HTML/CSS code is resolved. For some reason the CSS from BigCloset specifies the exact same color for both :link and :visited. Maybe there is an issue with the order of the selectors :link, :visited, :hover and :active in that specific order.
I am aware that it can be extremely frustrating when computer code works except one or two edge cases. So maybe we should better take this specific issue out of the public forum to try and resolve it via private messages.
I am using Firefox 128.9 as of the current update cycle.
Should NOW be 2 shades darker
I just adjusted the CSS for the site, and flushed the caches. The A:Visited and A:Active are now 2 shades darker than before.
Love Y'all
-Piper