Womanhood

Printer-friendly version

I’ve had a superannuated cervix for eight and a bit decades now, and I consider myself to be a woman, whatever that is. I have, however, never defined myself as a woman as a result of having afore mentioned body part, nor indeed any other body parts that are ‘considered’ to be ‘female’. So why do I consider myself to be a woman when I have never had any idea what a maternal instinct, feeling or behaviour is about? Simple, because I do, it fits my hard wired mind set, and that is despite having an interest in machine tools, a rather well equipped workshop and never having been even close to being married nor pregnant, from choice I hasten to add. Allow me some pride please. I am a ‘straight’ who has only ever had sex with ‘men’, whatever those two terms mean, but again neither of those concepts make me a woman, nor do they preclude others of any other inclination(s) from being a woman.

Identity is a subject that has always fascinated me and it is complex for everyone. I’ve never understood why anyone cares how others perceive themselves to be, and I certainly don’t understand why they get upset about it to the point of becoming vitriolic. I don’t know what’s in the mind of any other, I can’t always work out what’s in my own mind, so if they identify as female I treat them as such. I suppose to me it’s a matter of good manners and respect. I admit I struggle with the plethora of pronouns available these days, but I do try to get it right. I invariably use she, her and hers with someone who self identifies as female even if ‘they’ prefer to use something else, but as I said I’ve had a cervix for eight and bit decades, so some allowance has to be made for a bit of ‘senior slippage’.

However, and there always is a however isn’t there, good manners and respect has to be a two way street. For me that means just as I am prepared to accept all on their own terms I expect them to accept me on mine. My thoughts are my own and no one, including, or perhaps especially, the ‘thought police’ has a right to tell me how I should think. Ultimately, should I choose not to engage with someone, or indeed a particular group of persons, that is my right. No one has the right to insist someone else listens to them. We all have the right to walk away. It’s no different from me deciding I don’t like the work of a particular author, or even a particular genre, and hence not reading their works. Personally I don’t like Jean Plaidy, though I do like Georgette Heyer, and I can’t stand Horror or Westerns, so I don’t read Plaidy, Horror or Westerns. I don’t, however, have a problem with persons who enjoy some or all of those and so presumably read them, although the moment they start to tell me about what they’ve read I close down and walk away. I just don’t wish to hear it.

As for politicians, all politicians everywhere, pontificating on identity issues, or indeed anything else, I don’t know who said this first, but it contains a lot of truth. ‘I could never bring myself to trust anyone who wants to make a living out of telling others how to live,’ maybe it was Robert A. Heinlein’s Lazarus Long? It sounds like it could be doesn’t it?

up
56 users have voted.
If you liked this post, you can leave a comment and/or a kudos! Click the "Thumbs Up!" button above to leave a Kudos

Comments

This is almost an essay

Angharad's picture

pretending to be a short story, I don't have any quibble with the content except possibly reading Georgette Heyer, I couldn't get on with her stuff and never tried Jean Plaidy. However, I would commend you to read it and draw your own conclusions. Thank you Eolwaen.

Angharad

Essay

As some will be aware, there is quite a bit of me in the piece, but it is not true to say it's autobiographical. I don't have a problem with the way you see the piece because I can't argue with you. Regarding the authoresses mentioned, I have a complete collection of Heyer's works, including her detective stories, and I have read them many, many times. I tried Plaidy several times over the years, a goodly selection of her works, and I never managed to finish any of them. Thank you, Angharad, for taking te time to comment.
Regards,
Eolwaen

Eolwaen

"I’ve never understood why

leeanna19's picture

"I’ve never understood why anyone cares how others perceive themselves to be," I have an interest, but any opinion should be kept to one' self.
The media is full of incidents that are made to "trigger" feminist's and women that normally wouldn't care.

cs7.jpg
Leeanna

Oh that is somewhat easy

Lee's picture

That is as humans that want to quantify everything into one category or Another. For example naming every species that we know to exist. But for People Like Us we don't fit nicely into any category that they care to define but been told what you can and can't do is the root of most conflicts and problems around the world. I hope this makes some sense to people.

I am a male lolita.
So what is lolita fashion http://lolita-tips.tumblr.com/faq

Womanhood.

Being a woman is an infinitely more complex and preoccupative circumstance than being a man; and I for one can understand why women get wounded when transgendered women claim that they are women. As a post operative transgender myself I think I am being more empathetic with 'biologic women' when I recognise the totality of their condition and the impact that their bodies have on their very existence.
Transgender women can rarely, (if ever) experience all of the impacts that female reproduction has upon women nor the inconveniences these impacts can have on a woman's life/existence in an unforgiving or unsympathetic 'mans world'.

The sphere of sex and reproduction is for a woman a major element of her very being and existence and those complex responsibilities are what make her a woman.

This is why, when a woman accepts a transgender woman into her female sphere and society, she is making a far greater concession to the transgender community than a man does when he rejects a transgender person of any gender. from joining or leaving the 'men's club.

Being a woman is a total existence, mentally, physically, sexually and reproductively. Biological men are hard put to understand that totality while transgendered people can only wish and strive to reach that goal.

I call myself transgendered out of respect and consideration for the woman's total condition/situation that I can never FULLY enter and if that woman shows me acceptance and consideration for my circumstance, I am grateful and will tell her so.

I await the day when British Passports have a third box where gender is demanded and I can write 'X' or perhaps more appropriately, 'T'. in that box.

Even the Americans are doing this now.

For me 'Tee' would be more accurate and honest and open than writing 'Eff'. I am transgendered and I live in a feminine mode.

What's wrong with being transgendered; and why should I have to try and disguise it?

bev_1.jpg

I agree. It's your body. You

leeanna19's picture

I agree. It's your body. You can do what you like with it. The reproduction thing to most women is huge. This is why it's so traumatic for women who are born with reproductive problems. If they don't have periods they often see themselves as not "real" women.

Many women see having a child as the "proof" of being a woman. It's what their bodies are designed for. Some men see fathering a child as proof of manhood, perhaps not to the same extent though.

I think that's why many women get upset with trans women trying to get involved with women reproductive issues and rights. It's probably not done with harmful intent, but they probably feel "what the hell do you know about it?"

It's hard for me to comment, I'm just a guy that likes to act and dress as a woman sometimes,

cs7.jpg
Leeanna

M/F/X/T

There is possibly a western country somewhere, but I can't remember which country, that several years ago removed gender markers from ID documents deeming the photograph to be sufficient, or maybe they were just discussing the idea and I remember what was in the media incorrectly. New Zealand perhaps? Does someone out there know? I know the Netherlands are planning on removing gender markers off National ID documents in the next five years sometime to avoid harassment, discrimination and violence . It seems like a reasonable proposal to me.
Regards,
Eolwaen

Eolwaen

gender block

Sara Hawke's picture

I can't wait until it is removed.
It does not matter who you are under the clothes period.
It only matters that you are wearing clothes and are not overly exposed.
One day peoples mental perceptions will be finally separated from biological reality.

Emotion, yet peace.
Ignorance, yet knowledge.
Passion, yet serenity.
Chaos, yet harmony.
Contemplation, yet duty
Death, yet the Force.
Light with dark, I remain Balanced.

Amen to that.

leeanna19's picture

Amen to that.

cs7.jpg
Leeanna