If you think being a toy is like it is in Toy Story, it's not like that at all. It's actually pretty boring. When we're lying in the toybox, we don't carry out secret missions, because we can't move on our own. We don't have long conversations, because, you know, toys can't talk. We just lie there, thinking our thoughts. Or at least, I do. I'm lying on the yellow stuffed giraffe's head. I don't know what he (or is it she?) thinks. I don't even know if he (or she) thinks at all. We just lie there until Mommy takes us out and plays with us.
I'm a doll. Or at least, I look like one. I saw myself one time in a mirror and I know I look like a Raggedy Andy doll, with button eyes and a blue pair of short-pants overalls. My hands are like flat fists with black thread in lines to make it look like I have fingers.
I like it when Mommy takes us out and plays with us. Sometimes she cuddles me like a little baby and rocks me to sleep. I don't really sleep, because I'm a doll. My eyes don't close like the baby doll's. Her eyes close when you lay her on her back. Mommy used to take me to bed with her and let me lie next to her. But she doesn't any more.
Sometimes she plays school with me. She sets me in a chair at the table and teaches me. She's really smart. One time she taught me about German nouns. I wonder what an umlaut is. Is it something you spread on toast?
Sometimes she makes me play piano for a concert. She sets up the stuffed animals and dolls as the audience. She sets me in a little chair in front of the toy piano and makes my fists bang on the keys. Plink, plink, plink! When I'm done, she makes the other toys clap. I think I used to enjoy sitting by myself at a big piano and picking out tunes with my fingers. But it was a long time ago, I think, and I don't remember well.
One time, Mommy had a wedding for me and the princess doll. Princess has a pretty dress and has a special box. Mommy put black pants and a black jacket and hat on me, and she put a white satin dress on Princess. All the other stuffed animals and dolls were in the church. Well, really, on the floor. Mommy made us walk down the aisle while she hummed "here comes the bride." She was the minister and said "I do" for each of us. I wondered if we would have a honeymoon, but after she was done, she just put Princess back in her special box and then put us both back in the toybox.
I think Mommy sometimes dresses Princess up in a tutu and has her dance. One time, she put us all in rows like in a theater and dressed Princess up and had her do a ballet for us. I like looking at her. If I weren't a doll and could want things, I would want her to be my friend. Or I'd want to be a beautiful ballerina doll like her.
I think I used to not be a doll. I think I was a little boy. But I was always being bad and disappointing Mommy. I would take things out and make a mess, or fight with my brother, or be mean to my little sister. I would bother her when she was busy, and cry if I didn't get what I wanted. She said I was a big crybaby and a bad boy. So one day, Mommy told me to wait and she went out and came back with a big magic in her arms. It was a big round cloud, like a grey ball of lint, only a cloud. She told me it would make me a good boy. She told me to stand still and she dropped the cloud on me and it went all over and around me. And after that, I was a doll.
Sometimes I wish I could be a boy and play and have friends. Maybe if I were very good, Mommy would like me and talk to me and hug me and kiss me. But maybe it's better this way. This way, Mommy isn't mad at me or disappointed in me. This way I'm always good.
If I could wish, I would wish Mommy would take me out of the toybox and play with me more often, like she used to. Now, when she opens the toybox lid, she takes out other toys. She must know I'm here because she has to push me aside to get to the other toys. But I'm a toy and toys aren't supposed to wish. I'm not supposed to be sad even if she never plays with me. Only bad toys wish. Maybe that's why she doesn't play with me any more. Because she can tell I'm wishing and she knows I'm a bad doll. Just like I was a bad boy, back when I was a boy. If I really was a boy, and didn't just dream it.
Sometimes I pray. When I was a boy, they taught me I should pray. Only I'm not supposed to pray for things for myself. But I can't help it. I pray to God to make me stop wishing so I'll be a good doll and Mommy will want to play with me again. I know it makes me a bad doll, but I can't help it, Mommy.
Mommy: even though I'm bad -- can you please play with me?
Dec. 30, 2016: I made some revisions to chapters 20 and 21 and the epilog, mostly slightly expanding some details.
Jan. 14, 2017: Substantial additions to chapters 16 through epilog.
When I first saw him, the child who we planned to take into our lives, he looked for all the world like a refugee from a war zone. It wasn't so much the ragged clothes with the ground-in dirt and grass stains or the rats-nest of dirty blond hair. It was the look on his face: the face of someone who is afraid to hope. He was sitting hunched over in one of those miserable plastic institutional chairs with his knees drawn up under his chin. My heart went out to him, but I was also afraid that what he needed might be more than we could give.
Mrs. Templeton over at Social Services hadn't told us all that much about him. We knew that he was eleven, that he'd grown up in what seemed to be a normal middle-class family three states away, that he'd made two suicide attempts in the past year, the second of which triggered a CPS investigation which found no abuse, and had run away a month and a half ago, to be found two weeks later near here nearly dead of pneumonia. The social services people in the two states hadn't figured out exactly what to do with him long-term, presumably since returning him to his family no longer seemed like a good idea, but the hospital didn't want him staying any longer either, hence the need for short-term fostering. Which is where we came in. Mrs. Templeton had added, "he's a really sweet kid, I promise you'll love him," I suppose to convince us he wouldn't be like the last foster kid we took in. Right now, though, he didn't look sweet so much as lost. Well, we'd see how he responded to us.
My husband and my daughter looked at me, leaving it to me to start things off. "Hello, Michael," I said, smiling as sweetly as I could. We'd been told he didn't like nicknames. "We're the Davidsons, and we'd like you to come live with us for a while." He simply peered at us over his knees, saying nothing, so I went on. "I'm Mildred Davidson, I'd be your foster mother, but you can call me mom if you like." He just kept looking at us with that scared expression.
"I'm Jerry Davidson," said my husband, "but you can call me Jerry if you don't want to call me dad. And this is our daughter Margaret, but everyone calls her Margie." She did a sort of wig-wag wave with her palm facing out and said, "Hi." Michael seemed to thaw a little looking at her and after a bit said, "I never had a big sister before."
We explained the situation at our home, that he'd have his own room but share a bathroom with Margie, that there was a rec room downstairs, that we belonged to a pool club which would open for the summer in a few weeks.
"Can you swim?" I asked. He nodded.
"Do you have a swimsuit?" Margie asked.
"No, not here." He talks, but so far only to big sister.
"What sort of clothes do you have," I asked.
The social worker answered for him. "He just has the clothes he's wearing. It's what he was wearing when they brought him in, and it looks like he wore them the whole time he was on the run, sleeping on the ground and in the mud in them. We washed them as well as we could, what you see won't wash out. When these are in the wash, he wears the hospital pyjamas."
"Mrs. Blake, can we discuss this in your office?" I said it a little sharply. I didn't think it was very kind to be talking about him in front of him as if he weren't there. As we got up, I asked Margie, "can you stay here and keep Michael company? Maybe you can see if you all have things in common."
Mrs. Blake's office wasn't in the pediatric psychiatry unit. It wasn't even on the same floor, it turned out. Jerry stayed in the unit in case he was needed, while I followed Mrs. Blake. Once in her office, we discussed the clothing issue.
"We asked his parents to send him some clothes, but they just keep saying we should send him home. They've not been very cooperative so far. They think we shouldn't indulge his 'silliness.'"
"I wouldn't call suicide attempts 'silliness.'"
"No, I wouldn't," she agreed.
I decided not to ask why they couldn't have found some donated clothes or bought him something cheap from Walmart. Instead, I asked about what clothing allowance the foster care system had and got her to agree to let me use it for Michael. It wasn't nearly enough to buy what he needed, but I saw no point in not using it.
"You should know, he's kind of a baby. He cries a lot. And he's a bed-wetter."
"Bed-wetting we've dealt with before. What kind of crying?"
"We never know what sets him off. He starts saying how bad he is and then he just starts crying like crazy until he falls asleep."
"Does he ever get violent?"
"No, never. He's usually pretty obedient. Sometimes he gets mad about something and sulks, but he doesn't act up. Oh, and one time he managed to run out of the ward. He said he thought we were going to send him home. Anyway, he ran like the dickens, but when they caught him, he just gave up, didn't struggle or fight back. Sometimes a boy will hit him or call him names, and he just walks away and cries. Never hits back. Not much of a boy, if you ask me."
When we got back to the unit, I heard crying. I went into the room where Michael was and he was curled up in a ball crying and shaking. Margie was really upset. "I was just talking to him and asking him about what he liked to do with his friends, and he said he didn't have any and then started saying he was awful and we'd never want him around once we really knew him. I tried to talk him out of it, but he just got more upset." Margie was crying by now.
"Don't worry Margie, you didn't do anything wrong," I said as I sat down next to Michael. I didn't have much idea what to do, but I know most kids like hugs and gentle touching. I reached over and stroked his back, which was all I could reach, and softly said, "it's okay, honey. It's going to be okay." He uncurled and I gently tugged him to me. I got him over onto my lap and he snuggled into me, burying his face in my shoulder. I held him and kept stroking his back and telling him, "you're a good boy" over and over again. He kept crying, but stopped shaking and the crying got less hysterical. Finally, the crying stopped and he was just snuggling until he finally fell asleep in my arms. One of the nurses came in to carry him out, but I insisted on doing it myself. We followed her to his room, and I put him into bed and tucked him in and kissed his cheek.
On the ride home, I reassured Margie that she'd done nothing wrong, that he broke up crying a lot and it probably had nothing to do with what she'd said or done. I pointed out that he'd responded to her more than anyone else and I was sure she'd make a great foster sister if he came to live with us.
"If?" said Jerry with a smile in his voice.
"What do you mean?" I asked, though I knew exactly what he meant.
"He's got you hooked, hasn't he?"
"You don't want him?"
"No, I like the idea of fostering him, too. But I think you've really fallen for him and it's going to be hell on you when they finally place him and you have to watch him leave."
What if they place him with us? The thought jumped into my mind. That's just crazy talk, I answered myself and tried to put the thought out of my mind.
------------------------------------------------------------
Sunday afternoon, I came by again, having arranged it with Mrs. Blake as we were leaving Saturday. I was hoping it would be easier to talk to Michael if it was just me instead of the whole family.
"Hi, Michael," I said as we sat down in the room together. I hated the room -- it was one of those sterile institutional rooms, but I'd wanted some privacy. "I wondered if we could talk about whether you might come to stay with us."
He looked at me with blank incomprehension. "But I was so bad yesterday."
"I didn't think you were bad, just scared and overwhelmed. You settled down pretty fast when I took you into my lap."
"That was you? I thought I dreamed it."
"Yes, that was me. Would you like to sit on my lap now?"
He looked afraid, spooked in fact. "If I stay with you, you'll find out how bad I am and you won't want me any more and you won't like me, but I'll have to stay with you anyway and you'll always be mad at me."
"I don't believe you're really that bad. Why don't you tell me the bad things you might do that would make us hate you?"
"Well, I've been crying a lot. I'm afraid I'll do nothing but cry, and boys aren't supposed to cry."
"People cry when they're sad, even boys. I don't think that's bad. And I was able to comfort you, which made me feel good. How about another?"
"I -- I don't always do what I'm supposed to."
"You forget?"
"Sometimes. Sometimes I just don't want to and my parents yell at me."
"Like what things?"
"Cleaning up my room. Doing my homework. Notes from school. Especially when I've been bad. Sometimes I forget to feed the dog, but I don't want to, I just forget."
"Sounds normal to me. Anything else?"
"I talk too much. I say stuff that gets me into trouble. You know, you think something and then you just say it, and everybody gets mad."
I couldn't help snickering. "You sound like a normal kid to me. Do you get into fights? Beat people up?" I already knew the answer, of course.
"I'm no good at fighting. I'm a wimp. When I'm in a fight, it's always someone else beating me up. But I get into trouble anyway." He sighed. "I'm just no good as a boy."
"I guess that means you haven't killed anyone or robbed any banks, have you?"
He looked shocked. "N-no!"
"Sorry, I didn't mean to upset you, I was just teasing. Look, we know you're not perfect, no kid is. We still would like for you to come live with us. But not if you really don't want to."
"Do I have a choice?"
"To be honest, if you don't stay with us, they'll probably send you to another family." Or an emergency shelter, but I didn't want to scare him.
"Okay. You all seem nice. I'm sorry I'm being so difficult. My Mom always says I'm too difficult."
"I don't think you're being difficult. I think you're just scared, which I understand. You don't know us. I'm hoping that you'll find out that you don't have anything to be afraid of, but it's too soon right now. I'm asking you to trust that you'll be okay. Do you think you can?"
"I guess I have to," he sighed.
"Can I hold you in my lap?" I asked. He said nothing, but walked over and climbed up and I held him. We sat like that, just being together, until the nurse came to tell us I had to leave.
------------------------------------------------------------
Monday morning, I was back at the hospital. I found Michael and told him, "Michael, I've come to bring you home with me. Why don't you pack your things while Mrs. Blake and I get the paperwork done? Then you can say goodbye to everyone."
"Are you sure?" he said anxiously. "I know you said so yesterday, but ...."
I leaned down and hugged him. "Yes, we still want you." I hugged him a little longer, until I noticed Mrs. Blake standing there looking a little impatient. "Now, go and pack. I'll see you soon."
Mrs. Blake and I took longer than expected, it seems like they have more paperwork each time we take in a new kid. When I got out, I found Michael sitting in a plastic chair in the hall clutching a teddy bear.
"Did you pack?"
"This is all I have."
A sad little girl came up to Michael. "Will you read to me?"
"Sorry, I'm leaving. This lady--" he pointed to me "-- is taking me home. She's a foster mother."
"You can't read to me?"
"Sorry."
"Goodbye," she said with tears in her eyes. Michael gave her a long hug and looked like he might cry himself.
Another boy, maybe 14, came over and punched Michael on the shoulder. "So, they sprung you?" Michael held his shoulder like it hurt, but didn't change his expression.
"This is my new foster mother," Michael said. "I'll be staying with her. And her family."
"Is she nice?"
"I hope so."
A parade of children and nurses came by to say goodbye, each in their own way. When one young nurse came by, though, his face lit up and he started to run to her, then stopped dead and got a stern expression. "Wipe that rouge off your face!" he commanded. The two of them stood stock-still for about two seconds, then his face dissolved into a grin and they both broke into giggles. He ran to her and she lifted him up into a big hug while he wiggled all over with joy.
"Rouge?" I asked.
"Oh," the nurse said, still holding and hugging Michael. "I'm a student nurse, and when he found out, he started calling me 'Cherry Ames', from the book Cherry Ames, Student Nurse. One of the doctors in the book is always telling her to wipe the rouge off her face. The joke is that she doesn't have any, it's just how her face looks."
Michael had put his head on her shoulder. "I'll miss you," she said.
"Me, too," he said.
A tall woman in her 30's or 40's in a lab coat came out of one of the offices and walked up to me.
"Hi, I'm Elaine Conroy, Michael's psychiatrist. You must be his new foster mother. I've heard good things about you."
On hearing her voice, the nurse put Michael down and he came up to the doctor. "Goodbye, Dr. Conroy, and thanks for -- thanks."
"You're very welcome, Michael, but, you know, you will still be seeing me. You'll be coming twice a week to see me at my private office. I think you'll like it." She caressed his head and shoulders. "I know you're scared, but I promise you, it will be okay. Things will be good for you at the Davidsons. You can trust them."
"It's time to go home, honey," I told Michael. He fetched the bear and waved goodbye to the ward, then took my hand and we walked out the door and down to the car.
On the way home, I told him, "I bought some new clothes for you. Only a few days' worth, because I'd like to take you shopping so you can pick out clothes you like." He didn't say anything. "So when we get home, I'd like you to change your clothes while I make lunch. Do you like soup and grilled cheese sandwiches?"
"What kind of soup?" he asked timidly.
"Chicken noodle."
"That sounds good. The grilled cheese, too, I like grilled cheese sandwiches. Thank you." All said in a quiet, halting voice.
When we got home, he got out of the car and stared at the house. Our house is a rather normal suburban split-level house on the usual quarter-acre lot, so I wasn't sure what he found so fascinating. "Come on, sweetie," I said, but when he got to the foot of the front steps, he stopped and started shaking.
"What's the matter, honey?"
"I-I-I-I ... I'm sc- ... sc- ... scared." He had trouble getting the words out, he was so upset.
"What are you scared of?"
"I ... I ... I ... d- ... d- ... dunno. Uh- uh- uh- Everything, I guess." He started to cry. I squatted down and took him in my arms. Evidently I was going to get a lot of experience comforting him.
"I know, but it's going to be okay. You'll see." I comforted him until he stopped shaking. "Now, come along and see your new room."
I led him through the living room and up the stairs. I pointed out the bathroom and Margie's room on the way to his room. His room was on the small side, and the bed, dresser, bedside table, and chair took up most of the space. The dresser and table were white with gold trim and the bed was a canopy bed that we hadn't put the canopy back on. The curtains had a flowery countryside print and the bedspread had Disney princesses on it.
"I know the room looks like a girl's room. The last foster child kind of wrecked the old furniture, so we put Margie's old things in. We can replace the curtains and bedspread this weekend if you like."
"It's okay. I kind of like it. It's pretty."
"You're sure?" I noticed him running his hands over the bedspread.
"Yeah, I like it."
"Okay, your new clothes are in the dresser, why don't you change while I make lunch. When you're done, come down and find me in the kitchen."
I'd mostly finished making lunch when Michael came into the kitchen and sat at the kitchen table. I poured a bowl of soup for him, but instead of eating it, he just started crying again. I sat down next to him and pulled him into my lap.
"What is it, sweetie?"
He had trouble talking for crying. "I don't belong here. I'm so bad. I belong in a ditch. I wish they had left me there. I wish they'd just let me die!"
I didn't know what to say. I couldn't help thinking of the suicide attempts. And yet, the way he snuggled into me as I held him belied his words.
"You do belong here, honey, and not in any ditch. We want you here. You're not bad and you deserve to be with people who love you."
"Even though I cry all the time?" he said unbelievingly through his tears.
"Especially since you cry. We know you have a lot to cry about, and it's good that you feel safe enough to cry about it. Cry as much as you need to, and know that we'll be here for you."
I couldn't tell if he was actually taking the words in, but I went back to saying, "you belong here. We are here for you," and I think something got through, if only the tone of voice. Despite my brave words, I couldn't help wondering if he was going to do anything besides cry. It was beginning to get a little old, to say the least.
Once he had settled down, I asked him, "do you think you'd like to eat something?"
"I don't know if I can."
"Why don't you try a spoonful?" I held him in my lap with one arm and scooped up a spoonful of soup with the other. He ate one spoonful, then another and another, until he had eaten the whole bowl.
"Feel better?" I asked.
"Uh huh."
I slid him back onto his chair. "Ready for a grilled cheese sandwich? It's a bit cold."
"Then it won't burn my tongue," he answered brightly.
After we'd eaten and as he was bringing his bowl and plate to the sink, he said, "I know I'm supposed to just be grateful, but I still don't get it. I mean, how did I deserve --"
"Maybe you don't have to understand. Maybe it's like God's grace, it's something you're given whether you 'deserve' it or not." I put my arm around him. "I know it will take a while for you to trust us. But what we're giving you is what every child deserves. Now, I think you may need some down time. Do you like to read?"
He nodded.
"Downstairs in the rec room are some of Margie's old books, why don't you pick out a book or two and take them up to your room to read? Or read on the couch if you like. That's what Margie does." We went downstairs and I showed him the bookshelf in the rec room, then went to our "office." A few minutes later, he came by, two books in his hand, to tell me he was going to his room to read.
"What did you pick out?" I asked.
He showed me two Nancy Drew books. "You know about Nancy Drew? She's a girl."
"I've read some of her books. I don't think I've read these, though. They're interesting. And easy to read."
"Enjoy, then." He clumped off and I went back to looking at our finances.
An hour or so later, I went upstairs, and I heard quiet talking from Michael's room. I tiptoed up to his doorway, standing where he couldn't see me.
"Now you gotta remember, the last time Nancy was in this old staircase, there was lots of dust, but this time it's gone. What happened to it? We'll see."
I peeked around the corner. Michael was sitting on the bed holding his teddy bear with his left arm and holding the book open in his right. He was explaining the story to the bear. I couldn't help thinking of the little girl who'd asked him to read to her. As I went away, I could hear him reading: "Nancy looked carefully up and down the staircase, but didn't see anyone. But she didn't notice that ...."
Later that afternoon, I heard Margie shout, "Mom, I'm home!"
"I'm down here," I shouted back.
"Did Michael get here yet?" she asked when she saw me.
"Yes, he's in his room reading some of your old books. Why don't you look in on him and say hello?"
When I went upstairs again, I saw Margie sitting in her usual spot in the middle of the couch with her books and papers spread over the coffee table, and Michael curled up next to her with his nose in a book. When I came back by a little while later, Margie gave Michael a conspiratorial look and they both sat up and said, "Hi, Mom!" at exactly the same time and then dissolved in giggles.
I couldn't help smiling. "I'm glad you two are hitting it off so well," I said, but thought to myself, it's something that he isn't crying.
At 5:00, I asked Margie to help with dinner.
"Aw, Mom, can I skip it tonight? I have a ton of homework, I'll be working until bedtime as it is."
"Margie, dinner won't make itself."
"I'll make dinner all by myself tomorrow, okay?"
Michael piped up, "I'm not doing anything, can I help instead?"
"No," I said, "it's your first day with us, you need to relax."
"I might feel better if I thought I was doing something useful." He was actually disagreeing with me. Politely, but it was still more assertiveness than I'd expected. Michael was surprising me.
"You don't have to," said Margie. "I can do it."
"You don't want me to?" asked Michael, actually looking a little disappointed.
"I mean, it would really help me out. But Mom's right, it's your first day."
"You really want to?" I asked. I realized that he might actually feel better if he felt he were contributing to the family. He nodded.
"Okay, then. Come with me to the kitchen." He jumped up from the couch, dumping the books in the corner, and followed me. He was practically skipping. I put Margie's apron on him, adjusting the ties to fit his shorter height. The apron was pretty frilly, but that didn't seem to bother him. I set him to peeling potatoes to boil for mashed potatoes. He needed more instruction than Margie, but once he got started, he worked carefully and without complaining. I even got him to cut up some vegetables for the salad while the potatoes were boiling. He showed none of the insecurity he'd shown earlier. Maybe giving him something useful to do was all it took.
Most of the way through making dinner, Jerry came in the front door. And a half a minute later, I heard Michael and Margie say, "Hi, Daddy!" at exactly the same time, just as they'd done to me. I looked over and saw him looking around with a startled look on his face.
"Are there two Margie's now? I'm not sure the world is ready for two of them."
"No, one's just Michael. He volunteered to help with dinner so Margie could finish her homework." I could hear Michael giggling uncontrollably and saying, "I'm Margie two!"
Michael set the table (with a little instruction) and after we said grace, he sat down, still wearing the apron.
During dinner, we tried to engage Michael in conversation, but he closed up again and all we could get were one- or two-word answers. He looked more and more depressed and stopped eating.
"What is it, Michael?" I asked.
"Just me being stupid," he said, then added under his breath, "as usual." His eyes were getting damp.
"I want to know, I won't think it's stupid."
He sighed, which was half a sob. "You all are so nice and normal and I'm just this weirdo. I don't belong here. God, I sound so stupid."
"Who says you're weird?"
"I dunno, the kids at school. They pick on me and call me weirdo and queer. The grown-ups don't exactly say it, but they act like it. Like I'm some kind of weirdo queer."
"That's awful! Didn't your parents ever do anything about it?"
He stared at me like he couldn't make sense of what I had said.
"Didn't they talk to the school? Ask the adults to protect you?"
"Why would they? It was my fault for being so weird. I deserved it, I guess. For being such a wimp." He added under his breath: "can't even do a decent job of killing myself." He'd stopped crying and had that hopeless look again.
I took his hand between my two hands. "You did not deserve it. You're a very nice boy. What you did for Margie was very thoughtful. Now see if you can finish your dinner. You won't feel better for starving yourself." He reluctantly began picking at his food. I stroked his shoulder and smiled at him. It took a while, but he finished what was on his plate.
After dinner, he silently helped clear the table and rinsed the dishes while Margie loaded the dishwasher and I put the leftovers away. Margie went back to the couch while I took Michael upstairs to his room.
At first, I had planned to get him to shower and get ready for bed, but as we walked upstairs I changed my mind. When we got to his room, I sat on the chair and pulled him onto my lap. Once again, he snuggled into me.
"Why?" he asked as I held him and rocked him.
I thought for a second. "Because I thought you could use a little extra cuddling. And because I enjoy cuddling with you. I thought we needed a little time to simply enjoy being together."
"Even though I cry all the time and make more work for you?"
"Honey, comforting the people you love when they're sad and doing things for them isn't 'more work.' If you get an ice cream cone, is it 'more work' to eat it?"
The minute I said it, I wondered if I had done the right thing. I wasn't sure he was ready to hear the word 'love'. But he just giggled. "Ice cream. Oh, that's too much work!" It was nice to hear him laugh. It gave me hope.
"You know, honey, much as I love cuddling with you, you do need to get ready for bed. I was thinking, what you need to unwind from the day is a nice bubble bath. And after you've soaked the dirt and cares away, I'll come in and wash your hair for you."
"Hmm," he said. Then he stiffened. "Does that mean you'll see me --"
"Naked? Well, with all those bubbles, all I'll see is your head. I might even have to hunt for that."
"Okay," he said reluctantly and got out of my lap.
"Here's your bathrobe. I'll go run your bath while you undress and put on the bathrobe." I wasn't sure how he'd take to it, it was bright pink and very fluffy.
I ran the bath with perhaps too much bubble liquid, as the bubbles threatened to overflow onto the floor. Michael came in not so much wearing as being engulfed by the bathrobe.
"I like the bathrobe," he said.
"You know, it used to be Margie's."
He grinned. "Then I can pretend Margie is hugging me when I wear it."
"Okay, I'll leave you and you can hop in. But -- take off the bathrobe first."
"Ooh, you mean I can't wear it in the tub?" he said with some more of those delightful giggles. "You're no fun!"
I left him to his bath and went to lay out his nightclothes. I thought I'd give him some time to enjoy his bath, so I stopped off in our bedroom, where Jerry was relaxing on the bed.
"How did it go today?" he said and pulled me over next to him.
"Better than I hoped. He had a few crying fits, but I was able to cuddle him into a better mood each time. He isn't always down. He seemed to be good friends with a student nurse at the hospital, I saw them teasing and joking. He has a good relationship with Margie, too."
"I noticed."
"I've gotten him to laugh a few times this evening. He just gets so down on himself sometimes. He doesn't trust that anyone would like him for who he is. He seemed to go for the bubble bath, not what I'd have expected of an 11-year-old. In some ways he's more like a six-year-old."
I stayed a little longer. Jerry rubbed my back and shoulders and I felt a tension drain out of me that I hadn't known I'd had.
I knocked on the bathroom door and let myself in. The bubbles weren't as high, but they still covered him, all but his face. I knelt down and started working shampoo into his hair. "If you're going to have long hair, you're going to have to take care of it. You have to use shampoo, like I am now, and conditioner." When I was done, I left a large towel and a smaller one.
A few minutes later, a little boy with dripping hair, wrapped up in one towel and carrying the other over his arm like some sort of waiter at a spa, marched into the bedroom. I showed him how to use the smaller towel to dry and wrap around his hair.
"What's this?" he asked, pointing to what looked like a pair of very thick underpants with a plasticky coating, lying on the bed next to the pyjamas. His unhappy face indicated that he already had an idea.
"Honey, the hospital warned us that you had a little problem with staying dry at night. I know it's embarassing, but these will make sure that you won't wake up with wet, stinky sheets and pyjamas."
He started to cry again. Not the anguished cries of earlier in the day, but a quieter, defeated cry. I invited him up onto my lap and he crawled in and lay against me.
"I feel so stupid. I don't wet the bed when I'm at my parents. Why do I do it when I'm in the hospital? It's like I'm turning into a baby."
"Honey, don't worry. This sometimes happens when you've been in the ICU. It takes a while to get bladder control back."
"Are you sure?"
"Sweetheart, I'm a nurse. We know things like that."
"Do you work at a hospital? Is this your day off?"
"I used to work in a hospital. But now I'm a stay-at-home mom. But once nursing gets into your blood, you're a nurse forever."
Actually, I lied. It wasn't the ICU. I was pretty sure it was his unconscious saying, to anyone who would listen, that he desperately needed babying. He might have the mind of a bright sixth-grader, maybe even a seventh-grader, but the emotional needs of a pre-schooler. I couldn't help thinking, maybe we have a chance with this one. So many of the children we saw were so hurt already that they couldn't take in simple love and nurturing any more. I had the feeling that Michael was still at the stage where he couldn't help absorbing it.
I simply held him, feeling his heart beat and enjoying feeling his body against mine. Margie came by on her way to get ready for bed and I got her to bring his hairbrush to me. Together we brushed out the tangles in his fine, silky hair. I felt him falling asleep in my lap, and Margie and I got him dressed for bed without waking him up. Once he was completely asleep, we slipped him into bed and tucked him in. We each kissed his cheek and left, leaving the door partly open so we could hear if he woke up.
------------------------------------------------------------
Michael was still asleep when Margie and Jerry came down for breakfast the next morning.
"Mom," said Margie as she was eating, "last night, in the middle of the night, I heard Michael crying. I went in and he didn't exactly seem awake, so I just sat down by his bed and stroked his back until he quieted down and fell back asleep. Just thought you should know."
"Thank you for telling me and thank you for comforting him. You're a good big sister, and you'll be -- no, you already are a fine young lady. I'm proud of you." It wasn't the first time I'd said something like that, but she still blushed and beamed to hear me say it.
"And I'm proud and impressed with both of you," added Jerry. "He seems so sad, though. I hope we can help him."
I hope we'll be given enough time, I thought to myself.
After Jerry had left for work and Margie for school, I went up to wake Michael up. "Time to get up, sleepyhead."
His eyes flew open. He looked frantically around and sat up in bed. Even after he saw me, it took a couple of seconds before his eyes showed recognition of who I was and where he was and he relaxed a bit.
"The vampires," he muttered.
"What about vampires?"
"Just something stupid."
"I don't think dreaming about vampires is stupid. I'd say scary. Can you tell me about it? Sometimes, if you tell a scary dream, it isn't so scary any more."
He looked off in the distance, like he was talking to himself. "I was at home -- at my parents' -- and I was being chased by vampires and couldn't get out. They were going to do something really awful -- worse than killing me. You couldn't tell who was a vampire and who was a normal person. I would run up to someone because I thought they were normal and they would turn out to be a vampire."
"Were your parents there?"
"I thought so. Except when I'd run up to who I thought were my Mom or my Dad, they'd turn out to be a vampire."
"That sounds really scary. Maybe we can do something to protect you from the vampires."
"Oh, I'm not scared now. I'm not in the vampire house now."
"Are you ready to get dressed and have breakfast?"
"Okay."
"If you got your special underpants wet, just drop them in the pail in the bathroom and I'll wash them. There are more in your bottom drawer." Before I left, though, I reached over and stroked his back and kissed his cheek. "I'm glad you're here," I whispered.
When he came down, he was quiet, but we got through breakfast without any drama, and he put his dishes in the sink without being asked, which I thanked him for.
"I thought we could go grocery shopping this morning and you could let me know if there are any special foods you like."
Grocery shopping turned out to be more fun than I had expected. Michael delighted in being given commissions to find and bring back various items. He also turned out to be a lot easier to please than I'd expected. There were very few foods that he would admit to not being willing to eat, and a few more that he said he "wasn't wild about." To my surprise, he liked almost all vegetables, and most of the foods he didn't like were junk food, anyway. Cookies and ice cream were, of course, favorites, so we picked up a pint of chocolate ice cream to demolish after lunch. We came home in very good spirits.
After lunch, we went shopping for shoes. I hadn't bought him any before he came since you really need to try them on. The shoe store had displays of girls' shoes near the entrance which seemed to distract him. I got him to sit down and try on shoes, and we ended up picking out a pair of brown leather shoes and a pair of sneakers. As I was paying for them, I saw him gravitate back to the display of girls' shoes. I joined him and watched as he looked at a pair of plastic sandals with flowers on them and a pair of black patent-leather Mary Janes. He was running his fingertips over the patent leather. He looked at some bright red ballet flats and some sandals with slight heels. "They're really pretty," he said.
"Would you like to try them on?" I asked.
He looked embarassed and didn't say anything.
In the car, I tried to make him feel better. "I didn't mean to make fun of you when you were looking at the shoes. They were pretty, and when I see pretty shoes, I want to try them on."
"It's okay," was all he said.
When we got home, he went back to reading in his room, but when Margie came back, he joined her on the couch. The next time I walked through the living room, I saw that they'd found a position where he could snuggle up next to her and she could still do her homework. I snuck out and got my camera and took a picture of them before they figured out what I was doing. I don't think Michael even knew I did it.
At 5:00, I asked Margie to help with dinner. "Mom, actually, I was planning to make dinner tonight so you wouldn't have to," she replied.
"And I'm going to help," piped up Michael.
"Well!" I said, shaking my head. "I think you just made me an offer I can't refuse!" I went on to explain what I'd bought for dinner, and the two of them went into the kitchen. I realized I didn't know what to do with myself if I wasn't in the kitchen, so I went back down to our office and tried to find something to do. I heard the occasional loud discussion and a fair amount of laughing, so I assumed things were going okay. Later, I knew Jerry had gotten home when I heard a chorus of "hi, Dad!" He came into our office still shaking his head. "It's a lot less dull with him around, I have to admit," was all he had to say.
Michael was quiet all through dinner, but didn't seem upset. And he and Margie cleaned up afterwards, leaving me with nothing to do. Afterwards, I cuddled him like I had last night, hoping that some extra cuddling would make him less likely to cry, and then got him to take another bath and get ready for bed.
I'd decided to read him a bedtime story once he was dressed for bed, but I didn't find him in his room. Instead, he was in Margie's room. She was in her nightgown and he was brushing her hair.
"I brushed his hair already, and now I'm teaching him to braid mine," she said when she saw me. Michael stopped brushing and looked nervously at me. I smiled to try to tell him it was okay, and he went back to brushing.
"I'm glad to see you're getting along so well."
"It's nice to have someone to do stuff with. It's like having a little sister." I expected Michael to be insulted, but instead he looked guilty, like he'd been caught at something.
"Well, let me know when you're done. I'd like to get Michael to bed and read him a story, if he's in the mood for one."
"Can I listen in?"
"Of course."
It was quite cozy, reading the bedtime story. I sat in a chair by Michael's bed and Margie sat cross-legged on the bed, at the foot. I read The Runaway Bunny. It's written for preschoolers, but I thought the theme of a mother wanting her child no matter what might speak to him. He seemed to enjoy it; he had a smile on his face and held my hand while I read. After I was done, I put my hand on his shoulder and waited for him to fall asleep.
When I went to bed myself, I left the bedroom door open and told myself to be prepared to hear crying in the night. It was good I did, because sometime in the night I came up out of a deep sleep to hear him crying. I crept out of bed and sat down next to his and stroked his back until he fell asleep again.
As I dragged myself back into my own bed, I thought, this could get old real fast.
------------------------------------------------------------
When I got Michael up the next morning, he still startled, but recovered more quickly, and when he relaxed, he gave me a sleepy smile.
"Any more bad dreams?" I asked.
"No. At least, I can't remember any."
I pulled him onto my lap and gave him a nice long cuddle. He relaxed even more and started playing with the collar on my shirt. It felt good. It almost made up for him waking me out of a sound sleep.
"Why don't you get dressed and have some breakfast," I suggested when I felt we were cuddled out. "We have a big day today. We're going to get you some more clothes."
"Can Margie come along? She always dresses so pretty, she could help me pick out some pretty -- pretty nice clothes." I had a feeling he'd been about to say 'pretty clothes,' and then corrected himself. He seemed to go for 'pretty.'
"She can't go today, she has school and then homework. Besides, how do you know she even wants to?"
"I asked her last night. She said it sounded like fun."
"The earliest she could go would be Friday after school, and you don't have enough clothes to last until then."
"I could wash some, if you show me how to use the washing machine. I could even wash other people's clothes." This was a new one on me: a kid asking to do a chore? But then I remembered how much he enjoyed helping with dinner.
"Okay, but get dressed and eat breakfast first."
I hadn't even poured the milk in his cereal when he came down the stairs in his sock feet dragging his clothes hamper. He'd evidently figured out where the laundry room was, because he kept going down the stairs to the basement, which is where the laundry room was, and then scampered back up the stairs to the kitchen. I marvelled at how fast his mood had changed. I had to remind him to chew his cereal and to sip his milk, not gulp it.
After we'd cleaned up from breakfast, I got him to bring down the other hampers and to check Margie's floor and under her bed for dropped clothes, and then showed him how to sort the laundry and the settings for each type. After we got the first load started, I decided to trust him with the rest and headed back upstairs, still shaking my head. All morning I heard him scurrying around, and later on I even saw him hanging clothes on the line in the back yard; he'd found the kitchen stool and was using it to reach the clothesline. I noticed he'd washed his special overnight underpants, but had turned them inside out to make it less obvious what they were. I came downstairs to find him in the laundry room reading another Nancy Drew book, and I made a point of giving him a long hug and telling him what a good job he was doing.
The weather was so nice I decided to have lunch on the patio. I complimented him on his resourcefulness in using the clothesline. "I like how clothes smell when they've been dried on the line," he explained.
After lunch, I brought out a frisbee and we threw it back and forth in the back yard. We both ended up running more than I expected because Michael was so -- to be blunt -- uncoordinated. He usually couldn't catch it even when I threw it right to his hand: either he'd move his hand to the wrong place or it would bounce out before he could grab it. His throws usually went wild, so I'd have to run to catch them or, more often, run to where they landed. It didn't seem to bother him, though; I guess he just assumed this is how you play.
I noticed his T-shirt was soaked with sweat, so I said, "why don't you take your shirt off?"
"I'd rather keep it on."
"But it would be so much cooler."
He gave me an embarassed look. "I don't like it when people can see my chest," he finally admitted.
We played a little longer, then came inside. I made a pitcher of lemonade while Michael changed his shirt. When he came back, he drank two tall glasses, one right after the other.
When Margie came home, she decided it was too nice to study indoors, so she set up her homework on the patio table. I lay on a lounge chair soaking up the sun. Michael pulled up a chair next to Margie's and started reading again. I'd left the frisbee on the table, so after a few minutes, she told Michael, "go out in the yard and I'll throw you the frisbee." He scampered off to the middle of the yard. She threw the frisbee so it practically hit his hand, but somehow it just bounced off and he had to run after it. He brought it back and she sent him out again a few minutes later, with the same result.
She did a little more homework and then told him, "fetch!" He replied "woof! woof!" as he ran out to not catch it again.
That evening, as he was braiding Margie's hair, I asked her if she really wanted to go clothes shopping with Michael.
"Oh, yes, it would be fun! By the time we're done, he'll be a real fashion plate. And by September, he'll be the best-dressed boy in seventh grade."
"Let's not go overboard. He doesn't have a huge clothing allowance. Oh, speaking of September, I need to arrange with the school district for tutoring. He missed something like half of sixth grade."
For bedtime, I read him and Margie Goodnight Moon. It's funny how much we enjoyed these stories, even though we were much older than the children they were written for.
------------------------------------------------------------
Michael was a lot perkier than I was the next morning. He'd cried again in the middle of the night. This was not looking good. I hadn't had to get up every night since Margie was a baby. At least I wasn't having to nurse him or change him. In the morning, he had no memory of crying or waking so I couldn't guess what was causing it.
Thinking back on those days made me think: maybe if I used a baby monitor, I could sleep a little more soundly knowing I could hear him loud and clear if he cried. Maybe I could get him to come into our room when he woke and sleep with us, though I doubted Dr. Conroy would approve. Maybe I could recruit Jerry to do the nighttime wake-up duty sometimes. Michael had his appointment with Dr. Conroy today; maybe she'd have an idea.
Dr. Conroy had me come in first without Michael, so I left him in the waiting room reading a Boxcar Children book, wearing his freshly laundered clothes. The receptionist for the group was keeping an eye on him, though I doubted he would wander.
"How has it been going?" Dr. Conroy asked after I had sat down.
"Mostly okay. He cried a lot the first day, but I've been giving him lots of cuddling, even when he doesn't cry, and he's gotten a lot better. He's getting along great with Margie, they've really bonded. He likes to snuggle up to her and read when she's doing her homework. She tucks his shirt in when it comes untucked and brushes his hair at night, and he's learned to braid her hair for her. He asked her to come along when I take him clothes shopping. He's been really helpful and cooperative, helping to make dinner and wash up. He even volunteered to do the laundry yesterday.
"The only real down side is that he cries in the middle of the night and someone -- mainly me -- has to get up and comfort him. Last night I waited, hoping he'd stop by himself, but he just cried harder and harder and I couldn't sleep anyway. I was never any good at letting Margie 'cry it out,' either."
"Do you have any idea what he's crying about? Does he say anything?"
"No. At night, he's too sleepy to talk. And in the morning, he doesn't remember anything. I know he doesn't mean anything by it, but it does make me a little sour about having him, even though in every other way he's a treasure."
"I'll see if I can find something out during his session with me. But I think, hard as it is on you, you're filling some real need on his part by being there for him in the night. It sounds like you -- and Margie -- are giving him what he needs: unconditional love and reassurance."
We talked about various things for a while, and then I went out and Michael went in. I tried to read, but was too tired to concentrate, so I mostly just stared out the window. On the way home, I picked up a baby monitor.
When Margie got home, I took a nap, telling her to wake me in time to make dinner, but it was Jerry who woke me. It turned out that Margie and Michael had made dinner so I could sleep. It made me feel bad that I was so resentful.
That night, when Michael woke me up, I tried to get him to come into bed with us, but when I got him as far as our bedroom door, he hid behind me and sat down and cried and didn't calm down until we went back to his room. I ended up falling asleep on the floor by his bed.
------------------------------------------------------------
Friday morning, I decided to keep Michael busy by getting him to clean the bathrooms. Okay, I admit, there was an element of getting back at him for destroying my sleep. I expected him to balk, but aside from regular interjections of "ew!" and "yuck!" he went about the task without complaint. When he pronounced it done, they were definitely cleaner, even if there were a few spots that weren't as thoroughly cleaned as I would have done.
We made lunch together, and after lunch, I asked him to read quietly in his room while I took a nap. I thought if I could get a nap in each weekday and Jerry would handle Friday and Saturday night Michael duty, I could get through this. I didn't know why Michael needed someone to come to him every night, but if this was what he really needed, we could do it for him. For a while, anyway.
