The problems of being and becoming a trans lady in past.

A word from our sponsor:

Printer-friendly version

Author: 

Blog About: 

I realise how hard it is coming out and living as your heart tells you you must live. I have never had the courage to do it. After hearing the horror stories of those that did have the courage or perhaps the naivety to tell their parents or carers, I am often glad I didn't.

I came across this letter on another site. It has many "truths" that most of us will recognise.

Nearly my first memory was of having my hair cut in a ladies salon. As I was still in a push chair, I imagine I was about three, I know that I was not yet at school. The girl cut off the halo of curls I had around my head, but I still had quite long hair. I demanded that they tie my hair with a ribbon and after I kicked up an awful fuss, they at last found one and tied it into my hair, much to my mother's discomfort. On leaving the shop, a woman passing by said that it was dreadful to put a ribbon in a boy's hair, and suddenly I felt so shamed that I pulled the ribbon from my locks and threw it on the ground.

It was about this time that I found an old silky dress of mother's in the rag bag and I dragged it out and wore it in my bedroom after mother had put me to bed. I just loved the feel of the silk against my skin. At this time too, I had a repeated dream that my mother's best friend had cut off my penis with her scissors. This was a very strange dream to have for two reasons, the first was that at that time I had no knowledge of the difference between boys and girls, and the second was that I was pleased she had performed the operation.

When I went to school I played mostly with the girls. I envied them their dresses and pigtails and loved their simple games, dressing up, acting out being mothers or nurses. I hated my grey shorts and shirt, looked at my clumsy shoes and compared them with the girls' neat attractive footwear.

I felt exactly the same when I went to school.

I was sent away to a boy's boarding school to toughen me up. Although I hated it, I endeavoured to fit in and played a part, but it was hard work. Even so, I would pluck an eyebrow, steal some makeup from Woolworth's and secretly experiment with it and managed to buy some girl's vests and panties from Woolworths, which I wore under my school wear when ever we did not have sport or physical training. I was attractive to a certain type of boy and although they became quite pests, I rejected them. It was not what I wanted. I knew by the age of twelve that I wanted to be a girl. I also managed to get some more grown up undies, a bra, a petticoat and a nightie, as well as a couple of pairs of lace trimmed panties, which I kept in a biscuit tin in a special hiding place.

My hiding place was under the hessian bottom of my bed.

I was thirteen when mother found these items and challenged me about it. I broke down in tears and told her how I felt, of my earliest memories and how I hated being a boy. It was also at this time that there was the case in the papers of Roberta, who had been a world war II fighter pilot, but had now become a woman. To my surprise, mother was not cross, indeed she seemed sympathetic. I was taken to a child psychiatrist who's verdict was that I would if left alone, grow out of this affliction as puberty took control. Mother was skeptical.

Puberty came. It was awful. I actually had swelling in my breasts, but just as I was rejoicing at the pain of it and feeling the hard swelling behind the nipple, it subsided and disappeared as this female development was killed off by male hormones suddenly rushing through my body. I still wanted to be a girl and told my mother; I was sent to the GP. I sat there hoping for a miracle, but once again found no salvation. I was told bluntly, that I was male and always would be. It was like receiving a life sentence. I saw a psychiatrist in a London hospital who suggested group therapy. I could not see how that would help and declined.

Mother turned a blind eye to my experiments with her make-up and clothes. I did not dress up in front of the family, but often wore girls' undies underneath. Eventually mother found out and from that time on helped me buy girls' clothes. It was squirm making to go into a shop and select clothes and purchase them with the assistants knowing that I was a boy. Mother too felt the shame, and was bad tempered, not enjoying having a sissy son.

I eventually finished school and joined a bank in the city of London. I wore my underwear under my city suit. I was popular with the girls and the chaps I worked with, even playing rugger for the banks team. At the same time, my real feelings were tearing at me. Eventually, I was sent to Sierra Leone to work and did two tours of duty there, a total of 5 years with a six month leave in between. I enlarged my female wardrobe through mail order and spent my lonely evenings dress making, stitching whole outfits by hand in tiny stitches, working out the patterns and cuts in my head, with a deal of success.

