Author:
Taxonomy upgrade extras:
Dear Friends:
On Monday, I posted my second story, a story I wrote for the March Contest, entitled "The Consequences of Foolishness." It, as of my last check had just about 1100 reads, 27 votes and 1 comment. I think the number of reads is great. I wish it had received more votes, but the number is small but okay. I am not using this post to troll for people to read it now, and vote for it. However, I am disappointed by the lack of comments. The only one I received was from my good friend Andrea Lena DiMaggio, and I appreciate it.
I do not know if my story just stunk, or for some other reason missed the mark, since no one commented or perhaps PM me to say what they felt about my story. Was it so poorly written, that people just gave up on it? Was the story line stupid? Was it too long for a single post?
Was it not credible at all, and if so why, taking into account some of the other stories I have read? Prior to my last story, my last bit of creative writing was in college. Perhaps I forgot the basics.
I would appreciate comments, if anyone who read the story would tell me what they thought of it. I even want comments, that say that my writing s-cks, and I should give up now, as long as they tell me how it s-cks. Of course constructive comments would be most appreciated. PM's would help as well if you don't want to castigate me in public.
Of course if you liked it, I would appreciate hearing that as well.
Tomatoes in my face, and boos and hisses inmy ears are better then silence. Silence is not golden.
Thank you.
RAMI
Comments
I asked a synaesthetic once...
Silence is actually an off-shade of green with orange flecks in a kind of plaid pattern.
Silence clashes.
Comments
Welcome to the club.
Hugs & Sympathy,
Portia
Portia
A story may be considered good and yet no comments
Sometimes the story stands for it self. we often wonder if we did right or wrong. I will tell you from experience if it was not acceptable you wouold have PM's and comments galor. I personally have not read your story. I will and as a good samaritan I'll be happy to comment and give you my opinion.
Jill Micayla
Be kinder than necessary,Because everyone you meet
Is fighting some kind of battle.
Jill Micayla
Be kinder than necessary,Because everyone you meet
Is fighting some kind of battle.
Comments are over-rated
First of all, don't be fooled into thinking that everyone who has clicked on your story has read more than the first few lines - but more on that below. At the time of writing, you have 38 votes and 3 comments. A recent blog gave ratios of 8 or 9:1 for the vote to comment ratio. Yours is almost 13, but so what?
Comments seem to fall into three categories:
So my philosophy is that comments are over-rated, but since you've positively asked for them, here goes:
The story itself has a good base to it although I thought the legal issue was glossed over too glibly. You need a stronger way around breaking the law.
The problem is that once an author goes beyond writing for their own benefit and wants to attract readers, they have to start considering it as a marketing exercise. What attracts readers and what turns them off?
Appearance and first impressions are incredibly important. Your first sentence has to attract the reader, smack them in the face and make them want to read the rest of the paragraph. The first few paragraphs have to make the reader committed to reading the whole story.
I actually found the layout at the start of your story confusing. Was it a synopsis? Presumably so, but that should have been in the header with the sentence ending "fit perfectly". I assumed the story started with the FOOLISHNESS heading, but by now you may already have lost some readers!
Going on from there, your first sentence is quite good but the capitalisation made it seem strange and wondering about that made it lose some of its impact.
I know that in the next few paragraphs you are making everything revolve around the "Foolish" word, but it didn't pique my curiosity sufficient to make me read on. I think it was there where I abandoned the story when I first attempted it, a few days ago.
Now that I have picked it up again, I have read a little more and skimmed a lot. The next problem is one that most authors on BC seem to exhibit - putting boring background information in long paragraphs near the beginning. Do I care whether you have a BFA and weigh 150 pounds? Does that make your story seem interesting or boring? If this information is needed later, then put it in at the time, but don't bore readers right at the start, and only feed in as much background as is absolutely essential.
Now, as one gets more and more into the story, so everything improves. There are still a few long paragraphs, but as your story moves forward, it takes on a real life. So I think that if you hadn't turned off many readers right at the start, and hadn't bored many others with your background details, you'd have got many more votes and good comments.
One final message. Put your work aside of one or two months then return and read it in the same way as your readers will, without preconceptions. It's amazing how much benefit that will bring to your work.
and Good Luck
Over-rated?
Nah. I don't think so. I think they're under used. I know there are many reasons. One person recently blogged that they didn't comment, because they feared that somehow, someone might search and find their comment, and it might somehow get back to their family that didn't have a clue about them. So, I understand why some don't comment.
But, I actually use comments (when constructive) to hopefully improve the quality of my writing and story telling. When speculative, I use them to tell me whether, in an on-going story (serial if you will), readers are catching the "hints" that I drop every now and again when writing.
When I get little or no comments on a story - despite a LOT of hits - I take it as something wrong (as far as readership is concerned) with the story. In one recent case, I had my worst comment count to date on the site. As a result, I've decided to drop that "project"... It was a "much requested" sequel to a short story I'd posted a long time ago. I wasn't sure about it then, and now I am sure... Writing a non-planned sequel was a mistake, and one I'll not make again.
So, yes, comments - whether they should or not - do impact what is written (or at least posted here).
Annette
Forced Factor
Lindale's comments are exactly on point. If you would like to try re-writing the story as suggested I would be happy to critique it. Let me know with a PM and I will give you an e-mail address. Or, if you would like me to rewrite your story to a more reader-friendly style, let me know.
Further - you could be the best writer of forced fem imaginable and you still aren't going to get a lot of comments or votes. It's just the way things are. Some of Vickie Tern's stories are exceptionally well-written and receive very few comments or votes.
Some of the stories I've written in the forced fem genre have received huge thousands of hits and very few comments.
If you want comments and votes you need to write sweet/sentimental wish fulfillment stories with a teenage or pre-teen protagonist.
If you're serious about improving your writing skills, I'll be happy to work with you, but don't tie success to number of votes, hits, or comments, because there's little correlation between good writing and any of those standards.
Angela Rasch (Jill M I)
Angela Rasch (Jill M I)