When Margie got home, the three of us set off to go clothes shopping. First, we went to a thrift store to buy him an outfit for church. I was going to look for a suit for him, but Margie convinced me that boys didn't wear suits to Sunday School any more, and we found a white dress shirt and navy dress pants without any trouble. They had black shoes and socks. I thought we were done, but Michael fell in love with a western-style shirt with flower embroidery and it even fit. But then I noticed that the buttons were on the left.
"Michael, I think that's a girl's shirt. Boys' shirts have buttons on the other side."
He looked at me blankly. "It's pretty."
"It's also a more delicate fabric than boys' shirts. You aren't worried that you'll be teased by the other boys?"
He looked sad. "I guess that means I can't have it?"
"You aren't worried about being teased?"
"They all think I'm a queer anyway."
"Do you know what 'queer' means?"
"It means, like, weird, right? They've been calling me that since first grade."
I decided not to explain. "Okay, if you want it."
We went on to a regular department store. I picked up some boy's underwear and socks, which he took no interest in. Instead, he found a rack of T-shirts in the Junior's department, which he and Margie were going through and discussing. They weren't particularly girly, other than having somewhat shorter sleeves and larger neck openings than most boys' T-shirts. They did, however, come in brighter colors. They picked out two shirts: a cotton-candy pink shirt with a tree frog printed on the front and a mint green one with three colorful birds. From another rack, they picked a sky-blue long-sleeve T-shirt with daisies embroidered on the front and back. I insisted on a few heavier T-shirts and a hoodie from the boys' department and a pair of jeans and a pair of khakis. I noticed him looking at the girls' swimsuits, but fortunately he didn't ask to try any on. They did pick out a boy's swimsuit in the loudest possible colors and he insisted on a cobalt blue swim shirt. He ended up with one pair of shorts from the boys' department, but he also got one from the girls' department because he liked the colors better.
Nothing they picked out screamed "girl" exactly, but they weren't exactly boyish either, and I could imagine people being uncertain about his sex if he wore certain ones together.
We picked out Chinese take-out on the way home; fortunately Michael wasn't at all picky about the kind of food, but when we said Chinese, he knew exactly what he wanted: sweet and sour chicken and an egg roll. Margie and he spent the ride home doing ridiculous fake Chinese accents and laughing hysterically. When we got home and set up on the dining room table, he got really subdued.
After dinner, I put him on my lap for some cuddle time. I'd rocked him for a while when I heard, "thank you for the nice clothes. But ...."
When he didn't go on, I prompted him: "but what, honey?"
"Did I pick out the wrong clothes?"
"What do you mean? You don't like them?"
"No, I love them. But -- maybe I'm not supposed to like clothes like them."
"Why not?"
"Aren't boys supposed to want boring clothes in dull colors? Rough-looking?"
"Well, what do you usually pick out?"
"I never picked out my own clothes before. My Mom used to just buy stuff and that's what I would wear."
"Nobody ever asked you what you wanted?"
"No," he said, wonderingly. "I guess I never thought it mattered what I wanted."
"Well, now's your chance to experiment." He cuddled even closer and rubbed his cheek on my chin.
That night, I heard him crying and poked Jerry with my elbow. He eventually got up and I luxuriated in being able to stay in my nice warm bed.
------------------------------------------------------------
The next morning as we were lying in bed, Jerry told me, "I had a hard time getting Michael back to sleep. I tried rubbing his back, but he just woke up and cried even more. I finally had to pull him out of bed and cuddle him on my lap and rock him to sleep. I rubbed his back and said stuff like, 'it's going to be all right' and eventually he fell asleep."
"He probably doesn't know you that well yet. Maybe you could something with him today."
So, after breakfast, Jerry got out a softball and two gloves and he and Michael went out into the back yard. Michael wasn't any better at throwing or catching softballs than he was at frisbee. Jerry had to place Michael with his back to the house so that his wild throws wouldn't break a window. Jerry tried to be upbeat and encouraging, but I could tell he was amazed at just how bad Michael was.
"How was it when you played catch with your Dad?"
Michael stopped to think. "I never played with Dad."
"How about your brothers? Do you have brothers?"
"Yeah, three of them. But we never played catch, either."
"How about your friends?" I could see Michael getting upset.
"I never had any friends." He was about to cry, even Jerry could see that.
"Hey, let's go back to tossing the ball around. How about you stand out there and I'll see if I can get it into your glove."
But all the fun had gone out of Michael. He just stood there looking dejected. Jerry went out and put his arm around him as he started to cry. To my relief, Jerry didn't say anything, simply led Michael to a chair and sat down and put him on his lap and held him.
"I can't do anything right!" he sobbed. "That's why no one wants me around. I'm just no good. I wish I were dead."
"That's not true," my husband replied. "We want you around. And you're not 'no good,' you're good for a lot. Millie's been telling me how helpful you are."
"I can't throw, I can't catch, I'm no good as a boy."
"I don't care if you can't throw or catch. I was just doing it to have something to do with you. Because I wanted to be with you." He rocked Michael and stroked his back. "We'd be really sad if you were dead. We'd really miss you. For a long time. You're very special to us." It was moments like this when I was reminded what a special man I had married.
Jerry kept holding him and rocking him until Michael's cries diminished to sniffles and finally stopped. "I think it's time for a mid-morning snack," Jerry said. "How about some crackers and cheese and lemonade?" Michael nodded and smiled and slipped off Jerry's lap.
While we were all snacking at the kitchen table, the doorbell rang. Margie went to get it, and in a minute, Becky came into the kitchen, followed by Margie.
"Hi, want some?" I asked.
"Would you believe I just had breakfast?" she laughed.
"Astrid's coming, too," said Margie.
"So all Three Musketeers will be here?" I asked.
"Yup!" said Becky.
"This is Michael, our foster child," I said, looking at him as he scrunched down in his chair, still holding a huge half-eaten cracker with cheese.
"Nice to meet you," said Becky. "Oh, I won't bite. I only bite on alternate Tuesdays when the moon is full." She plunked herself down in Margie's chair, right next to him.
"What do you like to do on sunny Saturdays?" she asked him. Either Margie had briefed them, or she'd figured out that asking about his past wasn't a good idea.
"Read," said Michael shyly, still scrunched down and still holding on to the cracker.
"Found anything interesting?"
"Nancy Drew."
"Oh, which book are you reading now?"
"The Haunted Cave."
"Oh, that's a good one. Did you get to the part where --"
"Don't spoil it for him!" interrupted Margie.
The doorbell rang again, and Astrid came in.
"Hi, Mrs. Davidson, Mr. Davidson."
"Hi, nice to meet you." Jerry just waved.
Becky interrupted. "Michael, want to hang out with us downstairs?"
Michael's face brightened and he shoved the cracker and cheese into his mouth. The four of them headed down to the 'wreck room,' the girls chattering away and Michael manfully trying to chew with his mouth stuffed with cracker and cheese.
A half hour later, I went down to the 'office' to have an excuse to peek in on the four of them. Becky was on the floor, Astrid in the overstuffed chair, Margie was on the couch, and Michael was curled up between Margie and the end of the couch pretending to read but clearly listening to what was going on.
"How is everything going down here? Are you all okay with Michael being here?"
"He's fine," said Becky. "A little quiet, though."
"Anyone's quiet compared to you," said Astrid.
"I just don't believe in awkward silences," she shot back, laughing.
"Or any other kind," said Margie, and they all laughed.
"I think Margie won that round," said Astrid when the laughing died down. I saw Michael smiling and laughing along with the girls, and I think they liked having an audience.
I'd just finished balancing the checkbook when I heard the four of them clomp up the stairs, and a little while later, I heard footsteps going back and forth upstairs. My curiosity aroused, I went upstairs. Just as I got near Michael's room, I saw Margie lead him out and into her room. He was wearing the girls' shorts from Friday's shopping and one of the girls' T-shirts and had barrettes in his hair. I heard 'ooh's and 'aah's and other comments from Margie's room, so I stuck my head in.
"We're having a fashion show," explained Margie. Michael looked nervous and guilty when he saw me, but when I just smiled and nodded, he relaxed.
I shook my head and muttered, "kids!" which brought a laugh from the girls. "Would you all like some lunch?"
"We were thinking of making sandwiches for everyone, once we finish the fashion show," said Becky.
"Sounds good to me," I said. Actually, they usually made meals when they were over. It's one of the reasons nobody minded hosting them.
Margie got Michael to show off another ensemble, then the four of them went down to the kitchen. Michael put on Margie's apron, which we'd never adjusted back for Margie anyway, and collected Jerry's and my orders. Michael fit right in, mostly by being quiet and following orders.
While we were eating, Margie announced, "we were thinking of going down to the park to hang out for a while. You know, enjoy the day --"
"-- swing on the swings --" interrupted Becky.
"-- watch the kids. And the squirrels."
"Sounds good," I said.
"Can I come?" Michael asked.
"If it's okay with Mom."
"I'm okay with it, if you all will take responsibility for looking after him. He's not 16, you know. And Michael: don't run off."
"I don't think that will be a problem," said Astrid. "He's Margie's little shadow."
"Oh Margie: is everything arranged for your date tonight?"
"Yes, Brett's parents are driving us."
"Good. We'll be home. Give us a call if anything comes up."
The four disappeared out the front door, and I went back out onto the patio.
After a while, I realized I was relaxing in a way that I hadn't all week. This was the first time since I'd picked Michael up on Monday that I'd been separated from him, unless you count his session with Dr. Conroy. Much as I loved him as if he were my own, the constant worrying about what he could or could not deal with was a strain. I was going to have to have someone else take him occasionally. That made me think about what we would do with him in the fall, assuming he was still with us. I doubted he'd survive in a regular middle school.
I actually dozed off for a while. When I woke up, I heard Jerry trimming the bushes. I went up to him and hugged him from behind. "You know, we're temporarily childless. We should take advantage of it."
"I'd love to, but the bushes won't trim themselves."
"You do know that we have a boy in the house who just loves to make himself useful. You should take advantage of it."
What we did after that is nobody's business but our own. Suffice it to say, we were lying on the bed relaxing when Margie and Michael returned home.
"Where are the others?"
"They went home," said Margie.
"How was the park?"
"Oh, the park was great. We hung out on the swings and the turntables and watched the kids playing. Michael had a little problem with some boys who came by and wanted to push him around. I yelled at them and told them to leave him alone and then the three of us convinced them to go." She got more serious. "I did mess up, though. What I actually said was 'leave my little sister alone.' I guess I've been pretending in my mind that he's my little sister and it just slipped out."
I looked at Michael who looked nervous. Not insulted like I would have expected. "Michael, did that bother you?"
He shrank together. "Yeah. I wished I could have made them go away by myself. I am such a wimp."
"Did it bother you that Margie called you her sister?"
He looked baffled. "It's because she likes me, right?"
"I do like you," said Margie.
"I'm glad. I'm glad somebody likes me. Those boys sure didn't."
"Did nobody like you back at home?" I asked.
"Yeah," he said finally. He looked like he was about to cry, so I pulled him onto the bed and held him against my breast.
"We like you," I said. "And so do Margie's friends. You're very likable."
"Yeah, but they're going to send me back to my parents' and then I'll have no one who likes me." I wished I could reassure him, but I knew he was probably right.
Margie was gone, to get ready for her date, I assumed. I held Michael for a while longer, then said, "do you want to help make dinner?"
He looked a little more cheerful as we got out of the bed and went downstairs to the kitchen. Just as I'd gotten the apron on him, the doorbell rang and Margie came flying down the stairs.
"Hi, Brett," she said to the young man who came in. Michael ran out to see who it was.
"Michael, this is my boyfriend Brett. Brett, this is Michael, our foster child." By this time, Michael had insinuated himself between Margie's arm and her side, while staring at Brett with big eyes. "Say 'Hi, Michael."
"Hi," said Michael woodenly.
"We're going out to dinner and a movie."
"Can I go with you?" said Michael in a not exactly inaudible whisper.
"I'm afraid not. But you'll have Mom and Dad all to yourself tonight. And you'll see me tomorrow morning. Maybe we could make breakfast together. How does that sound?"
I reached out my hand and Michael reluctantly left Margie and came over to me. He waved Margie a sad goodbye.
"He's pretty attached to you," said Brett.
"I think he had a pretty rough time before he came to us," said Margie. "We've been trying to be really nice to him and make him happy here."
"Maybe I could come over sometime and we could do guy stuff together."
I thought Michael looked even more wary than before. "We'd have to discuss it first. He's still having trouble adjusting. But it's a nice idea and it was thoughtful of you to suggest it."
Jerry and I socialized with them for a minute or two longer and then they left.
Dinner was a quiet affair. Halfway through, Michael slipped off his chair and came over and stood next to me. I put my arm around him.
"You know Margie will be back tonight. You'll see her soon."
"Yeah, I know. But ...."
"It feels like she's gone forever?"
"Yeah," he said with leaky eyes. I cuddled with him a little longer, then he went back to his chair and finished the food on his plate.
After dinner, I gave him a long cuddle and then a bubble bath. I washed his hair again and tried to make it a caring experience. Jerry came in when he was dressed for bed and helped brush his hair and he stayed in and listened while I read a chapter from Winnie the Pooh. Michael knew the whole book almost by heart, but if anything, he enjoyed it even more for that.
Jerry and I got ready for bed and waited up for Margie. When she got home, she went in and gave Michael a kiss before going to bed.
And, yes, Michael woke us up crying. Jerry took care of it. I just smirked and snuggled even deeper into the covers.
------------------------------------------------------------
I woke on Sunday to the smell of bacon and pancakes. It smelled like Margie had made good on her threat to make breakfast. Michael seemed happy again. I noticed Margie putting her arm around him whenever they weren't doing anything and toussling his hair when they rushed back and forth, and every time, I saw him look at her and smile.
On the ride to church, Michael and Margie were in the back chattering to each other. Michael was talking more than I'd heard him talk all week, but I couldn't hear much. When I asked Margie about it after we got to church, she said, "he was telling me how he survived when he was running away. It's no wonder he got pneumonia, sleeping in ditches and behind dumpsters in the rain. And he still didn't want to go home."
We offered Michael the opportunity to go to Sunday school, but it didn't surprise me that he wanted to stay with us. He sat beween Margie and me and sang happily along with the hymns and followed along with the prayers in the prayer book. During the readings and the sermon, he would lean against me or Margie. I had the feeling he got more of a sense of God and Jesus from leaning up against us than from all the readings and lessons and sermons.
After the service, Margie was socializing with some of the teens and went off with them for the afternoon. I ran into my friend Cheryl, who had a son Michael's age and we decided to make a play date of it. Jerry dropped us off at her house, promising to pick us up when we were done.
Cheryl and I sat in her kitchen talking while Michael went off with Will to his room. Maybe fifteen minutes later, Michael came quietly into the kitchen and stood next to me. I put my arm around him.
"Not having fun?" I asked. He just shrugged.
"You all should be playing outside, anyway," sad Cheryl. "Will!" she shouted. A few minutes later, Will and Michael went into the back yard, Michael a little reluctantly, I thought. Will didn't seem too thrilled, either.
They lasted about ten minutes, during which there was a certain amount of shouting. It did not sound like it was going well, so it didn't surprise me when Michael crept into the kitchen and sat down on the floor at my feet, leaning against my legs. A few minutes later, Will stormed in.
"What is it, honey?" asked Cheryl.
"Michael is such a wuss. I tried to do fun stuff, but he doesn't join in, just sits there and won't say anything. I even threw a ball around, but he can't catch and he can't throw. He's no fun at all!"
Michael didn't say anything, just pushed himself even farther between my legs. Will stormed off to his room.
"I'm sorry it isn't working out between them," said Cheryl.
"I'm sorry, I probably shouldn't have suggested it. Michael is still rather fragile and wasn't all that enthusiastic in the first place."
I was going to call Jerry, but Cheryl's husband offered to run us home.
"I guess I ruined your visit," said Michael when we got home. "I'm just no good." He started to cry like he had the first few days. "No wonder no one likes me."
"It's not your fault," I told him as I pulled him onto my lap. "I should have made sure the two of you got along first."
Once I calmed him down, Jerry said the yard needed to be checked for sticks and rocks and such so he could mow. "I'll give you a bowl of ice cream for each wagon load you pick up."
"How about you? How will you get your ice cream?"
"Oh, I'll be picking up stuff, too." He showed Michael a child's wagon. "This is yours." He pointed to the garden cart. "That's mine."
"That's not fair. Your cart is bigger. It's more work to fill yours."
"I'm bigger and can pick up more sticks at a time. That evens it out."
Michael seemed to accept the explanation and ran out into the yard, pulling the wagon and examining the ground. Jerry ended up collecting the larger branches while Michael found hordes of twigs, rocks, small toys, and a dismayingly large number of soda cans and broken bottles. He kept going even when Jerry was ready to quit and filled two wagon loads. Jerry finally had to tell him to stop, saying that the ice cream was getting tired of waiting.
When Jerry put a bowl of ice cream in front of Michael, he came out with "ice cream! That's too much work!" and dissolved in laughter. Jerry was, as you might expect, utterly confused, and since Michael was unable to speak for laughter, I had to explain.
Once Michael managed to stop laughing, they dug into the ice cream, but Michael was satisfied with one bowl, as was Jerry. Jerry tried to interest Michael in throwing a ball back and forth, but though he participated, his heart wasn't in it.
------------------------------------------------------------
The next week went fairly smoothly. I took him to Dr. Conroy on Monday. The tutor came Tuesday morning and gave him some tests and a little homework which he did in an hour. Wednesday he did laundry again, this time also doing the sheets and towels. From the amount of overnight underwear in the wash, I culd see that he hadn't been able to stay dry a single night. It wasn't a problem as far as I was concerned, but I knew it was demoralizing for him. On Thursday, he went to Dr. Conroy and on Friday the tutor came again. He said Michael was a quick learner, but had some holes in his education and left some workbooks for him to do. I got a nap each day, which mostly made up for getting waked up every night.
Some days Margie stayed late at school; on those days Michael moped around until she came home.
On Saturday, Margie said she was going over to Becky's. She also wanted to take Michael, since Becky had a nine-year-old sister Lisa who she was sure Michael would get along with 'like a house afire.' Given how the previous play date went, I decided I'd better come along. Besides, I liked Becky's mom Sue Price and I hadn't seen her in a while.
Lisa turned out to be kind of a hurricane in braids. As soon as we arrived, she started talking a mile a minute, saying how glad she was to have Michael come over and he just had to see her climbing tree and -- well, I couldn't keep track any more. She kind of grabbed Michael and dragged him outside. As I sat with Sue in the kitchen, I could see her coaxing Michael up into a huge maple tree. Every now and then, I'd see Lisa waving through the leaves and a half a minute later, Michael attempting to wave while holding on to the tree with both hands. The next time I looked, I couldn't see them, but I noticed some bushes in the row at the back of the yard being jostled. They seemed okay, so I tried not to worry.
"I'm glad Michael was willing to play with her. She doesn't have a lot of friends. She's too bossy and too tomboyish for most of the girls, but she's isn't into being rough enough for the boys. You know how boys are."
"I know. I took Michael over to visit a boy last Sunday, and they were just not on the same wavelength at all. It doesn't help that Michael is still pretty fragile. I don't like to second-guess my foster children's parents, but I get the feeling he was emotionally abused. He has very little self-esteem."
As I was talking, I saw Michael walking up along a board propped up at one end by a log, with his hands behind him and Lisa poking him with a thin stick. He walked blindly off the end and fell into a heap. Lisa waved the stick around in the air, then looked over at Michael, who jumped up and started brushing the dirt off of himself. They then ran over to the swings.
"I think she's playing pirate," Sue said.
I'd stopped paying attention to their shenanigans when suddenly the two of them burst into the kitchen.
"Mom we're thirsty is there any lemonade or water and can we have some cookies too we're hungry." Lisa didn't wait for an answer but opened the refrigerator before she'd finished talking. Michael was covered in dust and wood chips but had a goofy smile on his face. I took Michael out to the porch to knock off the worst of the debris and take off and shake out his shoes.
"Hey, we were going to play in my room now."
"Then it's a good thing his Mom is cleaning him up a bit," said Sue. "I want you to take your shoes off -- on the porch -- and wash your hands and face. Then -- maybe -- you'll have earned a few cookies." Lisa sighed and did as directed and once both were halfway clean, Sue gave each of them a few chocolate chip cookies. Lisa stuffed them all in her mouth while Michael started eating them one by one. Lisa headed for the stairs, then turned around and extended her hand to Michael, who ran to catch up to her, and they stomped up the stairs hand in hand.
A while later, Becky went upstairs. When she came down, she spoke quietly to us. "You have to go look. They're so cute. Lisa is nursing one of her baby dolls and Michael is changing the other one's diaper. You'd think they were mommy and daddy."
"That's Lisa's view of parenthood," said Sue with a laugh. "Mommies are responsible for the one end and daddies for the other."
We tiptoed up the stairs and peeked in. Michael was rocking and quietly singing to his baby doll and Lisa was still nursing hers. They were so engrossed they didn't notice us looking in. We snuck back downstairs.
Sue and I made lunch for the whole crowd: split pea soup with chunks of ham, grilled cheese sandwiches, and carrots and celery. There were enough of us -- three adults (Sue's husband Tom made an appearance), the Three musketeers, Lisa and Michael -- that we used the dining room table. Michael insisted on sitting between Margie and Lisa.
"Lisa, I see you have a new friend," said Tom.
"Yeah, can we play together tomorrow?" she asked.
"We'll have to see," said Sue.
After lunch, Lisa and Michael ran back upstairs, but only after we got them to clear their places. Margie and her friends cleaned up, then said they were going to the school to watch the boys play pick-up basketball.
An hour later, I thought about going home and peeked into Lisa's room. I fetched Sue. "They're really cute now," I told her.
Lisa and Michael were fast asleep on her bed. Michael had his head against Lisa's chest and Lisa had her arm over him. Even though Michael was taller, the way he was curled up made him look shorter. Sue went out and brought back a camera and took a few pictures. "They're so adorable," she whispered. She slunk into the room and got a few more pictures from a different angle.
I decided to let them sleep and called Jerry to let him know we'd be a little longer than planned. Sue and I went out and lay on lounge chairs in the back yard in the sun and simply enjoyed not having to do anything. Bikinis would have been even nicer, but that would have required getting up and going to the trouble of finding some and changing. I think we dozed for a while.
We woke when the sun went below the neighbors' trees. Michael and Lisa had changed positions so his back was to her, but they were still pressed up against one another. I woke Michael, which woke Lisa. They were still a little sleepy when I got Michael ready to go, but Lisa insisted on giving him a big hug and a kiss on both cheeks. He didn't kiss her back, but he looked very happy and said he couldn't remember when he'd had so much fun.
On the way home, Michael got really quiet. I tried to get him to talk about the visit, but just got one-word answers. When we got home, he looked really down, so I sat him down on the couch.
"What's eating you, sweetie?"
"I just know I'm going to do something stupid and she'll find out how awful I am and she'll hate me. I almost wish I hadn't -- it's just going to be worse. I thought I had a friend, but I just know..." He broke down completely, crying and sobbing, and curled up into a ball on the couch. I pulled him over to me, so that even though he was curled up, his body was touching mine and I could stroke his back and head and sort of hug him and let him know I was there. Maybe he had to just cry it out, but I hoped knowing I was there for him might make him feel less lonely in his misery.
By the time he'd cried himself out, Jerry had started dinner and let us know that Margie had called to say that she and Astrid were going to hang out at the pizza place with Brett and another boy who wasn't Astrid's boyfriend, just a guy she liked to hang out with. Or so she said. So it was another Saturday night with just the three of us.
------------------------------------------------------------
On Sunday, Margie and Michael made breakfast again, and he again stayed with us during the service. Afterwards, I tried to get Michael to play with the other boys, but he showed no interest. He did stand around near a group of girls, but they rather pointedly ignored him. He spent the rest of the time clinging to me.
Margie had once again gone off with her friends, so it was just the three of us on the ride home. Michael was silent during the ride and went to his room as soon as we arrived. While I was making lunch, Sue Price called.
"Hi, Millie. It was really nice to see you yesterday."
"I really enjoyed talking to you. It was a wonderful visit."
"Lisa was in seventh heaven about having Michael there."
"I could tell! I think Michael loved it, too."
"She's been asking when he can come over again. You know how she can be. So I agreed to ask. I don't know how things are with you all, though."
"I think it was good for Michael. But I think it was a bit much for him, too. He had kind of an emotional meltdown afterwards. He hasn't had many friends in his life and he's not used to it yet. So I think we need to go slow. But I think this coming weekend might work. Will you all be at the pool opening this Saturday?"
"Wouldn't miss it for the world! So maybe Lisa and Michael can get together then? Some of the other girls Lisa gets along with will probably be there, though."
"And if the weather doesn't cooperate, we can make other plans for them to get together."
Michael came down for lunch, but didn't say much, and went right back to his room afterwards. I decided I needed to check in with him, so after I washed up, I knocked on his open door.
"Mind if I come in?"
"Sure." He was lying on the bed reading. I came in and sat on the end of the bed.
"Did you enjoy your visit with Lisa yesterday?"
"Yeah, it was a lot of fun."
"You'd like to go back?"
"Yeah! Can I go tomorrow?"
"Lisa has school tomorrow. You might see her on Saturday, at the pool."
"Cool!"
"Listen," I said cautiously. "I couldn't help noticing, after we got back, you got really upset."
"That was just me being stupid."
I tried to come up with something that would make him feel more okay. "You know, Lisa's mom called today. She says Lisa really enjoyed having you over. I think she wants to be your friend."
He was still staring at his book, but I could see tears in his eyes. "I don't know how to be a friend."
"It's not as hard as you think. Just be yourself."
"But nobody likes me being myself."
"Lisa did. Margie and her friends do."
"Nobody at home. Not even my parents." He was really crying now, and I got him onto my lap.
"I don't want to say anything bad about your parents, but I think they didn't know to appreciate you. And maybe the kids you met didn't either. Like Will. But there are people who do. Like Lisa."
"But boys aren't supposed to play with girls."
"Why not."
"I dunno. I guess boys aren't supposed to like girl stuff."
"Like chocolate chip cookies? Or ice cream?" I managed to get a chuckle out of him, but he went back to being sad.
"Lisa got me doing girl stuff." He looked guilty, like the guilty look when he was in the 'fashion show.' "She got me to play with her baby dolls." He got really quiet. "I changed a diaper and rocked one of the dolls to sleep."
"Sounds like what Jerry used to do when Margie was a baby. I'd say you're getting good practice in being a daddy. You know, Jerry sometimes rocks you to sleep, too." I started rocking him, which made him nestle deeper into my chest and arms. "You know, I think you're a very likeable kid. And I think if you look, you'll find lots of people who will love you just the way you are."
As I rocked him, I started humming the song. Actually, only the last line, since I couldn't remember anything beyond the "I love you just the way you are" part. It didn't matter. I felt such pleasure holding his body next to mine and cuddling and comforting him. I think it made him feel good, too.
At some point, my back started complaining, so I said, "would you like to help me make chocolate chip cookies?"
"Yeah!" Then he thought for a moment. "Does that mean I'd get to eat some of them?"
"Sure. But -- not too many!"
"Aw!" But he bounced out of my lap anyway and headed for the kitchen.
We'd just finished cleaning up from the cookie making and were still boxing up the cooled cookies when Margie came home. "Do I get some, too?" she asked.
"Remember the Little Red Hen?" I teased.
"I would have helped if I'd been home," she protested as she grabbed one of the ones still cooling on the brown paper. She agreed 'in penance' to make dinner, which amounted to reheating the week's leftovers. Michael helped, of course.
------------------------------------------------------------
Saturday morning dawned sunny and warm with the promise of becoming hot. I packed a cooler with healthy food and drinks and collected the usual towels, beach blankets hats, etc. Michael was up early and had breakfast in his swim suit. When we got to the pool, Sue and Tom had already staked out a picnic table for us to share near a grassy area. I was pretty sure Michael would need a nap.
Michael immediately shucked his sandals and headed for the steps at the shallow end. By the time I got there, he was already on the first underwater step, protesting, "it's cold!"
"They just filled it this week, of course it's cold. Plus the rain."
He didn't seem to be listening. He took another step in and shouted, "ooh, it's cold!" For all his complaints, he was soon in all the way and promptly dove forward. His strokes were ungainly and followed no particular style, but they seemed to move him along. He soon reached the rope at the five foot mark, where he found Lisa and her friend Fiona Malloy. When I saw him swim down straight to the bottom and come out on the other side of the girls and say "boo!", I realized that he was completely at home in the water and I needn't worry about him.
Back at the picnic table, Sue and I watched the three of them play in the water. Lisa was the obvious leader, and Michael and Fiona looked happy to go along with whatever she came up with. Since they seemed okay, Sue and I went in ourselves and swam back and forth for a while, then found some empty lounge chairs and enjoyed the sun.
Around noon, Lisa and Michael found us. Lisa asked for money to eat at the snack bar. Michael just looked nervous. "Well, go on, ask for it," prompted Lisa.
"Uh, can I have ...?" He looked guilty.
"Money for lunch at the snack bar?" He nodded. "Yes, you may." Fiona showed up as I was fishing money out of my wallet. The three of them scampered off to the snack bar, money in hand.
The "Three Musketeers" showed up as we were making sandwiches.
"No snack bar for you all?"
"We don't want to get fat," explained Becky. They settled down on the beach blanket to eat their sandwiches and chat, while we adults sat at the picnic table.
Around mid-afternoon, Michael came up to us. "I'm tired," he said.
"Go use the toilet, then you can lie down on the blanket. I'll watch out for you."
When he got back, he climbed into my lap and I rocked him and hummed to him and he promptly fell asleep. Jerry helped me lay him on the blanket. Lisa and Fiona came over a little while later and lay down on the blanket and chatted, which meant mostly Lisa talking, but after a while they got quiet and dozed. I covered the three of them with a large towel. Sue went off to let Fiona's parents know where she was while I dragged two lounge chairs over where I could keep an eye on the children. It warmed my mother's heart to have three cute sleepy children under my wing.
I read for a while, then just lay there, enjoying the breeze and the sunlight that filtered through the trees. When I looked at the children again, I saw that they were still asleep, but Michael was now snuggled up next to Lisa. They looked like three kittens sleeping together.
Later, Lisa woke up, which woke up Fiona, and the two of them cadged crackers and cheese and celery from our cooler. In the process, Michael woke up. Lisa and Fiona ran off to play somewhere, but Michael just sat on the blanket with his arms around his knees, staring off into space.
"Do you want to swim some more?" I asked. He just shrugged. I sat down next to him and put my arm around him.
"How are you feeling?" I asked after a while.
"I dunno," he said in a dull voice.
"I'd like to know, if you can tell me," I said quietly.
He looked at me, examining me closely. He looked puzzled and about to cry. "Why?" he asked, almost under his breath.
Now it was my turn to be puzzled. "Well," I said helplessly, "I guess -- if you're happy, it makes me happy, and if you're sad, it makes me sad. And I want to figure out how to make you happy." I sounded like an idiot.
"Why w--" He cut himself off. He looked forward again. "I just feel funny," he finally said.
Michael was quiet all through dinner. By the time we got home, he just looked tired and fell asleep in the bath. Jerry and I had to dress him for bed.
Sunday was quiet. Michael happily participated in the church service, but hung back from the other children after the service. When we got home, he just wanted to read by himself and went to bed right after dinner.
Memorial Day was a busy day. I took Michael and Lisa to watch the parade, while Jerry, Tom, and Sue set things up in the barbecue area we'd reserved in the park. When the kids and I got to the park, we could see that a lot of other people had had the same idea -- every barbecue area was occupied, and the playground was full of children. Fiona was there with her friend Emily, who fortunately seemed to get along well with Lisa and Michael. I noticed that they stuck together, perhaps because there were some rather rough boys who might have been tempted to push one or two smaller children around, but were reluctant to challenge a gang of four children led by two feisty girls. They ranged all over the park, sometimes disappearing in the wooded parts of the park, sometimes popping up to demand sandwiches or money for ice cream from the ice cream truck.
Fiona's and Emily's families had set up shop two grills down from us, so when dinnertime rolled around, the girls tried out the food from both groups. Sue had evidently had experience with this and had already confirmed that it was okay with them. Fiona and Emily's group was making Polish sausage and grilled chicken, while we were serving hamburgers and hot dogs and grilled corn. The three girls happily ate food from both family groups, but Michael didn't feel comfortable with it and restricted himself to hot dogs.
"I thought you liked chicken. And you could try a bit of the sausage."
"I dunno. They might get mad at me."
"But they said it was okay."
"I dunno. I guess I'm just stupid." He put his elbows on the table and held his face with his hands. He turned a little to watch the fire. I stroked his back, but he didn't react. When it came time to pack up, he helped carry stuff, but didn't say much. We got home after dark, and he just wanted to go to bed. I kissed him good-night and he smiled at me.
I woke up in the middle of the night again, I think because he wasn't crying. It was a little after three a.m. I used the toilet, then looked in on Michael. I couldn't see him, so I turned on the hall light. The bedclothes were thrown back and the bed was empty. I checked the hall toilet -- no Michael. I turned on the overhead light in his room. I saw that his pyjamas and overnight underwear were on the bed and one of the drawers in his bureau was half open, but there was no sign of Michael. The window was open as was the screen. Oh, my God! I thought: Michael is gone!
------------------------------------------------------------
I woke up Jerry. "Michael's not in his bed and I can't find him." He got up and the two of us searched the house. Our stumbling around woke Margie, who joined us. We checked all the rooms, under beds, behind chairs and couches, the back of closets. Margie looked in all the crawl spaces. We looked all around the front and back yard, under bushes, and even under the back porch. Michael was nowhere to be found.
We finally called the police. Someone came by and took our statements, looked all over the house and yard, and took a photo we had of him. I also got him to agree to notify the State Police, pointing out that he'd gone pretty far the last time he ran away.
Jerry had to work, so he went back to bed. Margie and I drove around the neighborhood with a flashlight looking for him.
By morning, we realized we weren't going to find him this way. I left a message with Dr. Conroy and Margie and I worked on putting together a notice we could copy and post up all over the place. Dr. Conroy called back a little before nine. I told her everything I could remember about what he did and how he was from Friday on.
"I'm worried that he's going to run another few hundred miles away and this time he actually will die of pneumonia."
"I don't think either is likely. It's good you asked to have the State Police notified, but I suspect he's within a few miles of home."
"Why?"
"He's very attached to you all. Especially you."
"Me? I know he's close to Margie, but ...."
"In our sessions, he talks a lot about you. It's obvious to me. He's afraid to get attached to anyone and won't admit it, though."
"Do you think he'll come home on his own?"
"He might. His pride might prevent him, though. He'd see coming home on his own as failure."
Margie and I got the poster copied and went all over the place posting them. Margie scouted out back yards while I drove around asking gas station attendants if they'd seen him, since they're outside a lot. Margie thought he'd probably hide, so I looked behind shopping malls and under bridges. We'd look for an hour or so; then, when we'd gotten discouraged, we'd go home and eat and rest and check with the police. Then we'd go out again.
When Jerry came home, we made a quick dinner and went out together. Margie remembered that he'd mentioned that one good place to hide was behind gas stations which had a dumpster next to the building, so he'd be sheltered by the dumpster and the wall. So we went to practically every gas station and convenience store and fast-food place, looking at their dumpsters. Most had dumpsters behind fences or out in the open somewhere. By now, it was getting dark, so when we found a suitable one, we'd shine a flashlight under it. At the fourth one, behind a gas station, we saw cardboard under the dumpster and between the dumpster and the building. Margie slithered behind the dumpster, up to the cardboard. We soon heard her talking in a coaxing voice, like you'd use to calm an animal. Jerry and I stationed ourselves around the dumpster in case he tried to run. Margie kept talking and finally she backed out, followed by Michael. Margie held his hand and helped him to his feet.
He had a dazed and frightened look. He smelled of pee. Even in the dim light it was obvious that he was incredibly filthy. I hated to think where he'd been. As soon as he saw me, he started babbling, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry," over and over. I opened my arms and said, "it's okay, honey, don't worry. We're just happy we found you." He approached me hesitantly, still saying "I'm sorry." I picked him up and held him and said, "thank God you're okay." I kept saying, "it's okay, don't worry, it's going to be okay" until he settled down. I got into the car, still holding him, and the four of us drove slowly home.
When we got home, we gave him something to eat and drink and then put him in a bath to soak the filth away. He was pretty out of it by then. As I was sitting with him in the bathroom, he asked sleepily, "are you mad at me, Mommy?" It was the first time he'd called me Mommy; in fact, the first time he'd used any name at all for me.
"No, honey, I'm not mad. I was really scared, though. I was afraid we'd lost you forever."
"I was really scared, too."
"I'm sure you were. I'm glad we have you back and can keep you safe." I washed his hair and Jerry and I got him dressed for bed. I decided to bring him into bed with us, putting him between Jerry and me. "I won't be able to sleep if I don't know where he is," I explained.
In the middle of the night I heard him whimper. I put my arm around him. He snuggled up to me and quieted down.
------------------------------------------------------------
The next morning, Jerry and Margie let Michael and me sleep in. Around eight, I decided we'd better get up. Michael was still snuggled up against me. I said, "time to get up, sleepyhead," and gently shook him. He opened his eyes and, after a second or so, he stiffened and his eyes grew wide with fear. I stroked him and gently said, "it's okay, Michael. Everything's okay." For a moment or so, I was afraid he'd bolt, but he slowly relaxed, but only a little.
"Why--?" he croaked.
"Why are you in our bed? I ... I felt safer having you here, where I could touch you and know you were still here. I got so scared when you -- disappeared."
He started to cry again. "I'm sorry, I'm sorry."
"Hush, it's okay, you're back and you're safe. That's what's important. Now do you want to get dressed and eat breakfast, or do you want to cuddle first?" He still looked scared, too scared to make a decision, so I sat up and pulled him into my lap. I rocked him until he relaxed. I sent him to get dressed while I showered and dressed for the day.
Dr. Conroy's office called while we were eating breakfast to tell us she could see us at 10:30.
"I thought I see her tomorrow?" Michael asked when I told him, as we were sitting on the couch.
"She wants to talk to you about yesterday. We want to understand why you ran away."
He looked at me anxiously. I put my arm around him. "You're not in trouble. We just need to understand."
He leaned against me. After a while he spoke. "I don't know. I just got really scared. Everything was so scary. Everybody was so scary. I just wanted to hide where no one could find me. So I'd be safe."
I couldn't resist asking, "and did you feel safe?"
"No," he said, half sobbing. "I tried all over, but there weren't any places where no one could find me. And they were all wet and smelly and dirty. That dumpster, you know, that place where you found me, was the best, but it still wasn't any good. And I felt really awful. 'Cause I knew I'd blown it. I knew you wouldn't want me any more, 'cause I'd been so bad. I wished I were dead. Well, not really but sort of."
"Oh, honey, we did want you. I noticed you were gone in the middle of the night and we spent all night and all next day looking for you until we found you."
"You did?? I thought you'd figure I'd just come back when I got hungry. That's what my parents said when my brother ran away. And when he did come home, I think they kind of laughed at him for being so stupid. They told it like a funny story."
"Laughed at him? That's so horrible. We hoped you'd come home, but we were afraid you wouldn't. Or couldn't."
"By the way," I continued, "did you manage to get anything to eat or drink while you were gone?"
"No, I was too busy hiding."
"You could have raided the kitchen and taken something with you.
A long silence ensued while he played with his shirt tail. "I never thought of that."
"Well, if you run away again -- I hope you never do, if you're ever scared, please come to talk to me, or Margie, or somebody -- but if you do ... please take some food and water with you. When you were brought to the hospital, they said you were malnourished and dehydrated, and that was worse than the pneumonia. I don't want you to leave, but if you do, I don't want you to starve. I want you to be okay, wherever you are."
He still looked forlorne, so I cuddled him on the couch until it was time to go.
"Do you think Dr. Conroy will be mad at me, Mommy?" he asked plaintively on the way to her office. Once again, he'd called me Mommy, I noticed.
"I don't think so. I think she just wants to understand why you got so scared."
We got there a little early, so I read him The Runaway Bunny. "See, you ran away, but we looked until we found you, just like the bunny's mommy."
When we finished, I noticed Dr. Conroy standing there, smiling at us. "Come, my runaway bunny, it's time for your session."
Once they were in her office, I heaved a sigh and started reading the book again. I thought about how he'd called me 'Mommy' twice now, and I had to admit, it really made me feel good. I wondered, not for the first time, if I was making a mistake by caring so much. It always hurt so much when they left, and I could count the scars on my heart. And I had fallen for Michael more than for any of the others, so it hurt even worse when he left. But -- this is how I am. This is who I am. And if I didn't give my heart so freely, I'd feel only half alive.
"Mrs. Davidson?" the receptionist called. "Dr. Conroy would like it if you came into her office."
Michael was sitting on the couch. Dr. Conroy was in an armchair facing the couch. I sat down next to Michael and tried to put my arm around him, but he pulled away. I let him be.
"Michael is worried that you're angry with him," began Dr. Conroy.
"I've told him several times that I'm not," I protested.
"I'm afraid people have not always been honest with him in the past." I could guess which 'people' she meant. "I'm asking you to be completely honest, even if it seems -- unkind."
"Well ... I was pretty upset. I mean I was afraid of what might happen to him. I was worried about his state of mind."
Dr. Conroy looked thoughtful. "How did you feel when he pulled away from you just now?"
"I don't know. Maybe a little hurt." She just looked at me. "Okay, maybe more than a little." I didn't want to look at Michael. Dr. Conroy kept looking at me, waiting. "You think -- when Michael -- I was scared, but also hurt and angry, too?"
"It's not what I think that matters."
"I guess I felt ...." I felt boxed in. I didn't really want to think about this stuff. I sighed. "I felt I'd taken him in, put all the love I have into him, tried to make him feel wanted, and he just --" I felt tears come to my eyes. "-- threw it away. Didn't we matter? Didn't he care? I'm sorry, Michael, I know it's not fair, you've had such a hard time and I'm just thinking about myself ...."
I couldn't say any more. I was looking at Dr. Conroy, afraid to see Michael's face; I was sure I'd destroyed whatever connection we'd developed in the past two weeks. I felt a hand on my shoulder and then felt Michael snuggling up to me. "Don't cry, Mommy." I finally turned to face him. I saw tears in his eyes, too. He reached around to hug me and I hugged him back. "I'm sorry I made you sad. I want to make you feel better."
"It makes me feel better when you hug me," I said.
"I don't know why I ran away. I just got so scared! I didn't want to hurt you."
"I know you didn't, honey. Maybe Dr. Conroy can help you figure out why you were so scared. I'm just glad to have you back."
"You see," said Dr. Conroy. "People can be upset with one another and hurt one another and still love one another and get over it. I'm speaking to both of you, by the way."
I couldn't help laughing through my tears. "So I'm a bit of a runaway bunny, too?" She just smiled.
"I'd like to talk with Michael a little more, one on one."
"Okay, Michael," I said as I gave him one last hug. "I'll be waiting for you."
