Where are the disabled characters in TG fiction?

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Taxonomy upgrade extras: 

I'm still fairly new to this site, so I should probably start with a bit of an introduction.

As my screen name (Ragtime Rachel) indicates, I'm a ragtime enthusiast. I'm quite enamored as well of the music of the Roaring Twenties and swing eras, and have dabbled a bit in composing ragtime on the computer. (I just wish I could play the piano worth a darn....)

I'm also a male-to-female pre-op transsexual who, incidentally, has cerebral palsy and uses a wheelchair.

It has always amazed me that I have never seen a protagonist in transgender fiction who is like me--a wheelchair user with a neurological disorder.

Is it because such a story proves too much of a challenge to most writers? (I mean no offense in saying this--I just imagine they might be skittish because they fear offending those with disabilities). It's been a daunting task even for me so far, or I would have written such a story myself.

Still, it's hard to get away from the thought that such a character would be intriguing--it would certainly put a unique spin on well-known conventions of the genre like the "mall scene": the moment when our young girl- or woman-to-be takes her first real plunge into the world of femininity, getting her hair and nails done, her ears pierced, and buying a female wardrobe to die for.

Just imagine such a scene with a character with physical challenges, and how differently it might play out. Take shoes--*please*!

For me, heels are *out* (though I do remember giving them the old college try once, clomping along on crutches. Not one of my best ideas.) So, really, are any shoes but high-tops, if I want to walk (I step right out of low shoes--my heel cords are so tight that when I did walk, I walked on my tiptoes).

Which brings to mind what could be a charming scene--say our heroine is nine, maybe ten, and wears leg braces with ugly, brown "Frankenstein shoes." (My personal horror at that age--and I grew up in an era of clunky metal leg braces). A sympathetic character who's somewhat artistic could make those shoes white, or pink, with a flower design painted on the toe.

Or the child/young girl could desire a truly pretty pair of shoes, which symbolize for her the femininity she feels within herself. She's told she could never wear them, never walk in them. They would provide an incentive for her to prove herself to the doubters.

Buttons and laces would likely have to be replaced with Velcro, unless our heroine has a sympathetic aide who would dress her. Tights and/or pantyhose could take forever for her to manage, depending on her level of mobility. And makeup? Oh, dear--that could easily reduce her to tears if her hands aren't steady.

Imagine her contending with an unsupportive parent, who seems to delight in rattling off these, and a host of other difficulties, as evidence that her decision to transition might be a mistake.

Not that it need be depressing. It could make that "Cinderella moment" all the more meaningful--when she sees herself in the mirror after her mall expedition, cute as a button or shockingly beautiful. Imagine she had been told all her life--or had convinced herself--that her disability made her ugly. Such a moment would bring a tear of joy to her eyes--and ours.

I suspect I shall have to leave such stories to someone else, however. It's all I can do to come up with a believable premise, let alone a plausible plotline and characters people care about.

Comments

your story reminds me of my first girlfriend's

she had CP, and had a curved spine they spent most of her teenage years fixing by having her in a back brace. To be TG on top of that, oh God that must be so hard...

I could try and write a story about a person like that, but I'm afraid it might end up being super depressing. Right now my own stories seem to head in that direction anyway ..

Huggles.

Dorothycolleen

DogSig.png

It can indeed be hard....

Ragtime Rachel's picture

I too had to endure a back brace, but I ended up with a rather badly curved spine anyway. (I hardly ever wore the plastic brace that was made for me, since it hurt and I had difficulty walking on crutches with it on). I have "kyphoscoliosis", meaning that my spine not only bends to the side (scoliosis) but forward (kyphosis). Talk about a clothing challenge--tops or dresses often have to be a couple of sizes too big, or they must be knit or some other stretchy material. Still, it's hard not to feel like a creature from a horror movie at times--it's especially disheartening for a male-to-female TG with my problems, because our culture so values physical beauty in women.

Yet my desire to live as female outweighed my concerns about my appearance, and am happier despite a body I find very difficult to look at in the mirror sometimes....

Rachel

Livin' A Ragtime Life,
aufder.jpg

Rachel

Welcome to BCTS Rachel.

One of my favourite TG authors (AJ James) wrote a wonferful story where the one of the changed characters was disabled. It wasn't cerebral palsy, but her walking difficulties were a central part of the plot. Here's a link:

http://www.fictionmania.tv/stories/readtextstory.html?storyI...

I'm pretty sure I've read a few other stories that include a handicapped character; I just can't think of them right now.

Hugs... Lora
.

I have a character

Raff01's picture

in some of my stories. She doesn't have CP, but she is stuck in a wheelchair. Major car accident put her in it. She's just a smaller character right now, but will be coming to the front of the story soon. Look for Through the years. She shows in the second book, Tracy emerging. Her name is Brooke. Plus there is a deaf girl in the story too, but Casey won't be as big

I'm definitely a fan of yours....

