Fiction stranger than truth?

A word from our sponsor:

1200-320-max.jpg
Printer-friendly version

Author: 

I wrote a story some years ago where the theme was the theft of one designers ideas by another.

http://bigclosetr.us/topshelf/book/25298/funny-business

Now we see that it has happened (alledgedly) in reality.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-31541088

There is a definite similarity in the underlying pattern of the dress.

I have to admit that when I read the article I got a little feeling of smugness but perhaps the plot of my story wasn't all that strange after all...

Samantha

Comments

Plaigarism/Theft vs terrible concidence

It's long seemed to me that when ideas are ready to come into the world, they often choose multiple paths. Maybe the 'creators' ingested the same influences and processed them into the same or nearly identical results.

The Alexander Graham Bell vs Elisha Gray 'invention' of the telephone seems a great example. I think with some digging, countless more examples can be found in pretty much any field one cares to explore.

While there can only be one 'first' often the seconds come too close on the tail to be considered 'ripoffs' since there wasn't really enough time to copy and steal an idea.

Not to say that others don't steal. But we all feed from the same cultural trough. If someone comes up with the same idea, I try to give them the benefit of the doubt. And if I come up with what I thought was an original idea, that turns out to be something that's a tired old trope among folks much further along than me, I will blush and crawl back under my rock, but try not to beat myself up too badly for my ignorant gaffe.

I always try to make allowances for intent.

K@

Can you say ripoff?

Looks like the Brit firm copied YellowTail's design and had someone from Mombasa color it in.

I know clothing manufacturers want to cut costs, but having someone sit on the internet all day, trolling through the newly posted pictures to get ideas for "the next big thing" instead of relying on a decent design staff is no way to do this.

I am not conviced

Hypatia Littlewings's picture

Elements? Geometric shapes? They don't seem similar enough to me to be a copy. There is a similarity though. That however does not seem to be the main controversy. It seem more to be about it being a ethnic type pattern and who should be allowed to sell such. Which can be a complicated question, many things have seeped between cultures over the years, food music art fashion. I suppose it is at least OK to buy stuff of other ethnic origins and designs.

As far as the is it a copy question goes how unique is the design really? Should only one manufacture be allowed to sell striped tops because they were the first?

>i< ..:::

Fashion and Copyright

rebecca.a's picture

James Surowiecki writes a column on economics for the New Yorker, and wrote on this subject eight years ago, here: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/09/24/the-piracy-paradox.

Of course, since he wrote this the world has become even smaller, and copies of fashions from the catwalks of Milan and Paris can be made within hours of the fashion shows, not days. But his argument for why fashion would suffer more from copyright protection than less is still, I think, a sound one.


not as think as i smart i am