"Me, too, Mommy. Bye."
After his session, we came home, had lunch, and then I cuddled him for a while on the couch. "I'm going to need a lot of cuddling from you to make up for your running away," I told him.
"Oh, that's too much work!" he giggled.
After a while, he asked. "Mommy? Is it okay if I call you Mommy?"
"Of course, sweetie."
"I mean, I have a real Mom, and Dad, too, and I feel like I'm not supposed to call anyone else Mom or Dad. It's just -- you're sort of being a mommy to me now."
"You know, when I got married, I called my husband's parents 'Mom' and 'Dad.' Even before. I guess because they really welcomed me into their family. When we got together for the wedding, I had to call them 'Mom Davidson' and 'Dad Davidson' so people wouldn't get confused as to who I was talking about."
He lay against me, playing with the buttons on my blouse. "Mommy, since it's Wednesday, should I do the laundry?"
"Only if you want to."
"It's like I want to earn my keep. You've done so much for me."
"Honey, you don't need to do anything. You're earning your keep just being you."
"Is it okay if I do it anyway?"
While Michael was running around doing the laundry with his usual overkill, Dr. Conroy called. I filled her in with all that had happened since we'd talked Tuesday morning.
"I think it meant a lot to him that you all went to such trouble to find him," she said. "I think, even thought it was scary for all of us, it's also been kind of a turning point for him. He's a little more open in the session. I think your admitting you were hurt and crying touched him as well."
"You know, he's been calling me 'Mommy' sometimes."
"I noticed."
"I hope he isn't feeling he's being disloyal to his real mother."
"Honestly, I don't know. He won't talk about his mother at all. I can get him to say a little bit about other people in his family, but if I had only what he says in session to go by, I'd wonder if he had a mother."
"Have you talked to her? I'm amazed she hasn't come by to see him."
"Yes, that is odd. I've spoken to her a few times on the phone, and she's pleasant and charming, but it somehow hasn't ever worked out for her to visit. I'm reluctant to talk to her about what Michael has said to you or in our sessions without having more of a feel for her, but she hasn't asked, either."
"I'm afraid they're going to show up one day and take him away. Selfish, I know."
"I don't think it's selfish. You care about him like a mother."
That night, Michael wanted to sleep in his own bed, and I reluctantly agreed. I read him and Margie -- and Jerry -- The Runaway Bunny again and kissed him good night. I prepared myself to get waked up again.
But instead, in the middle of the night, I heard him say "Mommy?" I woke to find him standing next to the bed. I nudged Jerry to move over and slid over myself and he got in next to me. I put my arm over him and he snuggled up to me. We slept well.
------------------------------------------------------------
The next few weeks went smoothly. His weekdays were spent in therapy sessions, tutoring and homework, a few chores, visits to the pool, and hanging out with Margie. He loved being with her and doing things with her, it didn't matter what. They got to doing each others' hair and talking about some of the subjects Margie was taking in school which Michael found fascinating. If Margie had a chore, he usually found a way to help so that it went faster, or at least seemed to.
Saturdays, he usually spent getting worn out by Lisa and whichever of her friends she had over. When she wasn't free, he'd hang out with the Three Musketeers. Sundays he went to the church service, but still didn't socialize with the other children, and in the afternoon he'd relax or go to a movie with Jerry and me.
He still had bouts of feeling like he was no good or like he didn't belong, which Margie or I could always cuddle away. He called me 'Mommy' regularly and even called Jerry 'Daddy.' Margie was 'Sis,' and she would sometimes call him 'Sis,' too, which always made him laugh.
He still woke up in the middle of the night a few times a week, but now he'd just crawl into bed with us, which I didn't mind. Jerry took it in good humor, for which I was grateful.
It was on a rainy Saturday afternoon a few weeks after he'd run away, just as school was ending for the summer, that things took an -- unexpected turn.
The previous day, Lisa and her friends had had no school, but Sue had to work, so I took Lisa and Michael over to Fiona's house. They'd done their usual running around and then (after lunch) repaired to Fiona's room. When I peeked in a little later, Lisa and Fiona had changed out of their shorts and T-shirts into dresses, but Michael was still in his orange girl shorts and mint green tee. They were playing some kind of adventure where Fiona's Barbie and Michael's teddy bear were rescuing Fiona's baby doll from her stuffed whale, which they were pretending was a giant shark that could fly. Fiona's mother Claire explained the clothing change that the girls like to play dress up with Fiona's clothes and changing after playing outside was a regular thing. Later, when they were all three asleep in Fiona's bed, I saw that the girls had changed yet again.
The next day, the Three Musketeers were over at our house and agreed to watch Michael in the afternoon so that Jerry and I could go out as just a couple. We had a nice lunch, walked in the rain, and necked in the car like lust-crazed teenagers. We got home in time to make dinner. I went down to the 'wreck room' to say hi to Michael and the girls. I saw the three girls, plus a young girl I didn't recognize in a pretty blue dress, white tights, Mary Janes, and a hairband. I was about to ask, 'who is she?' when she turned around and, as soon as she saw me, freaked out and started babbling, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry." It was then that I realized that it was Michael.
I immediately tried to calm him down. "It's okay, honey, you're not in trouble, nothing's wrong." I opened my arms and he fearfully approached me. I gave him a big hug and picked him up, saying, "it's okay," but he was still hysterical. Jerry showed up to find out what the fuss was about and I handed Michael to him.
"Can you take him to his room and calm him down?" I asked.
"Do you want me to get him changed?"
"I'd rather he stay dressed so I can talk to him about it, if you can manage it without him changing. I need to talk to the girls, first, though. Michael, sweetheart: Daddy's going to take care of you. You're not in trouble, you just need a chance to calm down a bit, and I need to talk to the girls. Just go with him, and I'll be up in a little while."
Jerry took him upstairs, saying things to him like, "don't worry, nobody's mad, you're not in trouble." He sometimes really amazes me, the way he just steps up when we need him.
As soon as Jerry and Michael had left, I turned to the girls.
"We're really sorry, Mrs. Davidson," Becky started in. "We didn't mean to --"
I cut her off. "You've done nothing wrong and you've nothing to be sorry for. I'm not upset at seeing Michael like this, just surprised. What I'd like is for you all to tell me what happened, so I know how to handle him; I doubt I'll be able to get a coherent account out of him."
They looked at each other. Becky started. "Well, we were talking about shopping. You know, just looking at stuff you know you'll never by, trying stuff on. And we were talking about how we'd seen some really pretty stuff, you know, the kind you'd love to have even though you don't have any place to wear it. And Michael said he wished he could have gone with us."
"You know how he is about pretty," Margie put in.
"We weren't sure at first that he wasn't just messing with us," Becky continued. "But then he talked about how yesterday Lisa and Fiona were trying on some of Fiona's things, and how pretty they looked. I had a feeling he might have been jealous."
"Oh, we could tell," said Astrid. "It was pretty obvious. He just didn't want to admit it."
"So when he finally did admit it, I said, why don't you try something on yourself? I wasn't really serious, I was just sort of teasing. He said no, but you could tell he liked the idea."
"So Becky and then Margie started saying how cute he'd look," said Astrid. Margie looked very guilty at this. "And eventually he said he'd try it as long as we promised to make sure nobody would find out."
"He must really trust you," I said.
"We also promised not to tease him," added Margie.
"So Margie got some of her outgrown things from the attic and she and Becky got him dressed up."
"He really did look cute," said Margie.
"Like a real girl," said Becky. "He really got into it. He was looking at himself, feeling the dress. He wanted to see himself in a full-length mirror. Then you came home. Look, we're really sorry. If we'd known he'd get this upset--"
"Don't be sorry," I interrupted. "He gets upset easily. You say he seemed to be enjoying it?"
"Oh, yeah," said Astrid. Becky and Margie nodded agreement.
"I'm glad. Now I need to go up and talk to Michael. Can you all stick around for a while? I'd like to bring him back down, but I have to talk to him first. If you want, you could stay for dinner."
I could see that they were still uncomfortable. "Please understand, I am not in any way upset with you. I'm glad Michael has such caring friends in his life. I don't see this as bad; actually this explains some things about him. Now, I need to go up and see to Michael. It may take a while."
"Should we make dinner?" asked Margie.
"Dinner? Oh, God, yes! I would be most grateful if you would take care of that for me. It would be a load off my mind."
Michael was sitting in Jerry's lap. He wasn't crying any more, but he wasn't happy, either. As soon as he saw me, he started say, "I'm sorry" over and over again.
I squatted down next to him. "Michael, it's okay. You've done nothing wrong. You've nothing to be sorry for." I kept saying this until he quieted down again.
"The girls told me you looked pretty in that dress. Could you stand up and let me see how pretty?" I had to remind him that he wasn't doing anything wrong before he would consent to slide off Jerry's lap and take a few steps.
"The girls were right, you do look pretty. Can you twirl? Dresses always look better when you twirl." Obediently, he twirled. "Do you want to look at yourself in the mirror?" I walked him over to the full-length mirror on the closet door. He stared in wonder at his image.
"I look like a girl," he said finally. He looked anxiously at me over his shoulder. "But I'm a boy. Boys aren't supposed to look like girls, are they?"
"At your age, boys and girls don't look very different."
That was the wrong thing to say. He started crying. "I'm not supposed to want to look like a girl. I'm supposed to hate it. What's wrong with me? Why am I always wrong? Wrong! Wrong! Wrong!" I had taken him into my arms by then, but he thrashed around and started hitting his head with his fists. "I hate myself! I wish I were dead!" I held him tighter. He hit himself a few more times, not very effectively, while shouting "Dead! Dead! Dead!", then slumped against me. "Why am I like this? Why do I have to be me?" I held him and rocked him as he cried. "I wish I could just go to sleep and never wake up." I couldn't help crying myself, to see him in so much pain.
I just held him for the longest time, sitting on his bed. Eventually he ran out of tears, as one always does. I felt his body pressed against my breast, his head on my shoulder. Sometimes that's all you can do for someone, just be with them in their pain.
"I don't think there's anything wrong about you. I don't think there's anything wrong with you, or any boy, wanting to wear a dress or wanting to look like a girl. I know Jerry doesn't, and Margie doesn't, nor do her friends. I think you're just right, just the way you are." He didn't say anything, nor did I expect him to. Michael understood the language of hugs and caresses, of physical contact, better than words, anyway.
Jerry knocked on the open door. "Dinner is ready."
"We'll be down in a moment. Can you find Michael's apron? We don't want to get food on his nice dress." I slid him off my lap and we walked down to the dining room, hand in hand.
------------------------------------------------------------
For the next few days, Michael went back to his usual routine and acted as if the 'dress episode,' as we called it, had never happened. The only difference was that sometimes he would wake up crying again and either he would come into our bed or I would go and bring him, and he would cry himself to sleep nestled up against me.
I'd left a message for Dr. Conroy, explaining the situation, and on Monday afternoon she called me.
"I'm not sure what to do," I said. "On the one hand, he seemed to like dressing like a girl, at least until he saw me. On the other hand, he got all upset because he felt like he was doing something wrong. I've been mostly trying to help him feel like he didn't do anything wrong, he spends too much time as it is thinking he's all wrong. We put the dress in his closet, in the back, to communicate that we don't think there's anything wrong with it. But I don't know what's best for him. So many people wouldn't understand and maybe it's better to nip it in the bud. And I'm only the foster mother, someday they'll place him and ...." I couldn't go on. The idea of him someday leaving us was something somehow too painful to think about.
"I'd not push him either way. Right now, he needs unconditional acceptance more than anything. Once he's in better shape, he'll be better able to deal with the demands of society."
"I was thinking of giving him more of Margie's old clothes. What do you think?"
"That sounds okay. Don't make a big deal out of it. Just put them in his room, but out of the way, and don't say anything about it. If he doesn't want them, he can assume you're just storing them there. If he asks -- take it from there."
"Has he talked to you about any of this?"
"I mentioned it, but he didn't seem to want to talk." She sighed. "He's that way about a lot of things."
Over the next few days we put some of Margie's outgrown clothes in his room. But he ignored them; if anything, he avoided even the clothes he had picked out himself, choosing instead to mostly wear the drab boy clothes I had picked out.
All that changed on Friday. Sue had to work again, so I had Lisa, and I was going to take Michael, Lisa, Fiona, and Emily to the Children's Theater production of The Thief of Baghdad. Michael had tutoring in the morning, so Lisa got to explore his room. She must have found Margie's clothes, because as soon as he got out of tutoring, she dragged Michael into his room and when they emerged an hour later, he was wearing his pink cap-sleeve tee with a brown knee-length skirt, white knee socks, and pink sneakers, and his hair was braided in two pigtails like Lisa's (only shorter) secured at the ends with pink barrettes. Lisa announced that 'they' had decided that he was now 'Amanda', but we should call him -- or rather her -- 'Mandy.'
I asked Michael if he was okay with it, and he replied "yes" in a small voice with a goofy smile. I shook my head. She was already a force of nature now, I wondered what she'd be like in ten years or so.
Fiona and Emily were dropped off, fortunately only a half-hour later. Fortunately, because Lisa had been leading 'Mandy' in a thorough search of the house and I'm not sure what state it would have been in if they'd gone on much longer. I fed them cheese sandwiches, except for Emily, who preferred ham. Fiona and Emily agreed that, though they liked Michael, Mandy was even better, because they could do more girl things with her.
When they piled into the car, they looked like any four elementary school girls. Mandy fit right in, though Mandy was clearly the shy one. During the show, Mandy shouted out warnings just like the rest when it looked like the thief was about to be caught by the sultan's guards. And during the intermission, when the girls went to the ladies' room, Mandy was dragged along with them. I didn't hear any screams, at least not more than usual, so I assume all went well. After the show, I took them out for ice cream, and you couldn't tell that Mandy hadn't been a girl all her life. (She did keep saying "eating ice cream is too much work" and then laughing hysterically, so I had to explain.) I dropped Fiona and Emily off at their homes and took Lisa and Mandy to the park, where they swung on the swings and talked.
As I watched Michael looking so alive and free, I felt happy, too. I had to admit, I liked him better as Mandy. I wasn't sure if that was because he was happier and more open as a girl, or because I wished I had a little girl in my life again, now that Margie was practically gone and didn't need me. Oh, well, I said to myself. They'll place him someday and it won't matter which. But then I felt my heart drop through the floor. I imagined him in a family that would force him to be a boy all the time, maybe even a boy like Will, and it felt like seeing someone killing puppies.
That night, after Michael's bath, I cuddled him. He was still wrapped in a towel and I found myself imagining him as an infant. What was he like, back before whatever it was that made him hurt and despair so much? What would it have been like to cuddle him and feel his warm, small body against mine back then?
"You had quite an exciting day today, honey. How are you feeling now?" He didn't say anything for a while.
"I guess I liked it. I liked being part of the gang. Like I was just one of the girls. But -- I'm not supposed to like it." He started to cry. "I'm supposed to hate it. Why am I like this? I can't do any of the boy stuff right. I'm a wuss. I'm a stupid sissy. I even still wet the bed. Why do I have to be me? I'm just no good." He sounded so lost.
"I think you're very good. And so do a lot of people. Margie and her friends, Lisa and her friends. You're only not good at being what some other people say you're supposed to be. You're like the ugly duckling. Everyone called him ugly because he wasn't good at being a duck, but he was really a swan and was good at being a swan. I think you're good at being you. And I think you'll be even better if you just try to be you and don't worry so much about what other people think you're supposed to be."
He just lay against me and sighed. "Yeah, but it's like the only thing I'm good at is being a girl."
------------------------------------------------------------
Saturday morning, Michael just wanted to sit in his room and read. He didn't even want to hang out with Margie and her friends. When she asked if he were mad at her, he said, "no, I'm just peopled out." He did give her a hug before going back to reading.
Sue called around mid-morning. "Lisa wants to know if Michael can come over and play. Only she says his name is Mandy now."
"I can check with Michael, but I think he just wants to be alone today. I think yesterday's excitement was a little much for him."
"What's with the Mandy thing, and him dressing in girls' clothes? I mean, I have nothing against it, he can dress however he wants, but I'd just like to know where it's going. Like, what should I call him?"
"I don't know. I don't think he knows. He's always liked 'pretty' things, I think that's the attraction. And he gets along well with girls and not with boys. He really feels mixed up about it."
"Well, Lisa would like to see him, whatever he's called. Is he going up to the pool?"
"Maybe in the afternoon. It's supposed to be really hot today. Jerry wants to do some yard work, but I think I'm going to tell him that in my professional opinion it's too hot and being in the pool is a lot healthier."
For lunch, we just had cold sandwiches. It was already pretty hot, so about a half-hour later, I easily convinced Jerry to go. I told Michael, "we're all going to the pool. It's too good a day to spend it all indoors."
He put on his trunks and swim shirt. I asked, "hot as it is, do you really need a shirt."
"I don't like it when people can see ...." Something I'd expect a girl to worry about, I thought, not a boy.
At the pool, I found Sue's encampment and dragged over the last free lounge chair, while Jerry went to talk with some friends of his. Michael set up on the blanket to read. When adult swim came, I asked Michael to watch our stuff while Sue and I swam. We came back to find Michael in tears and Lisa and Fiona chanting "come on, Mandy" in a sing-song voice. Sue led Lisa and Fiona off while I tried to calm Michael down.
"They came over and asked me to play, only they called me Mandy. I asked them to stop calling me Mandy, but they wouldn't, they just kept on calling me Mandy in a real loud voice so the other kids would hear and make fun of me. I kept asking them to stop but they wouldn't stop! They wouldn't stop!"
I held him and comforted him and told him Sue and I would make sure they stopped. Once he was mostly calm, I told him I was going to go over and talk to Sue.
Sue was already giving them a talking-to. I told them what Michael had said.
"Didn't you hear him asking you to stop?" asked Sue.
"But Mandy is such a nice name," said Lisa. "I don't get why he doesn't like it."
"It doesn't matter why. He asked you to stop, so you should have stopped. Couldn't you see how upset he was getting?"
"But it's silly to get upset by something like that."
"It may seem silly to you, but it wasn't to him."
"He didn't mind yesterday."
"Maybe he felt differently yesterday. Today he asked you to stop. You should have respected that. Do you want him to keep being your friend?"
"Yeah?" she said in a puzzled voice.
"Then you have to respect his feelings, even if you don't understand them."
I went back to reassure Michael, and about ten minutes later, Sue, Lisa, and Fiona came over. Lisa was holding her hands in front of her and looking at the ground as she spoke.
"Michael, we're sorry we called you Mandy when you asked us to stop. We know it wasn't a nice thing to do. Can we still be friends? We promise we won't call you Mandy unless you say it's okay."
"Me, too," said Fiona in a sad voice.
"You're still my friends," he answered with tears in his eyes.
"You want to play?" asked Lisa.
"I'm not in a playing mood today. I'm not mad, I just want to be alone." He noticed me. "Except for Mommy. I just want to be quiet with her."
Lisa looked like she was about to say something, but Sue rather dramatically cleared her throat. Lisa said to Fiona, "let's go play and leave him alone. Like he asked."
Lisa and Fiona went off and Michael went back to reading. I sat down next to him and put my arm around his shoulder. He leaned against me. When he finished the page he was reading, he asked, "why am I so messed up? They were just trying to be friendly, why did I get so upset? I'm supposed to -- I don't know what I'm supposed to, I just know I'm not doin' it. I'm a lousy friend. I'm no good for anybody or anything."
"No, you're a good friend. All yesterday you went along with what they wanted and you didn't reject them when they were mean to you today. Honey, these things happen, but if you're good friends, you work things out and stay friends."
"But I don't want to play with them today."
"That's okay. Sometimes even the best friends need time to themselves. Jerry and I are good friends, but we'd go crazy if we didn't have our own time."
Michael went back to reading, but kept leaning against me.
"Do you want to go in swimming with me?" I asked after a few pages.
"But it's not adult swim."
"Silly, adults can swim any time, not just during adult swim. Let's swim back and forth across the pool."
We got in just beyond the rope and I started swimming on my back. Michael kept up easily, but I could see it took a lot of effort.
"Why don't you try swimming on your back?"
He tried it, but he had trouble staying on top of the water. He was pretty thin, so he didn't have as much fat to help him float. I put one arm under his back and swam with the other arm and my feet. After a while, he stopped swimming and let me tow him along. It was very relaxing, if a bit slow. Of course, we weren't in a hurry to get anywhere.
Michael had to get out when it was adult swim. As he was sitting on the apron watching me swim, I saw Lisa and Fiona come up to him. Lisa in particular looked very contrite.
"Michael, want to play on the playground with us?"
He brightened up and nodded, and the three of them scampered off to the wooded area where the playground was.
------------------------------------------------------------
That evening, Michael was very clingy. He insisted on helping me make dinner, even though there wasn't much to do. Whenever I was in one place, he would come up and lean against me, and I would automatically put my arm around him. I made a point of coming over and rubbing his back when I could, and whenever I did, he would turn and smile at me with tears in his eyes.
Margie came home shortly before dinner, and Michael demanded a hug, but she was not her usual bubbly self. She wasn't very hungry during dinner, and she finally confessed that Brett had broken up with her that afternoon.
After we cleaned up from dinner, she went down to the rec room to watch TV. Michael followed her and sat next to her, leaning against her and rubbing her back. He must have learned it from me, since it was what I always did for him when he was upset, or as close as he could manage. Sometimes she'd start crying, and he'd put his arm around her and say things like, "I know it hurts, but it's gonna be okay." One time when I heard him say it, I looked at him and put my finger to my lips, and when he stopped, I gave him a thumbs up. He finally fell asleep snuggled up next to her, and we put him to bed without a bath.
That night, I woke up in the middle of the night to use the toilet, and I peeked in on Michael. He wasn't in the bed, which got me worried. I looked in on Margie, and saw that he was in her bed with her, and they were both asleep. I decided to leave well enough alone and went back to bed.
The next morning, I asked Michael about it.
"Oh, yeah. I heard her crying in the middle of the night, so I went in to try and make her feel better. I thought maybe she'd feel better if she knew someone who cared was with her. Like you used to do for me. I think it worked, because she stopped crying and went to sleep. I stayed because I figured she might wake up and cry again."
That day, he was still clingy, but was happy enough while we were all together during the church service. When Margie went off with her friends after the service, as usual, Michael wanted to be as close as possible to Jerry and me all afternoon. I had to go off in the middle of the afternoon, and when I came back, Jerry told me Michael was extra clingy.
"He wanted to hold me or be on my lap the whole time you were gone. He also asked if it was okay that he missed you and Margie, but not his Mom or Dad."
"And what did you say?"
"What could I say? I told him, how he feels is how he feels, there's no right or wrong. He's okay whatever he feels." I made a point of leaving a message for Dr. Conroy about it.
Michael got a little less clingy as the week went on. Margie was still sad, and Michael spent a lot of time hugging and trying to comfort her.
On Wednesday, it rained. Sue had to work again, so I watched Lisa, who watched Michael do the laundry. She tried to help, but they ended up arguing a lot because Michael had definite ideas of the Right Way To Wash Clothes. They also ended up playing some weird offshoot of hide-and-seek in the dirty clothes. Becky and Margie got back from summer school at lunch time, and we all went over to Becky's house after lunch. Lisa asked Michael if they could have some 'Mandy time,' so Michael packed up some of his 'Mandy clothes' to bring over. Becky dug out some of her outgrown clothes that were still a bit big for Lisa for Michael to try on, and Lisa and Michael played dress-up, while Becky and Margie offered fashion advice. Michael barely listened. You could see how entranced he was as he looked at himself in the mirror or looked down at his skirt as he swished it and twirled.
Fiona and Claire came by in mid-afternoon and Fiona joined in. Somewhat to my surprise, Michael showed no discomfort at being called Mandy and dressing as a girl all afternoon. When we came home, he went back to wanting to be called Michael, but he was happily still wearing the last dress he'd tried on, and when he wasn't doing anything else, he was looking at and playing with the skirt; he seemed to be marvelling at how it seemed to have a will of its own.
That evening, after his bath, during what I'd started to think of as our 'cuddle time,' I asked him how he felt about the day.
"It was okay." He was focused on playing with the frayed end of the towel.
"Did you like being Mandy?"
"It was okay." A little more fiddling with the end of the towel. "I guess it was kind of fun. Some of the stuff was pretty. I like looking pretty."
"Is it better than being Michael?"
"I dunno." He stopped playing with the towel and turned to face my body more and put his hand on my shoulder. He nuzzled my neck. "I guess I really wish I could just be me."
"And what would it be like to be you?"
"I dunno.... It's like I've been somebody else for so long I forgot how to be me." I could feel his tears on my neck and chest. I just stroked his back and head while he cried his silent tears, and prayed that he'd have a chance to remember -- or relearn -- to be himself. If he stayed with us, I would do my best to help him. He cried for a long time, and when he stopped, I realized it was because he'd fallen asleep.
Michael continued to try to cheer Margie up, even though I had the impression she was managing pretty well on her own by then. I'm not sure his attempts were all that helpful, but she seemed to appreciate the thought, anyway.
Friday night, after dinner, we all four went down to the ice cream shop. A crowd of teenagers came in as we were eating our ice cream, among them Brett, who came over to say hi.
"Hi, Brett," said Margie, making a noble but unsuccessful effort to smile.
"Hope everything's going okay," said Brett.
"It's okay."
Michael stood up and looked Brett right in the face. He had to tip his head back a ways to see him. "I hate you!" he yelled. "You hurt my sister and made her cry for days!"
Jerry and I were saying, "Michael!" in a vain attempt to calm him down. Margie covered her face in embarrassment. Brett just stared, nonplussed. The other teens stopped talking and looked over at us; some were giggling. Michael just stood there, looking defiant.
"Wha-a-at?" Brett said.
"You were mean to her! You shouldn't have been mean to my sister!"
Jerry and I finally got Michael's attention. "Michael," I said, "you don't have to defend your sister. She can take care of herself."
Margie finally got over her embarrassment long enough to speak. "Michael, it's okay. It's what happens between boys and girls. They like each other a lot and want to be together, and later they don't feel that way. I wouldn't want Brett to stay my boyfriend if he didn't really want to be. He's still a good guy even if he breaks up with me. You don't have to get mad at him for me. Sometimes things happen that make you sad and it's nobody's fault."
Brett joined in. "Hey, I think it's cool that Margie has a little brother who's so loyal to her that he gets upset for her sake when she's sad. I wish my little brother had my back the way you have Margie's. All he wants to do is annoy me. And, yeah, I broke up with her, but I still think she's a cool girl. You've got a great big sister and she has a great little brother."
"Yeah," said one of the other girls, "you better treat Margie right, or you'll have Michael to answer to." Some of the teenagers laughed, but they also said things like, "hey, Michael is the greatest."
Michael seemed oblivious to the conversation swirling around him. He looked embarrassed and finally said, "I'm sorry, Brett. I guess I shouldn't have hated you. I didn't really hate you, I was just mad because Margie was so sad."
"That's okay. People get upset and say things they don't mean. But it was great that you said you were sorry. I'd hate to think you'd hate me for the rest of my life."
Brett sat with us for a little while while we finished our ice cream, then got up and returned a few minutes later with a chocolate cone for Michael and a vanilla one for for Margie. That got a smile out of Michael, though I wasn't sure which cone made him smile more.
Margie decided to hang out with her friends, while Jerry, Michael, and I went home. By the time we got home, Michael was in tears again.
"I was so stupid, stupid, stupid! I do everything wrong! Now Margie is going to hate me!"
"No, she's not." I had him on my lap again, as usual. "She was a little embarrassed when it happened, but she'll be over it by the time she gets home. Most of her friends have little brothers or sisters who've embarrassed them. Besides, you really have been a very good little brother, she knows that and I think her friends do, too. Everything's going to be okay, you'll see. Take your bath, get ready for bed, and I'll read to you, okay?"
I had to say 'everything's going to be okay' quite a few times more before he finally went to bed and fell asleep.
When Margie came in, I asked her how it went after we left.
"Oh, it went okay. Everybody told their favorite 'annoying little brother' and 'embarrassing little sister' story. I think they thought Michael was cute, playing the knight in shining armor. And, yeah, it kind of announced to everyone that Brett had broken up with me, but I think everybody knew already, anyway."
"Could you talk to Michael in the morning? He's convinced you hate him now."
"Oh, jeez! It wasn't such a big deal. My friends embarrass me all the time, and we laugh and forget about it." Brave front, I thought. I knew it was often a bigger deal than she admitted. She'd cried on my shoulder often enough.
"I tried to tell him you'd be okay about it, but he didn't really believe me."
Next morning, I heard Margie go into Michael's room. I didn't hear what they said, but after a while, I heard them laughing and joking as they went down to fix breakfast. I love my kids ....
------------------------------------------------------------
The next few weeks went smoothly, for which I was grateful. Quiet times may make for boring reading, but they are a relief for me, and I think they gave Michael a chance to heal a little. He seemed to be getting more secure with us and freer to be himself, even if he didn't believe he knew how. He was beginning to trust us and to trust that Lisa and her friends accepted him. He was mostly pretty comfortable being Mandy with them, even if he was more often Michael. He'd had a few spats with Margie and learned that you can get mad at people you love and still be close to them. He still cried a lot and still had bouts of feeling worthless, but he was getting quicker to trust my love for him and my insistence that he was, indeed, worth something.
So it was on a pleasant, sunny Wednesday morning that the call came that I had been dreading. Michael was doing laundry and I was vacuuming and picking up the common areas of the house when Mrs. Templeton called.
"How are things going?" she asked.
"Things are going very well. Michael seems to be getting happier and more secure. This morning, we're doing some cleaning, then we'll head over to the pool."
"That's good to hear. Dr. Conroy says he's doing better with his depression, too. I'm just calling because Michael's mother, Elizabeth Simmons, is going to be here next week, and she would like to take Michael out for the afternoon on Tuesday, maybe to a museum or a concert."
"I'm glad she's taking an interest in him," I said with an attempt at sounding sincere. "But it's a long way to come for only an afternoon."
"Well, she's really here so we can work out a final placement for Michael."
"Can I be involved? By now, I think I know him pretty well."
"What? No, it wouldn't be appropriate. If you have anything to contribute, you can give it to me or Dr. Conroy and we'll pass it on."
I really didn't know what to say to that. As we finished up the conversation, I was imagining some social worker coming one day to take Michael from us and us never seeing him again. We finished up the chores and headed over to the pool. On the way there, I told him about his mother coming to see him.
"What's she going to do?" he asked.
"She wants to take you to a museum or a concert or something."
"Will she bring me back?"
"To our house? I assume so."
"That's good. There are some books I haven't finished reading."
At the pool, he wanted to stay with me most of the time. Lisa and Fiona were disappointed, and he had to explain that he wasn't mad, he just was 'feeling insecure.' I couldn't blame him, I was feeling pretty insecure, too. We swam together and then sat next to each other on the blanket, not saying anything. Sue got me to go in swimming with her during adult swim while Michael watched from the apron. Lisa came by with Fiona and prevailed upon him to join them on the playground. After adult swim, I went back to where our stuff was to sun myself on the lounge chair, and soon after, Michael came over looking miserable, followed by Lisa and Fiona. You could tell he'd cried a little.
"We were on the playground," said Lisa, "and he got really sad and wouldn't play and cried and some boys called him crybaby and he left and I yelled at them."
I held him and stroked his back until he settled down a little, then asked, "what's the matter, honey?"
"I was thinking how nice it is here with you and Lisa and Margie and all and I kinda want to stay here forever but I'm supposed to want to be with my Mom and Dad and when I see Mom she'll know, she always does, and she'll be so disappointed with me because I'm such a bad kid." He started crying again.
"She was so disappointed in me last time, after I tried to kill myself, the second time. I gave the police a phoney name so they didn't find me for over a day, and she was so disappointed because I lied and I guess because I caused so much trouble and I was so ungrateful and all."
Lisa looked really upset when she heard him say 'kill myself.' I looked at Sue and she nodded, which I hoped meant she'd talk to Lisa about it. Fortunately, I'd warned her about his history, but I was surprised he would talk about it in front of everyone.
Michael started sobbing while he talked. "She was disappointed for, like, forever and I kept screwing up and making her more disappointed and that's why I ran away. I was bad to run away and now I'm going to see her and I'm so bad and don't want to be with them and that's even worse."
I held him while he cried. I couldn't think of anything to say to make him feel better. Sue took Lisa and Fiona away, hopefully to explain things to them. After a while, he stopped crying and just lay against me. Lisa and Fiona came over a little later.
"We're sorry you feel so bad," said Lisa and gave him a hug. "Can you come and play with us when you feel better?" Fiona gave him a hug, too. Michael gave them a weak smile and said "thanks."
We went home early. Michael still didn't want to be separated from me. When I worked in our office, he lay on the floor and read. He stayed in the kitchen when I worked on dinner and he helped where he could. He was very quiet at dinner, where I told Jerry and Margie about the situation. He clung to Margie after dinner until it was time for his bath.
After the bath, during our cuddle time, he got upset. "I'm so bad. And now Lisa and Fiona and them know. I told them I'd tried to kill myself and they won't want to be with me, either. I wish I were dead."
"No they won't. Lisa's mom explained things to them. They don't hate you, they feel sorry for you. They said so, remember?"
He clung to me and cried as I rocked him and told him he was a good boy until he fell asleep in my arms.
In the middle of the night, he started screaming. I went in and he was wide awake and obviously terrified.
"Vampires!" he said when he saw me. I put him on my lap and asked him what he'd dreamed. He was clinging to me in terror and crying.
"I was in bed and vampires started getting into my room. They were squeezing under the door and through where the window is open. And they were going to make me a vampire, too. It was awful! The only way to keep them from turning me into a vampire was to kill myself."
I held him and told him, "don't worry, honey, we'll protect you from the vampires." Once he settled down, I brought him into our bed. He woke me up once more, but he didn't scream, he just clutched me so tight it hurt and whimpered for a while.
The next morning, when we went to his appointment with Dr. Conroy, he wouldn't let go of me. I had trouble getting him to stay in the session without me. Fortunately, I'd already left a message with her about how it was going with him. All day, all he wanted to do was read and be as close to me as possible, except for the times when he wanted to be close to Margie.
That evening, after his bath, Margie got Michael to come into her room for a while to do things with each other's hair, which gave me a break. I lay on the bed while Jerry cuddled me. It had been a while since I'd had the leisure to do that.
"I think I'm almost as upset about Michael's mother visiting as he is," I said. "I'm afraid she'll take him away, or maybe it's that she'll undo everything we've done for him, so he'll be like when we first saw him."
"You've really fallen for him," he said. "Just like I saw that first day." I said nothing. He stroked and caressed me. "Youve been really wanting another child of your own. Ever since we found out we couldn't have any more. The fostering didn't fill that hole, did it?" I felt tears dripping off my nose and cheeks as he gently rocked me.
"Am I so selfish?" I asked. "Am I only thinking of my own needs to believe we'd be a better family for him than his birth family?"
I turned and looked at him with my tear-streaked face and held his arms. "Jerry -- I don't know what I'll do if they take him away from us. I'm hating his mother already. I'm hoping they'll declare her an unfit mother. I'm thinking crazy thoughts. I'm afraid I'll never get over it. I want to say I wish we'd never seen him, but I can't make myself wish that." I let go and flopped against him, the way Michael so often flopped against me.
"Honey, we don't know what will happen. Try not to get yourself worked up over disasters that haven't happened and may well never happen. Michael needs you to keep yourself together so he can feel safe. If he sees you falling apart, it will only make it harder for him. Remember how you managed in the pediatric oncology unit?"
"Yeah, I remember I finally quit because I couldn't take it. Five years of watching children die."
"They didn't all die."
"Too many did, though." I sighed. "I guess I'm just jealous. She's got so many, she can't even be bothered to see him when he's half-dead in the hospital, and I was barely able to have one. It feels so unfair."
"So many?"
"Well, he told us he has brothers. Can't she spare one?"
He continued to hold me. It felt good to feel his strong arms around me, it made me feel safe, even as I was also still so upset.
"You know," he said, "I'll be pretty sad if they take him away, too. I don't get to cuddle him or do things with him as often as you -- I'm actually kind of jealous -- but he's very special to me, too. He's just so much ... I don't know, so Michael. I can't help but love him. It's like our home is so much homier since he's been here. It'll feel empty if he has to leave."
We cuddled a while longer in silence, just enjoying the comfort of one another's presence, until it seemed time to get Michael into bed. That night, though, he woke us up screaming because he'd had the vampire nightmare again.
Friday and Saturday were much the same. He did get his tutoring done and the homework from tutoring. Lisa came over Friday afternoon and tried to get him interested in playing, but he mostly just wanted to be hugged. He had no interest in being Mandy, mumbling that he didn't want to 'disappoint' his Mom, so Lisa went home early. Margie snuggled with him on the couch until it was time to make dinner, reading to him sometimes and sometimes just telling him what a cool kid he was.
Saturday night, he had a different nightmare.
"There was this man, all dark, like he was made out of shadows. He snuck out of the shadows and put a rope around my neck and choked me. I thought I was gonna die, but he stopped and said, 'this is so you'll know what it's like when I come back to kill you for real.'"
After that, he started being afraid of shadows.
By Monday, he was a worse emotional wreck than when we first saw him. He was having stomach pains and diarrhea. Monday dinner, he didn't want to eat, and right after dinner, he threw up. He felt hot and had trouble drinking the pedialyte I gave him. He threw up several times during the night. Another day of this and I'd need to take him to the ER.
When his mother called in the morning, I had to tell her he was too sick to go anywhere, let alone go out with her. She sounded a little skeptical, so I got Michael on the phone with her, and he did sound sick. He only managed a sentence or two before he had to run to the bathroom again.
"I'm only in town for a few days. Since I can't go out with Michael, do you suppose we could get together for coffee or something this afternoon? I'd like to hear how Michael has been doing."
We worked out a time and place. Fortunately, Margie would be home from summer school by lunch time and could take care of Michael in the afternoon.
------------------------------------------------------------
We'd agreed to meet at the Café au Lait, a coffee shop with outside seating in what passes for the artistic part of town. There are trees and small shops, and the coffee shop offers a selection of teas as well as coffee. Since I'm a tea drinker, this was a requirement.
I'd talked to Jerry on the phone, and he'd advised me to be as sympathetic to her as I could. "She'll be more cooperative if you can get her to see you as a friend and not an enemy. Assume she wants the best for Michael, too. You don't know what it's like for her, maybe you wouldn't be able to do any better if you were in her shoes." I'd been saying she's a good mother, she wants the best for him to myself the whole way over. By the time I got there, I was almost even convinced.
Elizabeth Simmons wasn't what I'd expected. I'm not sure what I'd expected except that I'd assumed I would see what there was about her that would explain Michael's utter lack of self-esteem. Instead, she turned out to be a pleasant, even charming, and unassuming woman, about fourty. I felt comfortable with her right away. She turned out to also be a tea drinker, so we made small talk about her trip and about the things to see in our town until our teas arrived.
It looked like she wasn't going to ask about Michael on her own, so I brought it up.
"Did you want to hear how Michael is doing?"
"Oh, yes, I'd love to. Are things going well? I know taking in foster children can be stressful."
"Oh, he's been a joy. He's really bonded with Margie, our teen-age daughter. He's helpful around the house, he's even taken on doing the laundry, and he and Margie sometimes cook dinner for us. There's this idea that children hate chores, but he's not like that."
"I'm glad. You know, children can sometimes be difficult, especially boys. I have four of them, counting Michael."
"Oh? What are they like?"
"Well, there's Collin, he's in high school. He's on the football team. He's having a little trouble with the academics, but he's trying. Our second is Andrew, he's not into sports, but he's bright; we think he'll be an engineer like his father. Doesn't have a lot of friends, though. Michael's our third. He used to be my cuddly one. He plays piano and sings, he's really talented. And he's bright. But I'm sure you know all that by now."
No, I didn't. I don't say it though, I just smile.
"And Peyton, he's the baby of the family. He's always sunny and never any trouble, which is a relief. But he doesn't get much of a chance to say anything, what with all those older brothers. Sometimes he'll try to say something, and by the time we get everyone to shut up, he's forgotten what he wanted to say." She said the last with a laugh.
"Sounds like you have your hands full, with four sons. Margie kept me busy all by herself. It's a little better now that she can get herself around."
Her face began to show more signs of strain. "Oh, you're right, four children is a lot. And you know boys. The older two fight like cats and dogs. Andrew's always deviling Collin until he explodes. And what with Michael always forgetting things -- I'm sure you've noticed how forgetful he is -- and school requirements, there's never a dull moment."
I weighed my words carefully. "Is it any easier with Michael not at home?" I didn't want to seem eager to take him off her hands, even if I was. Think of how she feels, I told myself.
She looked out at the trees and the boutique across the street. "Honestly?..." Her smile slumped. "Honestly, yes. It's not that Michael caused any serious trouble. But there was always something. Missing the bus, homework not done, losing things, not giving us notes from school or losing them. And endless detentions for little things, like talking back or out of turn, or reading in class or not having assignments. I'm able to focus on the older two now." I wondered about Peyton.
"That sounds like a lot to handle. Especially with the older two."
"Oh, goodness gracious, yes. Collin is having a lot of trouble with his schoolwork, we've tried everything. And Andy is always in trouble at school. Fights, really nasty fights, refusing to do things. He terrorizes the younger ones. You know, they're both seeing psychologists. I keep wondering: what did we do wrong? When we decided to have children, I thought we'd be so happy, we'd love them and they would love us, and they'd do Boy Scouts and school and sports and do well -- they're all bright, we're told. Nobody told us about colic, or babies that never were happy and didn't grow the way the books said. Or how tired you get. It seems like they're all trying to prove what a bad mother I am." She was crying by now. I was amazed -- I hadn't thought I'd sounded that sympathetic. "And Michael -- Michael was my good baby, didn't cry much, loved to cuddle. Then Peyton came, and by the time I had time for Michael, he didn't want me any more. Sometimes I could get him to talk about ideas, I love it when we can discuss ideas, but then suddenly he won't want anything to do with me. And he's always having problems that require my attention.
"And lately he lies! The second time he tried to kill himself, some college boys stopped him and took him to the police, and he lied! He gave them a false name and address, and it took a day to find him after we noticed he was gone and called the police. And the police wanted to know why he was trying to kill himself. I felt like such a bad mother. And then the social workers! They poked into everything, like we were terrible people. Why would he do that to me?"
"That sounds overwhelming," I said.
"He even lied in the hospital here. He gave them a false name again and it took them two weeks to figure out who he really was. He made us look like monsters! I felt so ashamed!"
"That must have felt awful."
She looked at me helplessly. I put my hand on her shoulder and she turned to me, tears in her eyes. I slid my chair closer to her and she leaned forward. I took her in my arms and let her cry on my shoulder.
When she stopped crying, I ordered a second round of tea to give her time to compose herself.
