Author:
Caution:
Blog About:
Because sometimes your brain won't let you sleep, and instead insists on another round of beating the dead horse that is your shitty emotional state.
What does your trans-ness mean to you?
For all of us, it seems to be something different. For some it's about freedom, from societal expectations or toxic masculinity. For some it's about expression. For others, it's something as simple as a fetish, or as complete as a feeling of cosmic wrongness needing made right.
For me, my trans-ness is about despair.
I know that probably sounds harsh, coming from someone who so often tries to be positive, tries to write positive, tries to go for the happy and the romantic and the supportive and the optimistic... but it is. It's that cosmic wrongness level of mis-match, combined with the utter hopelessness of knowing that nothing you can ever do can truly fix you... merely alleviate the side effects of the core problem.
I'm not simply a woman. To be a woman is an expression of a great many wonderful things, and is in and of itself a respectable goal. But that is only one small part of what my identity is.
In my heart I'm more than 'just' a girl or woman. In my heart, I am *female,* in an innate and difficult to define way that is nevertheless immutably core to my very being.
And therein lies my despair. Not just the discomfort or even pain of a failure to fit in. Not just the stress of being constrained to societal expectations that feel foreign to you. No. The absolute, utter despair inherent in absolute barren-ness, to such a degree it is impossible to ignore.
Not only am I barren, but my body mocks me in its barrenness: with every step, with every waking moment I am forced to experience the un-ignorable truth of it, the disgusting atrocity that is what my body has instead chosen to grow. Not a penis, for those are fine things, and I have no issue with them. No, what I have is a grotesque, cancerous malformation, a mockery of anything and everything core to my being. A clear and spiteful indication of how my own flesh wants to poison me and deny me all the things that, in my heart, I cannot help but hold so dear.
It's the despair of the mother who loses her child before she ever gets to know them. The despair of the girl whose first period never comes. It drains me, and drives me to depression and fugues I fight to pull myself out of.
Is it any wonder that some days it seems it takes all the effort I can muster just to make myself keep breathing? Is it any wonder that, for all I want to do more, to strive for more, I can barely find the energy to care for myself on the most basic of levels?
I try not to beg. Try not to plea. I try not to burden others with the weight of my pain... but the older I grow, the harder and harder it is to continue to bear the burden at all.
The old wisdom is that when you want something you simply have to pull yourself up by your own bootstraps to get it. But I have no bootstraps to pull: my feet are filthy, bloody, and as bare as my phantom womb, that aches for the children I can never have.
I'm trying, so hard it feels, to get myself to a point where I can, if not heal the wound at the root of my pain, then at least alleviate the symptoms of it. But every step takes so much effort, the mud of life sticking to me and dragging me under even as I desperately claw my way to the surface.
And, like with the pain, every year it feels like my goals draw not closer, but ever further away from me.
I don't know what to do. I don't know where to go, or even how to get there. Everything takes so much time, so much energy, so much money... and it feels like I have none of any of those things to leverage.
And, today at least, I lack even the escape of dreams, where I simply am, in my truest form, to help cope with it all.
Melanie E.
Comments
Deep Breaths...
Inner life versus outer life. We all live in between. Not just those of us unhappy with our bodies, one way or another, but everyone I've ever met.
Anxiety and depression are the result when we fail to simply be. We can wait to be happy, or be happy in being. We can care more about what others think of us or what we think of ourselves. Breathe deeply, look around, go for a walk in the sunshine now and again. Just be.
I'm not very good at this, either. I've cycled through talk therapists, various drug therapies. It all helped/helps. At some point, though, nothing helps more than accepting our lot in life and making peace with it. I manage now and again. Not well, but almost enough. The self-exploration continues, and I daily find more coherence. Male versus female doesn't need to be a stark dichotomy. And clothing and appearance don't either. Look for moments of peace, and dwell in those.
Now, please excuse me while I try to take my own advice....
I can only know how I feel. I
I can only know how I feel. I wanted to be female from about 4-5 years old. I just grew to accept I am what I am, until I saw what was possible. Then I ran through all the possible scenarios with me coming out. None looked good. So I knuckled down and tried the best to "be a man". I made a good go of it.
To cope I have crossdressed (whatever that really is?) Now I'm happy to dress when I can. A few weeks back I visited another crossdresser , we just dressed and chatted. I was wonderful , not an erect thing in the place. Just friendly chat, acceptance and advice. Things like this keep me going .I dip in when I can. The ladies on here seem really helpful and supportive.
I never had the hate of my body like you though. Sometimes , depending on circumstance, it's best to choose the lesser painful of two evils. Sometimes getting what you want can be more painful than wanting it.