On my leave, I became a girl, staying at a four star hotel in Cambridge and another in Torquay, going to the theatre in London and to Epsom races. I loved my days and hours as a girl, hated taking off the make-up and dressing as a man again. I was never challenged, but at that time I could have been arrested had I been discovered.

I saw another GP, told him of my problems and he arranged a consultation with another psychiatrist. This man told me that marriage would make a man of me and that I could accommodate my cross dressing tendencies by taking up amateur dramatics. He said there would never be any prospect of my becoming a woman, so to buck up and get on with my life. I left him severely depressed, considered suicide, thought about driving my car under a truck or into a brick wall. I sat by the cold grey sea, listened to the crashing waves and rocked on the seat as passers by stared. The cold eventually seeped into my consciousness and I got back in the car. I knew not which way to go. The future as a man was vile, being female, impossible. I determined to try to put the love of all things female away and do as the psychiatrist had instructed.

We all know how that works out don't we.


I met a girl at a horse riding school. She had a certain cheeky charm and her boss engineered a date for us. I liked her company and she seemed to like mine. Eventually, we became engaged and married a year later. Although I loved her, sex was extremely difficult for me, and I received precious little encouragement from her, but our infrequent love making resulted in two children.

All seemed well for two or three years, then I was hit by a terrible hopelessness. As much as I loved them all and enjoyed my life mostly, behind this outward facade was a black mood of depression as I saw my life stretching ahead, forever male, hating my body, envying women their figures, hair and clothes, their conversation and outlook on life. I was trapped, not only wondering what would become of me, but what would become of them without my support.

Eventually, 'she' found some of my clothes. Neither of us could talk about it. She and her mother were horrified, and I was so filled with a sense of failure and shame that any discussion was impossible.

I saw the GP again. He stated in Biblical terms, that 'this devil needed to be rooted out.'

I was sent to the consultant in London, who was at that time the foremost expert on sexual deviation. It was this man's theory that aversion therapy could cure most things, including alcoholism, smoking and sexual deviancy. I was instructed to supply photos of myself in various forms of female attire, I would then be given electric shocks when these were later displayed by the consultant. I spent an evening, self photographing myself and dispatched them. I received a letter back demanding photos of myself as male. This made me reconsider the whole matter. What did I want? The compulsion, even with the pressure of family was that I needed to be female. I declined the treatment. The GP then said that they could take me into the local mental hospital, put me to sleep for some three months, then see how I was on awakening. If that failed, electric shock therapy could be applied.

The marriage staggered on, with me gradually succumbing more and more to my need to feminise myself. Astonishingly, I continued to work, and even won a prize for the greatest increase in turnover amongst over one hundred and twenty sales people. Even so, she decided to divorce me and took the family home I had paid for. The Social Services decided that I was not a fit person to see my children. They were unenlightened times and I lived in an unenlightened area.

Alone and bereft of family, I demanded to get the treatment I desired.

My GP sent me back to London, to the same consultant who had wanted to use aversion therapy. He was now an expert in transsexualism. He lambasted me for failing to take his treatment five years before, to which I replied that it would not have worked anyway. The student doctors surrounding us during this conversation were amused. He was not, nor was I. He agreed to treat me as a transsexual. The conditions were that in exchange for hormones, I had to live and work as a female and if I survived, after four years I would receive reassignment therapy. I resigned from my work and started living as a female full time.

Finding work was an ordeal, but eventually I saw an advert recruiting civil servants. I applied, told them frankly of my predicament and after another three months was offered a position as a lowly clerical assistant. I grabbed the chance. It was a time of supreme fear but also one of euphoria. At last I could appear as a female, legally, paint my nails, crimp my hair, wear clothes I liked, be what my inner self told me to be. There were times of humiliation, when my true identity was exposed, but generally I was happier than I had ever been. The problems all seemed solvable, the rewards worth any sacrifice. After two years I was promoted and in another two years promoted again. Then came surgery. My breasts had emerged to become a B size, my male appendages had to go by surgery at Charing Cross. At 41 years old I was as near as I could get to being the person I always knew I was.

Although life is not perfect, perfection would have been rebirth as a natal female baby, I was and am still, happy, enjoying being a girl or rather, a woman.