"I must sound like a horrible mother," she said.
"No, you sound like someone who is trying her best but has more than even her best can cope with."
"It feels awful to say it, but having Michael out of the house has really helped things. I love him, he was one of my favorite children, but ...."
"I can see why you love him. You've raised a lovely child."
"But I can't handle him. Not on top of everything else."
"Is there anyone you know who can help relieve you of some of the burden? Perhaps take one or two of the children sometimes?"
She looked at me thoughtfully. "You know, my sister once took in one of her classmate's daughters when they were having a rough time with each other. She lived with my sister for several years, and it worked out well for everyone."
"You think that would be a good solution here?"
"Can you be honest? Do you think Michael is doing well living with you?"
A bizarre question -- I'd already said he was just a few minutes ago. "Yes. I think he'd say so, too, and so would Dr. Conroy."
She slowly picked her words. "Maybe ... a good mother ... would want her child ... to be in a situation that was ... good for him ... even if she had to ... sacrifice being with him. What do you think?"
Was this a trick question? "Yes I think so. Wouldn't she be putting her child's needs above her own?"
"I know this is a lot to ask, but how would you feel about Michael staying with you longer term? At least until things settle down at home?"
"I don't see a problem with that. We're enjoying having him with us now. I'd have to discuss it with my husband and I imagine we'd have to run it by Social Services. But since it's what we're doing now, I can't imagine they would object."
"I would be so grateful. I would be relieved to know he is in good hands."
"Why don't you discuss it with Dr. Conroy and I'll run it past my husband?"
"I think that sounds wonderful."
Promising to keep in touch, we embraced and went our separate ways.
------------------------------------------------------------
I decided to tell Michael that his mother was okay with the idea of him staying with us, but I couldn't promise anything yet. He stopped throwing up and started to relax. I wouldn't let him do the laundry on Wednesday, since he'd been so sick. He spent the next few days in his room or on the sofa reading, but he was a lot cheerier and laughed and joked with Margie when she was around.
I left the negotiations to Jerry, and by the time Elizabeth was ready to leave, there was a rough agreement in place, involving guardianship, some financial support from Michael's parents, and putting Michael on our health insurance.
We invited Elizabeth over for dinner the night before she was to return home. Michael was nervous about seeing his mother again, but we tried to reassure him and we at least partly succeeded. When she came in, he went up to her and hugged her with tears in his eyes, and even said, "hi, Mom." During dinner, we told her which parts of dinner Michael had helped with, and each time she smiled at him and said she was proud of him, and he anxiously smiled back.
When it was time for her to go, she hugged him again.
"Now be good, Michael, and don't give the Davidsons any trouble. I do love you, and I'll miss you." Then, barely controlling her tears, she added. "I hope you'll be happy here. Happier than you were ... with us," and quickly went out to her car. Michael cried as she left. When she drove off, he stood on the front porch and waved until she was gone.
That night, during our cuddle time, Michael was again upset. "I'm so bad."
"Why?"
"I've been not liking her, but she was so nice and she just wants the best for me. I should want to go home and be with her, and I don't. What kind of kid doesn't want to be with their mom and dad? What kind of awful kid?"
"You are not a bad kid. You were right not to want to be at home with them. Things aren't good there, and it's better for everyone if you're here and not there. Even she believes that. But you know, it's okay to miss her, too. And to love her and still know you're better off not with her.
"And maybe she can come to visit sometimes. Would you like that? Maybe if you see her when she's here and not at home, you'll get along better."
"You know," he said. "I kinda don't want to see her and kinda do. I kinda want to be at home and kinda don't. I'm all mixed up."
"That's okay. You're a kid, and being a kid means being mixed up about a lot of things. You can talk about them with me or with Dr. Conroy. And we'll be here to protect you no matter what."
He lay against me without saying anything for a while. Then he said, "I feel like I shouldn't have said goodbye. Doesn't that mean you won't see somebody any more? Like when someone is dying and you say goodbye to them?"
"No, it doesn't. It means 'God be with you.'"
"So I was saying, 'God be with Mom'?"
"Yes, you were. And that's a good wish. Your Mom has a lot of hard things to deal with at home. She needs all the help she can get. We're helping her by taking you in. Maybe that's a good way to think of it: by being here and being the kid you were meant to be, you're helping your Mom."
He started to giggle. "So by taking a bath, and playing with Lisa, and brushing Margie's hair, and reading Nancy Drew books, I'm helping Mom? Ooh, I never knew helping Mom could be so much fun!"
"You sure have enough fun when you and Margie make dinner, and you're helping me. But when you're doing these things, and learning to be happy -- that's what Moms want for their kids. Now how about getting dressed for bed?"
Once he was dressed, he crawled back into my lap and I rocked him to sleep. I rocked him long after, enjoying the closeness while he was still young enough to hold like this. And when I tucked his sleeping body into his bed, I placed his teddy bear where he could see Michael and told him, "keep a good watch over him." But in the middle of the night, he crawled into bed with us and clung to me until morning.
------------------------------------------------------------
The fosterage issues were, indeed, worked out, so we were Michael's legal guardians and could make decisions for him without clearing them with his parents. Michael has slowly -- very slowly -- gained confidence and is beginning to come out of his shell.
We found a small school that was known for being accepting and nurturing for him for the fall. They even accept him sometimes coming as Amanda. One time he brought Margie in for show and tell and they wore matching dresses. He's in seventh grade now, and doing very well, socially, psychologically, and academically. He has a few more friends, and we're all helping him learn how to deal with friends. He has a lot of catching up to do.
We bought a small piano and he's taking lessons again and slowly becoming comfortable playing when we're around. He sings in school and is now in the children's choir at church.
His mother visited at the end of August for a day and at our suggestion took him to the zoo and then to the city park to feed the ducks. He was clingy and cried frequently for a few days after that. She came again for a weekend in October and brought Peyton. The Three Musketeers were over and we all went to the park. Jerry played with Michael and Peyton while Michael's mother talked with the girls. She seemed to really enjoy socializing with the girls and Michael was less upset after the visit. She hasn't discussed another visit.
We don't know what the future will bring, not that anyone does, really. We are simply enjoying having him around. I never thought I'd have another young child, and he brings a lot of joy. He is so spontaneous and delights in everything, and it's making us see that our own lives are full of surprising wonders. Christmas is coming and he is happily playing along with the Santa myth, if only for the presents. I think he is beginning to remember -- or is it learn? -- to simply be himself. And what greater gift can one give than that?
"Hey, Fruit Cup. The boss wants to see you!" Joe shouted as he came down the stairs from the store office.
"Can it wait for a minute? I'm helping Nicholas set up a display." I'd taken time out from my shelving duties to help Nicholas with his latest assignment: to assemble a cardboard display for Nabisco's latest attempt at world domination: a 'health' cookie. Assembling these things is a lot like origami and is generally far beyond Nicholas's congitively impaired brain. Nicholas was part of corporate's push to hire handicapped workers and I'd been the only one willing to mentor him enough for him to do useful work, so Calvin, the night manager, was generally happy to cut me some slack.
"The ret--" My glare got him to cut off what he'd obviously planned to say.
"Don't let the boss hear you call Nick that." I'd learned to tolerate being called 'fruit cup,' but I'd be damned if I'd be quiet when people tried to put Nicholas down.
With a lot of directions and me occasionally stepping in, we got the display put together and set up in the correct orientation, so I left Nicholas to stock it while I went to see what Calvin wanted.
"Elise," he said when I came into the office. "One of the morning shift people is unexpectedly unavailable. Can you cover it for the next few days?"
"Is that in addition to my regular shifts?"
"Yes, if you can manage it. Yes, we'll okay the overtime." Brings my 'special fund' closer to where I need it.
"I can do it through Saturday. I'd rather not do Sunday."
"That should be good enough. Besides, even you need to sleep sometime. Can you start this morning?"
"Sure." Who needs to sleep, anyway?
I went back to unpacking and shelving and occasionally walking Nicholas through some task. At six a.m., when the night shift was over, Nicholas came over to me.
"Can I have your telephone number?"
"What for?"
"Well --" He sounded like he was having to think of what to say. "Sometimes I like to talk with my best friend. Only she's busy when we're at work."
My first impulse was to say 'no.' I'd had some calls in the past from people I really didn't want to hear from, and I'd changed the number to stop that. But this was Nicholas, and I guess I had a soft spot for him. "I'm pretty grouchy, especially after work. I wouldn't be a fun person to talk to."
"Oh, I always love talking to you!" I gave up and wrote my number on a scrap of brown paper from the wrapping for a bunch of bags of rice. He thanked me profusely as usual and told me what a good friend I was. I told him he made it easy. Once again I thought: what kind of world is it that just giving the occasional bit of help makes you someone's best friend? I checked in with Craig, the morning manager, and he had me stock produce and then when the morning rush started, do guard duty at the self-checkout lines. Around 7:30, it got crazy and Craig logged me in on a register for a while. The customers were decent to me, which was a relief. With this and that, the time passed and at 2 p.m., I drove home and crashed.
At 8:30 p.m., a half-hour before my alarm went off, I got a phone call.
"Is this Lisa Conner?"
"Yes. Who is --?"
"This is Catherine Sands, Nicholas's mother."
"Is he okay?"
"Oh, yes, quite well. You know, he keeps saying how wonderful you are and how much he's able to do now down at the supermarket with your help. In fact, he keeps asking if we can have you over for a visit. That's why we're calling. We'd like to invite you over for dinner." I groaned inside. Just what I always didn't need: yet again being somebody's freak show for an evening. Nicholas had mentioned me coming over to visit a few times before, but I'd always managed to fend him off. For Nicholas's sake, I tried to be polite.
"That's very kind of you. I should warn you, I'm pretty busy. I'm doing double shifts for the rest of the week and don't really have time to do anything but eat and sleep." I hoped this would put them off long enough for them to forget it.
"I understand. But surely there's some time when you don't have double shifts? I don't mean to press you, but Nicholas would be so disappointed if you can't ever come. He says you don't do much but work, it might do you good to get out."
"Well, I go to church on Sunday mornings."
"How about after church?"
I could see I wasn't going to get rid of them with polite fictions. Time to hit them with the truth.
"Actually, there's something you probably don't know about me, and if you did, you probably wouldn't want to invite me."
"Oh, my, are you, I don't know, some kind of criminal?"
"No, I'm --" I always hate to out myself, but if they ever see me at the supermarket, they'll know, anyway. "You see, I'm a transsexual. Until a few years ago, I was living as a man. And I look it. I'm not like LaVerne Cox or Caitlyn Jenner. I don't look like someone who was born female." I look like an ugly guy in a dress, I thought, but I didn't say it.
Dead silence. "I'll understand if you don't want me over." She put the phone down and had some kind of whispered conversation. Finally, she came back on.
"I don't understand. Are you trying to tell us you really don't want to visit?" Her voice sounded strained.
"Not if it would make you uncomfortable. Most people are around me."
"It's not a problem for us," she stated in a flat voice. "As long as it's not a problem for you. Do you want to think about it for a bit?"
Now I was feeling bad about being so unfriendly. "I'm off from Saturday afternoon until Sunday night."
"Would Saturday evening work for you?"
"Sure. I'll take a nap in the afternoon, after my shift."
"Are you sure? We can make it later."
"Oh, I'll be fine."
"How about 7:30?"
I got the address and directions. It was too late to go back to sleep, so I made a thermos mug of extra-strength coffee and got myself put together for work.
The rest of the week went about as smoothly as could be expected. I was getting maybe a half-hour of checkout experience each day, which might qualify me for a better-paying position. The 16 hour workdays left me exhausted, but it did mean that I slept like a log when I was off and didn't have any nightmares.
Saturday morning is always a madhouse. In our part of town, it's when the working stiffs are off work and can come in to do their weekly shopping, and all the registers are open. Craig had me on a register for much of the morning, and I thought I was doing pretty well until I saw a big guy a few carts back in the line give me the hate stare. I'd seen that a couple of times since I'd transitioned and it alway put me into full fight-or-flight mode, even though they usually didn't do anything more than stare. I felt my knees get weak and my mind fog up. Fortunately, I'd gotten a lot of practice scanning and coding, so I could do it mostly on autopilot. But once or twice I forgot where I was in ringing through and my customer had to remind me. Still, I held out until I was mostly done with the guy before the starer. I was grabbing the last few soda bottles when he spoke.
"Since when do they let faggots in this place?" he announced with a tone of total disgust. "When I was in the army, they knew what to do with pieces of shit like him." My hands were shaking to the point that I had trouble hitting the right keys. The guy I was checking out stared down the aisle away from the hater, the people behind the starer were staring off into space, all too obviously hoping to avoid getting involved.
When the previous guy had paid and loaded his cart, I turned to scan the starer's items.
"Don't you dare put your filthy hands on my stuff. Who knows where they've been? I don't want to get AIDS. Or worse."
"If I can't touch your items, how can I scan them?"
"I don't fucking care. You shouldn't be around decent people in the first place. All I know is I'm not letting some pervert put his hands all over stuff I'm going to eat."
Because the neighborhood isn't the best, every register has a button below the counter that you can hit with your leg to call the manager. Hit it twice in a row, and security comes; at least, that was what I was told. I hit it once and prayed Craig would come before this guy took it into his head to kill me. It looked like he could do me in with his bare hands without working up a sweat.
"There isn't anyone else to handle this register. If you don't like having me check you out, you can always go to another line that's more to your liking."
That got him mad. "I didn't stand in this fucking line for two fucking hours so some perverted tranny freak could make me stand in another fucking line for two fucking hours." He was leaning over the counter with his face practically in mine. For someone who was supposedly so repulsed by me, he was getting awfully close to me. "You know what I oughtta do?" He was flexing his hands above the belt that was full of his beer bottles and cans of food. I didn't say anything. I'd like to say it was because I knew better, but actually it was because I was paralyzed by fear. "I oughtta beat the crap out of you."
We both stood like that for a few minutes.
"I ain't got all day," he shouted.
"If I can't touch your groceries, and you aren't willing to us a different registery, how can you expect --"
"Don't talk to me like that. It's not my problem. It's your problem for being a sissy fag and your queer-loving boss's problem for hiring a sissy fag like you. I'll bet you like to--"
Just as I kneed the button twice, Craig showed up.
"What's the problem?" he asked cheerfully.
"You got this tranny fag trying to get AIDS all over my groceries. You need to get a normal guy here."
"This is who I have," he said in a no-nonsense voice. "You can either let her check you out or you can pack your stuff up and get in a different line."
"Her? That's no her, that's a dude!"
"I won't have you insulting my staff. If you don't want her to check you out and you don't want to go to another line, you'll have to leave." About then, two guys in company polo shirts who looked like former NFL players appeared at the bagging area of the checkout. I'd seen them doing small stocking jobs and nosing around, so I had already figured they were security and doing stocking mostly as way to keep an eye on things without giving themselves away.
The man gave Craig a challenging stare for a few minutes, then pushed his empty cart through the aisle, forcing Craig and the security guys to step back. Once the cart was out of his way, he stomped off, leaving his groceries on the belt. The security people followed him off towards the entrance, as he muttered curses about 'fag-loving pansies.'
"Lisa," he said gently, "put his stuff in the cart and re-shelve it. Then go to the break room. I'll take over the register and run the people already in line through." He looked at the woman at the end of the line. "You're the last one, I'm closing the line after you."
As I loaded the cart, I heard people muttering, "what an asshole!" "The nerve." "No cause to ...." It made me feel a little better that they weren't agreeing with him, but not much. Nobody had been willing to speak up while he was there, after all. When I was done, I pushed the cart around the end past the registers and into the store. There wasn't that much in the cart. I felt like a robot as I put the cans and bottles back where they'd come from.
I sat in the break room staring at the opposite wall, trying to control my breathing. I was somehow able to keep my hands steady, but inside I was shaking. I started to wonder how I was going to come back to work tomorrow night, but then did my best to stifle the thought. I had no choice, best not to even imagine the possibility of not coming back. I made a point of envisioning coming in Sunday night, of piling stacks of boxes on the handtruck and wheeling it out into an aisle. Like counting sheep, I thought. Craig stuck his head in. "Lisa, can you come up to the office? We need to file an incident report."
After we got the report done, Craig wanted to send me home, but I wanted the pay from the remaining hours in the shift and was afraid I'd lose that if I left. He kept me a little longer, saying he wanted to make sure I'd calmed down, then had me do simple jobs that kept me away from the customers. I was grateful to have something to keep my hands busy. At 2:00, I drove home and threw myself into bed without even bothering to undress.
My alarm woke me at 6:00. I dragged myself out of bed, shaved and showered, and put on one of my two moderately dressy outfits, the ones I wear to church and funerals: blouse, knee-length skirt with matching jacket, nude hose, and pumps. I'm not exactly into make-up, but I put on enough to disguise any five o'clock shadow, and added a brooch and a delicate necklace. I debated putting on the wig, but decided covering my bald spot wouldn't be enough for me to even halfway pass anyway. I picked up some flowers at a Korean market along the way and showed up at the Sands' house a few minutes early. Oh, well.
"Hi, I'm Bill Sands, Nick's father." The man who greeted me with a welcoming smile at the door was maybe in his fifties, with greying hair (and no receding hairline, I noticed with envy) and reminded me a little of Harrison Ford. He was wearing a tweed jacket over a beige turtleneck and khaki pants, all that was missing was the pipe.
"I'm Elise Conner," I replied, "pleased to meet you, Mr. Sands," and remembered to extend my hand for a handshake, a lesson drilled into me by my mother. "Oh, call me Bill," he insisted. I had expected at least some hesitation on his part, but either he had enormous self-control or he was one of those rare people who actually didn't care.
"Lisa! You came!" Nicholas had come up behind his father and was bursting with excitement. As Bill was leading me in, Nicholas grabbed me for a big hug. "I'm glad to see you, too, Nick," I said, hugging him back.
A woman done up a lot like June Cleaver came out of the kitchen wiping her hand on her flowery apron. "Hi, I'm Kathy Sands, Nick's mother," she said with a broad smile on her face as she put her arms out for a hug. It took me a few seconds for me to react and I thought I saw a brief twinge of disappointment in her face at the delay, so I approached her and let her hug me. It felt strange and it took me a little while to place the feeling because it was so unfamiliar: it felt good. "Dinner's almost ready," she said, "you all go in the living room, I'll call when it's done." She turned to the hallway beyond the living room and shouted, "yoo, hoo! Bryan! Come down and set the table."
Bill led Nick and me into the living room. "Would you like anything to drink? Soda? Beer?"
"Just water, thank you. I just got up and am still not quite awake." A young man in his twenties who I assumed was the Bryan Kathy had just called rushed past into the dining room.
"Did you have another one of those double shifts today?"
"Yes, but it's the last one. I don't go back to work until tomorrow night."
"Unfortunately, Nick has to work tonight, so he'll have to leave after dinner. But you can stay later, if you want." Bill went to get my drink, while Nick insisted I sit on the sofa with him. I looked around the living room, trying to feel comfortable with being in someone else's home. I felt a little like I'd gotten in on false pretenses and might get thrown out or worse once they found out who I really was, although I couldn't think of anything I hadn't told them. Nicholas saw me looking at the pictures on the wall and started explaining. "That picture's from when we went to Disneyland. I liked Disneyland. All those rides."
A few minutes later, Bill and the young man I'd seen rushing past came in together bringing four glasses. "Elise, this is my younger son Bryan. Bryan, this is Nick's friend Elise."
"Hey, I know you," said Bryan. "You're the guy they call Fruit Cup, right? At the supermarket?"
I tried to pretend it wasn't an insult, but Bill glared at him. "She is a guest," he said icily, "and her name is Elise. I'm sure she doesn't need to be reminded of whatever insulting nicknames her coworkers may use." There was a moment of silence, then Bryan lowered his head and sat down in one of the chairs.
"How is it, working, what, 16 hours straight?" said Bill in a friendlier voice as he sat down in an armchair.
"It's a bit of a grind, but I don't mind. It's not all that stressful, mostly, and it leaves me tired so I sleep well."
"Mostly not stressful?" asked Bill.
"Well, sometimes you get customers who are, uh, difficult."
"Got any good stories, Elise? I've worked in retail," said Bryan.
I shrugged. "There was one this morning. It was crowded and I was on a register. This guy is in line and he keeps giving me this really nasty stare. When he got to the front, he started calling me names and saying he didn't me want to touch his stuff." I was trying to tell it like it wasn't a big deal, but my voice started shaking. "He wouldn't go away, he threatened to beat me up. My manager came, and then some security guys, and they got him to leave. Then he -- my manager -- sent me to put the guy's stuff back and he took over the register." Nicholas put his arm around me and gave me a side hug, Bill just looked distressed.
"Jeez," Bryan started, "what an a--." Bill gave him a warning look. "What a jerk!" Bryan finished his thought. "Are people really that nasty to you? Why?"
"They can see I'm a transsexual." I tried to steady my voice. "A lot of people don't see me as human. Some of my coworkers weren't very nice at first, but Corporate insists that the stores have to be LGBT-friendly and my managers put a stop to the worst. All that's really left is that nickname. They used to call me 'the Fruit', among other things, and that turned into 'Fruit Cup.' I figure if that's the worst I have to put up with, I can live with it."
"Sorry, I didn't realize that 'Fr--' -- that that name was an insult."
Kathy stuck her head in and said, "dinner's ready." Bill led me to the dining room while Bryan and Nicholas went into the kitchen, to appear a few minutes later with bowls and platters of food. We all stood as Bill said grace, then we sat down. They'd seated me between Kathy and Bill, facing Bryan and Nicholas.
Dinner was a roast with mashed potatoes and green beans. Bill served us small glasses of red wine, and then the next five minutes or so were spent with Bill cutting the roast with an electric carving knife and Kathy filling our plates with potatoes and green beans, while we passed around the gravy boat. It wasn't til we'd gotten a start on eating that the conversation began again.
"We're so glad things are working out with Nick at the supermarket," said Kathy. "He's been through a couple of jobs, but this was the first one that he's been able to stay on with."
"I can imagine," I said. "Nicholas is a good worker, but you have to deal with the fact that he's not like the other workers. You have to be willing to make some adjustments in how you do things. He's a little like me in that way."
"Speaking of that, how did you end up working at a supermarket?" asked Bill. "Have you always worked in retail?"
"No, I used to be an auto mechanic. A pretty good one, if I do say so myself. But -- well, having to be a guy was wearing on me more and more until I couldn't stand it any more. You know, transition or die." I said that last with an attempt at a laugh.
"Transition?" asked Kathy.
"The process of going from being a man to being a woman. Or the other way around, if you started as a woman."
"Oh," she said thoughtfully.
"Anyway, when I finally came out at work, nobody could deal with it. Nobody wanted to work with me. I got harrassed, and my bosses didn't do anything because they didn't want me around, either. I got fired eventually, and I couldn't find any other shop that would hire me. I was homeless for a little while before someone at my church got me in touch with the supermarket. Oh, I'd switched churches because people at my old one weren't comfortable with me any more."
"Which one are you going to now?" asked Kathy.
"Hillside Unitarian Congregation. I keep a low profile and no one's given me a hard time yet."
"It's sad that your old church didn't have room for you. We are all the Lord's children, however we may look."
Bill added, "I'm afraid we had that problem even at our church. We adopted Nicholas because we were told we couldn't have children the usual way, and I'm afraid a lot of the other church members weren't able to accept a child like Nicholas. A number of them asked us to leave him at home. Fortunately, our pastor backed us up."
"'The Lord made him that way, and The Lord doesn't make mistakes,' is what he said," said Kathy forcefully. "But it took several years, and a few people left. I'm not sorry they left, though. It was obvious that Nick was doing the best he could, and I don't think they're all that Christian if they can't tolerate 'the least of these.'"
Nobody said anything for a while, other than the occasional 'please pass the --'. Finally, Bryan asked me, "do you have, like, a girlfriend?" He quickly added, looking at his father, "or a boyfriend?"
"I was married, back before my transition. She was a really nice woman, still is, but she couldn't handle me becoming a woman, and we got divorced. She remarried, and she's still not comfortable with me being, you know, the way I am, but we've learned to be civil with one another, at least. But even though she hates it, she's been a lot more decent than anybody in my family."
"Oh?" asked Kathy.
"My mom acted like I'd died when I came out to her and didn't want to see me, and my dad said I wasn't to visit them or call them or anything until I got over my 'perversion.' I had a brother and a sister, but they won't talk to me, either."
"Oh, jeez, that sucks," said Bryan, earning another glare from his father. That seemed to be their relationship: Bryan would act like a typical generation y-er, his father would glare at him, and he'd act chastened for like a millisecond. "Aren't your family supposed to have your back, no matter what? Me and Aaron, whenever someone would pick on Nick, we'd gang up on them and make sure they never did it again. Isn't that what everyone does?"
"I was the 'wimp' brother. Tom and Mary were disgusted that I didn't stick up for myself more. And when I transitioned...." I decided that dumping on my family didn't look good and stopped.
"You know, it's funny," said Kathy. "We adopted Nicholas because the doctors told us we couldn't have kids, but a few years later, while we were just trying to keep our heads above water with parenting, I got pregnant with Bryan, and then a few years after that, I got pregnant again with Aaron. People told us we should get rid of Nicholas now that we had 'real children,' which I thought was horrible! The Lord gave Nicholas to us, he was our responsibility now and one of His children, it was not for us to reject His gift. You know, I think The Lord kept us from having children for as long as He so we'd be ready to give Nicholas a home. And I think having Nicholas, it taught us so much. About loving people for who they are, about appreciating the good and not focussing on the negative. I think we're better parents and better people for it. To reject people, especially your own family, for not being who you think they ought to be, I just can't understand it."
We'd mostly finished eating the main course when Kathy brought out apple cobbler for dessert, and we switched to talking about lighter topics like the weather or good places to go on vacation. I was starting to feel really relaxed. I guess the wine was having an effect.
Then Bryan said, "do you do a lot of double shifts?"
"I do as many as I can. I can use the overtime."
"Is that because being, you know, a --"
"Trans woman?"
"Yeah. Is that really expensive?"
"Kind of. The insurance pays for the hormones, but I have to pay for getting rid of the beard. Electrolysis. $90 per week, I've been going for three years and I'll probably need to go another two at least. Plus, I'm saving up for some expensive stuff."
"Like the, you know, surgery? Where they --?"
"SRS -- sexual reassignment surgery?" I finished my glass of wine. "Yes, that's on my list." Part of me was shocked that I was talking about it, but it seemed that that part wasn't in control at the moment. Had I had so much wine?
"I guess you want to be completely a woman, right?" I nodded. "I guess that must be weird. Wanting to feel like you're a woman but having, you know."
"Yeah, I know. God, do I know!" I suddenly remembered they were pretty Christian, but I didn't get any glares. Maybe because I was a guest, or maybe because they figured they couldn't expect too much from a heathen.
"Wow. Lost your family, lost your wife, lost your job. You must have really wanted to do this."
"More like needed to. If I hadn't transitioned, I would have died."
Bill and Kathy and I decamped to the living room, while Bryan and Nicholas cleaned up. Bill brought over a photo album and we looked at pictures of their children's childhood: baby pictures, vacations at the beach, Disneyland of course, graduations, the usual. It all felt so normal it felt weird. Nicholas and Bryan came in and told stories about the pictures.
"Nick?" said Bill. "Isn't it getting time to get ready to go to work?"
"Right-o!" he said "Just let me wash up and get changed." For some reason, getting Nicholas ready involved the whole family and I was left alone on the couch. It felt very comfortable on the couch, looking at the pictures on the wall. Very peaceful. Very relaxing.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
I became aware that it was light, sunlight. I rolled over to look at my bedside clock to see how late I was, only I couldn't find it. There wasn't any table there. I slowly realized this wasn't my bed and this wasn't my room. The nightgown I had on wasn't my nightgown, but a long granny style gown in some sort of off-white synthetic flannel with little flowers printed on it. I also realized I needed to pee. I got up, found the door and peered out to see if I could figure out where the bathroom was. I suddenly recognized the hall as the hall in Nicholas's house and remembered that I'd been here for dinner. Oh God, I thought, I must have gotten drunk and passed out. I snuck around until I found the bathroom and used the toilet, then snuck back into the room I'd woken up in. I found my clothes, minus the pantyhose and underwear, neatly folded on a chair. There was also a big fuzzy bathrobe on another chair. I had no underwear on. Someone, the Sands, must have undressed me and put me in a nightgown. I wasn't sure which was more humiliating: passing out drunk or having the Sands see my naked body, especially the part of me that was proof positive that I wasn't a real woman.
"Elise?" I heard through the door. "Are you awake?"
"Yes," I replied meekly.
"Breakfast is ready. Don't bother to dress, just come on down to the kitchen." She didn't sound too upset. I put on the bathrobe and, as instructed, padded out the door and down to the kitchen.
The whole family was gathered around the kitchen table, except for Kathy, who was at the stove. Nick was still dressed from work, Bill and Bryan had bathrobes on with trouser legs showing underneath, and Kathy was wearing a full apron over a slip. Evidently they didn't want to get food on their good clothes. Bryan and Bill were reading the paper, Nicholas was still eating and waved to me.
"We've got bacon, eggs, and waffles," Kathy asked. "Toast, too, if you prefer. What would you like?"
"I'm really sorry," I said. "I guess I must have gotten drunk and --"
"Hardly drunk," interrupted Bill. "You had a half a glass of wine. I think you were just exhausted. Double shifts, a stressful day. Happens to all of us one time or another. Now: how about you tell Kathy what you'd like for breakfast and sit down?" he said kindly but firmly.
I sat down and said timidly, "might I have bacon and eggs?"
"Bacon and eggs coming up."
"Coffee?" asked Bill. "We also have orange juice."
"Might I have water? I'm not sure how my stomach is feeling right now."
"I'll get it," said Nicholas, as he got up and fetched a glass from the cupboard, filled it from the sink, and set it down in front of me
"Thank you."
"I'm sorry to have put you out," I said, after I'd drunk some of the water. "Putting me to bed. That must have been--"
"Don't worry about it," said Kathy. "We know you didn't mean it. You must have really needed the rest. We tried to wake you up, but you were just too out of it. There's no way you could have gotten home, so we just helped you into Aaron's bed. We figured you wouldn't want to mess up your nice clothes by sleeping in them, so we changed you. I hope you weren't upset."
"Not upset, exactly. But -- it seems like such an imposition on you. I hate being a burden."
"It wasn't a problem. I used to do that sort of thing for my Dad and then my Mom when they got too old to take care of themselves, so I'm used to it. Oh, I washed out your underwear, it should be dry by now." She put a plate in front of me. "Now, eat."
I ate.
It wasn't until I'd put a few forkfulls in my mouth that I realized I really was hungry.
"Would you like some more? Maybe a waffle?" asked Kathy when I'd eaten most of it and was engaged in collecting the scraps on my fork.
"A waffle would be nice," I admitted.
"One waffle, coming up!"
As I ate my waffle, I found myself tearing up. "I don't mean to be ungrateful," I said as I was finishing it up. "But why? Why take me in like this, put me to bed, like I was family? I'm just a stranger."
"You're not a stranger, you're Nick's friend!" said Kathy.
"You were in no shape to get yourself home," added Bill. "And it was no trouble to put you up, Aaron's off at college, so it's not like he was going to use his bed last night. What else could we do?"
"There have been plenty of people who would have been happy to push me out the door and let it be my problem."
"Doesn't sound very Christian, if you ask me," he concluded. "After all, if in the Bible even the despised Samaritan knew to help someone in need, could we do any less?"
By then, everyone was done eating. Bryan and Nicholas attacked the dishes, while Kathy fetched my clean underwear from the laundry room. We all went off to get dressed for church.
"I would invite you to come with us to our church," said Bill as we were waiting in the living room for the rest of his family to be ready, "but I'm afraid some of our members would not be very welcoming. You can of course come if you want, but I wouldn't want to talk you into coming and then have you face that."
"Thank you, but I think I'd rather go to my own church."
"I understand. I think it's our church's loss, though."
I didn't say anything, but I was having a hard time understanding his thinking. Why would they be missing out on anything by not having some pathetic tranny visit them?
Bryan and Nicholas came in, followed by Kathy. "I guess it's time for me to go," I said. "I really appreciate your hospitality. Two wonderful meals, and -- your kindness. Words cannot express how much I appreciate you all taking care of me when I ... well, zonked out right in your living room." I couldn't help blushing, I was still very embarrassed by the whole thing.
"We loved having you, and we weren't bothered by your unplanned sleep-over in the least," she said in an amused tone of voice. "It was an adventure. But if you really want to show how much you appreciate our hospitality, don't be so stubborn about letting us invite you over next time!" She gave me a hug and kissed my cheek to show she wasn't really mad. Nicholas gave me a hug, too, but Bill and Bryan just shook my hand.
I spent the drive over to my church trying to wrap my head around what had happened. I just felt confused. Why? I thought.
Our church was one of those classic white-painted churches, one that had started life as a Baptist church and it looked it, and had a parish hall on the opposite side from the parking lot. As I walked up from my car to the church, I noticed that there were flower beds on either side of the steps into the building, and in them were little brightly colored flowers sticking out of the ground. Some part of my mind supplied the word 'crocuses.' I hadn't remembered there being flowers there before. Pretty, I thought.
I took my usual seat in the back of the church and listend to the last little bit of the choir rehearsal. I suddenly remembered that the choir director would put out a call every month or so for anyone who wanted to to join the choir, no experience necessary. I used to sing, I thought, though I couldn't remember when.
People trickled into the church, and as the starting time approached, the trickle became a stream. Occasionally, I'd see people smile or wave in my general direction, but I wasn't sure it was for me, so I didn't say anything. Reverend Roberts began the service with a responsive invocation. Most people called her Ellen, but that's not how they did things in the church I grew up in. There were readings, there were hymns, which I would as usual quietly sing along to. The choir sang. There was a collection at one point. I was as usual mostly half-listening, just enjoying being among other people without the responsibility for actually interacting with them, but this time I couldn't so easily settle into my usual obscurity. Something had changed, but I couldn't figure out what.
I became aware that Reverend Roberts was delivering a sermon. I recalled that the word 'love' had been used a lot. I had missed most of the sermon, but this part I was fully awake for.
"There is a tendency to want to restrict love to those who, in our minds, deserve it. People like us, people whose lives make sense to us, people who fit our concept of 'humanity.' But we all are one underneath it all. 'No man is an island.' Whatever we reject in someone else is something we can find in ourselves. So when we exclude someone as being unworthy of our love, we exclude a piece of ourselves."
My mind went back to just hearing the music of the words and not the content, but at the same time, the words I had heard replayed themselves in my mind and even though I didn't process them, they contributed to my feeling of being unsettled.
After the closing words, I got up and followed the crowd to the parish hall. I was feeling the urge for something to nibble on and there was almost always a spread in the social room. There was at the door to the corridor, as usual, a clump of people around Reverend Roberts, but when she saw me walk by, she made a point of interrupting her conversation.
"Elise, how are you doing?" I wasn't sure if she really wanted to know, but I was too unsettled to hide how I was feeling.
"Uh, I -- I don't know," no doubt sounding as lost and bewildered as I felt.
She put her hand on my hand. "Elise, would you like to talk?" she said in a serious tone.
"I don't know," I whined even more helplessly.
"Elise," she said gently, "please sit on the bench out in the passageway, I'll come by in a few minutes when I finish up here."
I obeyed woodenly. From the bench I could see people walk back and forth. I observed them as if I were an escapee from another planet.
A little girl, maybe three or four years old, wearing a pink and green frock with two frogs embroidered on it, stopped and looked at me.
"You're pretty," she said, then giggled and looked up at her mother for reassurance. I was startled. I knew I wasn't pretty, perhaps she was talking about my suit. I did think it looked nice, especially with the brooch. "She's pretty," she said to her mother.
I pulled myself together and smiled at her and said, "you're pretty, too. That's a cute dress you have on."
She grinned but buried her face in her mother's pants leg. The mother gave me an indulgent smile, then looked down at her daughter. "What do you say, dear?" she said. The girl exposed enough of her face to look at me out of the corner of her eye.
"Thank -- you!" she said and buried her face again.
"Thanks!" her mother said to me, again with a big smile, then said to her daughter, "let's go and see if they have any chocolate chip cookies." The girl squealed and started running down the passage. Much like with the flowers, I'd been coming here for years, yet this was the first time I'd noticed the children.
A few minutes later, Reverend Roberts came and sat down next to me on the bench, turning so she was almost facing me.
"Reverend Roberts--"
She interrupted. "Please, it's Ellen," she said softly, then waited for me to speak.
"I don't know, I'm just so confused."
"Tell me what's been happening."
"Uh, one of my coworkers, his family invited me to dinner, they kind of twisted my arm, and they were just so -- they didn't say anything about -- they didn't mind that I'm --" I shook my head and waved my hands helplessly. "Friendly? I think that's -- and then, oh God, I fell asleep and they just put me to bed and gave me breakfast and weren't mad at all, they want me to come back. I'm just this tranny freak they don't know at all, why would they? I mean, why? I don't understand. Oh, God, I'm raving, you don't want to listen to my incoherent --"
She put her hand on my shoulder and gave me a sad smile. "Hush. I want to listen. I'm glad you're speaking to me."
"I'm only speaking because you asked me to. I don't know how you knew -- today --"
"Elise -- I don't know if I should say this, but -- ever since you started coming, every time we're both here, I've come over to you and asked if you wanted to talk. This is the first day you haven't -- well, it's the first time you've responded."
I remembered how Kathy had acted like they'd been trying to invite me over for years. "You mean ... all this time ...? God, I'm so stupid!!" I felt tears dripping down my face.
She shook her head. "Not stupid. Just hurt. Hurt and afraid." Her voice was low and soothing. "Afraid of rejection. I know it's hard to believe, but there are people who will accept you, if you let them in." She was looking straight at me. Her eyes looked damp. "We've all been waiting, Elise. Waiting for you to let us in."
At this, I broke down completely. Ellen pulled me over and held me to her chest so that my head lay on her shoulder. "Let it out," she said, as I sobbed and shook and she held me and stroked my back and my head. "Cry and be healed." Even as I sobbed, I felt the pain of years, of decades, pain that I had long ago stopped even being aware I suffered, being washed bit by bit out of me, and as it thinned and ebbed, I began to feel the first glimmers of a long-forgotten feeling, like sunlight sparkling on raindrop-laden leaves at the end of a thunderstorm. It took a while, but eventually I was able to put a name to it: it was hope.
Janet was sitting in her office, enjoying one of the rare quiet days at the Home That Love Built, when the phone rang. After a few rings, she concluded that no one else was in the office, so she picked up. She didn't recognize even the area code on the caller ID.
"Uh, is this the place where, uh, girls who used to be boys go?" The voice sounded young, pre-teen or early teens, probably a boy.
"I suppose you could put it that way. It's more for trans girls and women who have nowhere else to go. Our founder, Cathilynn, won a lot of money in the lottery a number of years ago, and spent it to set up this place." Probably more than he wanted to know, but Janet felt a deep pride and gratitude to the Home and enormous gratitude to Cathi on her own behalf and on behalf of all of her trans sisters for creating this place. It felt like a never-ending miracle, and, like a new convert to a religion, she couldn't help telling everyone about it.
"Oh." There was a brief period of silence. "Uh, do they have to prove they have nowhere to go? I mean, is there some kind of admissions process, like college or something?"
"Well, not exactly. Most of the time, we already know about someone before they come here. Or it's obvious, like if they've been beaten up or been on the streets for a while. May I ask if there's something in particular you're trying to find out?"
"Oh, no, just curious.... but--" The word just hung there.
"Yes?"
The voice got really quiet. "Uh, how do you know if you're, you know--"
"How do you know if you're trans?"
"Uh,..., yeah."
"Are you thinking because you think you might be trans?"
"Oh, no!" he answered, too quickly. "Uh, I have a -- a friend who -- who thinks he might be trans. You know, like that foxy black lady in that TV show."
"Could you give me a name? It doesn't have to be your real name, just a name so I don't have to call you 'hey you'. I'm Janet, by the way. Janet McGuire."
More silence. "Let's say it's, uh, Mark."
"Well, Mark, there's no one answer for everyone. Every trans person's experience is different. Some people just know, often when they're as young as two or three. Others just feel a sense that something's not right, that who they are just isn't working. And then they somehow get the idea that it might have something to do with their gender. Maybe they have the urge to dress up or do themselves up like the opposite sex, or just pretend they are, and it feels right. Maybe weird, too, but also right. And there are lots of other ways people can come to realize it. It's really about finding a way of living your life that works for you."
"Uh, what if, say, you're a boy, but a girl you know says she wishes you were a girl, so--"
There was a noise in the background. "Woops! My brother just got home, gotta go!" She heard a clunking, then the sound of the phone being hung up.
Janet couldn't help smiling at the transparent awkwardness of youth, even though she knew that dealing with emerging transgender feelings was no laughing matter at any age.
Cathilynn poked her head in. "Not rushing around?"
"No, a quiet afternoon. I got a call from a boy, around ten to fifteen I'd guess. Wanted to know how to tell if you're trans."
Cathi laughed. "That's a question we'd all like to know a good answer to. My best 'elevator speech' answer takes about ten minutes."
"I got a name: Mark, no last name, not sure if it's real. I didn't get very far, he hung up when his brother got home, so I'm assuming he doesn't want anyone at home to know. He might call back. Oh by the way, any idea where area code 704 is?"
- - - - -
The next time Mark called, a week later, Cathi was the one who picked up. She'd been on and off the phone all afternoon with people who'd required a certain amount of heavy-handed persuasion, so her rote greeting was a little more abrupt than usual.
"Uh, is this the --?" responded the uncertain pubescent voice.
"Is this Mark?"
"Uh, yeah, how did you guess?"
"Oh, just a guess. I'm Cathi. What can I do for you?" Cathi tried to shift to a softer demeanor.
"I hope I'm not bothering you?"
"No, that's what we're here for. I'm guessing you called to ask something?"
"Uh, yeah, um, I was talking to the other lady, and she was telling me -- so I could tell my friend -- how to figure out if you're, uh, like ...."
"Trans?"
"Yeah."
"The best thing is to find a good therapist with experience with gender issues and especially with transgender people."
"Therapist? That's, like, uh, a shrink?"
"Yes, usually a psychologist or psychiatrist."
"I don't think that would work. Shrinks are for crazy people. At least, that's what everybody around here says. My brother had to go to one, but that was because he tried to kill someone at school; at least, that's what everybody says. He had to stay home for two weeks and had to see the shrink for years. He pushed me around even more than usual. And we share a room, so it's not like I can get away from him. Anyway, I'm saying, I don't think my par- -- my friend's parents would go for that. And even if they did, I'd be dead if anyone found out."
"Another approach is to find a trans support group. That's a group of people who are trans or think they might be trans who meet regularly to talk about their experiences. Does your school have anything like a gay-straight alliance?"