Ragtime Rachel's picture

Oh yes, I know about Brooke and Casey. I am an avid follower of your series (and am impatiently waiting for you to post the next installment, already...=) ). I find it commendable you include such characters as more than mere "window dressing." Even Tracy herself was disabled, albeit temporarily.

Perhaps at some point in the future you could have a disabled person as your "star", so to speak?

Livin' A (TG) Ragtime Life
May_Aufderheide.jpg

Livin' A Ragtime Life,
aufder.jpg

Rachel

Thank you RR!

ALISON

'Rachel,I am quite sure that an articulate young lady like yourself could write YOUR story and give
an understanding of the problems that you face.You are obviously a very brave young lady and it would be
lovely to read a first hand account of your situation.Out here in Australia we have a CP guy who does 'stand up' comedy and is an inspiration to lots of people,both whole or with an impairment! I would welcome your
story,so go for it,girl.Oh,and I also love Ragtime and Trad Jazz!

ALISON

I've tried to be inclusive....

Andrea Lena's picture

...I have a transwoman in my Three Girls serial, Terri, who is dealing with lupus. My protagonist in my story Serenity is an adult transwoman who is diagnosed with Asperger's Syndrome. I've featured characters who are amputees, contend with mental illness, are afflicted with life ending diseases and also some characters who cope with the illnesses of their significant others and family members. I have a featured a blind transwoman as well.

None of the 'afflictions' and 'handicaps' that I portray are meant to do anything other than reflect that life isn't always kind, and often can be more than challenging. I am grateful for your candor and transparency. Hopefully my work reflects some of the realism and believability that 'real life' brings to us. Thank you for your blog.


Dio vi benedica tutti
Con grande amore e di affetto
Andrea Lena

  

To be alive is to be vulnerable. Madeleine L'Engle
Love, Andrea Lena

My main characters...

Tend to either be a lot like me, or a lot like how I wish I could be.

I've never had any serious physical ailments - unless you count an unimaginably low progesterone level even for a guy causing horrid skin, hair, and fingernail health. Self-corrected now through Chasteberry, as part of my herbal concoction to feminize me until I can get on the good stuff.

I do, however, suffer serious ADHD, and, arguably, Asperghers. Both are mental disabilities of a sort, though very high functioning, Asperghers is considered part of the autism spectrum. And everyone knows about ADHD.

Personally, I don't think of them as disabilities, just a different way for our brains to be wired up.

Also, I have a sneaking suspicion that if I were to be re-diagnosed now that I've woke up from all my years of deep self-suppression, at least the Asperghers would no longer show, and the ADHD might not either.

I intend to actually blog about my thoughts relating to that at some point... though it's getting rather late for it tonight.

Abigail Drew.

Abigail Drew.

Being legally blind and TS,

Zoe Taylor's picture

Being legally blind and TS, I've often wondered what it would be like to be totally blind and TS. I already know what it's like not to have my family's support, and I can see one of the most common questions a character like that would be asked, "If you can't see why does it even matter what you wear?" :-P

It's something I've wanted to do as a possible oneshot since I started writing again a year and a half ago, but if I were to tackle such a project, I'd want to do it justice. Being legally blind isn't quite the same as being totally blind, but it's close enough in restrictiveness of lifestyle that I should be able to muddle my way through :-)

~* Queen of Sweetness *~

Visit the Robinverse Story Universe page on TopShelf for information, links, and stories!

~* Queen of Sweetness *~

Become a Patron for early access ♥

That reminds me...

I do have bad eyes. I see great up close, but more than an arm-span away and things start getting very blurry without some serious prescription lenses. I also have "inexplicably" high Intra-Occular-Pressure - precursor for developing glaucoma... so far none of my characters have had to deal with either problem in any stories I've ever written, anywhere, for any genre.

It's really not that debilitating, though, just need to wear eye glasses all the time and should be dropping travatan-z into my eyes every night (which I can't presently afford).

I'm also curious if, were I to go to an optometrist or optomologist now that I'm out and no longer carrying that heavy load deep inside myself, maybe my IOP may have gone down. My last optometrist told me flat out that it made no sense from anything else he could find about my eyes that my IOP be so high. But stress from the kind of depression-causing suppression I'd been doing to myself... that could have done it, I'd think.

I imagine if I ever do develop full glaucoma that might cause some lifestyle changes though...

Abigail Drew.

Abigail Drew.

I have full blown glaucoma,

I have full blown glaucoma, and it is a matter of using drops twice a day to keep it under control. More and more of the meds are showing up as generic, though one of the more frequently prescibed one, Alphagan, is not yet generic. So though it is a chronic disease, if treated it will only advance slowly if not actually arrest from the drugs. I inherited the condition from my mom and maternal aunt, or at least from their side of the family.

I also have type II diabetes, that may be from being on hrt. It began rather suddenly about 8 months after I started hrt, and I am not the only person with that possible stimulus. Again, it is a chronic disease, and can be controlled with medication, most of which are generic and not too expensive.

