Preserving Trans Literature in Event of Censorship

A word from our sponsor:

The Breast Form Store Little Imperfections Big Rewards Sale Banner Ad (Save up to 50% off)
Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

Depending on how much of Project 2025 gets implemented, we might see major censorship of trans content. I urge everyone to read Bethany Karsten's essay on how to resist this censorship when/if it happens.

Comments

In the U.S. It's The 1st admendment

BarbieLee's picture

Securing one's own works is common sense. Believing any one in the U.S. government, including the president, can abolish free speech is giving into the fear mongers. Removing books from schools and library's is allowed as far as I understand the laws and how courts have ruled.
We have a few lawyers on this channel, maybe they would like to offer up their wisdom? If I may, everyone take a deep breath and step back from the precipice of fear. It won't help. What might help is read the United States Constitution so one knows rather than repeating what they were told. Also read the Federalist Papers as there is so much explained in our laws.
A kazillion years earlier everyday in school I and ever person there put our right hand over our heart and pledged allegiance to the United States of America and the "REPUBLIC" for which it stands. Maybe it would help if everyone understood the difference between a republic and a democracy. A few years after I took another oath the same as many others here on this channel. I would protect this nation against all enemies foreign and domestic. I've requested to speak before our House and Senate and even discuss transgender with our governor without any success. The letters I write seem to go into a void with no response.
What I hope and pray is everyone takes a step back and analyze this with intelligence not a knee jerk reaction. There are enough spreading lies and fear to give heartburn. Hopefully in the future we will find no substance to the rumors.
Hugs Trismegistus Shandy
Barb
I think I'll stop handing out treats to the goats. No more hugs from Elvis and Annie. Naaah on second thought. Maybe everyone needs a goat to tell all their problems to?

Oklahoma born and raised cowgirl

The First Amendment

joannebarbarella's picture

Only applies to acts of Congress, preventing that body from enacting laws that curtail free speech and/or attempting to establish a state-sponsored religion.

What it does not do is to prevent private, non-government organizations from imposing their interpretations of 'free speech' on the populace. Thus Fox News, for example, merely has to refrain from reporting the good things that those whom it opposes have propounded and only broadcast what it sees as the bad things. Publishers can decline to accept stories that favour LGBTQ+ groups and respond positively to Fascist/ Nazi propaganda.

That is censorship, just not sanctioned by the State. With-holding the truth does not contravene the 1st Amendment.

Preserving Trans Literature- A LINK to the essay

laika's picture

Bethany Karsten's essay is downloadable. It's free, she wants it disseminated.
Here's a link to it. I clicked it, it won't bite or fuck up your computer.
https://thetransfemininereview.com/2024/11/13/a-practical-gu...

Like the book of the same title says. IT CAN'T HAPPEN HERE is bullshit.
It can, but will it? I hope not, but I've read enough of the 900 page Project 2025 playbook
to know they've made their desires for America and their hatred of trans people clear;
and accepting your "Don't worry, they don't REALLY mean it" assurances;
(based on I'm not sure what exactly) would be a gamble
I'm not willing to take.

As with climate change (something else I'm told the experts are all wrong about,
so there's no need to recycle, drive less or turn down the thermostat. do anything
the least bit inconvenient...) It seems better to take precautions and not need them
than to need them and no longer be able to take them because it's too late.
And I'd better leave it at that before I start ranting....
~hugs, Veronica

.
What borders on stupidity?
Canada and Mexico.
.

Worst case scenario...

bryony marsh's picture

Worst case, I think, would mean that it becomes necessary to offshore certain websites, such that they're no longer affected by whatever "decency" laws the funamentalists might enact. Given that "People in Religious and Conservative States Seek Out More Pornography Online", I doubt that censorship will become the norm.

Even if the USA wants to roll things back to the 1950s, there's solutions like mirroring and VPNs; any disruption to groups like this one would be circumvented in about ten minutes. That's not to say it wouldn't be hateful; just that it wouldn't be effective.

Stay safe, people. Better yet, stay positive.