He laughed hollowly. "Nobody'd dare. There was a kid at my brother's school, people found out he was gay, he got hassled so badly, his family had to move away. The school did nothing to help him, in fact, some of his biggest harrassers were the teachers."
"I guess that's out. Have you looked for on-line support groups? Websites with message boards and chat rooms. I don't use them, but some of the people here might know of a good one."
"Yeah, I sometimes visit one, it's for cross-dressers. But I don't want to ask there. It's full of old guys who are into dressing up and acting really gay. And some of them are really creepy. But they did talk about your place. They said people should donate to it. That's how I knew about you. I mean, your place."
"Why don't I take your number and call you back when I find out more?"
"Oh my God, no! You can't call here. If my parents picked up, they'd find out and, no, that would be awful. Or if my brother picked up! I'd be dead."
"Do you have a cell phone?"
"No. My parents say I can't have one because I'm doing too badly at school."
"How about if you call back in a few days? I'll put something together and put it out here in the office, so whoever answers the phone can give it to you?"
"Okay. I'd better say goodbye, my brother's karate class is over and he'll be home soon."
Cathi knew just the person who would know about web resources: Sonya Frasier. She'd grown up in a strict fundamentalist Christian family with extremely restricted access to the Internet, so when she escaped at age 17 (or was thrown out, depending on how you want to look at it), she made up for lost time by getting involved in practically every social medium and web blog and forum she could find. She'd get Sonya to put together a sheet of paper with information that anyone who ended up taking Mark's call could rattle off in the brief times that he seemed to have to make calls.
- - - - - -
As it happens, Sonya was in the office the next time Mark called. Connie picked up, but when she found out who it was, she signaled to Sonya to use the phone in Irene's office, as she was out for the day.
"Hiya, Mark!" she said when she picked up.
"You know my name?" he said anxiously.
"Sure! You're kind of famous around here. The kid who keeps calling up to find out if he's trans."
"But it's not me that--"
"Hey, chill out, it's not like it's a big deal either way. You or your friend. Why don't we just pretend it's you, and you can tell your friend later?"
"Uh, okay. I'm not sayin' it's me, you understand."
"Gotcha. Now, are you on Facebook?"
"No. I don't even have E-mail."
"What do you do on your computer?"
"I don't have one. I use the ones in the school library, or I sneak onto my brother's computer when he's not home. He never bothers to log out, so I just turn on the monitor and run the browser."
"You know about clearing the history, right?"
"Yeah, I picked up that much."
"How come you don't have a computer?"
"My folks say I can't have one because my grades are too bad. Plus, I keep getting detentions."
"Detentions? What, are you some kind of JD? Just kidding."
"Mostly for 'being disrespectful.' Sometimes I do mouth off, everybody thinks I'm some kind of queer and they're always hasseling me because they don't like queers, even the teachers, and sometimes I lose it and talk back. But sometimes I'm just like asking a question or saying what happened and I don't even know why it's supposed to be 'disrespectful.' Like, if I don't have my homework, and they say, why not? And I say, because I didn't hear about it. Bang! Instant detention."
"That sucks." She said it in a way that made it all too obvious that she was still getting used to saying it.
She continued. "How about I see if I can set you up on a website for trans kids. I'm support staff on one, tgteens.org
, so it's easy. You don't have to be trans to join, you can be just wondering, or maybe have a friend who thinks he or she is trans or might be. It's got talk boards, chat rooms, information pages, and on-line support via IM and PM twenty-four hours a day. We keep a close eye on things to discourage creepers."
"Creepers?"
"Grown-ups who pretend to be kids so they can perv on the kids or worse."
"Ew, gross!"
"So, what do you want as your screen name?"
"Huh?"
"The name you want to log in as. You know, like 'Mark' or OzTheGreat, or whatever."
He thought for a minute. "Can I use somebody's initials?"
"Sure. Mine is SFF -- Sonya For Frasier."
"Your middle name is a number?"
"No, it's a preposition. 'For' like in 'Sonya for president'." She giggled for a bit. "Somebody already had SF."
"How about 'MT'? The letter M and the letter T. Capital letters."
"Hmm ... No conflicts ... looks like it's yours." She finished setting it up and talked him through logging in and looking around the website.
"Uh, if I have questions, can I PM you? I might not want to post my dumb questions for everyone to see."
"No problem. I'd love to answer your questions, or find answers. Lots of people helped me on my way, now it's my turn. If you want to talk to me via IM, just look at the support IM page. There's a list of which support people are on. If you see SFF listed, you can IM me directly. Or if it's an emergency, you can just IM to 'hotline' and everyone who's on will see it. Otherwise, just PM to 'SFF', and I'll see it when I log on."
"I better get off now. It's almost time for my brother's karate class to be over, and if he catches me on his computer, I'm in deep doo-doo."
"'Deep doo-doo'?" Sonya giggled.
"He'd probably beat me up. Punch me, twist my arm, make me call myself names. And threaten me." She could hear him shudder. "It's bad enough even when I don't do anything."
"Don't your parents do anything?"
"They tell me I just have to be tougher. Hit him back, my Mom says. He tried to kill a kid, he had to go to a shrink, he's bigger than me, too, and I'm gonna 'hit him back'? Yeah, right. And he's taking karate. Brown belt. That stupid shrink was the one who had that stupid idea. He said it would 'help him get his aggressions out'. He's getting them out, all right. On me. He's already practicing his kicks and punches on me, all he'd have to do is let one go a little too far and then my neck would be broken or something and he'd just go, 'so sorry, it was an accident.' And if he found out I was hanging out with 'trannie queers' -- that's what he says when he sees stories about transsexuals on the news -- if he found out, I'd be dead. I'd be literally dead. Oh, shit! He'll be home any minute. Bye!"
Two days later, Sonya found a PM from "MT".
Cant use the computers at school there Net Nanny thing wont let me connect. got a screen saying inappropriate content. I'm at the library.
I tell parents Im gonna study lol. tell me if u get this.
She replied:
Got your message. If you tell me when your at library, maybe I can be online and we can chat. If you have questions about schoolwork I can try and answer then you won't be lying about studying.
The next week, Mark didn't call. The next day, she got another PM.
Parents got phone bill. Saw calls to u. Big mess Now can't call ANYONE. Plus brother locking computer. Library 2morrow chat at 4:30?
She made a point of being on at 4:30. About fifteen minutes later, she got an IM:
MT:
SFF?
SFF:
Hiya kiddo. Parents still mad?
MT:
sorta. stupid. phone calls were maybe $50. I mean, whats $50? Dad buys golf clubs for $1000, and he doesn't even like golf.
SFF:
Plays golf?
MT:
yea. guys from work. always complains about how stupid the game is.
MT:
at home, not to guys he plays with.
SFF:
how long can you stay on?
MT:
15 min, more if no one is waiting.
SFF:
how late?
MT:
9:00 parents are out with sis til late, bro is home, tho. Ugh!
SFF:
do you need help with school?
MT:
lol. yeah, lots, but not with homework. school sux.
MT:
PE teacher called me a girl cuz I couldnt get a basket in 2 tries.
MT:
plus the usual: calling me fag, queer. didnt steal my lunch, tho, so good day.
SFF:
did you talk to teachers or staff?
MT:
no. when I do, they say no tattling.
SFF:
how about parents?
MT:
ha ha. dad says no whining. mom says too busy. theyre answer to any problem.
MT:
wups, my fame is done. gotta go.
SFF:
fame?
MT:
15 mins of, lol. (warhol) bye.
Things continued this way. Mark would PM once or twice a week to say when he could get to the library, and they would chat.
SFF:
any brothers and sisters?
MT:
Kurt he's a senior. and a meanie. Lisa is 7. parents spoil her rotten. me, but I don't count. ha ha.
SFF:
you count.
MT:
you have brothers sisters?
SFF:
2 little brothers, 2 littler sisters, 1 don't know.
MT:
dont know??
SFF:
father banished me while mom was pregnant. won't let me talk to them
SFF:
I'm a "bad influence." Devil's snare, that stuff. might even be more siblings I don't know about.
MT:
sux.
SFF:
agreed.
MT:
you miss them?
SFF:
and how. never had friends, only family.
MT:
like me.
SFF:
no. father wouldn't let me. home schooled me so I wouldn't have temptations like friends.
MT:
wow.
SFF:
now I have friends. mostly at HTLB.
MT:
htlb?
SFF:
the Home That Love Built. The place you called.
MT:
wish I had friends.
SFF:
you have no friends?
MT:
nope
SFF:
you got one now. :)
MT:
?
SFF:
me!
A typical IM conversation from few weeks later:
SFF:
why do you think you're trans?
MT:
my friend not me
SFF:
why does your friend think he's trans?
MT:
wants to know how girls do it. clothes, makeup, hair, talk.
MT:
sees girls, wonders: what if I were a girl
MT:
crazy weird stuff. going crazy.
SFF:
not crazy. normal for trans girls. like seeing a big pizza with all the toppings when you're starving.
MT:
yeah like that
MT:
scary. other boys say, your a girl, maybe their seeing something.
MT:
so dead if they find out. time for witness protection program ha ha
SFF:
sux. you can't be yourself.
MT:
nobody wants my self around anyway. when they see me
MT:
theyre like ew gross! like I was dog doo.
SFF:
oh god that is so awful! so wrong. you're cute & funny
A PM that came in the spring:
We just had spring break, and i was home like always, I remembered your idea that I should try to make friends with my bratty sister. I played dolls with her. Kurt picked on me for being girly, I said I just want to make friends with my sister. they were going to take her to the beach but she got sick just before they were going to leave. I brought her water and red to her and snuck cookies. she gave me a hug. Ill probably get sick, but that's okay. if I get sick, I won't get to go to school, that's so awful. not. oh and she said she wishes I were her big sister. I wish to.
shes spoiled rotten but I love her.
wish I could see you you ever get to NC?
In May:
MT:
I wish I were a girl. girls are so much nicer.
SFF:
not always.
MT:
they dont steal your lunch or dump your underwear in the toilit or hit you with a towell.
MT:
being a boy sux.
MT:
whats it like at htlb?
SFF:
just about everyone is a trans woman. the residents do most of the stuff to keep things going,
SFF:
like cleaning, minor repairs, shopping, office work.
SFF:
there's pretty much everything you'd need for a shelter, except people have their own rooms.
SFF:
residents are expected to work or study. I just got my GED and am working on a pre-med degree.
MT:
so being trans is normal there?
SFF:
exactly.
MT:
sounds like heaven.
SFF:
yeah, except I miss my brothers and sisters. Dad won't let me even say hi on the phone until I give up 'sinful ways.'
MT:
I wouldnt miss big bro. starting to like bratty little sis tho.
MT:
hey I rymed
SFF:
people here are like family. Maybe you too?
SFF:
You can be my adopted online little brother. or is it sister?
MT:
kewl!
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It was a Friday in June and things were crazy at the Home that Love Built. The Home was nearly at capacity already and today a few more women were expected. Irene and Sandra were trying to figure out where to put them, and were about to consider getting camping cots when the doorbell rang. But instead of a trans woman with all her earthly posessions in shopping bags, Irene found at the door a boy who looked to be around 12 or 14 with an overstuffed school knapsack, a mop of unruly dark brown hair, and a nervous smile.
"Can I help you?"
"Um, is Sonya here?"
"I'm afraid before I can tell you who might or might not be here, I'll have to know who you are and what you want."
He shrank into himself a little and shifted his feet. "Um, I'm a friend of hers from on-line, and -- and I thought maybe I could visit? Um, I go by M-T online--"
"'Empty'?" asked Irene.
"Uh, no, the letters M and T. Actually, my real name is, uh, Mark." He added in a nearly inaudible mumble, "I'm hoping it will be Amanda or something someday."
"Oh, so you're Mark! Well, come in. Wait here in the office, I'll see if I can track Sonya down. We're pretty busy right now, we're full up and we're trying to find space for a few more that are expected. That's who I thought it was when you rang."
"You're full?"
"Yes. Were you hoping to stay here?"
"Um, it's okay. I just want to see Sonya. If she's not busy. She's like my only friend."
"Take a seat, then." Irene gave Connie a look so she'd know to keep an eye on the boy and then bustled off into the labyrinth that the Home had become over the years. Connie worked on the accounts, glancing every minute or so at the folding chair where the boy sat, but other than fidgeting, he showed no sign of going anywhere.
About ten minutes later, Sonya burst into the office, followed by Irene. When she saw the boy on the chair, she stopped and stared at him.
"Amanda? Is that you?"
"Yeah. M-T, Mark, whatever." He looked anxious, like he didn't know if he would get hugged or hit.
"What are you doing here? I mean, it's great to see you. It's -- a surprise, though."
"Uh, yeah. I thought I'd drop by."
"I thought you were in North Carolina. How did you get here?"
By way of answer, he put out a fist with his thumb pointed up, accompanied by an embarrassed smile. "Uh, if it's a bad time, I can go. She said you all were busy, I don't want to make trouble."
"No, don't go." She looked questioningly at Irene.
"Yes, stay. But we have to get a few things cleared up first." Sonya moved the chair next to him so she could see him and Irene pulled over an office chair. Sonya put out her arms and asked, "do you mind if I have a hug first? I've often wanted to give you a hug, and this is my first chance." He had already stood up and she had taken him into her arms before she finished talking. She was a good head taller than him, so she ended up picking him up in the process. When they were finally done, she set him down in front of his chair and they both sat down and looked at Irene.
Irene spoke. "First of all, what should we call you?"
"Amanda's fine. So is Mark. I'm still not sure what I want to be called."
"Now, where are your parents?"
"Um. I'm not sure. Probably back home. In North Carolina. But sometimes they go away."
"Do they know you're here?"
"Um, ah, well, maybe ... but, uh, probably not?"
Irene sighed. "I'll take that as a 'no'." When it rains... "So, first of all, we need to contact your parents. They're probably sick with worry. When did you leave?"
He looked at first like he was going to make something up, but then gave up and said. "Wednesday."
Irene thought for a minute. "I don't think you hitchhiked here from North Carolina in two days." She gave him her best penetrating stare.
"Uh, well actually, I took the bus, and I walked from the bus station. Well, gas station where the bus stopped."
"I'll need your full name -- your legal name -- and the names and telephone number of your parents. And then, we'll need to figure out where to put you, since I doubt we can get you back to North Carolina today."
"She can stay in my room," said Sonya. "I've got that trundle bed. It's too small for an adult, but I think Amanda would fit. And I could keep an eye on her."
"Is that okay with you?" said Irene, looking hard at him. "You'll do what she says?" He nodded.
"Okay, let's contact your parents." The three of them went into Irene's office. The boy dictated his full name -- Mark Tindall -- and gave his parents' names and home telephone. After ten rings, the voice mail picked up, and Irene left the number of the Home, told them it was about Mark, and asked them to call back. Irene looked at Sonya and said, "okay, he's your responsibility now. Just make sure we can find you all when his parents call back." Sonya agreed and led the boy off, and Irene went back to trying to figure out how to fit two quarts into a one-quart bottle.
In all of the busyness involved in sorting out the arriving women and girls, the problem of Mark Tindall slipped Irene's mind. It wasn't until late afternoon, when she and Sandra and Janet were relaxing with cups of coffee, that a reminder came in the form of a commotion in the hall. A second later, Sonya came in with what Irene eventually recognized as Sonya's friend.
She (it looked like it was "she" now) was dressed in a sundress in a wild print with garish colors that made Irene's eyes hurt. She had on girl's white ankle socks with pink-edged ruffles and navy blue boat shoes. Her hair had been washed and brushed and tied in short pigtails and the bangs held back with one red and one blue barrette. And her face was split by the world's biggest grin.
Sonya announced, "she has her true name now: Joy!"
The newly named Joy looked like she was about to burst. "'Cause when Sonya dressed me up like a girl, I cried, and she asked, what's the matter, and I said, nothing, these are tears of joy. And we both said, 'Joy!' So now I'm Joy! Joy Wilson!"
The three of them clapped, not knowing how else to react. Janet gave Sonya a look and whispered, "who was the fashion consultant?"
"She picked them out. We were down in the spare clothing storage, and when she saw the dress, she had to have it. Same with the socks. The shoes were the only ones we could find that fit her. I figured, there's plenty of time to teach her how to coordinate. Or match your figure and color. The main thing is, she has clean clothes and she's happy. Oh, I got her to take a bath and I washed her hair and got her clean underwear. Girls'."
"Isn't this a little hasty? He just got here."
"It wasn't my decision. As soon as I got her out of the office, she wanted to know when she could start being a girl. It was easiest to just go along with it. How long do we have before I have to get her back into boy mode?"
"Nobody's called yet," said Irene. "Why don't you take her with you to help with dinner. I'm sure Jackie could use the help, and it would be good to give Joy something to do."
Sonya beckoned Joy over and headed out the door with Joy bouncing around her like a hyperactive puppy.
"I guess we'll have to get used to calling her Joy," said Sandra after they'd had a chance to recover from the excitement. "She does seem happier than she was when she arrived."
"Actually, Sonya looks more alive, too," added Janet. "I'd been a little worried about her. Being cut off from her siblings was getting to her. Now she has someone to take care of and take her mind off of what her family's doing to her."
Later, as Janet was walking to the kitchen to get some more coffee, she heard singing. Jackie, the retired cook who volunteered to come in to make dinners and keep the kitchen in some semblance of order, usually brought her boom box to fill the kitchen with music while she cooked and today's selection was an album of Beatles songs. When Janet walked in, she saw Sonya and Joy wearing full aprons and sitting at the kitchen table cutting vegetables, Jackie at the stove, and the three of them loudly singing along to the music. Joy didn't seem to know all the words, but that didn't stop her from 'la la la'ing through the parts she didn't know and belting out the refrains.
After dinner, Joy insisted on helping clean up and was set to work scrubbing the pots and pans. She required a little instruction, but Jackie later said Joy was quite a help and she'd only had to rewash one pan. Considering Joy had, as far as anyone knew, never washed a dish before, that was quite an accomplishment.
Around nine, Janet peeked in on Sonya and Joy. Sonya was at her desk studying and Joy was on the trundle bed in a long cotton nightgown, reading a book.
"How is it going?" asked Janet. Joy looked up with a worried expression.
"No problems. She's happy to do what I tell her. She does seem to require a lot of hugs, though," she added, grinning at Joy, who grinned back. "She said she wished I were her big sister, so we've taken to calling each other big sister and little sister."
The next day, when Irene went into the kitchen to make her lunch, Joy and Sonya were there. Joy was wearing a denim skirt with a pink short-sleeved blouse over a white camisole, and her hair, long for a boy but short for a girl, was held away from her face with a tortoise-shell hairband. It made her look a lot more like an average girl, if a flat-chested and rather girly one, and it was honestly easier on Irene's eyes than the outfit she'd worn the previous day.
"What kind of sandwich would you like?" asked Joy.
"Do you know how to make tuna and cheese?"
Joy looked at Sonya, who nodded. "Sure!" Irene sat down and watched as Joy, following Sonya's instructions, pulled food out of the refrigerator and made the sandwich. She added some sandwich toothpicks which Irene didn't know they had and some potato chips and brought the plate to the table. Sonya brought a cup of coffee, and she and Joy joined Irene at the kitchen table.
"Your parents still haven't called back," Irene told Joy. "Joy, don't your parents have a cell phone?"
"Yeah -- I mean, yes, Sonya's trying to teach me to be a proper girl, and proper girls don't say 'yeah' -- but I'm not supposed to call it unless it's a real emergency, and I never have. It's on a piece of paper on the refrigerator back home. Besides, it isn't really an emergency, is it?"
"They don't seem to have reported you missing. At least, you're not on any of the national missing persons databases. I guess you're stuck here for a while longer." Joy just grinned and leaned against Sonya. Sonya put her arm around her. "So how is it going?"
Joy said nothing, so Sonya answered. "I've shown her around to the regulars. They all think she's cute and say they can't imagine her as a boy. She's soaking up the attention." Joy started to look upset. "Joy, there's nothing wrong with wanting attention. Everybody needs attention."
"My family thinks I want too much. They alway say I'm just looking for attention."
"That's probably because you haven't been getting as much as you need," Irene put in. Sonya thought of Irene as being only focused on the practical, so it always took her by surprise when she showed her empathic side.
"That's right, sis," said Sonya, "you're just getting what you need."
"Anyway," she continued, "I went back to studying, and she was looking for something to do, so I set her to sweeping and vacuuming the halls and entry. When she was done, Nellie got her to bring the new girls fresh sheets and towels, and when she did, she showed them the supply closets in case they needed more. Vicky -- that's one of the new girls, or should I say ladies, she's old enough to be my mom" -- a look of sadness crossed her face when she said 'my mom' -- "anyway, Vicky went along with Joy and started telling Joy her story, and when they were done bringing the sheets, Joy sat with her and kept listening."
"Yeah -- oops! -- yes. It was really sad," said Joy. "How can people be so mean?"
"So then Nellie asked her to do some loads of laundry and Vicky showed her how. Actually, they did it as a team, but Joy thinks she could do it herself next time. Right?" Joy nodded, positively glowing. "What else?"
"Vicky and I went to the living room and I sat on the couch and vegged out, but that other lady -- what was her name?"
"The chess player? Roseanne."
"Anyway, they were playing chess, and I asked them about it and they explained their strategies, and Roseanne said if I stayed, she'd show me how to play winning chess. And then Vicky asked if I was here because my parent was here and I was with her, and I said no, I was here alone because I was a boy who wanted to be a girl, and she said, you already are. I didn't tell her that I was probably going to have to go home because my family wasn't mean enough to me."
Irene said, "'mean enough'? Young lady, I think you and I are going to have to have a talk." Joy looked properly abashed for a few seconds, but her expression then dissolved into a grin, and Irene smiled in spite of herself.
Sonya picked up. "I came by to take Joy to the kitchen to make sandwiches for lunch, and she took it into her head to ask the women in the living room what kind of sandwiches they'd like. So we've spent the past half-hour making sandwiches."
"This doesn't sound like the shy boy who called me up months ago," said Irene, "or the shy boy who I saw at the door who looked like he was scared of his own shadow."
"I think I'm going to send her over to the hospice this afternoon. Janet's crew could use the help, and her patients might appreciate Joy's -- well, joy. And to be honest" -- she glaced at Joy -- "I wouldn't mind having her out of my hair for a few hours." She gave Joy a hug. "I don't want to get rid of you, but you don't want me to overdose on you, do you? I'd be lying on the floor comatose, and Janet would be shouting, 'quick, bring me a shot of Sadness, she's had a near-fatal overdose of Joy!'" Joy could barely contain her giggling.
That evening, Janet went by Sonya's room again. Sonya was sitting on her bed reading and Joy was lying down asleep with her head on Sonya's lap. Sonya put her finger to her lips, then gave the OK sign. Janet watched for a while and noticed Sonya distractedly stroking Joy's head and playing with her hair as she read.
Irene was off on Sunday, so it was Sandra who tracked Joy and Sonya down at breakfast. Joy had a new outfit: a white puffed-sleeve blouse, a knee-length navy-blue pleated skirt, white knee socks, and the same shoes as before. It looked like someone had located a training bra, too. "Joy, still nothing from your parents, sorry." Joy didn't seem upset by the news. "Also, Nancy's coming by today, she'd like to see you this afternoon."
"Who's Nancy?"
"Nancy Kane. She's our psychiatrist."
Joy looked uncertain and anxious. "Does this mean you all think I'm crazy?"
"No, it doesn't. But you might be a little mixed up about things. You've gone awfully quickly from asking how you'd know if you were trans to trying to live full-time as a girl, and we thought it would be a good idea for you to talk with someone about it. Nancy has a lot of experience with gender issues."
"She's really nice," added Sonya. "You'll be safe with her."
Nancy found Joy at lunch and took her to her office. The office looked like a small living room, despite the desk in the corner. It had a sofa, an overstuffed armchair, a coffee table, a plain wooden chair, and some folding chairs in the corner. She sat Joy on the couch and sat down herself in the armchair. She gave Joy a smile, but Joy still looked ill at ease.
"How was your day?" she asked Joy.
"Wonderful!" said Joy, with slightly forced enthusiasm. "Sonya took me to her church. I was afraid people would figure out I was really a boy, but they didn't. I was scared they'd want me to go to Sunday school, but it turned out the kids my age stayed in church and did youth group at a different time. It looked kind of like my church at home, you know, with songs and prayers, and everybody -- well, most people -- dressed up, but not too dressed up. I thought I fit right in."
"Sounds like you like being a girl."
"Yeah!" she said enthusiastically. She suddenly noticed her posture and sat up a little straighter and pulled her knees together. "I mean, yes. I keep forgetting."
Nancy decided to plunge ahead, since she didn't have time to wait for Joy to open up on her own.
"I'm told you asked us how you'd know if you were trans. You're the only one who can really answer that question, but I'd like to help you answer it. First of all, what made you think you might be transgender?"
"Um, what got me thinking was what a girl said to me. She was my lab partner in science, none of the boys wanted to partner with me, so the teacher assigned her to me. That's because they -- the boys -- all think I'm weird, they call me queer or fag or sometimes sissy, because I'm no good at being a boy. Well a lot of the girls think so, too. Anyway, after the first few labs, she said she wished I were a girl so I could be her girlfriend, maybe even her BFF. I wished I could be her BFF, too, she was so nice. I started, you know, thinking about the idea, but not like it could ever happen. That's when I started looking at crossdressers and stuff on the internet. God, some of that stuff is weird! Anyway then I was hearing about people like that lady on the prison show, and she didn't look gross, and I started to wonder if maybe I really could be a girl."
"And how did that make you feel?"
"Really weird. Scary weird. I mean, I know I'm supposed to be a boy, but sometimes -- you know, my Mom is alway saying, 'it's so nice that Mark can take care of himself, I don't need to do anything for him,' but my sister -- she's seven -- my parents are always taking care of her, like, driving her everywhere, and getting her nice stuff and saying how cute she is. And I'm kind of jealous. Sometimes I wish I were a girl so they'd spend time with me and do stuff for me."
"And think you were cute?"
Joy -- now more 'Mark' than 'Joy' -- blushed, but after a second he nodded. "I wish I didn't have to take care of myself all the time. I know I'm not supposed to, being jealous is a sin and I'm supposed to be proud I'm a boy, but not too proud, that's a sin, too."
He laughed, but it was a hollow laugh. "You know that joke, 'first prize, one week in Philadelphia, second prize, two weeks in Philadelphia'? It's like 'first prize one year as a boy, second prize, two years as a boy,' or something like that. I feel like I'd rather lose. Uh, that doesn't make any sense. More like being a boy means I'm losing. Or am a loser. Oh, I don't know what I mean."
He stopped and looked nervous. "Does this sound stupid? Everybody says I talk too much and say stupid stuff."
"No, I don't think it's stupid at all. It's interesting. Please go on."
"Maybe that's why I'm so bad in school. Rather losing, I mean. It's not like I can't learn stuff, it's more that I'm always screwing up, so I get C's and D's. My parents won't get me a computer or cell phone like my brother until I do better. Except last year in science, when I had that girl as my lab partner, I got all A's on the lab reports and B's and A's on my tests. But just in science. I even got all the homework done. I guess because she was working with me.
"I remember one time, I went over to her house to work on our lab reports together. I rode on the bus with her and we sat at the dining room table and talked about the experiment and stuff and worked on our reports and I didn't feel weird once. And her Mom brought us both a snack. I can't remember when my Mom brought me a snack. I mean, if she's making dinner, she'll make some for me, but I always have to make my breakfast and lunch. It was so nice. I mean, at the girl's house. It was so comfortable, I didn't want to leave. Being a girl is so much nicer than being a boy.
"Oh, and she showed me her room, I don't remember why. It felt so nice. It was girly, but not too girly, she mostly wears pants and jeans, but sometimes a skirt. The bed had a bedspread, and the curtains had flowers, and there were stuffed animals on the bed, and she had a nice dresser and there was a mirror on top and a brush and a hairband. Oh, and the closet door was open and I could see a pink satin dress hanging there with all the other stuff. I kind of wanted to go over and just feel it, but I knew she'd think I was weird. And when we were done, I didn't have to hitchhike or find a county bus, her mom drove me home. And she rode with me." Mark started to tear up. "She didn't need to, but she wanted to." He stopped talking while he fought back sobs. "Her name was Jeanne. Jeanne Miller." A few more sobs escaped. "I wish she was my lab partner this year."
They both sat in silence while Mark none too successfully tried to stifle his sobbing and hold back his tears. Mark, because even though he was dressed as Joy, his face and his posture showed Mark, the nervous, confused Mark who'd called and the shy, awkward Mark who'd shown up at the door two days earlier.
"You know what's really weird," he said, still crying. "When I saw the dress, after I thought about touching it, I wondered what it would be like to wear it. I wished I could be her twin sister and we'd both be wearing identical pink satin dresses. Then I felt ashamed, I felt like some kind of pervert and I was afraid maybe she could tell I was thinking these perverted thoughts. Maybe I am crazy. Maybe I do need a shrink. You're the expert on crazy people, am I crazy?" He tried to make it sound like he was just kidding about being crazy, but the worry showed around the edges.
"No, you're not crazy. And your thoughts aren't perverted, not at all. You've just got some feelings you don't know what to do with."
"Am I trans, like Sonya and the ladies here?"
"You definitely could be. You should really spend a number of sessions with a good therapist who can help you figure out what you feel and you want to do about what you feel. You might decide to transition and live as a woman, like Sonya. Or you might crossdress occasionally. Or you might live as a man, but let yourself do some things your friends would call 'feminine.' When we finally get in touch with your parents, I'd like to talk to them about setting you up with a good gender therapist back home."
"Uh, I don't think they'd be too keen on that. When my brother Kurt got suspended for fighting, they didn't want to take him to a shrink, they only did it because the school wouldn't let him back in unless he was seeing a shrink. And the one they took him to, I don't think he was very good. He got my parents to put Kurt into a karate class 'so he can get his aggressions out.' But I don't think it helped. He was mean to me before he went, and he was mean after he finished. Except now he has lots of karate attacks to threaten me with."
"Do your parents know about him being mean to you?"
"Yeah, I told them, lots of times. They just told me I had to be tough and to stop being a tattle-tale. I'm supposed to be able to take care of my self, see?"
"That sounds hard."
"Yeah." They sat quietly for a few minutes.
"Can I ask you how you feel about dressing like a girl and having everybody treat you like a girl?"
"Right now, it seems weird, but if I don't think about it, it's just fun. No, not just fun, it feels right, like it's just what I want to do and what I should be doing. Usually I feel like I'm weird no matter what I'm doing, but here I don't feel like I'm weird at all, even though I'm wearing girls' clothes. I feel like I'm being me, and it's nice. Isn't that weird?"
"Not weird at all. You're in a supportive, affirming environment and you're getting to do something you've wanted to do for a long time. I'd expect you to feel good. I'd be more worried if you were feeling weird. It's been great talking to you. Now, are you planning to do anything fun?"
She grinned and suddenly she was Joy again. "I'm going swimming tomorrow, maybe even this afternoon if we can find someone to lifeguard. Sonya found me a nice bathing suit -- a girl's suit! You know, a one-piece one that covers your" -- she suddenly got quieter -- "breasts." She continued. "It's pink and purple and has a ruffle on the top and the bottom. It makes me look kind of like a little girl, but I like that. Sonya told me how to push things around so I don't look so much like a boy."
Nancy couldn't help smiling. "I think I've found out what I wanted to, it's time for you to go out and enjoy yourself and and to keep on feeling not weird."
They both got up. Joy reached out for a hug, and after a second of hesitation, Nancy gave her a big hug. When they were done, Joy got thoughtful. "At home, we don't hug. I mean, not much. I think I've gotten more hugs since I've been here than I get in a whole year at home. Maybe longer." She thought again. "And I like it!" She gave Nancy a big smile, then another quick hug, and then scampered out the door.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Cathilynn got the call late Monday afternoon. Joy had been at the Home for three days and already she was becoming a part of the life of the Home. She continued to entertain with her energy and enthusiasm and to help with whatever she could find to occupy herself with. There was a part of her that had irrationally hoped that Joy's parents would never call and she could just stay. But it was not to be.
"The Home that Love Built, how may I help you?"
"Hi, I'm Margaret Tindall. I got a message on my voicemail asking me to call you. I'm sorry not to call back sooner, but we were away for the weekend and I just got around to checking my voicemail. What is this about?"
"We called about your son Mark--"
"Oh, yes, let me get him on the line."
"Mrs. Tindall--" But Mrs. Tindall had already put the phone down and could be heard in the background shouting, "Mark? Mark?"
It was almost five minutes before she came back. "He doesn't seem to be home, he's probably over at a friend's house."
Cathi recalled that Mark had said he had no friends, so she wondered where exactly Mrs. Tindall thought he'd be. "Mrs. Tindall, we know he's not at home. He's here with us."
"Oh, then, is there a problem?" She sounded puzzled. "Is he acting up? Has he worn out his welcome?"
Cathi was getting frustrated. "Do you know where here is?" She proceeded to explain exactly where the Home was and how far it was from Charlotte, North Carolina. "That's where your son is."
"Goodness, how did he get there?"
"By bus. He left your home last Wednesday. Were you aware that he's been gone for five days?" It was a little blunt, even for Cathi, but she couldn't figure out how else to get through to the woman.
"Five days? No, I --" It seemed that the seriousness of the situation, or at least how bad it would make her look, was finally getting through to her, because she then said. "Maybe I'd better talk with my husband when he gets home. We'll call you back this evening, is that okay?"
"I can arrange to be back in my office with Mark by eight o'clock. Please call then."
Cathi found Joy and Sonya in the kitchen. Joy was wearing a white T-shirt with a kitten on it and the denim skirt. She was kneading dough for dinner rolls while Sonya peeled potatoes. "Joy, I'm going to need your attention." Joy stopped kneading and Sonya came to the table and pushed the dough to one side. "Your mother called."
"Was she mad?" asked Joy anxiously.
"No, I think she was confused. She thought you'd been home the whole time. When she couldn't find you, she thought you were at a friend's."
"She didn't know I was gone?" Joy looked dismayed.
"I don't think she knew until I told her. She said she'd need to talk to your father and they'd call back."
But Joy wasn't listening any more. She seemed to slowly crumple. Sonya quickly sat next to her and held her head against her shoulder as tears started to roll down her cheeks. Her face fell and she began to silently sob. She pushed even tighter against Sonya and buried her face in Sonya's shoulder and her body began to shake. Sonya stroked Joy's back and head and tried to comfort her. Only after several minutes did Joy's crying become audible. She gave long, anguished sobs and occasionally said things that were too broken up by sobs and muffled by Sonya's blouse to be understood. Jackie put down her utensils and came over and patted Joy's shoulder. "Poor kid."
Jackie went back to the stove and Cathi took over peeling the potatoes. She'd peeled a potfull before Joy's face emerged, red and wet with crying. "She didn't notice I was gone," she moaned. "I could have been dead and nobody would have noticed." She sobbed some more and repeated, "she didn't notice." After a few more sobs, she sat up and grabbed the dough and started pounding it with big, angry blows. She stopped and started sobbing again. "How could she not notice?" she whimpered as Sonya put her arms around her and held her. "How?"
Dinner was a somber affair. Joy just picked at her food. Word had gotten around of how upset Joy was and why. A few came by to commiserate. Vicky and Nellie gave her a hug. Even Claudia, one of the girls from the hospice wing who Joy had read to and who had been given only a few weeks to live, came by in a wheelchair to say, "I care, and when I pass on, I'll be looking down and praying for you." She gave Joy a kiss.
By eight, Cathi's office was crowded. Cathi, Sonya, Joy, Nancy, Janet, and Sandra sat inside, and Irene said she was coming but would be late. As it happened, the Tindalls didn't call until eight thirty, by which time Joy's nerves were stretched to the breaking point. She was fidgeting and clutching Sonya's arm to the point Sonya had to ask her to stop because she was starting to bruise.
"Hello, Home That Love Built."
"This is Fred Tindall. I understand my son Mark is there?"
Cathi looked at Joy, who looked at the floor. Sonya whispered, "you've got to say hi."
"Hi, Dad," said Joy listlessly.
"Have you been behaving yourself?"
"Yes, Dad."
"I'm sorry my son has imposed on you."
"Oh, it's been no bother, we've loved having him here," said Cathi.
"If you can arrange to send him home, we'll be happy to pay the cost."
Joy interrupted. "Dad, can't I stay here? At least, can I if they say I can? Please?"
Mr. Tindall was silent. "I think you've imposed on them enough, I want you to come home."
Janet spoke up. "It was no imposition, we enjoyed having her -- him -- here."
Mr. Tindall replied, "son, I'm sure they're just being polite. Now, get ready to come home. You know we've all missed you. Ms. --"
"Michel."
"Ms. Michel, I'd like to arrange for Mark's trip home."
"I'll have to see what is the nearest airport with a direct flight to Charlotte."
"Didn't you say he took the bus to get to you?"
"He did."
"I think he can take the bus home, he's already shown he can manage it. If he doesn't have enough money, let us know what we owe, and we'll send a check. Oh, and let us know what we owe for his stay there."
"We don't charge people to stay here," said Cathi a litle indignantly. "But aren't you concerned that something will go wrong? That he'll miss a bus and get stranded?"
"We've always been proud of how well Mark can take care of himself."
Nancy Kane spoke up. "Mr. Tindall, there's another issue. We've had a chance to observe your -- son -- over the past few days, and in my opinion as a psychiatrist, he has some gender issues and would benefit from sessions with a gender therapist."
"I don't see why. I know my son, and I don't see any 'gender issues.' He's a perfectly normal boy. And if he does need to see a therapist, I'm sure Kurt's former psychiatrist will do just fine."
"Fine," said Cathi, "I'll let you know when Mark is due to arrive in Charlotte."
"Oh, that won't be necessary. He can call from the bus station when he gets in. Just put him on the bus." With that, he hung up.
As soon as they heard the click of the phone hanging up, Janet exploded. "What an awful, awful man!"
"Unfortunately, it looks like Joy is going to have to live with them for the next few years," said Cathi.
Joy had been quietly sobbing for a while while Sonya held her. "I don't know -- I don't know if I can," she sobbed. "Now that I've been Joy, I don't think I can go back to being Mark. They'll kill me. My brother. The kids at school. The teachers. It was bad enough being a queer and a sissy. Now they'll know I'm a girl. I'm dead. I am so dead."
"They want to go on pretending everything is fine," said Janet. "They refuse to see her, they insist on seeing what they want to see. How stupid --" She ran out of words to express her anger.
Cathi went on, "I'll talk to Sam to see if there's anything we can do legally, but I don't have a lot of hope. We'd have to show abuse, and I don't think CPS would see this as abuse. Otherwise, we'd have to convince them to give us guardianship, and it doesn't sound like they'd be willing."
"Couldn't we just keep her here?" asked Sonya. "What if she just doesn't go back?"
"We'd get in big trouble. Legally, where she stays is up to her parents, not to her. It would count as kidnapping or something. We would be lucky not to get arrested. They'd probably shut the Home down. And she would still have to go back to her parents."
Joy stuck close to Sonya for the next day, rarely letting go of her hand. Sonya didn't even try to study, but followed Joy around as she did her self-appointed chores. Her face was a mask of misery and her eyes were rarely dry. People would come up to her and hug her, and she would mumble thanks.
Cathi found them late in the afternoon. Joy had found a girls' black T-shirt and a long black skirt and looked like an avatar of despair. "Joy, I've made the arrangements. Tomorrow morning, we'll be driving you to the bus to Chicago, and someone will meet you there and you'll spend the night there. The same thing in Columbus. If you want, I'll see if I can find someone in Charlotte who you can talk to."
Joy clung to Sonya as Sonya put her arm protectively around her. "I don't know if it'll do any good. My parents might not even let me talk to them. They'll probably ground me."
Cathi privately thought that her parents weren't likely to be willing to go to that much trouble, but said nothing.
Wednesday morning, Joy, dressed as Mark and carrying his overstuffed knapsack, got into Irene's car. Sonya and Janet had insisted on joining her for the hour and a half drive to the bus station for the bus to Chicago. "Anita Ross will be meeting you in Chicago," said Irene. "She'll have a sign saying 'Joy.'"
"Better make it say 'Mark'," she replied. "I may as well start getting used to not being Joy any more. I am so dead."
As Joy was waiting to board the bus, Irene pressed a pile of bills into her hand. "In case you need anything." Janet gave her a hug and a kiss, and Sonya took her in her arms and cuddled her until it was time for her to board the bus. Her eyes were red with crying as she waved from the steps of the bus.
Cathi got a call from Anita in the afternoon that Mark had arrived safely, and another the next morning to say that she'd put her on the bus to Columbus and had contacted Vince in Columbus with the number of the bus.
That afternoon though, just before dinner, she got a call from a worried Vince. "He didn't get off the bus in Columbus. The driver and I searched the bus. His knapsack was gone, too. I asked the driver if he'd seen him get off the bus at an intermediate stop, and he said, no. Anita had asked him to look out for Mark, and he swears he would have noticed if he'd gotten off."
Cathi stomped out of her office saying, "shit! Shit! SHIT!" Irene and Connie came out to find out what was the matter.
"Joy has disappeared. Somewhere between Chicago and Columbus. She evidently decided she'd rather take her chances on the street than go home. Stupid, but she doesn't know any better. That man! Why did I listen to him? I should have insisted on a direct flight! I should never agreed to the bus."
"Should we report her as a runaway?" asked Irene.
Cathi's eyes got big. "Oh, God, I should have realized. She was already a runaway when she came here. She ran away from what she considered an intolerable home situation. I am so stupid! If I'd thought of her that way, I would never have thought of letting her take the bus. I would have even demanded that they come and get her."
"I guess we'll have to call her parents," said Irene.
Cathi waited until after dinner, in the hope that she would have settled down a little. Irene and Janet were with her. Sonya wanted to be there, but Janet said no. Mrs. Tindall picked up.
"Mrs. Tindall? This is Cathilynn Michel, about your son."
"I'll go get my husband."
"I want both of you on the line. I won't start until both of you are on the line." When Mr. Tindall picked up, Cathi got them both to confirm that they were listening.
"Your son has disappeared. We had someone put him on the bus in Chicago, but he wasn't on the bus when it got to Columbus. He must have gotten off at an intermediate stop. You need to file a missing person report."
"Why would he run off?"
Cathi wanted to scream. "That's not the point. The point is that he is 14 and has no one to look after him. We need to find him."
"I don't understand why it's so urgent. I'm sure he'll turn up after a few days. Mark can take care of himself."
"Mr. Tindall, do you have any idea what happens to runaway children? That's what your son is at this point. There's no place he can legally go, so he'll be living on the streets. We know what happens to kids on the streets because some of the girls who come here were living on the streets before they came. It's not pretty. Living in abandoned buildings, culverts. Or they get picked up by a pimp or someone who wants to abuse them. They get raped, beaten up, killed. They die in accidents, they drown, they get sick from exposure and die."
