Our story begins where The Treasure of Eerie, Arizona leaves off. For Myra, going into town and impersonating her cousin Abigail amounts to a sink or swim proposition. Having to keep company with the likes of Molly O'Toole doesn't make a bad situation any better. While Myra's seeks to adjust to life from a new perspective, Aunt Irene is starting to gain a new perspective also. She introduces Myra to several Eerie residencts, and these include Clyde Ritter and Reverend Yingling. What could possibly go wrong?