CaroL

CaroL

Special Ed by Wanda

erin's picture

Wanda's story about a developmentally disabled boy, Special Ed is here on the site: http://bigclosetr.us/topshelf/fiction/3713/transglimpses-15-...

Also, my current story, The Pregnant Boy has a father in a wheelchair.

Hugs,
Erin

= Give everyone the benefit of the doubt because certainty is a fragile thing that can be shattered by one overlooked fact.

= Give everyone the benefit of the doubt because certainty is a fragile thing that can be shattered by one overlooked fact.

Awww

Raff01's picture

I had forgotten about this story too. Now I get to cry.

It would be

an interesting story to write but require a lot of research.

Peaches

One of the main characters in Peaches is disabled. He isn;t the TG character, but it did add to the authenticity of the story.

I donated Peaches to Erin to sell to support this site.

Angela Rasch (Jill M I)

Angela Rasch (Jill M I)

I haven't read Peaches....

Andrea Lena's picture

...but I read Sky, and it's one of the best stories of our 'persuasion.' I thoroughly enjoyed it! Thanks


Dio vi benedica tutti
Con grande amore e di affetto
Andrea Lena

  

To be alive is to be vulnerable. Madeleine L'Engle
Love, Andrea Lena

To be honest I wouldn't know where to start with a character

To be honest I wouldn't know where to start with a character like that. Simply not good enough of a writer to even attempt to craft a story with a disabled tg lead.

The closet I have come was a very very rough outline (less then a page) about a kid that got into a big accident that left him with a spinal cord injury, making him into a quadriplegic. It would have been a scifi story, with the main character living mostly in a sort of Virtual reality as a form of escape/substitute from reality. Heavily borrowing concepts from 'Other land' and '.hack//sign' . Still think about the idea a bit, but always in the back of my mind is thought that it be damn hard for me to write it (just don't have the skill to do it justice). along with not really having a clear plot outline.

Disabled Stories

Its probably because we don't have many disabled authors who think people want others to hear about their difficult lives. Likes transgendereds in general... disabled people are misunderstood pigeon holed and marginalised.

Unlike transgendereds... disabled people can't pretend to be non-disabled.

You seem able to type quite well so I can only assume you could write a story explaining your journey and how you couldn't overcome the hurdles in your life to you had to build a life around them.

I for one might just read such a story.

Dayna.

Currently writing one

I'm in the process of writing a story with a slightly disabled character. Destiny, previously David, has her left leg amputated below the knee. This will effect the activities she can do. Even with a false leg, heels are out of the question. She will also have a preference for skirts due to them being easier to manage with the prosthetic limb.

The first reason for doing this is to make the character a bit different. The second is that this story is an Aunt Jane/Seasons fanfic, and I'm trying to mess with the usual forced fem format by removing the normal teaching methods of high heels and a book balanced on your head.

Not sure when this will get published yet. I have three stories on the go and I don't publish until they are complete. I've spent the last month dedicated to getting my terror contest entry written, so haven't been able to work on my other stories.

Disability

My current story, 'Too Little, Too Late?', features a number of people with autism spectrum disorder. 'Uniforms' and 'Ride on/Riding Home' feature people with massive PTSD and associated problems. 'Viewpoints/Another Point of View' feature main characters that are, respectively, mentally ill and in a wheelchair after losing a leg to a bomb, with all the baggage that results from such an event.

It would be too controversial.

WebDeb's picture

Mixing two ethnic subjects into one would cause an outcry within that "majority group." I do believe they go by the name of "Political Correctness." To write such a story would be an invitation to be attacked. Not the person with a so called disability but the transgendered person who would dare write such a story.

Remember, transgenderism is the last taboo of our modern day society. The only way to enlighten is to write the story you wish for with your own pen.

I for one as a transgendered person am too frightened to write a fictional story on the subject of which you propose.

Can I be so arrogant...

...as to suggest you read mine, at least 'Viewpoints', and then decide if you can or can't write?

Some of us ARE Disabled

I know a number of authors and readers that are disabled. Because I don't have permission I will not name names, except me. I have no more toes and am nearly on dialysis. BTW my mom indirectly died of MS.

shalimar

It should

Raff01's picture

This blog is what prompted her to write it and I'm looking at expanding on "The Impossible dream"

Just got to your blog

Pamreed's picture

I found my way here from your comment on Tracy's Story. Then I read through all the posts here. It made me so proud
to be a part of this community!!! All the people here are so wonderful!! Rachel, you are an inspiration!! I thought
It was bad what I have gone through, being an insulin dependant diabetic with part of my right foot being amputated.
At least I can still wear shoes, even heels. But they have to have backs on them!! I would love to have a get together
of all of us, so I could hug everyone!! My facebook is Pamela Reed and I live in Ohio. All of you are invited to be
my friends!!

Hugs,
Pamela