I just hope you find a way to cope. Talk helps.
xx
Leeanna
From an optimist
Firstly Melanie, let me compliment you on how well you have written down your feelings here. You make me feel them. You are a talent that needs to continue to contribute here.
But I cannot help much with empathy because I am not a depressive person. That does not mean that I have not wept buckets about my dysphoria, it just means that I get on with it.
I knew a girl once who had a port wine stain over half of her face. She was an example of how to take on the world with a smile despite the stares and the pity, and I never get that.
I also stayed up and watched some of the Paralympics this year, and saw the joy on the faces of the disfigured and handicapped. People are worse off. We have a deformity. We must learn to cope.
But I understand what depression is. Even the rich and beautiful may suffer. "Snap out it" is not the answer.
Just remember that you are not alone.
BTW I love my phantom womb. Actually it is all of have. When I feel that in tweak of pain I smile in the knowledge that I am a woman on the inside. I am just different from other women, but that does not have to be bad.
Wishing you well
Maryanne
If You Could. . .
If you could be ____________ but had to give up your _________ would you do it?
I don't know anyone who is totally satisfied with themselves. In the United States in 2019 $6.5 Billion dollars were spent on cosmetic surgery. $33 Billion was spent on weight loss products.
Think of all demeaning names for tall people and short people. We all are wrong. . .in some way.
We're dumped on every day by Madison Avenue/Hollywood phony perfection.
Gender dysphoria takes wishful thinking to another level. It's far from me to suggest that pining away for femininity is silly . . . having done it for eight decades.
I just think that spending time thinking of others is a healthy recipe for feeling better about yourself.
There are millions of people who crave your artistic talent.
There are millions of people who wish they were as nice as you. I'm one of them.
Your depression is real. I wish I could wave a wand and help you find a way toward happiness. All I can do is send a hug and tell you again how immensely terrific you are.
About forty years ago I had just started a business and had three female partners. We struggled for months and then suddenly hit it out of the park. I came in one morning to find a string of plastic ants leading up to a rubber tree plant in my office.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJVewWbeBiY
Jill
Angela Rasch (Jill M I)
all I got is huggles
but you can take as many as you want
Trans-ness
I can only speak for myself, but to me, trans-ness is just me being me. I've known I was a girl since (according to my mother) age 2... based on the fact that at that age I was already trying to wear my older sister's clothes. I don't remember back that far... I only remember back to age 3... but it makes sense to me. Clothes are the primary way in which we as human being identify gender... since we cover the 'obvious' signs. Most prepubescent children are androgynous at best... so the only way to tell who is a girl and who is a boy is hair and clothes... so we are acculturated to see them that way.
Since I (apparently) always knew I was a girl, I naturally gravitated to dress like one. I know I played like one... my sister confirms that much... and it matches what I remember. Once I was told I had to stop and be a 'boy', my dysphoria became almost unbearable.
I too know the depth of sorrow of the knowledge that I could never bear my own children... but I took the joy of being 'Mom' to my two boys. My 1st co-wife insisted that I never lie to our kids about who I am. I did have one advantage in learning to cope with it... my Great-aunt Viola.
I'll start by saying that my family is weird. On my grandmother's side, three sisters married three brothers... Great-aunt Viola married my Great-uncle Robert... and then my great-aunt Lorna married my great-uncle Kieth... and then my grandparents married. So my maternal grandmother and grandfather were already related by marriage when they married. At any rate, my Great-aunt Viola was barren, so she and uncle Robert never could have kids... so they 'adopted' all the kids of their sisters and brothers... being as much a parent to them as their own birth parents... and thus when they had kids, they all became their 'grandchildren'.
I never got a chance to meet my Great-uncle Robert... he died months before I was born... but I was named for him. Since this was in the 'dark ages' before sonograms, my parents didn't know if I was going to be a boy or girl before I was born, so they decided on a girl name for me if I had been physically female from birth... Roberta Maxine instead of Robert Maxell. This is where my name comes from. It also gave me a special connection to my Aunt Vie... so when I realized (at age 4) that I could never bear my own children, I took solace in the knowledge that just because I was 'barren' didn't make me any less of a woman... any more than Aunt Vie wasn't a woman just because she couldn't have kids of her own. Instead she ended up with over a dozen kids and grand-kids.
I know it sucks. I know it sometimes hurts so much just to think about it feels intolerable. Just know that you're not alone in it... that many wonderful women have been unable to be mothers for dozens of different reasons... that being barren doesn't make you any less a woman than it did me or my Aunt Vie... and take solace in that you cannot know why it had to be that way... other than the fact that if you hadn't been born that way, you wouldn't be here today to share your pain and sorrow and stories with others that suffer the same as you... and that your words words help us all.
Hugs,
Roberta