Plagiarism

A word from our sponsor:

The Breast Form Store Little Imperfections Big Rewards Sale Banner Ad (Save up to 50% off)
Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

I was informed today by Cat Lochley that I have been Plagiarized by Mia Perry who is selling one of my stories on Amazon.UK. Don't buy the book Cross-dresser by Mia Perry. It is my story and has been posted on BCTS for over five years.

Comments

Interesting

Mia Perry has over 40 (43 books to be exact) books or anthologies for sale on Amazon.UK The anthologies range from 50 to 70 individual stories in each book.

Indeed

And this is the only self-contained book to be published in the last few months.

-
You can't choose your relatives but you can choose your family.

Don't forget

Don't forget to mention this to Amazon UK as well as posting it here!

Is this another?

There was another book that used the same style cover by a different author, here is the blurb does anyone recognise it?


An Effeminate Boy by Christian Westlund

A TRANSGENDER COMING OF AGE TALE
Christian is an average high school kid who likes to dress in women's clothes. Fearing his overbearing father's reaction to his activities, he takes great pains to keep it a secret. But one day, when his father walks in on him as he is fully dressed, he has no choice but to confess. Christian moves out and starts living as Christine. Time moves on as Christine gains acceptance among her new circle of friends but she still wants to reconcile with her father. This a story of love, family and accepting one's true self.

== End of blurb ==

-
You can't choose your relatives but you can choose your family.

Just been flagged

The story in my above comment has just been flagged up by someone as being a story by SaraUK

-
You can't choose your relatives but you can choose your family.

Yep I do

It's "You have it all wrong" by SaraUK.

I have left 1star reviews on both stories reporting they are stolen.

This is likely plagiarism as well.

I read the first few pages of the book "An Effeminate Boy" and it is plagiarism, unless Christian Westlund and SaraUK are one and the same person. The first few words of AEB:

Christian was sitting in the coach heading away from the town he had come to hate.

The first few words of You Have it All Wrong by SaraUK (from 2007):

Chris was sitting in the coach heading away from the town he had come to hate.

Paolo

is it?

Hypatia Littlewings's picture

Is it the same "Mia Perry"?
I do not see an actual author page.
We now know its possible for more then one person ti use the same name on amazon.

Mia Perry

It is the same name, but a search on the 'author page' does not bring up the book. The ones on the author page are all porn, by their blurbs and titles.

Send cease and desist letters to Amazon

erin's picture

Even free stuff has copyright protection. Look at the bottom of the BC home page, I claim copyright in the name of all contributors. It isn't registered but it counts. You just can't sue for punitive damages without registration.

Hugs,
Erin

= Give everyone the benefit of the doubt because certainty is a fragile thing that can be shattered by one overlooked fact.

here

dawnfyre's picture

the Canadian definitions of Copyright.

Understanding copyright—The basics

Although this guide is not a complete text on law regarding copyright, we have designed it as an introduction to copyright and copyright registration.
Protect your valuable creations

A poem, painting, musical score, performer's performance, computer program—all are valuable creations, although perhaps no one can measure their worth. Some works may earn a lot of money in the marketplace, while others earn none at all.

Regardless of their merit or commercial value, Canadian law protects all original creative works, provided the conditions set out in the Copyright Act have been met. This means that if you own the copyright to a poem, song or other original work, you have rights that are protected.

Simply put, the Act prohibits others from copying your work without your permission. Its purpose is to protect copyright owners while promoting creativity and the orderly exchange of ideas.
Copyright defined

In the simplest terms, "copyright" means "the right to copy." In general, copyright means the sole right to produce or reproduce a work or a substantial part of it in any form. It includes the right to perform the work or any substantial part of it or, in the case of a lecture, to deliver it. If the work is unpublished, copyright includes the right to publish the work or any substantial part of it.

Copyright also applies to performers' performances, sound recordings and communication signals, though the applicable rights may differ somewhat. For example, the copyright in a sound recording consists of the sole right to publish the sound recording for the first time, to reproduce it in any material form, to rent it out and to authorize any such acts.