"Oh my God!" cried Mrs. Tindall. "Fred, please, do what she says! We've got to find him! We'd feel awful if anything happened to him."
"Don't we have to wait for a few days, in case he turns up?"
"He's already been away from home for a week. If you describe the situation, I'm certain they'll file one right away. The sooner you file one, the greater the chance that we'll find him alive. And when you do file it, be sure to include his aliases. Joy Wilson. Possibly Amanda Wilson."
"Why would we say Joy Wilson?" said Mr. Tindall. "That's a girl's name."
"That's the name he insisted we call him when he was here. Please, just file the report. And include those names."
"Fred, please do what they say!" said Mrs. Tindall. "I can't bear the thought that he might be dead."
"We'll be doing what we can, Mrs. Tindall. But make sure you report him. Anyone who deals with runaways checks those databases. Once he's in the databases, they'll know to contact you."
A week later, Sonya rushed into the office. "I got a PM from her," she told everyone. "She says she's fine. She wants to get to New York because everyone says it's a trans-friendly place. She didn't say where she was, just that she'd found a library where she could get onto a computer with Internet access. She said she wasn't Mark any more, Mark was dead, she was a girl named Joy and she was never going home, she'd kill herself before that. Oh, and she explained how she got off the bus. She'd had a complete set of girl clothes in her knapsack and she changed in the bathroom in the back of the bus. She sounded proud of herself."
"Can you PM her back and tell her to at least call us?" said Irene. "Tell her we'll find a safe place for her. We won't make her go home." She hoped she wasn't making a promise she couldn't keep.
The weeks dragged on with no more word of or from Joy. They worried she was dead. It was over a month later that Irene got an unexpected phone call.
"This is Mercy Hospital in Cleveland. We have a boy here, dressed as a girl. All we could get out of him was the name 'Joy Wilson.' We found a card with your name and number in his pocket. The people from a local soup kitchen brought him in, he'd shown up for lunch at their place feverish and barely coherent."
"Joy? You found her? She's alive? Thank God! She disappeared several weeks ago, and we've been worried sick. How is she?"
"I really shouldn't say, but.... He's in the ICU. He's got severe pneumonia, it looks like he's been sleeping outside for quite a while. It's summer, but some of the places homeless people sleep are pretty unhealthy."
"Is she okay?"
"I wouldn't call being in the ICU 'okay,' but it looks like he'll pull through. By the way, why do you keep calling him 'she'?"
"She's transgender. You know, girl in a boy's body? She ran away from home and came to us, we're kind of a shelter for trans girls. She was on her way home when she disappeared. Her legal name is Mark Tindall. By the way, didn't you run her name through the missing persons database? Her parents filed a report weeks ago. I'm surprised her name didn't pop up."
"We ran his -- her name, the only one we had: Joy Wilson. Nothing came up."
"Can we see her? I'm sure someone here will want to fly out and see her and make sure she's okay."
"We'll need a medical authorization from his next of kin. I assume they'll want to come, you can probably get it from them when they come up. He'll need someone to take care of him when he's discharged, anyway. He won't be in any shape to be left on his own for quite a while."
Irene got the doctor's name and the name of the people who ran the soup kitchen, a local church group. She checked the missing persons database. 'Joy Wilson' brought nothing up. 'Mark Tindall' brought a report up, but there was no mention of any other names. "Damn that man!" muttered Irene.
She let Connie know, who put the good news onto the grapevine.
Cathi was on a week's vacation, ordered by her doctor. She wasn't to be contacted except in case of emergency. Irene decided this counted as an emergency. She called Cathi's cell and got her voice mail.
"Cathi, it's Irene. Joy has turned up in a hospital in Cleveland. I'm going to try to extract a medical authorization from her parents and one of us will fly out to be with her. You don't need to do anything, but I thought you'd be relieved to know. Oh, and I'll see if we can get them to agree to make us guardians. I assume we agree that she'd be better off here than with her parents."
When she called the Tindalls' home, she got their voice mail. Fortunately, the missing person report had a cell number, and when she called that, she got Mrs. Tindall.
"Mrs. Tindall? They've found your son. He's in a hospital in Cleveland, in the ICU."
"Oh, that's good news. Do you know how long he'll be in? I'd fly up, but, ah, I have a busy week, do you think he'll still be in the hospital next week?" She sounded like she was trying rather hard to sound like everything was fine.
"We'd like to send one of our people to be around and visit him, but we'd need a medical authorization. Our lawyer can fax you a letter that you could just sign and send back."
"Oh, that sounds good. You all are so kind." She gave Irene the fax number.
"Mrs. Tindall, are you sure you don't want to come up now? To be honest, part of his problem is that he thinks you don't care."
"Oh, all right. I guess you're right, I should rush right up. It's just so hard to think of Mark needing anything, he's so self-sufficient. I'll see if Fred can book me a flight."
Irene contacted Sam about faxing the letter to the Tindalls. She was relieved to hear from Sam a few hours later that he'd received the authorization back with her signature. She had been worried that her husband would balk, but evidently she had signed it without consulting with him. She asked Sam for a guardianship letter covering them legally in the case that the Tindalls would agree to Joy staying at the Home; whoever visited Joy would take a few copies and see if they could get her parents to sign it.
As Irene was about to go and see who might be free for a couple of days, Janet came in.
"I heard you need someone to go to Cleveland to stay with Joy. I'd like to go."
"Don't you need to stay here to handle the hospice?"
"I think things are pretty much set up, I've got people to handle almost anything, and besides, since Claudia died, we don't have anyone who is close to the end. If anything serious comes up, I'll have my cell phone and my laptop. Also ...."
"You feel as if she were your daughter, don't you? You can't imagine not being there for her." Janet nodded. "Go. Bring her our love. And yours."
A little under 24 hours later, a nurse was leading Janet through the ICU to Joy's bed. "She's still pretty out of it. She's on high doses of antibiotics and she was undernourished and dehydrated. I don't know if she'll recognize anyone." Even though Janet had some idea what to expect, it was still a shock to see how the child that had once been so full of life was now lying motionless and full of tubes and monitors. Janet sat next to the bed and put her hand on Joy's. "Joy, it's Janet. I'm here, honey."
Joy turned her head to Janet and opened her eyes. "Mommy?" she croaked. Janet felt herself tear up. "I'm here." Joy managed a weak smile. She closed her eyes, but the smile remained. Over the next hour, she turned her head occasionally and one time opened her eyes and looked briefly at Janet and smiled. Then the nurse came to say, "her mother's waiting outside. She'd like to see her -- son."
"Of course," said Janet. She found Mrs. Tindall in the ICU waiting room. "Mrs. Tindall? I'm Janet, Janet McGuire. From the Home."
"Pleased to meet you. Call me Margaret, please." The well-practiced Southern charm could not hide that she was so anxious as to be barely functioning. "How is he doing?"
"She's in serious condition -- she wouldn't be in the ICU if she weren't -- but they say she's improving. She's pretty out of it, but she did seem aware that I was there."
"Do you think it would help if I sat with him? I -- I really don't know what I should do. I'm afraid of getting him upset. Oh, raising children is so complicated! Especially boys! I don't understand them at all! I just have no idea what to do!"
"Right now, it's easy. Just sit next to her. Maybe say something, like 'hi, honey,' so she'll know you're there. She seemed to like it when I laid my hand on top of hers."
"How do you do that?"
"Like this." Janet gently laid Margaret's hand on hers. It felt surreal, teaching a mother of three how to be a mother.
"And say, 'hi, honey'?"
"'Hi, honey, Mommy is here.'"
Margaret repeated, "'hi, honey, Mommy is here.' Do you think it will help?"
"I'm sure of it. The important thing is to show you're there and you care. Remember, no matter what happens, you're still her mom."
After Margaret had gone, Janet pulled out her laptop, but her mind was not on the documents and memos. She was beginning to think that the problem with the Tindalls' parenting, or at least Margaret's, wasn't deliberate neglect so much as simple ignorance and lack of confidence. She simply didn't know how to mother, which made her so anxious that she simply withdrew from her son. Janet couldn't help wondering what Margaret's growing-up had been like.
An hour later, Margaret emerged from the ICU. Her face was wet with tears and her make-up was streaked and blotchy. She was daubing her face with a wad of tissues. Janet took her into her arms and Margaret started sobbing.
"I put my hand on his and said, 'hi, honey, it's Mommy,' like you said. And he smiled and said, 'Mommy.' He looked so small and helpless lying there, sick and full of tubes and wires. I couldn't help thinking: what have we done to you? What have I done to you?" She broke into a bigger fit of crying. "I started petting his hand, like a kitten. I know it wasn't what I was supposed to do, but he smiled in his sleep and I felt my heart --"
"You're doing great, Margaret. Small steps."
Later, over dinner in the hospital cafeteria, they talked. "Why do you keep saying 'her' when you talk about Mark?"
"When she stayed with us, almost as soon as she got there, she announced that her name was Joy, and she dressed and tried to act like a girl the whole time. We just think of her as a girl, because that's the only way we've known her. Margaret -- we got a communication from her after she ran off. She said Mark was dead, she was Joy and wouldn't answer to Mark any more. I suggest you not argue with her about it, at least not at this point."
"I don't understand. Why did he suddenly decide he was going to be a girl? And how?"
"I think it's been brewing for a while. She contacted us over six months ago, asking how to tell if you're transgender."
"Why you?"
"Do you know what our Home is? I mean, the Home That Love Built."
"I don't know, a home for runaways?"
"Do you know what a trans woman is?"
"Are you talking about people like Bruce Jenner? Men who pretend they're women? And even get their --" Janet winced.
"I wouldn't put it that way, but I think you get the idea. A lot of trans women get cut off by their families, lose their wife and children, lose their jobs, get shunned and beaten. Our Home is for trans women who have nowhere else to go. We keep a low profile, because there are people out there who hate trans people and would attack us, even physically, and we don't want to attract their attention. Mark somehow found us, which means she'd been doing a lot of looking around. My guess is that she'd been thinking about her issues around gender for years, and when she came to us and saw that we really would accept her as a girl if she wanted, she dived right in."
"I feel like such a bad mother. I thought I knew all about my son, but now I see I didn't know him at all." She sighed. "Maybe he's better off with you than with us."
"I think you're right, at least for the moment. She trusts us, and unfortunately she doesn't trust you and your husband. She was pretty adamant that there was no way she was going to go home. Even if we forced her, she'd probably just run away again. Or kill herself. Roughly half of all trans people try to kill themselves at some point."
"Oh, my God! Kill himself?"
"That's only if the people around her refuse to face up to her transgender, well, transgender nature. If she gets acceptance and support, she's no more likely than anyone else. She's a wonderful, loving, joyful, compassionate, helpful, cooperative child; that's who we saw while she was with us. She was a joy to be around. And she loves you. But she's convinced you don't love her, and she's horribly hurt by that."
"I feel like a horrible mother. He has every right to hate me."
"Not that horrible. You rushed up here as soon as you found out where she was. That's going to mean a lot."
"I only did it because that woman at your place shamed me into it. I was going to wait."
"But you did come, that's what matters. Margaret, I think you can repair your relationship with your son. It will be a long and hard road, I won't lie to you, but there are people -- professionals -- who can guide you and Joy. We have a lot of contacts, and I believe we can find people to help you."
Joy's father and her sister Lisa arrived on Saturday. Kurt had elected to stay at home, not wanting to be subjected to "my faggot brother." Joy was out of the ICU and in a room by then. The fever and the mental fog were gone, but she still tired easily and was seriously underweight.
Lisa had fully and enthusiastically adjusted to the idea of Mark being Joy: when they arrived, she rushed into the hospital room, jumped on the bed, and practically smothered Joy with a big hug. "Oh, I'm so HAPPY you're my big sister now!"
"Uff! I'm going to be your dead big sister in a minute if you don't get off and let me breathe," Joy protested, but smiled to show she wasn't mad. Lisa slid to the edge of the bed and sat, twisting to face Joy. "Don't worry, I'm not mad. I'm glad to be your big sister." Lisa smiled. "I love you, little sister."
"And I love you too, big sister. Ooh, we're going to have so much fun! You're going to play with me and do all kinds of sister things and you'll tell me all kinds of big girl things."
"Leese, I'll play with you, but I can't tell you any girl things. I've only been a girl for, what, two months? I'm just a two-month-old, how much can I know?"
"If you're a two month old baby, can I feed you a bottle?"
"Goo goo gah gah. Look, I'm a baby!"
"Ooh, you're so much more fun now that you're my sister. You were always so grumpy and no fun when you were Mark."
Joy's father was less thrilled. "Marge, I still don't get it. Why do we have to pretend Mark is a girl named Joy Wilson? It all sounds like nonsense to me. And I don't like the idea of him being halfway across the country instead of at home where he belongs."
The two of them were sitting in the waiting room outside the ward. Janet had brought them coffee and sandwiches from the cafeteria and was sitting a few seats away from them, trying to look like she was busy with other things.
"Fred, I know it's strange. It's still strange to me. But we don't have a choice. We know if we try to make him come home, he'll just run off again, and this time he might really die. We're lucky he didn't die this time. We know he'll stay if he's living at the Home, and they'll take care of him. We can't make him be Mark. And I don't want to any more. He -- well, really she -- is so much happier now. I hadn't really paid attention before, but when I think back on it, I realise that he -- I mean, she -- wasn't doing so well. It was like he -- she -- wasn't really there. I don't remember her having any friends, and she never seemed to do anything. I don't remember her ever smiling. She's completely different now. I've got my baby back, my baby that I hadn't noticed I had lost, in spirit I mean and then almost for real, and I don't care if my baby is my son or my daughter, I'm just glad to have her back."
They sat in silence for a while. Finally, Fred heaved a big sigh. He reached over and held Margaret's hand. "I guess you're right. You usually are. I'll just have to get used to saying 'she' and calling -- her -- 'Joy'. It's going to be hard, though. We'll have to drag ourselves halfway across the country if we want to see her, so it won't happen often. Lisa won't like that."
"I think you'll miss her too, Fred. I think you love her more than you want to admit. Try spending time with her and listen to her. Forget what you think she should be and see who she is. Maybe if we get better at that, we'll be able to be together again."
"Where did you learn to talk like that?" asked Fred, trying to sound stern and failing.
"Some from Janet. Some from the nurses and the hospital social worker. But a lot from Joy. She picked a good name."
Fred Tindall had to fly back Sunday night, so Tuesday late morning found the rest of them at the Cleveland airport. Joy was in a wheelchair on doctor's orders. Though it was still summer, she was wearing a denim jumper over an orange T-shirt, black tights, and a light blue cardigan. Janet and Joy's flight west back to the Home was first, the Tindalls' flight to Charlotte was an hour later. Lisa and Margaret had tearful goodbye hugs with Joy.
"I'll see if we can visit for Thanksgiving," said Margaret. "At least Lisa and me."
"I'm going to miss my big sister so much!" mourned Lisa. Margaret hugged Janet, and then it was time for Joy and Janet to board.
Joy looked out the window as they reached cruising altitude, but her mind wasn't on the patchwork landscape far below. "Janet?" she asked anxiously. "Do you think someday my parents will be okay with me being Joy? And maybe I'll -- I'll have a family? I mean, I know I have a family, but will they feel like a family? My Mom was so different at the hospital, it was like she really wanted to know how I felt. Like it mattered to her whether I was happy or sad. God, it would be so weird. But a nice kind of weird. And maybe -- I wonder -- could Kurt even be nice to me, like, be my big brother the way Sonya is my big sister."
Janet just let her talk. She could see Joy's eyes mist up.
"I'll be seeing Sonya soon. I can't wait to get home. To The Home, I mean. I can't believe how different everything is now." Her eyes and her cheeks were wet with tears, but she was smiling. Just then, the stewardess came by to take lunch orders. "Honey, is something the matter?" she asked.
"No, these aren't sad tears. They're happy tears. They're tears of joy."
I didn't used to be a girl with a bright future.
I used to be a "loser" at West High.
I used to be a boy named Martin Rawlings.
This is my story.
Chapters 1--15
Through a series of unfortunate events, Martin's body is transformed, and his life takes a turn for the worse.
[Note: Cautions apply to the entire story.]
I wasn't always the girl you know. I didn't used to go to a great school. I didn't used to have a gang of great friends. I didn't used to think that I mattered all that much.
I used to live with my brothers and my parents over on the west side of town.
I used to go to West High School.
I used to be a boy named Martin Rawlings.
This is my story.
It all happened because I was in love.
I was madly in love with my brother Pete's motorcycle.
Pete had gotten the motorcycle so he could get to his classes at the local community college when our parents couldn't spare one of their cars for him. It mostly sat in our carport, but sometimes he would ride it to school, and sometimes, if he was in a good mood and I begged him hard enough, he'd give me a ride on it. My parents were scared half to death, of course. That was part of the fun. When I was on it, I was in heaven, and when I wasn't, all I could think about was when I'd next be on it. In class, instead of paying attention to the lesson, I dreamed of riding down country roads with the wind on my face and all my cares left far behind. I got in trouble for it, but what did I care? I was already branded a "loser", which is what they called us boys at the bottom of the social pecking order, and it wasn't like I could fall any lower.
The trouble started with me just looking at it. It was a warm June day, my parents were at work and Pete at the campus and Biff was somewhere or other, and I had only a half-day of school. I felt it call me. I was just going to take a look and then go back to whatever boring stuff I usually did. The motorcycle was standing in the carport, just begging me to come closer. When I did, I saw the key still in the ignition. Pete was always doing that. It was a miracle it never got stolen.
It couldn't hurt to just sit on the motorcycle, could it? So I swung my leg over the saddle and sat on it. Not in back, where I sat when riding with Pete, but in front, where I could reach the handlebars. After pretending I was riding all over the place with it, I thought, now that I'm here, I could see if I can start the engine, but I won't go anywhere.
Well, one thing led to another and before long, I was on the open road, enjoying the wind on my face and the thrill of speed. Just like riding a bike, not so hard, is it? Then I saw that the road in front of me made a sharp right turn at the bottom of a hill, and then I saw the gravel.
The last thing I remember was going "oh, shit!"
[Note: Cautions apply to the entire story.]
When you've had a head injury, you don't just wake up. It's more like bits and pieces start to sort themselves out like a jigsaw puzzle, only over months. And the pieces sometimes unsort themselves for a while. At least, that was how it was for me. I have pieces of memory from early August, and longer ones from later in the month.
At some point I realized that I had been in a serious accident, with broken bones and a bad concussion. I hadn't worn a helmet (because I wasn't going to actually ride it, right?) and they said it was a miracle I was even alive. They told me I had spent a month and a half at the University medical center and had been in a medically-induced coma for a month while they pumped gene therapy drugs into me to encourage my brain to heal. I wasn't healing as fast as they hoped, which said something about how bad the concussion was.
But by September, most of the casts were off and my brain was working well enough that the doctors thought I could go back to school, although I should avoid anything that might bang my head. I hoped my brain injuries hadn't hurt my survival skills -- I needed to be in top form to survive at West High. They let me go back as a sophomore, even though I had missed freshman year finals. I don't know if I'd done well enough or if they just didn't want to have me around any longer than they had to.
I'd hoped that I'd get out of gym class, which I hated, but no such luck. The other classes were okay, although I got a lot of headaches, especially when the other guys harrassed me too much.
Now I should say that sports, and especially football, are a big deal at West High. West High is like a small town. The parents all know each other; most went to West High themselves. And in the fall, most of the conversation, in school or out, is about whether the team will win the next game. If the team wins, especially the big game with Hollingsworth, everybody screams and drives around honking and throwing stuff. And that's the grown-ups. So the guys on the football team are gods. They can do anything they want, and nobody will say anything. Even the freshman team is a big deal. The basketball team is a big deal, too, but those guys are just demigods.
For some reason, my gym class was always getting out when some of the football players were coming in. They liked to hang out and harrass anybody they thought was a wimp, which meant pretty much anyone who wasn't on the varsity or one of their buddies. I didn't do well in gym, anyway, so the class kept proving I was no good as a guy. And then I'd get to the showers, and they and the jocks in my class would make fun of people's private parts and pop them with towels. I always had a splitting headache after gym, what with the concussion and all.
[Note: Cautions apply to the entire story.]
It was in the boys' shower that it started. Tom Prescott, one of the football players and a ringleader of the jock clique, was pointing at my penis, when he shouted, "hey, what's with your dick? It looks like a little boy's dick. Hey, little boy, whacha doin' in high school?" I did my best to ignore him, but that night I looked in the mirror for the first time. My penis was about half its usual length and smaller around, too. My scrotum was shrunk and pinning my balls to my crotch. I also noticed that my nipples were sore.
I started worrying that puberty was throwing some new humiliation my way, then I started worrying that I was worrying for nothing. I actually started measuring it. To my distress, a week later, it was a half an inch shorter. I couldn't even stretch it to the length it was a week earlier. I thought about asking my father about it, but I couldn't imagine him coming back with anything but one of those idiotic man-to-man platitudes. I thought about my mother, but she was uncomfortable with anything that reminded her that I was male. She had trouble even washing my underwear.
I was still seeing the neurologist every two weeks, so I brought my measurements to my next appointment. At first, he thought it was just some adolescent thing, but I insisted he examine me. When he did, he said, "I think we need a second opinion." He gave me a very thorough examination, including blood tests, and set up an appointment with a colleague before he let me go.
It was October by then. Every week, I got sent to a different specialist, each one more eminent than the last, and each one did a thorough exam. The third one noticed that I was a few inches shorter than at my first exam. The fourth one noticed that my nipples were enlarged and my chest had started to develop breasts. By then, my penis was so short that I had to sit to pee, and my scrotum had flattened into my crotch. I had no idea what had happened to my balls. I started wrapping my chest with several ace bandages to flatten the breasts out, but it made the nipples hurt and I started getting backaches.
The fourth doctor didn't set up another appointment. "I have a few ideas, but I'm not ready to say anything yet. I'll have someone call you." Four days later, yet another doctor called -- in person, not through a receptionist -- and asked my parents and me to come in.
[Note: Cautions, themes, etc., apply to the entire story.]
When we got there, the doctor -- Dr. Newcomb -- ushered us into his office. He must have been really somebody, because it was big and carpeted and had lots of mahogany and leather furniture. I didn't know if this was how he always looked, but he looked nervous and sweaty.
"I'm -- I'm not a neurologist. I'm the director of research for what is usually called 'gene therapy' here at the University. We've been working with other gene therapy groups on techniques for regrowth -- and corrective growth."
My parents looked as perplexed as I felt.
"One of the uses is regrowing lost limbs, or correcting congenital defects. That's still experimental, but we all hope to have it FDA approved in a few years. Our work here is more experimental. One group of patients we work with are people with gender dysphoria." He must have realized we had no idea what he was talking about, because he tried to clarify it. "You know, men who feel they're a woman in a man's body, and vice versa? The usual treatment is sexual reassignment surgery. We're trying to do it using gene therapy techniques."
"And what does that have to do with Martin?" my father asked.
"One of our subjects was in the coma ward at the same time your son was. We're still running tests to be sure -- by the way, Mr. Rawlings" -- here, he looked at me -- "could you stop by the lab on the way out and leave us another blood sample -- but we think that whoever was actually doing the work, taking samples and injecting the material mixed up our subject and your son."
"You mean, your guy got the brain drugs and our son got the sex-change ones?"
"Essentially, yes."
My father looked stunned. We all did. Then he sat back and said, very quietly, "then you've got to fix it."
The doctor looked even more nervous and sweaty. He'd been sitting with us, like it was a social visit, but now he got up and stood behind the desk. "I'm afraid that isn't possible. I'm sorry." He rushed ahead. "Once the genes have been delivered to all the cells, there's no removing them. Maybe we could have done something if we'd caught it, say, a half-hour after the vectors were injected. But now it's too late."
My father isn't the rant-and-rave type, so he just stared at the doctor. Finally he said, "don't you have a treatment to turn women into men? Couldn't you use that?" My dad is pretty smart. I'd never have thought of that.
"Unfortunately, we can't do a second gene therapy -- any kind of second gene therapy. For some reason, the two therapies interact, and you get bad results. We've tried it in animals, and the results were hideous."
"So I'm going to -- turn into a girl?" I sputtered.
"Externally, yes. You'll develop a normal-looking clitoris, labia, and vagina with a cervix, but there won't be a uterus or ovaries behind it. There's a gland that puts out female hormones, so you'll have breasts. We've even developed an approximation of female sexual response."
I could see that my parents had mentally checked out. Any kind of discussion of sex made them uncomfortable, I'm sure that hearing about the sexual parts that their son was in the process of growing was tripping all their circuit breakers. I was still thinking, "this isn't real, I'm going to wake up and it was all a bad dream." Except I knew it wasn't.
I don't think it ever occurred to my brothers that there might be any reason not to tell everyone about what the doctor had told us. I survived the first day after we met with the doctor only because the word hadn't really gotten around yet. The second day, I could hear the whispers and see the pointing and smirks from the minute I got on the bus. Soon, the bolder guys would make open taunts, like, "sissy, you're a sissy girl now," or "why aren't you wearing a dress, stupid?" I was able to sort of ignore them during my classes. Gym class, of course, was another story.
It started the minute I got into the locker room to change for gym. "Hey, girlie, whacha doing in the boys locker room?" "Isn't your name Martina now?" I raced through changing and hustled into the gym. I didn't even take time to put on my gym shoes before going in. In the shower, after gym, it was much, much worse. Tom Prescott started by getting everyone to look at my crotch, then trying to grab it. Several of his buddies tried to, too, but I punched them. Or tried to, anyway -- they had no trouble avoiding my punches. But at least they kept their distance, sort of. I didn't really wash and just sort of wiped the water off with my towel before jumping into my clothes and rushing out of the locker room. I swore to myself I'd never go in there again.
The next day, the whispers and taunts continued. I was starting to get used to it, or at least inured. When I was supposed to go to gym class, I took my books to the library. Mrs. Tomlinson, the librarian, was very strict about quiet, so I didn't need to worry about people bothering me there. I expected trouble, but nobody said anything. I went to all my other classes as usual, but went to the library during gym class. After a week of this, I got called to the office. They told me I had to start going to gym class. I told them, no way in Hell, They said I'd get an F. I said I didn't care. And that was that. Afterwards I though: I should have done this years ago.
By now, my penis was completely gone and my crotch didn't look a lot different from a girl's. At least, if the pictures on the web were any guide; it's not like I'd ever had seen any girls naked in real life. I also noticed that my hips were wider, so my pants were really tight there. On the other hand, they were now a few inches too long. The worst part, though, was that the pants legs rubbed on my thighs and it was driving me crazy. It was a mix of feeling turned on and hurting. My crotch and thighs were very sensitive now. If I lay in bed and gently tickled and stroked down there, I got really, really turned on. I finally got my mother to pay for some new pants, shorter and wider, and it helped a little, but not that much.
At home, things weren't easy, either. My dad was mostly interested in suing the hospital, the doctor, and the University. He didn't want to think about what I was going through. My mom would barely look at me. And my brothers thought that my predicament was the funniest thing that ever happened and were forever making jokes at my expense. They were always threatening to come into the bathroom when I was on the toilet or taking a shower, though fortunately they never did.
The bathroom was a problem at school, too. I had to sit down even to pee and a lot of the boys, if they were in the bathroom when I was, they'd pull themselves up and look over the partition at me. I complained to the assistant principal and he said he couldn't do anything unless he caught somebody doing it. That just told those boys exactly what to do to stay out of trouble. They'd post a lookout as soon as I went in. I asked whether I could use some bathroom other than the boys' bathroom. The teachers didn't want me in the teachers' bathrooms and the popular girls decided to claim they would be afraid to use the girls' bathroom if I could use it and got their mothers and their friends' mothers to complain, even before I asked. I hadn't even suggested it yet. I asked about the handicapped bathroom, but they said it had been converted into a supply closet because they never had handicapped kids, and besides, I wasn't handicapped. So I tried to hold it in as much as possible.
The doctor had recommended counselling for me. First, my parents had me go to the school psychologist, but she was useless. I didn't have any of the problems she'd been trained for, so she simply talked to me as if I had one of them. I'd talk about the bathroom problem and she'd offer me studying advice. Or suggest I have a talk with my parents. Then my parents sent me to a shrink that the school social worker recommended. He was worse. He spent the first session asking about whether I had the hots for my mom and seemed to think my transformation was because deep down inside I really wanted to be a girl. The second session, he tried to get me to take my clothes off so he could "accurately assess" my problem. I decided there wasn't ever going to be a third session.
Not everyone was trying to make my life miserable. My fellow "losers" would sometimes secretly warn me and help me hide if they saw the bullies coming, but if they got caught, they'd catch it, too. And some of the "uglies" -- that's what they called the girls on the bottom of the social heap -- would sometimes come over when no one was looking and tell me they thought it was really awful and unfair what was happening to me, but they couldn't do much because they were afraid of the popular girls. I couldn't blame them.
Every year, at Thanksgiving, we get together with my dad's sister and her family for dinner. This year, it was at our place. My mom put the turkey in to bake and a little while later, Aunt Edith, Uncle Boris, and my cousin Teresa showed up with salad and deserts. Aunt Edith and my mom would then work together to make the rest of the meal.
My brothers had been making fun of me all day and they didn't stop when my Aunt and her family came in. "Hey, Martina," Pete would say to me, "got a boyfriend, yet?" Biff chimed in, on cue: "would that make him -- I mean her -- gay?" Then Biff would mince across the living room. "Don't you think she looks cute?" We'd done a little of this sort of thing to Teresa, which used to get her so mad she would punch us. Then Dad would tell us to be nice to her, which would quiet us down for a while. Dad wasn't saying anything to them at all now. And while they were doing this, my breasts were killing me under the ace bandages and my crotch was driving me crazy.
My aunt and uncle just stood in the entrance to the living room and stared as my brothers teased me. I remember my aunt having this appalled look on her face. Then she turned to my dad and said, "Claude, aren't you going to do something?" He just stood there. Then she got him to go into the front hall, and a few minutes later, he stormed into the living room and started yelling at my brothers.
"How can you do this to your own brother? You should be supporting him." They looked stunned. "How's he getting treated at school?" They just stared. He looked at me.
"Like they were doing to me now," I said. "Sometimes worse. I stopped going to gym, it was so bad."
He looked at Biff. "Is it true?" Biff nodded. "You should be defending your brother. Haven't you heard, 'he ain't heavy, he's my brother'? I'm very, very disappointed in you. In both of you." It didn't make much sense to me, either. Pete wasn't even at my school, so how could he defend me?
Both of them got really quiet, and after a few minutes, they politely excused themselves and went downstairs to the TV room. Aunt Edith and Mom went into the kitchen. That left Uncle Boris and Dad in the living room in the upholstered chairs talking about work and cars and Dad trying to sue the hospital and Teresa and me on the couch, saying nothing.
"Want to go upstairs and hang out in my room?" I asked. She nodded, and we quietly snuck out of the living room. I don't know if my dad even noticed. I showed her my CD collection and asked if there was anything she'd like to hear. She kept looking at me like she was trying to figure me out. She picked out a CD and I put it on. She sat on the floor with her arms around her knees and I sat on the bed. She was wearing a simple shirt dress which wouldn't have actually hid what she had on underneath, except she was sitting so I couldn't. I suddenly wondered: is this intentional? Has she learned exactly how to sit so no one can see? Was this something I needed to learn?
"You know, Martin, you're a lot nicer to me than you usually are."
"Making fun of you isn't any fun now, now that I know what it's like to be on the receiving end. I'm sorry now that I was so mean to you in the past. That was really shitty of me. Also, it's nice to be around someone who isn't picking on me. My own age, I mean."
"Is it that bad? Don't you have any friends?"
"I used to have some guys who would talk with me about stuff, like music or motorcycles or what we'd do when we got out of West Hell -- that's our name for West High. But they're afraid to be seen around me now."
"Martin?" She looked straight at me. "I'd be willing to talk to you. I'd even try to help. I think I could get my parents to help, too. I know you're going through Hell right now. Just -- well, just don't be mean to me any more, okay?"
"I promise," I said, with as serious an expression as I could manage. "I really appreciate you being willing to talk to me. The worst part of all this is that I don't have anyone to talk to." I told her about the shrink. "And Dad and Mom just don't want to think about what's happening to me, so there's no point in talking to them."
We listened to another CD, just rocking and grooving on it. When it was over, I said, "you know, there's something you might be able to help with, but it might be a little embarrassing."
"For me? Or for you?"
"Both, maybe. You see, my body's turning into a female body, and there's lots of stuff I don't know about it. I can't talk to my mom about it. I figure, your mom must have helped you when you were growing up and getting, uh, you know."
"Breasts? Menstruation? Sex?"
I blushed a little. "Yeah, that kind of stuff."
"Maybe I'm not so easy to embarrass as you think. How far along is your, ah, transformation?"
"Pretty far. I have breasts and my crotch looks like what those medical web sites show for a woman's crotch. I've been squashing my breasts with lots of ace bandages, but it hurts like hell. Do you have any suggestions?"
"Do you mind showing me? I won't make fun of you."
I was afraid I was going to get really embarrassed. At least I didn't have to worry about getting a hard-on. I pretended it was another one of those physical exams and took my shirt off, then the ace bandages. If she'd smiled or giggled, I don't know what I'd have done, but she kept a serious expression and looked carefully at my chest.
"They look like full-sized breasts all right. A little bruised -- I don't think the ace bandages are doing them any good. I'll ask my mom, but I think you're going to have to get used to the idea that you'll need a bra."
"Oh, great. That's all the guys at school need, to see me in a bra."
"There might be a way to make it less obvious." She didn't sound too hopeful, though. "Anyway, do you want to come by this weekend? I'll check with my parents if it's okay, but we're not doing anything."
Mom called us to dinner then. Teresa helped me wrap my breasts up before we went down. We spent dinner mostly talking about neutral subjects, like sports, or how we were doing in school, but every now and then Uncle Boris or Aunt Edith would ask about my condition or what I was enduring in school. Nothing too personal, and always in a way that I could avoid going into more detail than I wanted to. I had a feeling they were listening to every word I said and maybe some I wasn't saying. They also asked my parents things, but whenever it was about me, the questions just slid right off like they were made of Teflon. I was mostly enjoying being able to eat without my brothers persecuting me.
After dinner, I followed Aunt Edith, Teresa, and my mom into the kitchen to help with the cleaning up. The other guys went into the living room. Aunt Edith gave me a questioning look.
"If I'm here, Pete and Biff won't be tempted to pick on me." She went back to scraping plates.
"Hey, Mom?" Teresa said. "Can Martin come over this weekend?"
"Certainly. Not Friday, we have some chores to get done and your dad has to work that day. But Saturday would be fine."
"When?" I asked.
"All day, if you want. We get up by 8:00; if you're there then, we could feed you breakfast. We go to bed arond 10:00. P.m.," she added.
"I don't think I could get anyone to drive me over that early."
"If you have trouble getting a ride, one of us could fetch you."
"That's really nice of you, but I'll try to get my mom or dad to drive me."
By the time we finished cleaning up and dividing up the left-overs, it was dark. We all sat around in the living room for a while making small talk, and then my aunt and uncle and Teresa left.
I got my mother to agree to take me over to Teresa's. The earliest she'd leave was 8:00, though. She said she'd pick me up if I gave her a few hours' notice. So, Saturday morning, I packed up a few CDs and got driven to my aunt's and uncle's.
When I got there, they were just finishing breakfast. Teresa was still in her pyjamas, working on some toast, and looked surprised to see me. I apologized for getting there too early, but Teresa said it was fine and offered me a muffin. I showed her the CDs, but she said it was too early. We went upstairs to her room.
"I talked to my mom, and she thinks you probably need a bra. You can't keep squashing your breasts like that, and since you say the nipples are sore, you need a bra that protects them. She also says you can get bras that make your breasts less obvious. But you need to go to a store that specializes in bras. We can take you shopping next weekend."
"Thanks. It's sort of scary, but I guess that's what I need to do."
"Anything else I can help you with?"
"There is something. I hope it's not too stupid." I think I blushed again. "What do you do about when your pants legs bother you -- irritate your legs right up here." I pointed to right near my crotch.
"Is it getting red and all?"
"No, more like it, uh, tickles or itches or something." I didn't want to describe it more accurately.
"Is it better when you don't have pants on?"
"Oh, yes. When I'm alone in my room, I take them off, and it's so much better. But I can't walk around the house or outside in just my underwear."
She looked like she was weighing her words. "I don't know if you'll like this suggestion, but: would you be willing to try a skirt? It wouldn't have pants legs to irritate you. And it wouldn't have to look all girly."
I thought about it for a minute or two, but the way my legs were bothering me kind of pushed me over. "Okay, I'll try one. But -- would you have one that fit me?"
"I've got one in a one-size-fits-all size. It's sort of flowery and long, but I don't think it's too bad." She went into her closet and pulled it out. It was long and crinkly and had some sort of pink and blue pattern. "Do you want to put it on now?"
I nodded.
"I'll turn my back while you change," she said, and turned. I took off my shoes, then took a deep breath, slipped off my pants, and pulled the skirt on up to my waist. Within a few seconds, I felt relief.
"You know, maybe you can take off the ace bandage. No one here is going to tease you about it." I pulled my shirt off, and she started taking the bandages off. When she was done, I could see my breasts kind of slumping down. They weren't exactly pin-up size, but they weren't tiny. And I had to admit, on a girl, they wouldn't have looked half bad. I tried putting my shirt back on and looked in the mirror. The breasts weren't all that obvious, but you could tell they were there if you looked. I stood back and looked at myself. It had been a long time since I'd looked at my whole body in the mirror. I hadn't even looked at my face since October, when what little beard hair that I'd had had been gone for weeks.
I looked like someone else.
I looked like a girl. A fashion-challenged girl, but still a girl.
It wasn't just my chest that had changed. I was shorter, my hips were wider. And my face looked different. I couldn't figure out exactly what had changed, but it didn't look like I remembered it.
"It's so weird. I'm looking in the mirror, and I'm seeing a girl. Not me. The skirt and the no bandage and ...."
"Hey, Martin. Have you looked at yourself in the mirror lately? You don't look a lot different from when you came in. I know it sucks. I know it's not what you want. Hey, I'd be pretty upset, too, if one day I started looking like a boy. But maybe you need to start getting used to it. I mean, suppose you'd gotten this horrible burn scar. You could have gotten one in that motorcycle accident. You'd have to get used to looking that way."
"I guess you're right. But -- I don't think I'm ready yet."
"Now, can you turn your back so I can get dressed?"
After she got dressed, I tried looking in the mirror again. If I didn't think about it being me, I could see that "she" wasn't bad-looking. Maybe even a little pretty. I shuddered and felt a heavy rock drop down through the bottom of my stomach. I turned away.
"Let's go downstairs and talk to my mom."
"Dressed like this?"
"Why not? It's not like it will bother them. It's not half as weird as what they already know about you.
When her mother saw me, she looked me up and down, but said nothing and her expression was pretty casual.
"He's wearing a skirt because pants rub in sensitive places."
My aunt nodded. "Do you like it?" she asked.
"It's a little girly for my taste."
"Maybe when we go shopping next Saturday we can find something that's a little more masculine-looking."
I plopped down on a chair. "What's the use?" I moaned. "I'm going to look like a girl no matter what I do."
Teresa started to say something, but her mother interrupted. "Give him some space. Let him feel it. It's going to take a while for -- it'll just take a while. Martin: do you want us to leave you alone?"
I shook my head. I was trying to hold off tears, but I didn't want to be alone. "But I'm keeping you from whatever you were going to do today. And I'm sure I'm boring Teresa."
"This is more important."
"What's more important?"
"How you're feeling. Helping you deal with all this."
Now I did start to cry. The idea that how I felt was important to somebody besides me, that they'd drop what they were doing to make me feel better. I couldn't take it in.
I won't bore you with the details. Short version: I spent the next fifteen minutes or so crying and feeling sorry for myself and Aunt Edith stroking my shoulder until I'd cried myself out.
Once I was able to do more than whimper, Aunt Edith and I arranged that we would all go clothes shopping next Saturday. She extracted from me the fact that my boy-underwear wasn't fitting right any more, so she added that to the list. Bras, skirts, now underwear. And shirts that would hide my breasts, sort of.
Teresa suggested we go for a walk.
"Dressed like this?"
Teresa rolled her eyes. "Is that all you can say? Nobody's going to think anything weird, even if they see us. Most people are inside, or if they're outside, they're working and won't pay attention to us."
We got on our shoes and coats and walked the block to the nature preserve. It was warm for the end of November, but that's still not warm, and my legs got cold. I reminded myself that outdoor gym class in gym shorts was even colder and soldiered on, but by the time we got back, I was cold through and through. Uncle Boris was in the kitchen, and when he saw us, he made some mugs of hot chocolate to warm us up.
"How's it going?" my uncle asked.
"Should I be honest?"
"Of course."
"Pretty shook up. I looked in the mirror and I don't look like me any more. Nobody's going to see me, they'll see some girl."
He'd been standing while Teresa and I sat, but he squatted down until his eyes were level with mine, in a sort of man-to-man attitude.
"When I look at you, I see my nephew Martin. Your appearance may have changed a little, but I still see the same Martin." He stared at me for a few more minutes. "Your appearance is not you. It's what's inside that's you, okay?" Then he stood up. "What do you say we download a movie and make some popcorn?"
"A horror movie!" Teresa squealed. Then she got a serious look on her face and asked me, "do you like horror movies?"
I didn't, actually, but didn't want to disappoint her. "As long as they're not too scary." So we downloaded a campy horror movie, which took us to dinner time. I thought I should call my mom for a ride, since she wanted a few hours notice, but Uncle Boris said he'd drive me. I stayed for dinner -- leftover turkey.
When it was time to go, I went to change into my pants.
"Don't you want to keep the skirt on?"
"I don't want to have to deal with my family's reaction. I don't know how I'm going to explain it if your mom really does buy me a skirt next week. It really was a lot more comfortable, though," I added wistfully.
I changed, but she insisted on giving it to me in a bag. "Don't worry about the skirt," my uncle said as he drove me home. "Edith will talk to your dad and straighten it out."
When I got home, my brothers were in the living room watching the TV there. Since Thanksgiving, they hadn't dared to harrass me. They looked all stiff and nervous, like they didn't know how to act around me. Actually, my parents did, too. It was like I was living with strangers.
On Monday, I plunged back into West Hell, doing my best to just focus on schoolwork and ignore everything else. Wednesday night, I called Teresa but got my aunt.
"Everything's straightened out. They won't bother you about wearing a skirt or a bra or whatever. Whether at home or out."