This is such a common tale. But It just shows that however crap it seems now. It used to be so much worse.

Comments

Year?

During which time period is this story set in?

I transitioned hormonally in the US in the late 1980s and there were only ad hoc ways of getting proper gender identification where at least in my state you had to be lucky to get a sympathetic supervisor at a department of motor vehicles office to do it for you.

Like it or not, being really passable was an absolute necessity consequently as it made them more amenable.

That was the main barrier for me aside of the thorny issue of getting bosses to vouch for you when you changed jobs.

I did not get final surgery till about a decade later due to mainly financial challenges through that decade. This had the side benefit of getting a better surgical result though. The poor cosmetic quality of earlier Biber surgeries (a lady at a support group volunteered to show us her surgical result so yes I saw it first hand) was dismaying.

Nowadays, unless you have the misfortune to be in a 'red state' who refuses to change you BC it is not too bad.

Unfortunately there are a lot of red states around.

When I first read it I

leeanna19's picture

When I first read it I assumed the 60's. The mention of Roberta Cowell places it around 1954. That would mean the writer is about 81 now.

By 1950, Cowell was taking large doses of oestrogen, but was still living as a man.She had become acquainted with Michael Dillon, a British physician who was the first trans man to get a phalloplasty, after reading his 1946 volume Self: A Study in Endocrinology and Ethics. This work proposed that individuals should have the right to change gender, to have the kind of body they desired.The two developed a close friendship.

Dillon subsequently carried out an inguinal orchiectomy on Cowell. Secrecy was necessary for this as the procedure was then illegal in the United Kingdom under so-called "mayhem" laws and no surgeon would agree to perform it openly.

Cowell then presented herself to a private Harley Street gynaecologist and was able to obtain from him a document stating she was intersex. This allowed her to have a new birth certificate issued, with her recorded sex changed to female. She had a vaginoplasty on 15 May 1951. The operation was carried out by Sir Harold Gillies, widely considered the father of plastic surgery, with the assistance of American surgeon Ralph Millard. Gillies had operated on Michael Dillon, but vaginoplasty was then an entirely novel procedure, which Gillies had only performed experimentally on a cadaver. The name on her birth certificate was changed on 17 May of that year.

Cowell then presented herself to a private Harley Street gynaecologist and was able to obtain from him a document stating she was intersex. This allowed her to have a new birth certificate issued, with her recorded sex changed to female. She had a vaginoplasty on 15 May 1951. The operation was carried out by Sir Harold Gillies, widely considered the father of plastic surgery, with the assistance of American surgeon Ralph Millard. Gillies had operated on Michael Dillon, but vaginoplasty was then an entirely novel procedure, which Gillies had only performed experimentally on a cadaver. The name on her birth certificate was changed on 17 May of that year.

in March 1954, news of her gender reassignment broke, gaining public interest around the world. In the United Kingdom, her story was published in the magazine Picture Post, and Cowell received a fee of around £8,000 from the magazine (equivalent to £230,000 in 2021, when adjusted for inflation). Cowell's biography was published soon after this, earning a further £1,500 (£43,700 in 2021).

In the United States, the widespread sensation caused by the news stories about Christine Jorgensen in 1952 had introduced the American public to the concept of changing sex.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roberta_Cowell

cs7.jpg
Leeanna

Thx

Those were difficult times, full stop.

As difficult as it was for my experience, being so early days, they are definitely quite a bit worse especially for the social aspect of it.

I Lived Through The Same Times

joannebarbarella's picture

I remember my first cross-dressing experiences around about 1956 when I was fourteen. I couldn't resist my impulses but was terrified going out, which I did anyway. The feeling of being a girl was just too much.

I couldn't admit my need to be a girl to anybody. My parents would have killed me, so I dressed as a girl intermittently and in secret until my late teens and then tried to put it behind me. We all know how well that works.

Anyway, I met a girl and we got married and I kept my desires hidden for over forty years although my work afforded me opportunities to indulge myself fairly frequently because I spent many periods away from home. I did get caught once but managed to talk my way out of it.

All through this time it was very evident that society violently disapproved of anyone who aspired to be of the opposite sex. Yes, there were the few cases of the celebrity "sex changes" who seemed to be tolerated but I never felt that it would apply to me. I would be ostracised and reviled by my family and friends if I "came out".