People occasionally confuse copyrights with patents, trademarks, industrial designs and integrated circuit topographies. Like copyright, these others are rights granted for intellectual creativity and are forms of IP. However, there are important differences:

Copyright provides protection for literary, artistic, dramatic or musical works (including computer programs) and other subject-matter known as performer's performances, sound recordings and communication signals.
Patents cover new and useful inventions (product, composition, machine, process) or any new and useful improvement to an existing invention.
Trademarks may be one or a combination of words, sounds or designs used to distinguish the goods or services of one person or organization from those of others.
Industrial designs are the visual features of shape, configuration, pattern or ornament, or any combination of these features applied to a finished article.
Integrated circuit topographies are the three-dimensional configurations of electronic circuits embodied in integrated circuit products or layout designs.

What copyright protects

Copyright applies to all original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic works provided the conditions set out in the Copyright Act have been met. Each of these general categories covers a wide range of creations, including:

literary works such as books, pamphlets, computer programs and other works consisting of text
dramatic works such as motion picture films, plays, screenplays and scripts
musical works such as compositions with or without words
artistic works such as paintings, drawings, maps, photographs, sculptures and plans

Copyright also applies to other subject-matter consisting of:

performers' performances, meaning any of the following:
a performance of an artistic, dramatic or musical work, whether or not the work was previously recorded and whether or not the work's term of copyright protection has expired
a recitation or reading of a literary work, whether or not the work's term of copyright protection has expired
an improvisation of a dramatic, musical or literary work, whether or not the improvised work is based on a pre-existing work
sound recordings, meaning recordings consisting of sounds, whether or not a performance of a work, but excluding any soundtrack of a cinematographic work where it accompanies the cinematographic work
communication signals, meaning radio waves transmitted through space without any artificial guide, for reception by the public

The conditions for copyright
Works

Copyright applies to every original literary, dramatic, musical and artistic work where the author was at the date of the making of the work a citizen or subject of, or a person ordinarily resident in, Canada or some other treaty country. (A treaty country is defined as a Berne Convention country, a Universal Copyright Convention country or a World Trade Organization [WTO] member.)

Copyright also applies when a work is first published in a treaty country even if the author was not a citizen or subject of, or a person ordinarily resident in, Canada or some other treaty country. The Minister may also extend protection to other countries that are not treaty countries by way of notice in the Canada Gazette.
Subject-matter other than works
Performers' performances

Copyright applies to a performer's performance if it takes place in Canada or a Rome Convention country, or if it is embodied in a sound recording whose maker is a citizen or permanent resident of Canada or a Rome Convention country. If the maker of the sound recording is a corporation, it must have its headquarters in Canada or a Rome Convention country.

Copyright also applies if the performance is embodied in a sound recording whose first publication occurred in Canada or a Rome Convention country, or if the performer's performance is transmitted by a communication signal broadcast from Canada or a Rome Convention country by a broadcaster that has its headquarters in the country of broadcast.
Sound recordings

The maker of a sound recording has a copyright in the sound recording if at the date of the first recording the maker is a citizen or permanent resident of Canada, a Berne Convention country, a Rome Convention country or a WTO member. If the maker of the sound recording is a corporation, it must have its headquarters in one of these countries. Copyright also applies if the sound recording is first published in one of those countries.
Communication signals

A broadcaster has a copyright in the communication signal that it broadcasts if it has its headquarters in Canada, in a country that is a WTO member or in a Rome Convention country and broadcasts the communication signal from that country.
Benefits of registration

The Copyright Act states that a certificate of registration of copyright is evidence that copyright exists and that the person registered is the owner of the copyright. However, the Copyright Office is not responsible for policing or checking on registered works and how people use them. It also cannot guarantee that the legitimacy of ownership or the originality of a work will never be questioned.
A lifetime of protection

Generally, copyright lasts for the life of the author, the remainder of the calendar year in which the author dies, and for 50 years following the end of that calendar year. Therefore, protection will expire on December 31 of the 50th year after the author dies.