I spoke to Teresa, but she said couldn't talk long because of homework. She suggested I text her, but not expect her to answer right away. I had to look around on the web to find out how to text on my phone. I texted "see you Saturday" and went to bed. Next morning, I saw a reply that was sent an hour or so after my message: "Saturday see you :)"
Meanwhile, at school, I saw some signs that Biff was trying to stick up for me. When I saw him with his friends, a lot of the time he was arguing with them. One time I thought they'd get into a fight, but he just stormed off. I don't think it did much good, though.
Saturday, I put on the skirt and I didn't bandage my chest. My mom didn't say anything, but did take me over to my aunt's. I couldn't help noticing that she didn't talk to me, except for the essentials. It was a very quiet ride. Just as I was getting out, she said, "maybe you should look at the bus routes. I think there's a crosstown bus that goes near your aunt's house."
Aunt Edith said we'd go to the bra shop first, but before we went, she got me to measure myself for underwear. Then she sat me down.
"Martin, you're going to have to decide how you'd like us to introduce you to the salespeople: as a girl or as a boy. If we present you as a boy, you'll end up having to give more explanations than I think you want to. If you don't want that, I think you'll have to put up with being my niece and having people refer to you as 'she'. I'll go with whatever you decide, but I'd like to settle it now, not when we walk into a store."
I thought about it: letting them pretend I was a girl was one more step down a path I really didn't want to go, but I really didn't want to have a long conversation with every salesperson, and I really, really didn't want people to look at me like I was a freak all day. I sighed and said, "I'll go as your niece. What's my name?"
"Martina?" suggested my aunt. "That way if we slip up and call you 'Martin,' it won't be so obvious."
I winced. "That's what the jerks at school have been calling me. But maybe I can stand it for one day. If I have to use a girl's name, I'd like to think about which one."
The lady at the bra store was just what I'd expected: a hearty, big-chested lady in who looked like one of those society matrons out of a Marx Brothers movie. Aunt Edith introduced me.
"This is my niece Martina. She's getting fitted for her first bra. She's not too wild about it and she'd like something that doesn't make it too obvious."
I was afraid the lady would start getting chummy with me, but she didn't. Either my aunt's comments or my hunched shoulders and unhappy face must have signalled to her that I wasn't in the mood for being jollied or for nosy questions.
"I'll see if I have something in a Minimizer. I think you want it to fit right," she directed to me. I just nodded. "Any other things I need to think about? Special closures?"
My aunt replied for me, "she's having sore nipples, do you have something that won't rub or press on them?"
"I'll see." She turned to me and in what I guess was her most clinical way, she said, "Martina, I'm going to have to measure you. You'll have to pull up your shirt. If you want, we can go in a dressing room. Do you want your aunt or -- is that your cousin?"
"Cousin. No, I'm okay with just you. In a dressing room." It wasn't as embarrassing as I thought it'd be. The exams at the sex-change lab (that's what I was calling it) were worse. She told me to stand up straight with my shoulders back, took a few measurements, looked carefully at my breasts, and then went out to her stockroom. A few minutes later, she returned with a stack of boxes and started putting bras against my chest. When she'd narrowed them down to a few, she showed me how to put one on and got me to try them all. We found one that wasn't too uncomfortable and didn't press too hard on my nipples, which were still a little sore. I took a deep breath, left that one on, and put my shirt back on. My aunt bought three and also bought some women's panties in what I assumed was my size.
The next stop was a clothing store. I basically put myself in Aunt Edith's and Teresa's hands, and they found me a denim skirt that went over my knees and didn't look too girly and some shirts that were loose enough that the bra didn't show much. They also picked up some cotton T-shirts, which they said would make it so you couldn't see the bra through the shirt. They found a sock store at the same mall and picked up some knee socks. They also insisted on getting a package of black tights. When I protested, they said that men also wear tights and I would need them if I wore the skirt in winter. I didn't talk much, but still the sales people called me "miss." It grated, but I didn't protest.
We stopped off at a fast-food place for lunch, then headed home. The bra felt funny, but my back and chest no longer hurt and my nipples just felt tingly instead of sore. On the way back, Teresa was lost in thought, then looked at me and laughed.
"Am I so funny?"
"No, I was just thinking about a story I read, and you were reminding me of it. It's Kafka's The Metamorphosis"
"What's it about?"
"It's about this guy.... Uh, maybe I shouldn't have said anything."
"You might as well tell me, I'll find out anyway."
"It's this guy who wakes up one morning and finds out he's now a giant cockroach. His family isn't very nice to him. I'm sorry, that's not how I think of you. I shouldn't have said anything."
"You've got a point. Things could be a lot worse. Maybe if they'd done the brain treatment on me the same time as the sex-change, I would have been turned into a giant cockroach. Can you imagine what they'd say at school if I'd shown up as a giant cockroach?" We laughed all the way home.
Back at their house, I changed into my new clothes. I looked at myself in the mirror. I looked like a boyish girl, but I had to admit, I now had a "look."
"It actually looks kind of cool," Teresa said after I'd looked at myself for a while. "But I have to agree, you're not a 'Martina.' If you end up going as a girl much, we'll have to come up with a better name."
"What do you mean, 'going as a girl'?" This was getting to be too much. I'd spent the morning letting myself be called "miss" and I didn't want to think about having to do it regularly.
"Be reasonable, Martin. There are going to be times like today when you can't pass as a boy, and it'll be easier to just let people assume you're a girl. You can still be Martin the rest of the time."
Uncle Boris called us downstairs, which cut off further discussion. My aunt and uncle looked at me and pronounced my clothing a success, then we all went out to a movie and then came back for dinner. When it was time for me to go home, I mentioned my mother's comment about busses, so Uncle Boris looked up the bus routes. I asked Teresa if we could get together again next Saturday.
"Oh, Martin, I'm sorry, but I have friends coming over."
"And you don't want me around then, I guess." As soon as I said it, I felt like a petulant little kid.
"Martin, it wouldn't work. Right now, you need all my attention when I'm with you. I'm not putting you down, you're in a tough spot right now. But I can't pay attention to my friends and give you the attention you need at the same time. Why don't you come over Sunday afternoon? I'll try and get my homework done by then."
I agreed to that and tried to look grateful. Uncle Boris had printed out some timetables and we all worked out times and routes for next Sunday. Then my uncle drove me home.
I tried wearing the bra and T-shirt combination to school. I had to wear one of my new shirts over it, because my old ones were too small. I expected people to find out and harrass me for it, but I actually didn't have much trouble. Either they didn't notice, or they already assumed I was wearing one. The harrassment wasn't better, but it wasn't worse than last week, which I counted as a plus.
Meanwhile, I was discovering things about my body. At home, I'd always spent a lot of time in my room, but more so now that things were so weird at home and I didn't have any friends. I'd taken to feeling my breasts and my crotch a lot, mostly to get used to what they were shaped like and to the feelings I got when I touched them. It felt funny to be shaped that way, and I guess it was a way of getting used to it. I was discovering that gently rubbing my breasts or just touching the insides of my thighs or pretty much anywhere near my crotch turned me on.
Anyway, I'd be rubbing somewhere and I wouldn't want to stop, and then, after another while that just felt better and better, I'd have a feeling sort of like what I had when I had a penis and I'd jack off, only different. I'd heard that girls masturbate. I didn't exactly know how they did it, but I wondered if this was it. I also wondered if Teresa did it. I was sure her parents would have let her know that it was just fine for her to do it. Once I got the hang of it, it wasn't hard for me to get myself off. One time, I managed it just rubbing my breasts and tickling my nipples. This must be what Dr. Newcomb meant by "an approximation of female sexual response." I have to admit, I liked it, but at the same time, I was weirded out by it.
I was trying out wearing the skirt at home. It really was a lot more comfortable and it felt kind of cool to be able to move my legs around without pants legs pulling on them. Sort of like being naked from the waist down without actually being naked. I came down to dinner once or twice wearing it and nobody said anything. I think they were trying to pretend it wasn't happening. I didn't blame them. I even went out a few times after dark, when I figured no one would see. But the cold air got under my skirt, and I was really cold!
I tried the tights a few times, just to see what it felt like. It felt really funny, cold and hot at the same time. But one thing I noticed: I didn't have the same problem with my thighs that I had with pants. They didn't rub me the same way. Mostly, they didn't move around at all. I thought about wearing them under my pants at school.
I'd go back and forth. One minute, it all felt perfectly logical and normal, the next minute I felt like I was getting swallowed up by quicksand. Every move I made seemed to be pulling me into being a girl. It felt like it was turning me into not-me.
I survived the week. I spoke to Teresa on the phone once, and texted her almost every night. I don't know what I wanted, maybe just to know that someone would talk to me and would return my texts.
I spent Saturday Christmas shopping. I went to a mall on the other side of town, to practice using the bus. It also had the advantage that I wasn't likely to see anyone from West High there. I wore the skirt with knee socks. I got called "miss" most of the time, but I ignored it. It was cold outside and, with just knee socks, my legs were numb by the time I got on the bus. Maybe tights weren't such a bad idea, after all.
I tried wearing tights the next day on my trip to Teresa's, and they were a lot warmer. I had to walk a mile from my house to the bus, wait for the bus, then walk a mile and a half to Teresa's. I was still cold, but it wasn't as bad as the day before.
When I got there, I went up to Teresa's room. We listened to music for a while, then Teresa asked me, "Martin, have you considered just living as a girl? Or at least trying it out.?"
"What do you mean?" I could feel the walls closing in on me. It seemed like everyone was calling me a girl, putting me down.
"It would be a lot easier. Maybe change schools and register as a girl. You'd still be the same person--"
I interrupted her. "What is this? Is everyone in league with the sex-change mad scientists? I'm a boy, dammit, but you and your aunt -- and the jerks in school -- you're all out to make me what I'm not. Like the guy in that story."
"Martin --" she protested, but I was really going now.
"Is that why you've been pretending to be nice to me? So you can get me to act like a girl? And maybe make fun of me then? You're trying to turn me into a giant cockroach! You and your aunt and uncle, you're all as bad as the kids at school!"
I was screaming now. And so was Teresa.
"You're awful!" she shouted. "You promised not to be mean to me and now you've broken your promise! You're just as bad as your brothers! I hate you! I never want to see you again!"
I could feel tears coming into my eyes. I grabbed my jacket and ran down the stairs and out the door. It was a lot colder, so I ran all the way to the bus stop. I only had to wait for about 10 minutes, so I didn't freeze.
By the time the bus had reached center city, my anger had cooled and I was beginning to feel like I'd been unfair. My accusations were ridiculous, I was just upset by the whole sex-change thing and had dumped it all on her. As we got closer to my stop, I was also realizing that I'd just driven away the only friend I had. By the time I reached my house, I felt like I was the one who was just as bad as the kids at school. I wanted to kill myself, I felt so bad.
In my room, I thought, well, you could at least apologize. Even if she never wants to see you again, at least you'll have done one halfway decent thing. I spent the rest of the afternoon writing a letter:
Dear Teresa,
I was wrong. I was unfair. Your suggestion was a a reasonable one, and I'm thinking it over, and even if I decide not to do it, I know you did it with the best intentions. I was just frustrated with lots of things, none of which are your fault, and I took it out on you. You've done nothing but good to me and I treated you like shit. I'm sorry. I don't deserve to have you forgive me, but I'll ask anyway. I'll do whatever you ask. But if you don't want to see me ever again, I'll understand. Whatever happens, I wish you the best. You deserve that much.
I went out and found a mailbox and mailed the letter. Then I came home and texted Teresa: "I was wrong. Please read letter."
At dinner, my dad asked Biff if he'd managed to get the boys to lay off of me.
"I tried, Dad. I really did. But they won't listen to me. Now they won't be my friends and they're harrassing me, too. I've almost gotten in a fight several times. I never realized what jerks -- total jerks -- they are. I'm not sorry for myself that they aren't my friends, but I'm sorry for Martin that I can't do anything for him."
My mom and dad got this empty look that really scared me. I think Biff and Pete were scared, too.
School was much harder to face now that I didn't have a friend in the world. I hoped Teresa would get the letter and at least know I didn't mean what I said. I didn't want to get my hopes up that she'd maybe forgive me. Monday, Tuesday went by. Wednesday night, I got a call. From Teresa.
"I got your letter," she said.
"I'm sorry I said those things to you. I was really a jerk. A total jerk."
"You were being a jerk, but I shouldn't have said what I did, either. I know you're under a lot of strain, and people who are under a lot of strain say things they don't really mean. I'll forgive you. But, please, try not to take things out on me. It really hurts when you do that."
"I promise. But I don't know how much my promise is worth now."
"It's okay. You made up for it with that letter. I have a lot of respect for a guy who'll admit he was wrong. One thing, though. You keep talking like being a girl is something horrible. But I'm a girl. Don't you think it's a little insulting to me, and my mom, and, well, all of us to act like it's the end of the world? Think about it."
I said I would.
"Now that we've got that out of the way, do you want to come over Saturday? I still need to do some Christmas shopping and would love to have company."
"I'd love to. I've taken care of my family, but I'd like to get stuff for your parents and I could use your advice."
The rest of the week of school was almost tolerable. Nothing had actually changed at school, but Teresa was back to being my friend.
I took the bus over on Saturday and we went shopping. I was getting used to going out in public in a bra and a skirt and tights. Nobody ever even looked twice at me.
I was having trouble figuring out what to get my aunt and uncle. They were suddenly a big part of my life -- Teresa, too -- and I didn't feel like I could give them sort of random presents. "You know, I don't really know what your parents like. I mean, I've always just gotten your dad a tie and your mom something for the kitchen, but now that I think of it, that makes it sound like I'd gone to a store and grabbed the first thing I saw on the 'for Mom' and 'for Dad' tables."
"You know Dad likes to cook, even if he doesn't do it that often. Um... He likes classical music. No, rennaisance music, really. You know, before Bach. But I don't know what he has, if you're not careful, you'd probably get him something he already has. Oh, I know! He likes Legos. It's kind of a secret vice, he doesn't want anyone outside the family to know. I think it's cool, but he's afraid other people will think he's immature.
"I don't know about Mom. I usually get her a scarf or a blouse, but that would be hard for you. She also likes books. She's got all of Jane Austin's books, she majored in English in college."
Teresa had gotten her Dad a T-shirt that said, "Champion Beer Drinker." I think that was some kind of in-joke, because she also got him some flower bulbs. I don't remember what kind, but they must have been the kind you can plant in the winter. She was going to buy another blouse, but then found a necklace. After that we went to one of the toy stores where I got her dad a Lego railroad car, and then to the bookstore. I must have spent an hour looking for stuff I thought an English major might like. I finally settled on Little Women, and just hoped she didn't already have it. I wasn't sure I wanted to think about why I wanted that book to be her gift from me.
We wandered around a little longer to see if there was anything that jumped out at us as being just right for someone. At the last store, a poster shop, Teresa ran into a friend of hers.
"Hi, Teresa! Long time no see."
"Hi, Carol. This is my cousin Martin. Martin, this is my BFF Carol Vanderbrook."
I could see her trying to figure it out. "Is Martin a girl's name now?" she asked.
"It's a long story. If I tell it to you, you've got to promise to keep it secret, at least for now."
"It won't be much of a secret if you tell it at the mall. Can I come over? I'm almost done shopping. If I can ride with you, I'll tell my mom. And then you can tell me."
Teresa looked at me. I shrugged. "Sure," she said. "My dad's picking us up at 3:00."
So Carol called her parents and said she'd be going over to Teresa's, and Teresa called her dad to ask if it was okay for Carol to come over. ("It always is," she said.) My uncle drove us home and fed us hot chocolate. Then the three of us ended up in Teresa's room. She told the story of the motorcycle accident, the mix-up at the hospital, and mentioned the crap I was going through at school.
"I was saying, he might find it easier to pass as a girl. He's still thinking about it."
"She -- I mean he -- did a good job of fooling me. Is your body really -- I mean, is everything --"
"Yes, I look like a girl under my clothes. I mean, I haven't seen a lot of naked girls, but from the pictures I've seen, yeah, you'd probably never guess I used to be a boy. And Teresa is right," I sighed, "it'll probably be easier if at least sometimes, I just let people think I'm a girl. I'm sure the salespeople at the mall thought I was. I'm still not ready to do it with people who know me."
"We're still working on a name," Teresa continued. "He doesn't like 'Martina,' because the kids at school tease him with that. And I don't think he looks like a Martina, anyway."
"How about Melanie?" Carol suggested. "It also starts with M, and it's nice and smooth."
We batted around a few other names, like "Michelle" and "Moira," but I didn't like any of them as much as Melanie.
"Melanie it is, then," pronounced Teresa.
We listend to a CD. Carol asked, "was it tough, suddenly finding out you were going to be transformed into a girl?"
"You have no idea."
"Probably not. I imagine it would turn me upside down. I don't know what I'd do if I found out I was going to turn into a boy. I mean, there's nothing wrong with being a boy, but I'm happy as a girl."
Teresa and Carol started talking about mutual friends, and I just leaned against the wall, eventually stretching out on the carpet. It was nice and friendly and I enjoyed just being around people who accepted me and weren't being mean to me. Teresa started stroking my hair while they talked. It felt a little weird, but it was nice. Eventually, my aunt called us down to dinner. I don't remember what we said or did, just that I felt relaxed and at home in a way I hadn't felt in who knows how long. My uncle drove Carol and me home, and when Carol got out, she said, "goodbye, Melanie." It took me a second to realize she was talking about me. It felt kinda weird, but also kinda nice, like she was accepting me -- maybe more than I was accepting myself. It left me with a glow that lasted all the way home, and maybe even a little afterwards.
I could never have believed it, but it seemed like I was almost getting used to all the crap at school. I also wondered if they were getting bored by it. Besides, there was Christmas to think of. At home, I was pretty much always wearing my skirt and thinking maybe I'd like a second one. I was also texting Teresa. I tried not to do it too often, maybe once an evening, and she'd reply in an hour or so.
Two days before Christmas -- the first day of Christmas break -- I woke up to a nasty surprise. I'd been dreaming that I was peeing in my clothes and was feeling my legs and pants all wet. When I woke up, I still felt sort of damp down there. When I felt around, it felt sticky. It was blood. I totally freaked out, but quietly. Was there something wrong with their sex-change thing, and now I was dying? I got up and found some blood in my pj's, and some on the sheet, but it hadn't made it onto the matress. I took the sheet and the pj's to the bathroom and quietly washed the blood out, because I'd heard that you won't get a stain if you wash it out soon enough. I discovered that the blood was coming from my vagina. It felt so weird to put those two words together: "my" and "vagina." It wasn't really bleeding, just sort of oozing. I washed it off and stuffed some toilet paper inside. I put on some underwear -- my new underwear -- and stuffed lots of toilet paper inside.
As soon as I thought someone would be in, I called Dr. Newcomb's office. I must have been on some kind of VIP list, because he called me back in about 5 minutes.
"Doctor, I'm bleeding. From my, uh, vagina." I said the last word kind of quietly.
"Is it a large quantity? Would it fill a cup?" He sounded worried.
"No, it's just sort of oozing."
He sounded relieved. "You're just menstruating. You know what that is, right?"
"What!?! Yes, I know, but why am I, uh, you know?"
"It's something our subjects -- our patients -- wanted, and it wasn't hard to add."
"So now I'm going to be bleeding -- how often?"
"About once very 28 days. It's usually pretty regular."
"Oh, jeez! I gotta sit down." I was already sitting down, but, whatever. "And you didn't think to warn me about this? You wanted it to be some kind of Christmas present? Thanks, Santa!"
"I didn't want to get you worried. You were upset enough already." No, you didn't want us to get any madder at you.
"So, do you have any more surprises for me? When does my head fall off?"
"You're head won't fall off, don't worry." Doesn't this guy have any sense of sarcasm? "Hmm. Oh, yes, you may lactate a bit certain times of the month."
"Lactate?" I thought I knew what he meant, but I didn't want to.
"You have functional milk glands. Most men, do. Well, the hormones your body is producing at certain points in your monthly cycle will stimulate them to produce milk. With the right stimulation, you could get them to produce enough to nourish a baby. It probably won't be very much, but I thought I'd warn you."
I went and changed the toilet paper and peed. It was pretty messy. Then I texted Teresa:
"Dr Newconb's Xmas surprise: I'm menstruating."
To fill up the time, I wrapped my Christmas presents. About 20 minutes later, I was almost finished, when Teresa called me.
"You're kidding, aren't you?"
"I wish I were. Now I have to figure out how to not bleed all over everything. I should have paid attention in health class, I guess."
"Do you want me or my mom to come over and help you with it? I could take the bus, or my mom could pop over on her lunch hour. Or you could come here."
We arranged that I would take the bus over. She would show me how to use a tampon and a sanitary napkin, and then we'd walk over to the local drug store and I would buy my first "feminine hygene products."
When I got there, she gave me a washcloth and sent me into the bathroom to take off my tights and underwear and wash up. When I finished, I suddenly felt weird about letting her see my body like this, but I didn't see any alternative, either. I steeled myself and went into her room.
"I've got a tampon and a sanitary napkin. You could try using one, or we can do both so you can see how to do it yourself. I don't mind showing you, but I'm not going to do it for you each time!" She looked at my red face and added, "I admit it, I kind of like embarrassing you a little. Revenge for all the mean things you used to say to me, I guess."
She got me to pull up my skirt and sit on a towel on her bed. Then she showed me a tampon and how to slide it into my vagina. I was afraid I would feel weird, but by this point, we were too involved in what we were doing. She then showed me how to put a sanitary napkin into my underwear. "If you're using a tampon, you have to change it every couple of hours. And you shouldn't wear just tampons during your period, you should sometimes use a pad." I put my underpants and tights back on. I didn't go back to the bathroom to get dressed because, well, she'd seen it all already.
"Thanks for helping me out. I don't know who else I could have talked to. I don't think my mom could have dealt with it."
"Probably not."
"But -- isn't it a little weird for you, doing it with your cousin, knowing that I'm really a boy, or at least used to be?"
She shrugged. "It isn't weird for me. I guess my parents raised me not to be self-conscious about my body. I mean, I don't take my clothes off at school or anything, but if I'm in a situation where I need to get undressed, like skinny dipping or a physical exam, it doesn't bother me that much. I don't mind a boy seeing me naked, as long as I think he isn't going to use it as an excuse to be mean to me. Which a lot of boys do, by the way."
We walked over to the drug store, which was a half-dozen blocks away. On the way, she explained the different sizes and absorbancies I might need. When we got there, she pointed out the boxes of tampons and pads, but I had to actually pick them out and carry them to the register. I was feeling embarrassed and afraid the salespeople would notice, but the cashier didn't really even look at me. I might just as well have been buying cough drops.
I stayed for dinner. During dinner, her dad said to me, "as often as you come over, maybe you should just move in." Teresa giggled and I felt my face getting warm.
"I'm sorry, maybe I am over here too often."
"Your uncle is just teasing you a little," my aunt explained. "He's really saying that we all like having you here. You're welcome any time. But do call first," she added with a smile.
Around the time I discovered Dr. Newcomb's "Christmas present," as I started calling it, we got a call from a local TV reporter, Gary Saunders. He'd apparently heard about my little mishap at the hospital and wanted to run a story about it. I thought I needed that like a baseball bat to the head, but my Dad thought it would help put pressure on the hospital to settle the malpractice suit. We talked with the lawyer and also with my uncle, because he had a lot more experience with PR and talking to the press than my Dad. So we agreed to an interview to take place sometime between Christmas and New Year's.
The lawyer and my uncle had me in for a couple of sessions where they explained to me what I needed to emphasize and what I should downplay. They thought I should mostly say how weird and unhappy it made me feel, and though I should mention some of the bullying, I shouldn't make a big deal about it since it might make people think that the school was the problem and not the hospital. I thought that was backwards -- the sex change wasn't fun, but what was really making me miserable was all the crap I was getting at school.
Anyway, a few days after Christmas, we met on a sidewalk across from the hospital. I insisted I didn't want it near my house because the last thing I wanted was for people to go drive by to see where the freak lives. It was a grey day so they had lights set up so we wouldn't look like zombies. The reporter looked like he thought he was the biggest celebrity on the planet. He had a fancy suit and a tie with the TV station's logo and his hair was slicked up in a fancy wave and he had this big self-satisfied smile on his face. Yeah, he didn't make a good impession on me.
The lawyer had had me put on my boy-jeans which were really too small and a band T-shirt which was also now a little too small, so I would look like I was supposed to be a boy, but they would also see that I had boobs and a girl's butt. It was kind of humiliating.
They started off with some shots of me and Mr. Saunders with the hospital behind us. The hospital hadn't let them inside (I couldn't blame them), but they'd gotten some close-up shots of the outside. Then they got me to face the camera and Mr. Saunders started in.
"For KZTV, this is Gary Saunders, star reporter--" No, he didn't actually say "star reporter", but he might as well have. "-- and I have with me Martin Rawlings. Until six months ago, Martin was a normal boy, spending time with other boys, playing baseball. Then an unfortunate motorcycle accident landed him in here" -- he pointed to the hospital -- "where he was mistakenly exposed to an experimental treatment which turned him from a boy into --" (dramatic pause while they pointed the camera straight at me) "-- a girl. Martin, can you describe for us what happened to you?"
"Well, uh, it's kind of embarrassing."
"I understand. But we need to know. We need to know what they (points at hospital) did to you."
"My, uh, stuff started shrinking. It took a while. Months. And then I started getting, uh, breasts. I didn't know what was happening. I thought maybe I had some strange fatal disease. It was scary. Weird. Surreal."
"Would you say, humiliating?"
"Kind of. I mean, if I were a girl, at least it would be what's supposed to happen. But I'm a boy. It's like if I had put a West High shirt on in the morning and came to school and when I looked, I saw it had morphed into a Hollingsworth sweatshirt."
"Hollingsworth High is the arch rival of Martin's school," Mr. Saunders explained. "Did you have a lot of problems at school because of it? Or with your friends?"
"Oh, yeah! Lots of people act like I'm some kind of pervert, even thought it wasn't me that did anything. And my friends are afraid to say anything because the other kids might think they were perverts, too." The lawyer was watching, and I could see he wasn't happy."
"So would you say you're getting bullied because of it?"
I knew I was supposed to downplay it, but I'm no good at lying. "Yeah, kind of." I couldn't look at the lawyer.
"How is your family taking it?"
"They're trying to be supportive. Like, my brother is trying to stick up for me at school. But it's hard. It's weird for them, too."
"Are you starting to get interested in boys now?" He gave me kind of a leering look.
I looked at him like he was crazy, then I remembered I was supposed to look at the camera. "Right now, I don't have time to get interested in boys or girls. I'm still trying to figure out what's happening to me."
"This must be horrible for you, suddenly having to be a girl. Who would want that?"
I kept thinking what Teresa said, and I started getting mad. "What do you mean, 'who would want that'? Look: I didn't want to be a girl. I was, well, okay with being a boy. But I've got a Mom, and an aunt, and a cousin, she's been like the best friend and the biggest help to me in all of this, and" -- I pointed at the script lady -- "her, and all these girls and women. And if I say who would want to be like them, then I'm telling them, your lives are no good. And that's an insult and a lie. Being a girl is just as good as being a boy!" I practically shouted that last bit, but then I didn't know what to say next. I was sure the lawyer was super pissed at me. "But it's a big change, and getting used to it is hard. Really hard."
"Cut!" said Mr. Saunders. "I think we have enough." Then he shook my hand and said "thanks, boy. Keep up the fight." Fortunately, the lawyer didn't try to talk to me. My uncle and Teresa led me to their car. Teresa gave me a big hug.
"I really liked what you said at the end. I hope they air it. 'Being a girl is just as good as being a boy.' That's a great line."
"I'm sure the lawyer is pissed, though. He wants to say the hospital ruined my life, and here I am saying it's just as good as it was before."
My uncle answered, "he won't have any trouble spinning it. What you said just shows your injury hasn't defeated you, it doesn't say that what the hospital did isn't an injury. And you did say that it's causing you problems."
The next day, the TV station told us I would be on the 7:00 p.m. news. Most of what I said was there, especially my rant at the end. They somehow got a closeup of me when I sad the bit about "really hard." It was a real tear-jerker. But I couldn't help wondering if it would make things better or worse at school.
Due to reader demand, I am posting two shorter chapters as one post. I'll do this going forward when chapters are short and the chapters seem to fit together.
I don't know if it was because of my interview or just because Christmas was over and the people picking on me didn't have to worry about getting on Santa's "naughty" list, but things got a lot worse when I went back to school.
The biggest problem was that the harrassment started to get physical. Sometimes someone would sneak up behind me and try to pull my pants down. They usually managed to expose some of my underwear. Or they'd try to grab the back of my bra and let the band snap back against me. Sometimes two guys would corner me and feel up my breasts. They'd stop if a teacher came by, but if I told the teacher what happened, they'd say I was lying. I don't think the teachers believed them, but they didn't do anything, either. One time, when I was in class and the teacher stepped out, someone tossed a dirty condom on my desk.
The verbal abuse got worse, too. For one thing, the football guys started calling me "it" instead of "he" or even "she." Stuff like, "look what it's wearing today. Doesn't it look stupid." Or, "they say it's a girl, but it's so ugly, I wouldn't fuck it if you paid me." Or if I had books in my hands, they'd knock them down and say things like, "look, it's such a wimp it can't even hold a few books." The guys who always sucked up to the jocks started doing it, too, and then some of the girls from the popular girls' clique. I talked to the teachers, I talked to the administrators, I talked to the school psychologist, but nobody took it seriously.
I told my parents that the harrassment was getting worse, but just hearing that made them so upset that I didn't give any details. When they asked Biff, he just got a sick look on his face and said, "it's bad. Really bad."
The only thing that kept me going was visiting with Teresa. Sometimes she'd have some friends over, but I think she picked who it was, because they were all really nice and sympathetic to me. They said that West High had a reputation for people being pretty mean. Her parents were really nice to me, too. When I was at Teresa's, I felt like it was okay to be myself, whatever that was. I'd hoped I could hang out with her more during winter break, but it seems that for the past six months her family had been planning a vacation to Hawaii for that week, so she wouldn't be around.
One day, about a week before winter break, Tom Prescott and a couple of his buddies cornered me again and dragged me into an empty classroom. I started screaming, and one of them covered my mouth. Tom said, "let's see what it looks like under those stupid clothes," and one of his friends pulled up my shirt so the bra was showing. "Hey, it's got tits," he said, but not too loud, and put his hand on my breast and started squeezing. It hurt some, but it mostly felt gross and made me feel dirty. "It feels like a girl. Let's see if it has a cunt like a girl," he said and started pulling down my pants. He had to unbuckle the belt. They got me onto a desk and pulled my pants down past my shoes. He pulled down my underwear and put his fingers all over my crotch and then stuck one of them inside me. Somehow, I got a cramp there, so he had to push hard and it hurt. I bit the hand that was over my mouth. The guy yelled and then hit me on the head real hard, so my head rang like a bell and I was dazed. When I could see again, Tom's pants were around his knees.
Right then, one of Tom's flunkies stuck his head in the door and yelled, "teacher!" The boys started running out of the classroom. Tom was getting his pants back up when a teacher came in. I guess someone had heard my screams and called a teacher. Tom was still arranging his pants, and two of his buddies were still in the room with him.
"What's going on here?" asked the teacher. I'd seen this teacher, but I didn't know his name.
"Tom and the other guys dragged me in here and pulled my clothes off," I said. I was struggling to get my pants back up over my shoes, and my shirt was still pulled up. "They also hit me." I had a headache from the blow and I could feel a tender spot.
"He's lying, like he always does," Tom said. "He asked us to come in so he could show us his you-know-what."
I don't think the teacher believed him, so he waited for me to get dressed and then hauled all four of us to the principal's office. We all told our stories, and of course the principal believed Tom and his friends. Wouldn't want to mistreat their star athlete. The principal gave me a one-week suspension for being undressed, causing a disturbance, and for lying. They called my mother to pick me up, and got a teacher to walk me back to my locker to pick up my stuff.
My mom was completely silent when she picked me up. The principal had told her his story when he called my mom, but he told her again when she arrived, anyway. We both walked silently to the car and I got in the back. Only when we were on the road did I say anything.
"Mom, the truth is a couple of the jocks dragged me into a classroom and pulled my clothes down. I think they were going to--" I couldn't say it. "Please, Mom, believe me."
"I believe you, son. Oh, how I believe you!" Her voice was really tight. A block later, she pulled over, stopped the car, and turned to face the street.
"Mom--" I said. Then I noticed her shoulders were shaking. She was crying, but without making a sound. I put my hand on her shoulder, and she put a hand on my hand. We sat there, parked, for I don't know how long. At last she stopped shaking and faced the front.
"Yes, I believe you." Her voice sounded all broken up. Then she drove me home.
I was up in my room after dinner, and my parents were in their bedroom. I went down to get a snack, and I heard my mother's voice through the door. I stopped. I could clearly hear my mother say, in that same broken-up voice, "Claude, I don't know what to do. What are we going to do?" Dad said something I couldn't make out. Biff came down and when he saw me standing there, he stopped and started listening, too.
"Claude, I can't stand watching him suffer any more." She was crying. "He's out of it for a week. Two weeks with winter break, but after that, what?" Again, Dad said something we couldn't understand.
We listened some more, but she got quieter, so we couldn't hear what she was saying.
I talked to Teresa that night and told her the story. She was horrified, and called her parents over to talk to me. I told it to them, and they sounded horrified, too. I told them what I'd overheard my mother say.
"We'll figure something out," my uncle said.
"Should we postpone our trip?" asked my aunt.
"No, don't, you all have been looking forward to it for so long. I'll be okay. After all, I'm out of West Hell until after you get back, anyway."
"Just hold on," my uncle said. "You're not going back to that place if I can do anything about it."
I spent the week in my room. I tried dressing in my "girl clothes," then in my "boy clothes." It didn't feel any different. Actually, it didn't feel like anything. To add to my troubles, I got my second period. Another thing to get used to. I texted Teresa and sometimes talked to her on the phone, but she was busy with schoolwork and with getting ready for the trip. She told me I could text her while she was away. She would check from time to time. "Just sit tight and don't do anything stupid." On Saturday, my mom and dad drove me to the airport to see them off.
After Teresa and her family left, I got really down. I kept thinking of the future, and every possibility looked miserable. I could live as a girl, but any school would find out I was born as a boy. My driver's license, whenever I got one, would say Martin, sex male. I could try to live as a boy, but I'd already learned that wouldn't work. And even though Uncle Boris had sort of promised that I wouldn't have to, I was pretty sure that, sooner or later, I'd have to go back to West High, or else some place just as bad.
The only comfort I had was my CDs. I started to listen to real emo groups, ones about how awful life is and how people suck, and it made me feel better while I was listening. But the end of winter break kept getting closer.
Biff and Pete were out a lot, so I had time to wander around the house. I discovered my mom had a bottle of sleeping pills. I kept thinking about taking the whole bottle. I'd heard that alcohol makes them even more deadly, and I knew where my parents kept their vodka. Vodka and sleeping pills, the phrase kept running through my head.
Friday morning, I woke up and knew, if I was going to do it, today was the day. My parents would be around on the weekend, I didn't think I could sneak the pills or the vodka with them around. Plus, they might find me before I was dead. I wrote a letter to Teresa, saying I was very sorry, and that I appreciated all she had done for me. She and her parents had done the best they could, but it was better this way. I waited for my brothers to go out. It was about 10:00. I walked out to the mailbox and stood for a long time with the letter in my hand. If I dropped it in, there was no going back.
I pulled open the door. It felt like it was happening to someone else. I put the letter in, and let go. I walked back home. I went in and got the pills, then went to the kitchen and filled a glass with vodka. I took them up to my room. I took the pills one by one, each with a mouthful of vodka. The vodka tasted terrible, and my stomach started to feel upset, so after half a glass, I switched to water. I went to lie down, then I decided to write a will.
"Please let Teresa take whatever CDs she wants. She is also welcome to take my bunny." I had a stuffed bunny rabbit that I'd had since I was a little kid. I slept with it almost every night, but I'd hide it in a drawer so my mom couldn't find it. He was going to be with me when I went to sleep for the last time, but after that, he'd need a good home.
I wrote a note to my mom and dad. "I know you've done your best, I appreciate it. But this is better. I won't hurt any more. Goodbye." I went to lie down again. Then I thought: I should send a goodbye to Teresa. So I texted, "Thanks for everything. I love you. Goodbye" I don't know why I said "I love you." Then I turned off the ringer. I had my skirt on, but I was getting cold, so I put the tights on. I looked in a mirror. I looked like a girl. Maybe even a pretty girl, I thought. I'll die a girl. It didn't seem so bad.
I turned on my CD player, put my headphones on, and lay down. "Now I lay me down to sleep," I thought. It was the last thought I remember having.
Chapters 16--34
Martin, now Melanie, adjusts to a new family, a new school, and a new sex.
My throat was sore. It hurt like hell. That was the first thing I was aware of. After a while, I noticed I couldn't close my mouth. I remember a long time of just being a sore throat and a mouth stuck open. And I noticed a finger tip hurt, like someone was squeezing it with pliers. And my arms hurt, I couldn't tell exactly where, but there was a sort of burning, pulling feeling, a little like I'd been stung by a big yellow jacket.
I opened my eyes, but couldn't figure out where I was. About then, I remembered I was supposed to be dead. I flirted with the idea that this was the afterlife, but I gave that up pretty fast. I guess I didn't take enough pills, or they were the wrong kind.
I noticed I couldn't move my hands. At first I thought I was paralyzed, but finally figured out that my hands were tied down somewhere. I still wasn't thinking too clearly. I tried to say, untie my hands, but I couldn't form words. I couldn't even control my breath. The thing in my mouth must be a breathing tube. I started to thrash around.
Somebody came over. "She's awake," I heard. I wondered who she was talking about. She disappeared. A few minutes later, someone else in a white coat came by. "Can you hear me?" I nodded vigorously. "Are you ready for me to take the tube out?" I nodded again. "Do you want it to stay in?" I shook my head really hard. "She's responsive." I realized they must think I'm a girl, not that I could blame them.
I won't say anything about taking the breathing tube out, except that it was uncomfortable. Very uncomforatble. My throat hurt even more, but it was nice to be breathing normally. After that, I just lay there, really bored, for the longest time. I looked around and figured out that there were IVs in both arms, and maybe other places.
Eventually, my mom and then my dad came in. They didn't say much, and I couldn't say much. My mom tried to hold my hand even though it was tied down.
"Why are my hands tied?"
"They were afraid you'd hurt yourself. " I wanted to say, that's stupid, but then I remembered I'd just tried to kill myself. "Oh, Martin--" she said and started to cry. I felt really, really bad, because I'd made my mother cry. I had a feeling I'd really fucked up. Finally, my mother calmed down and just sat with me.
"We sat by your bedside last night. We watched the machine breathe for you and prayed you'd be all right." I didn't know what to say.
I think I slept for a while, because the next thing I knew, my mom was gone, and all I heard was the beeping of all those machines. I wondered what time it was. Then I wondered what day it was. Finally, a doctor -- well, someone in a white coat -- came by. He got me to answer some questions, including "how many fingers do I have up?" I was tempted to lie, but then I figured he'd just leave me tied up and full of needles until the next time he came around. He walked away, and a little while later, some nurses came and started taking the needles and gadgets off of me, but they didn't untie me. They wheeled me all over the place into a room with three beds, and then they untied me. There were two guys like football players on either side of me. "Psych ward?" They nodded. "Locked?" They nodded again. "Shit," I said.
"What time is it?" I asked.
"4:30"
"A.m. or p.m.?"
"4:30 p.m. And before you ask, it's Saturday."
I found out why I was still alive. Teresa had looked at her phone when she got up to use the bathroom and she saw my message. She immediately guessed what it was about, flipped out and woke her parents. They read it and figured it out, too. They tried to call my parents but couldn't reach them, and nobody answered at home. They then got the number of the police and called them and persuaded them to go by. Aunt Edith being a social worker, she must have known what to say. They found the back door we never lock, searched around, found unresponsive me, the notes, the pill bottle, and the glass of vodka, and called an ambulance. If I'd lain there until my parents came home, I'd have been dead. Teresa had saved my life.
My mom and dad came in occasionally, but mostly I just looked out the window. It was nice, other than the fact that I couldn't go to the bathroom by myself. There were woods across the street and pigeons flying around. I didn't have any roommates, and I got all my meals in my room under the watchful eye of a nurse, so it took a while to figure out I was in a women's ward.
I asked the staff when I could go home.
"The psychiatrist will have to give her okay before you can leave. She'll be in on Monday." Well, more one day I won't have to go to West Hell. I thought, hey, why don't I just not go, like I did with gym? Why had I thought that killing myself was the only way out? It seemed so simple now, just refuse to go! I suddenly felt so stupid.
Sunday afternoon, Aunt Edith and Uncle Boris visited me. They'd come straight from the airport. Teresa wanted to come, too, but she was too young to be allowed to visit, so my folks took her home. They both gave me big hugs and cried and said they were so grateful I was still alive, which made me feel guilty. "I wish you could have waited a few more days to see what your old Uncle Bore could come up with. Well, you're alive, that's what counts."
On Monday, the psychiatrist visited me. She was nice, not like the analyst the school recommended. I told her about the sex-change and about the hell at school. I told her I just couldn't face another day at West Hell or any other school.
"Well, we'll just have to make sure you don't go back there, won't we?" She talked with my parents and my aunt and uncle, they'd all taken the day off. She arranged with them that I should see her twice a week in the out-patient facility. The hospital gave me my clothes -- the girl clothes I'd had on when I lay down to die. Then the four of them brought me home.
Teresa was waiting in the living room. When she saw me, she jumped up and ran to me. Then she started punching me, really hard. She hit my arms and kicked my legs. It hurt like hell.
"I am so mad at you! How could you do this? Why didn't you talk with me first? Or my parents?" She was punching me the whole time and crying. I tried to pull away, but she shouted, "don't move. I'm not going to injure you, I'm just going to give you lots of bruises because you deserve it."
Nobody stopped her. She kept yelling at me and hitting me. I tried to fend her off, but she just hit my arms more. She pushed me over the back of the sofa and started spanking me, hard. Then she just stood there, shaking and crying, and pulled me over onto the sofa and hugged me and said, "thank God you're alive. Don't ever do that again!" She kept hugging me and we flopped onto the sofa. We arranged ourselves so we were sitting next to each other, and she held one of my arms with both hands. My parents and my aunt and uncle sat down.
"Martin, we have a proposal," my uncle started. "The quickest way to get you out of West High is for you to move into a different district. If you'd like, we'd like for you to come and live with us. The local high school is Greenwood, and you could go there. It's not perfect, but it's not as bad as West. Or we could see if we can get you into Gabriel School, which is where Teresa goes. It's a charter school, and it's different from the other schools. They run a tight ship, and you wouldn't have to worry about bullying there."
I just looked at him.
"Okay, that's probably too many choices. Would you like to come live with us, which would mean no West High?"
I didn't know what to say. It would mean leaving the people I'd known all my life. They weren't perfect, but they tried. But I thought my aunt and uncle would be better at dealing with my problems. And no West High sounded great.