Sugar and Spiiice – TG Fiction by Bryony Marsh

Living under a dictatorship

I grew up in a country ruled by a [military] dictator for the first 23 years of my life. The constitution, on paper, was a pretty liberal piece of legislation. But in practice the only thing that mattered was the so-called “orden superior” or “order from above”. And human rights violations were the order of the day, unless you had connections all the way to the very top. In 1989 that dictator was toppled by a military coup. This is the second longest dictatorship in America, after Fidel Castro. And during the following four years of [military] dictatorship a new democratic constitution was adopted. The special election right after the coup gave a nearly 90% electoral result to the “dictator”. But the new constitution made it very clear that any person who had occupied the office of president was NOT eligible to be elected to that position ever again.

Even today, over 30 years later, the constitutional guaranty of “innocent until proven guilty” is very often a nice fiction. Especially in cases of child care, custody and abuse. The unfortunate reality is, that the majority of social workers and judicial employees (including district attorneys and judges) consider the father as always guilty until proven innocent and the mother as always innocent until proven guilty by an overwhelming preponderance of in-flagranti evidence.

Case in point. I spent almost ten years embroiled in almost two dozen lawsuits related to the care of my daughters after our marriage finally shattered. At one point I counted fifteen simultaneous lawsuits all related to the issue of custody. I have had judges, public defenders and court clerks tell me, that even though the law as written was on my side and in my favor, they were receiving direct orders from several members of the supreme court to rule against me. Even though I did win a few battles, in the end I lost the war and I also lost my daughters.


So when I see what is currently happening in the United States of America, I am getting genuinely worried. Because I recognize the signs that are eerily similar to what I lived through in the 1980s. And when the “law of the land” (as reported by attorneys and lawyers from within the USA) is written by partisan judges with lifetime terms and no accountability to the citizens in direct opposition to the written constitution and laws passed by congress, that has all the hallmarks of a dictatorship.

And when people say “that can not happen, because I am protected by the first amendment”, I just have to shake my head at the naivety. Call me sarcastic or even alarmist, but having lived through dictatorship I can clearly see the signs of what is coming. And I feel sorry for all the trans and gender queer people in the USA.

And it might really be a good idea to, at the very least, establish a mirror site that is hosted outside of North America.

Agreed

I love studying history, and the number of parallels with 1920s and 1930s Germany right now are scary to me. Really worldwide we see so many similarities with populism and right-wing agendas coming together. Just looking at the historical perspectives of Hitler getting defeated initially, ending up in prison, then coming out and within a shockingly short time was the leader of Germany. Lots of people of the time did not believe that could really happen. They didn't believe that the Jews were being rounded up, and it was very easy to ignore it for a lot of the society.

I like to hope right now that we're going to have four dark years and then things turn over. My fear right now is the fact that all of the power belongs to one group. The Supreme Court today did not instill any confidence in me that we're going to see rulings in favor of trans rights at all. If they rule against the plaintiffs here, then I see the next step will be to ban everything else with transgender rights. With both the senate, house, and supreme court in control Trans legislation becomes very plausible for them to pass. Again, this is a small minority group much like the Jews were in Germany/Poland. It's easy to other the groups. Same with the hardline immigration plans.

I happen to also live in a very rightwing state, and I do not think we're going to see much good out of the next four years. My only hope is that Trump leaves the white house at the end of his term without A, saying he won't, or B, placing one of his kids there next.

Right now we are in a full place of being an oligarchy. Ever since campaign laws ruled companies are people, we've been on a quick slope to this point. The scariest part of that is the US has arguably still the strongest military in the world... Someone with absolute power over that making decisions in this context has historically not been a good thing. Since Trump has been told he has absolute immunity for official acts, you can guarantee official acts are going to only get worse.

There is no way Republicans would ever stand against him at this point.

Deep back-up option?

I'm not going to talk myself into being more paranoid than is already true. One might save their work on several thumb drives and hide them. Perhaps even print it and bury it.

I recently discovered stories that I had printed on dead tree media using a dot matrix printer. They are still barely readable using my poor Oklahoma, USA language.

:) Best to ya.