We discuss a few exceptions below, but other exceptions exist. If you need clarity about the term of copyright in a particular work, you should seek the services of a legal professional knowledgeable in the area of intellectual property.

Registration only gives you proof of ownership of copyright, it makes going after someone for damages easier since you don't need anything else to prove ownership.

edit to add:

http://www.ic.gc.ca/eic/site/cipointernet-internetopic.nsf/e...

the financial costs for copyright, in Canada. ( fees )

$50 if you file online, $65 if using hard copy and fax / snail mail / in person.
additional costs for copies of certificates.


Stupidity is a capital offense. A summary not indictable.

Different Countries, different laws

You don't have to register a work to have copyright on it. The simple act of publishing it is enough, well it is here in the UK.
If you want to go the whole hog when publishing an E-Book or a dead-tree edition there are many boilerplates available.

For example:-
The right of [insert author name] to be identified as the Author of the Work has been asserted by him/her in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

Personally people who basically steal someone else's work should be tarred and feathered and put in the stocks. Plagurism is theft, clear and simple.

Canadian Law and UK law

dawnfyre's picture

same code base.

nowhere did I state registration was required for copyright to exist, it only makes it easier to prove ownership of the copyright.


Stupidity is a capital offense. A summary not indictable.

I remember that one

I looked at the 'sample' page on Amazon and immediately recognised the story. I have left a comment. What was your title, Paula?

Edited to add: "The Diary"

Ooh, the effort they went into to change "Ricky" to "Robbie"

Link

I didn't want to pur the link in without prior approval from Erin and Paula.

Link Away

You may link my story if you like.

Paula

Seek freedom and become captive of your desires. Seek discipline and find your liberty.

The Coda
Chapterhouse: Dune

In general, copyright is difficult to enforce...

Puddintane's picture

...without a lawyer, and with a pot of money to pay said lawyer. Under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act you can demand that it be taken down, and you can do that on your own. I've had things (artworks, mostly) stolen and published in real books and complained to exactly no purpose, but registering your copyright gives you the right to what they call "statutory damages," which can be substantial enough to interest a lawyer. Otherwise, you have to prove "actual damages," which is very difficult to do for a story that was provided gratis for any casual reader to peruse.

In the EU (in general) there are also laws protecting author's and artist's right to be recognised as the creator of their works, but much the same caveats apply as to copyright.

In the UK, and generally in Europe, the various defamation laws may come into play as well, but these too are difficult to prove and difficult to enforce, e.g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_defamation_law

Many European countries have modified their defamation laws to conform more closely to US law, which complicates the matter of defamation by roping in "free speech." Again, hiring a lawyer is both a good idea and an expensive one, probably not worth it unless something egregious has been alleged.

P.S. The particular incarnation of the ancient Hawaiian "Honu" (green turtle) symbol used in this note is in particular "Kailua," whose powers extended to the protection of young children. You can tell the difference between turtle symbols intended to depict male and female 'honus' by the length of their tail, since male green turtles have longer tails than females.

-

Cheers,

Puddin'

A tender heart is an asset to an editor: it helps us be ruthless in a tactful way.
--- The Chicago Manual of Style

Stolen books

Just searched on Amazon UK and both appear to be gone.

Always been an ongoing problem

Sadly this has been going on for centuries. Ever since people wrote and published their stories. The internet has only made it easier for plagiarists. I remember at college it was instant dismissal from the course for plagiarism. Like others have stated legally there is little that can be done without a good lawyer and a whole bunch of dollars to back you up. It has taken years for the pirate music sites online that downloads free music to be hit. But even that was not completely successful a lot still exist in one form or another.

As a small community of writers we can only watch out for each other. At the moment I think this is about the only real action we have and hope that Amazon and other sites respond. In all fairness up to now they do seem to be doing that. As Erin has said we do have some protection in the fact that any work published is covered by copy write. I know when I was in High School I hated the fact that someone would copy my work. I never dreamed that I would still be thinking about these things when I was a Mom lol. Needless to say that I certainly will be looking out to avoid buying any book by Mia Perry.