Author:
Caution:
Blog About:
Had a friend who works at a store I shop at ask me if I watch RuPaul's Drag Race. She assumed that because I'm trans that of course I do.
I told her no. That I hated the show, that I would turn it to the worst Z-movie in the world before I'd watch it. She laughed and asked me why.
I know other transwomen have talked about RuPaul's tragic Transmisogyny, transphobia, disparaging remarks and more. I won't rehash that. I will also say that I loved the character of RuPaul many years ago. Here's an elegant woman who PASSES, 6' tall, in 6" heels looking FANTASTIC. I loved it. Then I heard from the Drag community that I'm not a woman.
That was a shock to say the least. One would think that a group (gay men, crossdressers, and performers) who is marginalized and made fun of would go out of their way to include others who were also marginalized for the very same reason, instead of going out of their way to hurt them. Especially when a transwoman was responsible for starting their Gay Pride and getting them most of the rights they now enjoy.
But it comes down to a few key things:
1. Hate does not belong in our community at all.
2. They are performance artists, and exaggerated.
3. They are purposefully doing all they can to look extreme.
4. They say they are celebrating femininity, but I know of no woman, cis or other, who wears screaming green neon eyeshadow up to their hairline and out to their ears.
5. At the end of the day, THEY are the man in the dress.
5a. They get to go home and untape themselves
5b. They get to take their tits off and put them in a box.
5c. They get to say all they want about me and my life.
6. I HAVE TO LIVE WITH THEIR DISPARAGING REMARKS ABOUT ME.
I am not a man in a dress. I live as a woman all the time. I have extra body parts that I don't want, would cut off if I could, will have cut off if I get the money, DESPERATELY want to have transplants from any transman who has body parts they don't want. I want all of being a woman. I don't care about the bathrooms, I want to get rid of feces and piss when I go in there, or to put my makeup on.
But because of what RuPaul, Dame Edna and many other drag actors have said over time, I'M the one who gets punched, I'M the one who has a woman scream "DID I COME INTO THE WRONG BATHROOM" when I'm doing my makeup, I'M the one who watches a woman walk backwards away from me while I do the makeup because I'm in the Lady's room. I get to have that happen. I get "Dude Looks Like a Lady" sung at me in bad a bad voice while I walk down the street (which has totally destroyed Lola and that song for me, I cannot enjoy them).
Yes, I am gay. I am a lesbian. I love women, my wife, and I have had bi leanings sometimes. But I'm not trying to peep on your wives or daughters, I'm in the fucking bathroom to piss.
At the end of the day, the Drag Performers on Drag Race are men pretending to be an exaggerated form of a woman, and they get to go back to being male and having male privilege. I lost all my privilege when I started this 7 years ago. I and ladies like me are at the BOTTOM of the empowerment chart.
RuPaul and others like him have sacrificed little, really, to disparage me.
There's a saying among men, "I'd give my left (or right) nut to have ________________." Meaning they would sacrifice something they love dearly to get what they want.
This is me. This is who I am. I am a woman, and I have LITERALLY tried to give BOTH nuts to be this.
RuPaul, the Drag Race, transmisogynists, transphobes and all those who can't see that, can suck my left tit.
Comments
Thanks for what you wrote.
While I do not *know* where I am on the gender and sex spectrum, since my non-cisgender exploration is infrequent and of short duration, I suspect with some degree of accuracy that I fit somewhere in the crossdresser area of the spectrum with the only thing I do regularly that is non-cisgender is choice of underwear.
The fears of being hurt or humiliated that I have are there no matter where I am or who I'm with because I was bullied in 7th to 12th grade (USA junior high (7th & 8th grades) and high school (9th to 12th grades)) as well as when I was obtaining my degree. The last was by far the worst because I had a roommate who either (a) thought nothing of allowing others in the rooom when neither he nor I were there, and/or (b) passively or actively permitted others to look at my stuff while he was and I wasn't there.
With my experiences, I have a foggy and dim idea of what you have been through; and hope that things are at least a little better than they used to be.
Sincerely,
KR
30 years ago
30 years ago I would have said exactly what you did. Short forays into feminine expression which led to me deciding, like you, that panties were my underwear of choice. Within a year of deciding that, I couldn't stand men's underwear. The years went by and my men's pajamas went by the wayside in favor of nightgowns. Along the way, I tried nylon versions of men's underwear and pajamas only to determine that it wasn't the fabric that attracted me, but that it was the fulfillment of my need to experience femininity in my life.
Somewhere about 25 years ago, I began to desire breasts on my chest. I fantasied about hiring homeless girls to go to the free clinic and get me birth control pills; I figured I'd need to triple up on them to get enough. Remember this was pre-internet I had no way to know what all was involved with HRT.
As I got older the forays into feminine expression became more frequent and I desired extended periods of dressing. It was about about 15 years ago that I started coming home from work and shedding my male garb and putting on some form of women's wear. It was about the same time that I began to get bold about venturing out. Going to my local grocery store en femme. I also started wearing a bra full time with A cup breast forms under my men's clothes and C cup under my feminine, even to church. I also began looking for women's clothes that were butch enough to pass as men's. Mostly shirts and jackets that had the buttons on the distaff side and slacks that had the fly going the same way. I expanded into some trousers that had side zip and finally those that had elastic waist and not even a faux fly. I included women's penny loafers and finally loafer style flats and most recently ankle boots.
I retired a year ago and have since forgone the A cup forms in favor of the C cup 24/7. I have even started wearing feminine style glasses everywhere. Just prior to retiring I went on HRT.
Now the only time I butch up my presentation is when my wife is out with me. The only reason I butch it up at all is in deference to her concerns about how other people perceive her.
Actually having SRS is not on my radar. I really doubt that I'll ever even consider it. My thought mirrors the of Lacy Leigh... "Why build a garage if you never intend to own a car?"
But yeah, I'm a woman... my HRT renders it nearly impossible to perform sexually with my wife, who is post menopausal and has no sex drive anyway. Therefore the possibility that a woman has anything to be concerned about me in the rest room is nil. While I love my wife and still enjoy a nightly cuddle with her, other women are noticed only as a comparison to how good I look.
Hugs
Patricia
Happiness is being all dressed up and HAVING some place to go.
Semper in femineo gerunt
Ich bin eine Mann
Can’t argue with that
The gay community does not really ‘get’ trans.
At their core they are guys.
I don’t care how perfect ones’ presentation is, haters will try to find something to pick on you.
I see the comments on Carmen Carrerra’s youtube stuff and even for her, people find something to pick on her, merely to be mean.
For goodness sakes, she puts most women to shame and people are probably uncomfortable with being attracted to her, or it is the usual green eyed monster rearing its head.
I prefer to be anonymous as much as possible for good reason.
would love to give my right nut
but left it on a barb wire fence when i was eleven
polite horse let me go first
ed
ed
OUCH
Just ... ouch. My sympathies to your eleven year old self.
- Leona
Well Said
I can't watch that show for the same reasons, not a proper portrayal of the trans community 100% the wrong picture and does more hurt because homophobic people think that is real. Trans woman want to blend in not stand out like those clowns.