It was not until my wife died and my kids were gone and living their own lives that I felt able to express myself as the woman that I had always been, and even now society constrains me to maintain a male persona for various purposes, so that I can only be a part-time woman.

I first went out dressed at

leeanna19's picture

I first went out dressed at the age of 13. It was 1975. I wore a headscarf, cork wedge sandals, and a brown overcoat. I was petrified. I did it 6 or 7 times over that year. I bunked off school to do it.

I read every article on trans or men dressing as women. What I hated was how they were portrayed as freaks.

cs7.jpg
Leeanna

Aversion Therapy was no joke.

Aversion Therapy was no joke.

I had just went through a year of 1-5x incidents of sexual abuse a week from 7-8. When it was found out they shipped me off to one of those wards.

So much abuse went on that it was 100x worse than what I already went through. When I stated as such the abuse ramped up again. Violent rape was one solution as to show me what I should expect staying on that path.

Being strapped to a chair forced to watch gay porn while they shocked the absolute shit out of me.

All in the name of Jesus. Like WTF I was 8 assholes.

That is horrible. Was the

leeanna19's picture

That is horrible. Was the "therapy" because you wanted to be female, or because they/you thought you were gay?

cs7.jpg
Leeanna

I was intersex at birth and

I was intersex at birth and the surgery didn’t quite take. I was assigned male but that really didn’t stop adults from messing with me once I was found out. Aversion therapy was a thing since 4-5 but after that being shipped off was where the truly horrible stuff started.

I take that back. Some lay on hands crap when I was 5 put me in the hospital for a few months and made it to where I couldn’t urinate. I had a tap line run in my stomach for awhile.

The long abuse was more reasoned as my stepfather trying to pull my junk out so I wouldn’t need more surgery. Which my mother was pushing. She more took it as I stole her husband and turned him gay so shipped me off to be abused.

Artificial Construct

The whole skirt/pants "thing" is a relatively recent occurrence, certainly in the last 1-1500 years. If you get out of so called, Western, culture, men wear skirts, and still do. Here in America the Judeo/Christian poison deludes themselves into that being evil because of miss translated books.

Excellent detailing of early transsitions

BarbieLee's picture

I had no way of knowing what went on across the pond but I remember Christine Jorgenson surgery 1952, when she was first outed. It was brutal as they published the worse pictures of her they could find. She actually was a very beautiful woman.
Then there was April Ashley had a seven-hour-long sex reassignment surgery on 12 May 1960, performed in Casablanca, Morocco, by Georges Burou. All her hair fell out, and she endured significant pain, but the operation was successful. As a performer in a French Night club she was outed until she married a British noble. When his parents found out they had the marriage annulled.
Einar Wegener, Einar also spelled Ejner, (born December 28, 1882, Vejle, Denmark—died September 13, 1931, Dresden, Germany), Danish painter who was assigned male at birth, experienced what is now called gender dysphoria, and underwent the world's first documented sex reassignment surgery

Brutal times for transgender and in some places still is.
Hugs Leeanna
Barb

Oklahoma born and raised cowgirl

Einar Wegener or Lili Elbe

leeanna19's picture

Einar Wegener or Lili Elbe the subject of the 2015 film called The Danish Girl died after In 1931, she had surgery to transplant a uterus and construct a vaginal canal.Her immune system rejected the transplanted uterus, and the operation and a subsequent surgical revision caused the infection, which led to her death from cardiac arrest.

Even now such a thing is almost impossible.

Transplanting a uterus into a male body poses a challenge due to the lack of natural ligaments, vasculature, and hormones required to support the uterus. The uterus would either have to be donated by a willing donor or be tissue-engineered using the male's stem cells and then implanted into the pelvic region. Afterward, an in vitro fertilisation (IVF) procedure would be followed to insert the embryo into the male's transplanted womb. Due to the risks posed by long term anti-rejection medication, the uterus would need to be removed following the implied pregnancy. Given that humans do not require a uterus to survive, and knowing the predictable complications associated with uterus transplants in females, let alone males, many surgeons advise against the procedure altogether for healthy individuals.

cs7.jpg
Leeanna