"Mom, Dad, I don't want to leave you all, but maybe I would be better off with Aunt Edith and Uncle Boris. I'd still come to see you."
"We want what's best for you," my dad said. "If you're willing, we think you should go." My mom nodded.
"Okay, I'll come."
Teresa interrupted. "I haven't agreed yet." She let go of me and turned to face me. Her face was maybe six inches from mine. "Martin, if you come to live with us, will you promise, cross your heart and hope to die, that you will never, never try to kill yourself without talking with us first? Never, never, NEVER, NEVER, NEVER?"
I got lost in all the "never"s, but I said, "I promise." She grabbed me and hugged me.
"So, when would I move?"
"Tonight, if you're ready."
"Now's as good a time as any." Dad found me a suitcase and Teresa and I went upstairs to my room. I packed one or two boy T-shirts that I liked and some of the pants that fit me, but mostly I just packed my girl clothes and my warm clothes. Teresa packed my CDs and rolled up my posters. She saw the note I left, my "will."
"Bunny?" I showed her my bunny, still stuck between the matress and the wall where it must have fallen when the EMTs pulled me out. "Oh, he's so cute. Like you. But I think he wants to be with you. And I think he was really sad that you -- well, you know." She packed him gently in the suitcase with my girl clothes.
When we got downstairs, my mother had picked my clothes out of the laundry to take with me. I gathered my stuff. Biff and Pete were downstairs, and I hugged them and then my mom and dad. Then Teresa and my aunt and uncle and I went out the door.
On the way over to her folks' place -- my new home -- Teresa talked about her school. She made it pretty obvious she hoped I would go there.
"It's not like other schools. They have uniforms, one uniform for the boys and another for the girls. There's always somebody around from the school keeping an eye on things wherever you are, and if they think things are getting out of hand, they step in right away. I've never seen a fight, and only ever seen someone hit someone once, my whole time there. They're also strict about anyone saying nasty things about someone else. They take kids disrespecting one another just as seriously as disrespecting a teacher.
"But they encourage you to think. You can disagree with the teachers, as long as you're not disruptive. Sometimes you can convince them to change their mind. And they're good about encouraging girls to do well. My dad put me into Gabriel when I was in fifth grade because the regular school was saying stuff like: girls just don't do well at math."
The keeping an eye on things didn't bother me; I wished they'd done more of that at West High. I didn't mind a uniform, either, as long as it wasn't too uncomfortable.
Speaking of uncomfortable, my arms and legs were aching from where Teresa had hit me. I knew I was going to have some big bruises. But in a way, I liked them. I liked having Teresa care enough to be that mad at me.
When we got there, Teresa and Aunt Edith helped me get my stuff upstairs. "You'll stay in the guest room for now," said my aunt. "You and Teresa can decide if you will share a room or we'll make the guest room yours."
"Oh, I hope we can share a room! I always wanted a sister" -- then she corrected herself -- "or a brother, too, anyway, someone I could share a room with."
It was obvious she wanted to see me as a sister, not a brother, but it didn't get to me the way it would have. Maybe the suicide attempt had changed me. Maybe it killed the part of me that got so upset at the idea. Or maybe the part of me that could get upset at all.
The guest room was sort of half office, half bedroom. There was a bed with some cushions so it was sort of like a couch. There was a desk and a bookcase, but no dresser. There was a closet which was partly empty. We unpacked. I put the laundry my mom had gathered in the hamper in the bathroom. I piled the clothes that didn't go into the closet on the desk. Aunt Edith brought in some sheets and some extra blankets.
We hung around in the room, not saying much. I realized I hadn't showered in over three days, then I realized I'd forgotten to bring any soap or shampoo. Teresa said I could use hers, so I took a shower and put on clean clothes. It was still funny that "clean clothes" now meant a bra and girl-style underwear and a skirt.
At dinner, they all tried to make me feel like I belonged there, but I felt like only a piece of me was there. Another piece was in my old bedroom, and another was in the hospital, and another was still in that classroom where Tom and his buddies dragged me to.
At the end of dinner, Aunt Edith talked to me.
"Martin, I know you're still shook up by everything, but soon you're going to have to make some decisions. Not right now, I think you need some time, but we'd like you to be thinking about them.
"First, which school. Greenwood is pretty good, but it has some of the same problems as West High, just not as bad. If you want to go to Gabriel, we'll have to apply and see if they accept you. I don't know how long that will take. I think it would be a good place for you. They're known for being good at dealing with people with problems like handicaps or racism. They've had a few trans kids there, too. But they're old-fashioned in some ways and strict about behavior.
"Second, whichever school you go to, you'll have to decide if you want to go as a boy or as a girl. You know as well as I do what's involved with each.
"You don't have to decide right away, but we'd like to know this week if you can."
My uncle spoke up. "Martin, I don't know how you're feeling now. If you think you need more time to recover from all you've been through, please do. If you need more than a week, let us know. But the sooner you decide, the sooner you can settle into a new routine."
It took me a while before I could say anything. Nobody said anything. Finally, I said, "can I have a day or two to settle down?"
"Sure," my aunt said.
After dinner, I helped clean up. Afterwards, I went up to bed, but first my uncle and aunt each gave me a big hug and told me they loved me. My aunt told me, "no matter what you decide, we'll support you. It doesn't matter if you're a nephew or niece or somewhere in between."
I was beat. It had been a long day, but not in hours. But after I got into my pj's and into bed and Teresa gave a couple of good-night hugs, I lay in bed awake for a while, not really thinking. Maybe I was gathering the pieces of myself. Like my soul had to walk all the way to West High and then to my house and then to the hospital to pick up the pieces.
The next day, I had my first appointment with Dr. Gordon, the psychiatrist who had seen me in the hospital. My uncle took me over. He works in the admissions office at a college nearby, so he can duck out during the day. Dr. Gordon was real nice. She said she thought I had some acute stress disorder from the rape attempt, made worse by the constant assaults at school. I talked about the decisions I had to make, but she didn't give me any guidance, just encouraged me to talk about how I felt about them.
It was real quiet in the house during the day, with my aunt and uncle at work and Teresa at school. I mostly just sat or lay around in my room and listened to CDs or read books. When I couldn't stand being cooped up any more, I'd take a walk in the woods. When I got bored with that, I'd do chores around the house. I did the laundry. One time, I even vacuumed the house. It was better when Teresa got home, but she always had homework, so she could only hang out for a little while. By Thursday, I wanted to make my decisions, if only because I was tired of being in limbo.
I talked it over with Teresa first when she got home. "I think I want to go to Gabriel. That way, at least I'll know one person."
"Two. Carol goes there, too."
"Also, the idea that people don't harrass each other sounds like heaven. Is that really true?"
"If you don't believe me, do you want to call Carol and ask her?"
"No, I believe you. Also, I think I'll try going as a girl. I don't exactly want to, it's just that it sounds less complicated than getting everyone to see me as a boy who just happens to look like a girl." I sighed. "The trouble is, I don't know how to act like a girl."
"Why don't you just act like yourself? My mom and I can help you with anything you really need to know. And the nice thing about Gabriel is that a lot of it doesn't matter. They won't pick on you for not acting like a girl is supposed to act. You just have to behave. And do your work." She looked over at her stack of books and sighed.
"What if I don't get in?" I wondered.
"Try Greenwood. I know some people who go there, and they've survived. I'd go as a girl, though. There are a lot of people there who would never understand somebody being a guy who just happens to look exactly like a girl."
When my uncle got home, I told him, and then tried to help him with dinner. When my aunt got home, I told her.
"Do you want us to start calling you Melanie?" she asked "Or do you want to continue to be Martin when you're at home?"
"Either one is fine." What I actually meant was 'whatever', but I thought I'd practice being a little more upbeat than I usually am.
"We'll see how it goes."
The next day, Uncle Boris set things up with the school. West High would send my school records, Dr. Gordon would send a report, the doctors would send their records, and I would have an interview next week, after the paperwork got there. Teresa offered to lend me her spare uniform for the interview. "It'll look better if you dress like you're already going there."
Friday night, Teresa and my aunt inventoried my clothes, so we could go shopping the next day and buy what I needed. Some of the clothes I'd brought were from before my "metamorphosis" and didn't fit me. (I'd found the Kafka story and decided I liked the word, even though the story was pretty depressing.) Now that I was going to dress as a girl, there were things I'd need. Like another skirt or two -- one denim skirt wasn't going to cut it. I could have gone with pants, but the pants I'd tried were still pretty uncomfortable. More underwear, socks, and tights. Shoes. Some blouses and sweaters. And a nicer-looking outfit, maybe a dress or blouse and skirt.
So, Saturday morning, Teresa and my aunt packed me in the car to go clothes shopping. Carol had attached herself to the expedition, too: her words were "I wouldn't miss it for the world." In the car, Teresa and Carol did most of the talking, but since Teresa was in the front and Carol in the back, I could hear what they were saying, and they tried to include me.
My aunt asked me, "Melanie, do you think you'd like to come with us to church on Sundays?"
"Sure."
"Then you'll probably want a nice outfit. People at our church dress up for church -- we're a little old-fashioned that way -- and you'll feel out of place if you don't."
The three of them pretty much took over once we got to the mall. They were nice about it, and asked if I liked the things they were recommending, but mostly they treated me like a dress-up doll. I didn't mind. It was nice to be fussed over. I ended up with a longer skirt in some kind of cotton, a nice-looking navy blue skirt that went just past my knees, some white blouses and some pastel ones, some camisoles and a slip so my bra wouldn't be visible, some more underwear, now that they knew my size, and some more socks and tights. Oh, and some sweaters. They also got some pantyhose, saying that if I ever needed to dress up, I'd need them. They also got me some shoes. None of them were ones I would have ever worn as a guy, but they weren't super-girly, either. One pair was for dressing up, like for church. They did a good job. Nothing was super-feminine, but it was still nice-looking.
We also looked for pants, but we couldn't find anything that didn't rub too much. We tried on one pair that looked like silk pajama bottoms and didn't irritate my thighs too much, but I just couldn't see wearing it anywhere.
Finally, we went to look for an outfit for church. I was pretty tired by this time, so I wasn't paying much attention. They got me to try on a couple of dresses, but weren't satisfied with any of them, so I didn't bother even looking in the mirror. I did decide I didn't want any sleeveless dresses, though. Then they found a blue one, and this time, I did look in the mirror. It was kind of a shock. It was some kind of light blue satin with a darker blue sheer layer over it that moved, so some parts were lighter and others darker. It had a full skirt that went over my knees and puffed short sleeves. It looked really pretty and it made me look pretty, too. I wasn't sure I was ready to look that pretty, though. They all liked it, so they bought it and hoped I would someday like it, too. It helped that it was on sale. Finally, Aunt Edith picked out a navy blue shirtdress for me.
When we got home, Teresa and Carol insisted I model all the clothes for my aunt and uncle. They also started teaching me how I had to stand and sit so I wouldn't flash anyone. That pretty much took up the rest of the afternoon, and Carol hung around for dinner.
I wore the shirtdress with pantyhose and the slip to church. I noticed that my outfit was pretty plain compared to the other girls there, but I didn't think it looked too out of place. After church, Teresa introduced me to some of the high school kids there, but didn't say anything about my past. They asked if I was going to come to youth group. I said I didn't know, I hadn't even settled school yet. Fortunately, we had to go then, so I didn't have to answer any questions I wasn't ready to answer.
My paperwork got to the school, and they told me to come in Thursday afternoon. Teresa lent me her spare uniform: a skirt and vest. I could use my own tights and blouse. Fortunately, they were a bit big on her, because I was a little larger than Teresa, even after the shrinkage caused by my metamorphosis.
My uncle walked me into the school office. They seemed to know exactly who we were. That was pretty much how it always was there: they seemed to know who you were and what you were doing even before you did. They took my cell phone -- they had a cabinet with lots of little slots for cell phones -- and then had me sit down. I told my uncle I'd call him when I was done, and he left. After about ten minutes, the school psychologist called me in.
I sat up straight on the chair with my knees together, like I'd been taught, and pulled the hem of my skirt down. She looked at me patiently, and then asked, "tell me about what brings you to our school."
I was real nervous. I started with the accident and the mix-up at the hospital. Then I told about changing and the harrassment at school. I kind of glossed over the assault in the classroom (I had trouble saying the word "rape") and my suicide attempt. I knew the suicide would come up, but I couldn't figure out how to talk about it. I tried to remember how Teresa had told me that we were supposed to say "ma'am" or "sir," but I wasn't sure I was getting it right.
"Your records say 'Martin', but you've applied as 'Melanie.'"
"Well, ma'am, after the, uh, change, I tried telling people I was a boy, and I got nothing but trouble. People who didn't know me assumed I was a girl, and people who did know me acted mean or weird. I thought I'd try living as a girl for a while. It can't be any worse."
"That makes sense. From now on, as far as we're concerned, you're Melanie, but we'll know you used to be Martin. You're living with your aunt and uncle, now. Why?"
"I had to get out of West High, and moving to a different district was a way to do it. Besides, my, uh, change has been hard on my parents. They don't really know what to do about it. My aunt and uncle are a lot easier with it. I hope it isn't a problem."
"No, I just wanted to know the why. Now, tell me about this incident which got you suspended."
"Isn't it in the psychiatrist's report, ma'am?"
"Yes, but I'd like to hear it from you."
"Yes, ma'am." She looked amused, I think at all the "ma'am"s. I explained about people groping and grabbing me, and then how they pulled me into the classroom. When I described my clothes being pulled off, I started to shake. I finished with, "and then they hit my head, hard, and then I saw the boy's pants were down." I couldn't finish.
"Did he touch you?"
"With his fingers. Ma'am. A teacher came in before he had time to do anything else."
"I saw the school report." I was afraid it was all over. "Your version is a lot more believable. I can see you've been through a lot. Are you anxious about coming back to school?"
I nodded. "A little, ma'am." I suddenly remembered how I was supposed to be sitting and arranged myself. "But I can't just stay at home. And they say your school is a lot better than West High. I would be ...." I trailed off, not knowing the right word.
"Safe?" I nodded. "I guess that explains the suicide attempt?" I nodded again. She looked at me expectantly.
"I was afraid I'd have to go back to West High. I couldn't face that." I was looking at the floor now.
"It says you sent a message to your cousin after you took the pills. Were you hoping she'd save you?" Dr. Gordon had asked me that, too.
"I didn't think that was what I was doing. But she was the only person my age I knew who had stuck with me. I wrote her a letter, but I wanted to leave her something, I don't know, more personal. I didn't know she'd be able to get the cops there within an hour and a half. Maybe some part of me did want to live."
"I think that's why you're here now." We sat quietly for a few minutes. "I think you're very brave. Now, it's time for you to see Ms. Williamson. She's the principal. She'll decide whether you get in. Oh, and Melanie: if you do get in, please don't kill yourself." She said that last with an attempt at a chuckle.
"Don't worry, I wouldn't dare. Teresa would kill me if I did." This time, she did chuckle.
I sat on a chair outside Ms. Williamson's office for maybe five minutes. I figured she was talking with the psychologist. Then she called me in.
Ms. Williams was a large black woman. I think the word "formidable" was invented to describe her. She didn't look like someone you wanted to mess with. She was looking kindly at me, so maybe you were safe if she liked you.
"Hello, Melanie," she said, then added, "who used to be Martin."
"Hello, Ms. Williams." I was doing my best to say the right thing. She showed me to a chair, and I tried to sit properly.
"Is the 'used to be Martin' correct? Or are you just Melanie at school?"
"It's not a secret that I was -- or maybe really am -- a boy, ma'am. My parents still call me Martin, and that's fine with me. My aunt and uncle and cousin have started calling me Melanie. I'm fine with either name. I just thought it would be simpler to be called Melanie and be a girl at school."
"Just to satisfy my curiousity, do you plan on continuing to be Melanie after you graduate?"
"Ma'am, I haven't had time to think about that. I have a hard time thinking past the end of this year."
"Fair enough." Then she started getting more formal.
"Melanie, do you understand that we're a lot stricter here than at your old school?" I nodded. "You'll be supervised everywhere, and only allowed to be where you are supposed to be. Some students have difficulty with that."
"It will be worth it to me if it means I won't get harrassed, ma'am." I shuddered.
"Do you understand that you'll be expected to be polite and respectful at all times?" I nodded. "I see you've already heard about our dress code. You don't mind the uniform?"
"No, ma'am. It's nice, actually. Teresa lent it to me."
"In particular, you will have to be respectful of the other students, and of the teachers. Bad language and insults, even insults about people who aren't there, will not be tolerated. It goes without saying that physical assaults are not allowed."
"Ma'am, that sounds like heaven."
"Some of our methods are a little old-fashioned, do you think you can adjust?"
"Ma'am, I'll do my best."
She sat down in a chair opposite me. "Melanie, what do you hope to get out of coming to Gabriel School?"
"Ma'am, I'm hoping to be able to study and learn in peace. Not have to worry about what people will do to me. Maybe make a few friends."
She seemed satisfied, and went to her desk. "Your grades look good. A little lower this year, but that's not surprising. I see you got an F in physical education."
"I got harrassed a lot in the locker room, once I started, uh, changing. Especially the shower. Especially after the kids found out what was happening to me. I refused to go any more."
"Where did you go?"
"The library. I used to do my homework there, because they had to leave me alone there. You can ask the librarian."
"You realize you would have to go to physical education class here? Are you willing to do that if you can trust that you won't be harrassed?"
"Yes, ma'am. I didn't mind the activities, just being dumped on and jumped on all the time. I'm not very good at it, though."
"Don't worry, we only expect you to make an effort."
She looked at me, sort of examining me. Then she stood up, walked over to me, and shook my hand.
"We look forward to having you as a student. Can you start on Monday?"
"I think so. Ma'am." I was dizzy with relief and had trouble standing. She practically had to pull me up.
"Good. Stop by the nurse's office and then the guidance counselor to set up your schedule on your way out. Report to the office at 8:15 on Monday. We'll have someone accompany you for the first day or two until you get adjusted."
"Thank you, ma'am. I hope I won't give you any reason to regret it."
"I'm sure you won't."
I stumbled out of her office and looked around for the nurse's office. I walked by an open door and someone called out "Melanie!" It was the nurse's office. We went through the usual health questions, but one question got to me: "are you menstruating?" Six months ago I would have thought it was crazy. Now, all I could say was, "yes, ma'am. Twice so far." She told me she had supplies, plus there were tampons in the bathrooms. If I needed to, I could come to her any time, just ask a teacher.
The guidance counselor was a man. Like everyone else, he seemed to know my whole story.
"I've scheduled you with the same classes you were taking at West High," he said. "The teachers will help you get up to speed. Are you good at math?"
I shrugged, "I like it, sir."
"We'll schedule you for regular math at the same time as the advanced class. Once you're settled in, maybe we can switch you." He handed me a sheet of paper. "Here are the supplies you need to pick up for your first day. I assume your cousin can fill you in on the dress code." He reached out his hand. "Welcome to Gabriel, Melanie."
I shook it, and said, "thank you, sir." I retrieved my cell phone and called my uncle to go home. My new home. From my new school.
Teresa filled me in on the dress code. For girls it was:
We also had to have a "gym suit," which Teresa didn't explain.
I already had everything except the jumper or skirt and vest. And the gym suit. We went to the store that carried the school uniform and picked up one jumper, one skirt, and one vest in my size. I noticed that the jumper and vest had a patch with a yellow starburst. I wondered if this was part of the uniform or just a decoration. I recalled that Teresa's had had one, too. They measured me and picked out a navy blue package for me, which turned out to be the gym suit. Anyway, I took the opportunity to get the school supplies and a backpack just like Teresa's.
Teresa drilled me on correct behavior at Gabriel on and off over the weekend. I don't know if I actually learned anything, or just found more reasons to be nervous.
So, bright and early Monday morning, I put on my new school uniform, and my uncle dropped me and Teresa off at Gabriel school. She headed for her first class and I went to the office. A man who looked like he had just graduated from college was waiting for me. He had a sweater vest on with the same starburst patch as mine, though he wasn't in the school plaid. He showed me my locker, but I didn't have anything to put in it yet.
As he led me to my first class, which was English, I saw other students walking up and down the halls rather purposefully, but nobody just hanging out. It seemed awfully quiet, even though I could see people talking to one another, and I noticed that the ceiling and the walls above the lockers had some sort of panels. My guide saw me gawking and informed me that they were sound-absorbing. "That way, students can talk to one another and not have to shout."
The room was mostly full when I arrived. It had about thirty old-fashioned school desks in neat rows. The teacher said, "Miss Melanie Rawlings, I presume?" When I nodded, she handed me a stack with some papers and a few paperback books. "We're studying The Grapes of Wrath right now, have you read it?" I nodded again. "Then we'll be happy to have you join in the discussion." She directed me to an empty desk. Teresa had explained that we all had assigned desks, so I tried to remember which one it was. She told the class, "this is Melanie Rawlings. She's just starting today, as I think you're all aware. Let's try to make her feel welcome."
I planned to keep quiet the first day to give me a chance to figure out how things worked. I noticed that everyone addressed the students as "Mr." or "Miss" with last names, including other students, so I was "Miss Rawlings." The teacher rated a "Ms." Everyone seemed intent on the discussion. There wasn't any chatter, just people raising their hands and speaking when recognized. The teacher was mostly a moderator, but sometimes stepped in with observations or questions, or, occasionally, to ask a person to be more "respectful." I noticed for the first time that, atop the old-fashioned blackboard, there was a big banner that said "respect."
I tried to inconspicuously look at the stack the teacher had given me. It had a syllabus, a schedule of homework for the week, and a short list of supplies I needed.
My guide appeared just as class was ending and brought me to math. I noticed that Teresa was there, and waved. She gave me a big smile, but didn't wave. Maybe waving was not okay. I got the same little speech from the teacher as in English, and a textbook and a small stack of papers. Aside from the Mister- and Miss-ing and the lack of chit-chat, it could have been my class at West High.
The 10th graders all had lunch at the same time, so I sat with Teresa and her friends. She introduced me, and I apologized in advance that I might not remember them all right away. The lunchroom was quiet, like the halls, and I saw the same sound absorbing stuff there. The conversations seemed normal, with everyone using first names, not like the classroom. One girl, who I later got to know was Bethany, asked Teresa, "can I ask her about--?" but Teresa said, "come on, give her a few days before you start giving her the third degree."
I had to use the bathroom, which meant the girls' bathroom. I thought it would be weird, but I went in and used a stall and although people gave me a second glance, nobody said anything. I already had the impression that everyone knew everyone, so maybe they were just noticing a new face. I hoped so.
They had one funny class, though. It was called "Respect," like the banner over the blackboard in each classroom. What it mainly was was us discussing interactions during the day. We sat with desks in a circle and students would bring up things that had happened at school or elsewhere, or the teacher would bring up a situation, and we were supposed to figure out how to handle it with respect. Fortunately, we got some coaching from the teacher. There was a lot of trying to figure out how someone else might feel, and even some role-playing. I found out later that for most of the students, it was their first year at the school, so it must have been the beginner class.
My guide brought me to the girls' locker room when it was time for Phys Ed, but didn't follow me in. One of the girls noticed me standing around looking puzzled, and said, "New here?" I nodded. "Well, you have to change into your gym suit. Find an empty locker." I dug out the navy blue package and pulled out something with short sleeves and a zipper. I looked at the other girls. They were undressing completely and putting on something that looked like a shirt and a pair of loose shorts with elastic cuffs sewn together. The other girls were stepping into it and pulling it on and zipping it up. I undressed, but couldn't figure out the suit. Maybe I would have been nervous about undressing, except that I was so busy trying to figure out the gym suit. Another girl, who was already suited up, came over and helped me with it. I expected people to make fun of me, but all she said was, "new?" I nodded. "Pretty dorky, huh? But it's kind of practical. Come on, get your gym shoes on." That I could handle.
I was the last one into the gym. Everyone else was sitting on a bench or standing and stretching. The coach, a woman wearing a suit similar to ours, but with utter self-assurance, gave me a smile and said, "Miss Melanie Rawlings?" I was beginning to get used to this.
"Yes, ma'am. Sorry I'm late."
"Trouble with the suit?"
"Yes, ma'am."
"Did anyone help you?"
"Yes, ma'am. I don't think I would have figured it out if someone hadn't helped me. I'm sorry, I don't know her name."
She directed us in a series of calisthenics: push-ups, sit-ups, and some more complicated ones I didn't recognize the names of. I think the directions were more for me; the other girls seemed to know what to do already. Some of the girls were pretty athletic and did one sit-up after another for the longest time. Another girl, who was fairly fat, looked like she was having trouble doing even one of each, but to my surprise, nobody made any disparaging comments. Her partner simply said words of encouragement and counted what she managed to do. I think I was about average for the class. By the end of it, we were all sweaty and I was tired all over. She had us run across the gym and back in groups of three, and then gave some people suggestions for how to run. Finally we did some basketball practice. Not games exactly, but dribbling, throwing, and shooting baskets. The athletic girls would do trick shots, even blocking one another. People like me just dribbled and shot, and if we missed, one of the girls who was waiting would retrieve the ball and give me another chance. The fat girl and one or two others got two extra chances, though they got it in pretty often.
I was really nervous about the shower, but the other girls just took off their suits, grabbed towels from a bin, and marched into the showers. The showers were individual stalls, which I was grateful for, but nobody seemed to care if people saw them. And nobody seemed to be paying any attention to me. When I was drying, though, I caught one girl sort of staring. When she saw me see her, she said, "I'm sorry. You're Melanie, right? The new girl? I heard your story and, well, I wasn't expecting someone who looked like any other girl. I'm sorry I made you uncomfortable. Especially your first day."
"It's okay," I said as I continued drying myself. "I figured everyone would be curious and asking all kinds of questions. In fact, I'm surprised you were the only one who stared."
"Oh, we wouldn't. It wouldn't be respecting you."
"Boy, it's sure not like West High. By the way, what do I do with the suit?"
"There should be a basket with your name on it on the shelves by the wall. You bring it home on Friday to wash it. Maybe earlier if it gets really stinky. You leave your shoes and gym socks there, too. And your gym underwear, if you use any. The girls with big boobs usually bring a sports bra."
"Why the 'dorky' suit, anyway? Why not a T-shirt and shorts?" It was the first time since lunch I'd had the chance to just talk to someone.
"It's so you can do all kinds of things, like head-stands and stuff, and you don't have to worry about flashing anyone. And since we're all dorky together, we don't mind that they make us look dorky."
By now I was dressed. My guide was patiently waiting for me just outside the door to take me to my last class, which was study period. It was right next door to the library, so we could go directly in to look at reference books. I took the time to go through my textbooks and all the papers the teachers had given me.
And then it was time to catch the bus to go home. Teresa and my guide were waiting for me and they both showed me where to wait for the district school bus. My guide asked if I needed him the next day, and I said I thought I could find my way now and thanked him.
When the bus came, there were already kids on it. The bus served several private schools in addition to Gabriel. Teresa and some of the others made a point of greeting several of them by name, but when she found an empty bench, she put me next to her, next to the window. "There's a feeling at the other schools that Gabriel students are snobby and cliquish. We do tend to stick together, because we can trust that other Gabriel students will act respectfully, and we can't always with other schools. We've been trying to do stuff to make us seem less snobby, but it doesn't always work. So we have to be careful."
For the rest of the ride, I told Teresa about my day. She told me I did pretty well. "I'm sorry I didn't show you how to put on the gym suit. I had trouble my first day, too."
"It's okay. The other girls were very helpful. If I'd known how to do it the first time, I wouldn't have found out how helpful they are."
When we got home we went upstairs to study. Teresa changed out of her uniform, but I didn't bother. Actually, I kind of liked it. We went to our desks, me in the guest room and Teresa in her room. I kept needing to ask Teresa things about the homework, and one time, she asked me something about math.
"You know," she said, "it would be easier if we shared a room. And a lot more fun. Hint, hint, hint."
Homework and dinner took up most of the evening, but we finished up in time to spend an hour hanging out before we had to go to bed. I was pretty beat and went to bed a little early.
Content note: dream violence.
The rest of the week went so smoothly I got a little nervous. I got all my homework done. I had my third period, and thought I managed it okay. I started to participate a little in discussions, and I was learning the other students' names. People were friendly but a little distant. I kept eating lunch with Teresa, and her friends were a little less distant there. Bethany finally got to ask about me, and I told her the short version of my story which didn't go into the gory details. Even the sanitized version made them look on in horror. It surpassed their darkest suspicions about West High.
Tuesday, I was notified that I would take a different bus on Tuesdays and Fridays which would drop me off at Dr. Gordon's office. Wednesday, I rode the bus home alone, because Teresa was in chorus on Wednesdays.
By Friday night, I was feeling better about everything than I had in a long time. Living as a girl was working out, at least in the short term. School was working out. So when Teresa asked if we could share a room, I said, sure. It turned out that Teresa's bed was a bunk bed, which they'd bought hoping they'd have a second child, and the upper bunk was in the attic. Saturday, we went out to buy a mattress, a dresser, and some desk and bed lights. Teresa made room for my clothes in her closet. Her parents arranged the room with the dressers between the desks so we wouldn't distract each other, set up the lights so one of us could sleep while the other had light to study or read. And by Saturday night, I was moved in her room.
It had been a long time since I'd shared a room. At first, I felt like I had to interact with Teresa all the time, but that didn't work. I had to learn to ignore her sometimes, especially when we had to study. But it was also nice, to have someone to say good night to you and then, when we were in bed, to hear her breathing and know I wasn't all alone. I guess I still had some boy in me, because it also felt cool to be sharing a room with a girl, even if nothing was going to happen.
Teresa started giving me lessons on how to act more like a girl. How to sit, how to stand, how to walk, how to talk. She got me to brush my hair a lot, and reminded me to check how my clothes were fitting, so I would look my best. I couldn't believe how much time I needed to spend on my appearance just so I'd look "presentable." My voice had gone up in pitch, but I needed to raise my speaking voice even higher. I wasn't sure she was right, since some of the girls at school had lower voices than me, but I did what she told me, anyway.
I also spent a lot of time watching the other girls to see what they did, what they liked, what they talked about, how they acted friendly or not friendly. I really wanted to fit in so people would treat me like I was normal. I knew how to act like a normal boy, sort of, but now that anyone who looked at me would see a girl and not a boy, I was going to have to learn to act like a girl. I was really sick of being a freak.
Youth group was two Sunday evenings a month, and that Sunday was youth group, so at church, the kids my age asked again if I was coming. I said maybe next time, but I was still pretty stressed out about my new school. I also called up my parents, because Uncle Boris reminded me that they hadn't seen or heard from me in three weeks. I told them how things were going and they told me they missed me. They called me Martin, which was both nice and strange.
The second week of school went about as smoothly as the first week, except that every now and then, I'd get this weird feeling like everything was strange and weird and I didn't know where I was or how I got there, except that part of me knew exactly where I was and what I had to do. It was like having double vision. I'd have to stand for a minute and ask the part of my brain that remembered where I was and what I was supposed to do next. One time somebody noticed me standing there with a dazed look and asked if I was okay. I mentioned it to Dr. Gordon and she said it was called dissociation. She wasn't surprised it was happening, what with all the stuff I'd gone through, but as long as it didn't happen too often or make problems I shouldn't worry about it.
Then, one night, I think it was Thursday because I saw Dr. Gordon the next day, I had a nightmare. I woke up shaking and a second later, the light went on and Teresa was standing next to my bunk looking at me (I was sleeping on the top bunk.)
"What's the matter? You were screaming."
"Just a nightmare." I started remembering the dream, which was funny because usually my dreams start fading as soon as I wake up.
I heard Aunt Edith and Uncle Boris coming up the stairs and got down off the bed.
"Melanie had a nightmare," Teresa explained when they came in.
"Can you tell us what it was?" asked my aunt.
"I was back at West High. It was Halloween, and I was dressed in a school uniform, only it was very girly, lots of ruffles and bows and stuff, and it made me look like I was six years old. Everything was going fine, nobody was harrassing me, and then Tom Prescott and his gang dragged me off to the gym. The principal was helping them. They had this big altar set up and a bonfire with stones around it, and Ms. Williams was the priestess and the principal was the priest. They needed to sacrifice a virgin, and they'd picked me. It seems the accident in the hospital wasn't an accident, they had arranged it so they would have a virgin. I kept pleading with them, saying I was really a boy, but they said I wasn't any more. For some reason, I was more virginal than any of the real girls, or maybe they just didn't want to sacrifice any of them. Anyway, Ms. Williams was holding a stake. She was going to drive it through my vagina, and then they were going to cut out my heart and throw it on the bonfire. That's when I woke up."
I was still pretty shaken by the dream, even though it was just a dream. Teresa looked grossed out by it, my aunt and uncle just looked concerned. We all went down to the living room and my aunt sat next to me on the sofa while my uncle got me something to drink. Teresa sat on the other end of the sofa with her knees pulled up to her chin, looking at me. My aunt put her arms around me and held me close to her, and it made me feel a little better. After I'd had something to drink, my uncle put a blanket over us and gave Teresa another one. My aunt held me and stroked my shoulder until I fell asleep.
I told Dr. Gordon about it. She tried to get me to think about the things that were going well, but she also told me that she wanted me to tell her about things like this. I'd run out of things to tell her about the time before my suicide attempt. I was mostly talking about what it was like living as a girl and not knowing if I was really a girl or a boy or both or neither. And being afraid I wasn't going to be me any more.
I wouldn't have remembered the third week, except that two things happened. The first was that I got paddled. I was used to using curse words, especially when I was upset. We did this all the time at West High and nobody thought anything of it. I knew it was forbidden at Gabriel and thought I was doing pretty well, except that every now and then, the teacher would look sharply at me and say, "Miss Rawlings, what did you just say?" I'd replay what I said in my mind and realize I'd used one of those words. They told me I'd get two warnings and then I'd have to go to the principal's office.
Sometime in the third week, I used up my warnings. I got sent to the principal's office. She was waiting for me.
"Miss Rawlings, I understand you've been using certain words in class that we've made it clear to you you shouldn't use."
I was really scared. I wasn't sure what would happen to me, maybe get expelled. "Y-y-yes, ma'am. I'm very sorry and will try harder not to in the future."
"I'm sure you will. However, I think your intentions need some reinforcement. I think I warned you that some of our methods are a little old-fashioned."
Ms. Ellis, the psychologist came in. Her face looked grim. I was even more scared.
"Please pull down your tights and underwear," said Ms. Williams. I had to pull the waistband of my skirt up to about my chest to get to the top of the tights. I pulled them down to my knees. "That's good enough," she said. "Now turn around and bend over the desk." I noticed that there weren't any papers or anything on one end of the desk. I put my hands down on the desk and lay my face on them. I was really scared, mostly because I didn't know what was going to happen, but also humiliated, having my butt exposed like that. I felt like I was ready to cry, but I tried not to, it would have made me even more humiliated.
I felt someone flip my skirt up onto my back. I heard a whoosh and then felt something hard slap my butt, very hard. I couldn't help letting out an "oh!" I felt my butt starting to sting when the second slap came. It was all I could do not to shout or turn around and defend myself with my hands. I counted ten whacks.
"You may turn around and pull your clothes back up," Ms. Williams said. When I turned around, I noticed her holding a kind of paddle. I pulled up my underpants and tights as quickly as I could, but that wasn't very fast. They tended to get tangled, maybe because I didn't have much experience. Once I got them up and arranged, I slid my skirt down and tugged and twisted things until they looked more or less okay. Ms. Williams looked satisfied, while Ms. Ellis still looked grim. No one said anything until I was done.
"You may return to class. Please try to be more careful with your words in the future."
I don't know if I was supposed to say anything, but I didn't. I stumbled out of the office and back to class. I was having trouble believing what had just happened, and maybe I wouldn't have, except that my butt was still stinging. No one said anything when I got back, and we went on as if nothing had happened. My butt hurt for a while, but it wasn't intolerable. I was mostly shocked.
When we got home, I told Teresa about the paddling and how upset I was. She didn't seem to think it was such a big deal.
"That's one of the things they mean by being 'old-fashioned.' Most of us have gotten one. Some of my friends have gotten it twice. It's upsetting, nobody likes it, but you get over it. One good thing: they don't hold it against you. Once it's over, it's over. They're not into threatening to put stuff in your permanent record."
I wasn't sure I agreed with her, but I had to admit, it wasn't as bad as what I'd been going through every day at West High recently.
The other memorable thing was at the end of the week, I got switched to the advanced math class. I was just leaving math class, and the teacher asked me to stay for a minute.
"Miss Rawlings, I can see that you're not having any trouble keeping up with the work in this class. I think you are ready to switch to the advanced class, and I think you would find it more satisfying. It's your choice, though. Do you want to switch?"
I still wasn't used to talking one-on-one with the staff, so I simply said, "Yes, sir. I mean, yes, I would like to switch."
"Good. Drop your old textbook off when you have a chance. You can leave it on my desk if I'm out. And on Monday, report to Ms. Higgens class, in room 121."
So far, I hadn't made any friends of my own. I mostly just knew Teresa's friends. Usually, you make friends at school, but there wasn't any chance to hang out there except for lunch, and everybody seemed to have their own group there. I could have tried sitting with a different group from Teresa's, but I was still afraid of people being mean to me.
I tried joining the chorus, like Teresa, but there wasn't much free time there, either. Actually, for a while, we had less. The chorus director was shocked to discover I couldn't read music and made dire comments about schools in the West End not teaching children how to read. I couldn't just stand next to Teresa and listen to her because she sang soprano and I got put in the alto section. So Teresa had to spend what little free time we had left in the evening teaching me the alto parts and also to read music.
So the people I got together with on weekends were all Teresa's friends. Not that they were bad. They were fine with me hanging out with them on weekends, usually at somebody's house or other. They knew my story, though maybe not the worst details, but didn't act like it made any difference. As far as they were concerned, I belonged.
One thing, though: they didn't think much of my choice of clothes. "You need to come up with a look, at least one," they'd say. "You look like you just picked up the first thing you saw at the mall." So much for Teresa's and her mother's efforts at shopping for me. Especially, they thought I could look prettier if I paid more attention to how I dressed. I explained that I wasn't sure I wanted to be pretty. A part of me still thought of myself as a boy, and boys aren't supposed to be "pretty."
"That's pretty stupid," one of them said. I think it was Ellen Gundersen. "What's the matter with looking pretty? Do they think their penis will fall off if they do?" They all cracked up at that. They seemed to think the word 'penis' was the funniest thing they'd ever heard. I couldn't help thinking that my penis had as good as fallen off, even without me trying to be pretty, but I decided not to make a stink about it. "Besides," she added in a sly voice, "maybe if they were pretty, they'd get further with us girls."
One thing they did get me to do was to get a haircut. They all had different ideas of what I should do with it, from getting a 'butch' cut to growing it down to my waist. My aunt took me out one day and, with Teresa's advice, had my hair trimmed to a page-boy cut that was fairly feminine but still wouldn't have looked stupid on a boy.
Anyway, one day they were digging through our closet to find something for me to wear, and they ran across a petticoat on Teresa's side: one of those net things that makes a skirt pouf out.
"What's this?" someone asked.
"That's a petticoat I picked up at a thrift shop," answered Teresa. "It's short enough to fit under my school uniform, so one day last year, I wore it to school."
"Did you get in trouble for it?"
"Nobody said anything. I think a lot of people could tell, but it wasn't showing, so it didn't count as 'visible underwear.' I did have to work to keep it from pushing my skirt up too far when I sat down. It was fun. It spiced up the day. I should really wear it again some time."
"Maybe it will spice up Melanie's wardrobe. Come on, Melanie, try it on." They talked me into putting it on under the boring skirt I was wearing and pronounced it "spicier." Then they had me take the skirt off and put my school jumper on over it. They decided that was good, too. When they got bored with having me model it, the girls who were wearing skirts wanted to try it on, too.
They were still going through the closet, and they found the blue dress. When they found out it was for me, they all insisted that I put it on. "Hey, we finally found something that looks good on you," they said. They got me to walk around the house and show it off to my aunt and uncle.
"You should wear it to church tomorrow," said my aunt. I gave in, and said I would. After the girls had gone, I looked at myself in the mirror for a while. Part of me really liked looking like this. The haircut was a little boyish for the dress, though. Maybe shoulder-length hair would be better. I was lost in thought when Teresa came in. She came up behind me and gave me a gentle hug, then started fussing a little with the dress, arranging things.
"It feels funny," I said, "having someone else doing stuff to me. You know, putting your hands on my clothes and my hair. I know you're not doing anything to hurt me, and it feels nice, but it's not what anybody would ever do when I was a boy. Except my mom, when I was a lot younger."
"Girls do that all the time with each other. Grown-up women, too. It feels friendly, I guess. And since we can't see what we look like to other people, and we want to look our best, we do things like that for each other. Like, I don't do make-up much, so when I do, I get another girl to do it for me. By the way, do you want to go to Youth Group tomorrow night?"
"Can I go and not answer lots of questions about my past? I've been trying not to think about who I was and what I went through, it makes it easier to deal with all the, uh, stuff that's going on right now. Actually, I'd rather not talk much at all, just listen and enjoy being there. Like how I used to be when your friends came over."
"I think so. We can talk it over with the youth pastor tomorrow."
I did wear the dress to church the next day, and nothing awful happened. A few of the grown-ups complimented me on it. We talked with the youth pastor, Reverend Jennifer Smallman, and she said she'd try to get the other kids "to give you some time to open up."
Youth group was in a room in the basement with old couches and overstuffed chairs and a ping-pong table. I wore the blue skirt and a blouse, and I was more dressed up than most of the kids there. Teresa and I and one other girl were the only girls wearing skirts. When we got there, two boys were playing ping-pong, while a boy and a girl were figuring out what kinds of pizza to order. Everone else was sitting or lying sort of draped on couches or chairs. They reminded me of a bunch of cats, the way they were in each others' laps or leaning on shoulders. After Teresa introduced me, I found an empty chair where I hoped I wouldn't be the center of attention. I tried to sit so I wouldn't flash anyone, but Teresa and the other girl in a skirt didn't seem to care. Sometimes they'd shift position and their underwear would show, and sometimes they'd move or pull on their skirt, and sometimes not, and nobody seemed to care.
After they called the pizza order in, Rev. Smallman, who everyone called "Jen" or, if they wanted to be formal, "Reverend Jen," got us all to sit in a circle and so a sort of introduction game, where we'd say our name and one good thing that happened since the last meeting. When it was my turn, I told how I'd gotten switched to a more advanced math class. Then Rev. Jen introduced the topic: how we feel about people's differences. We did some brainstorming, and then the pizza came, which we ate in the next room, which had tables and chairs. Teresa sat with me, and a boy and the girl with the skirt and another girl sat down with us. They asked about school, and I told them I'd transferred to Gabriel from West High. They were blown away. The boy said, "wow, that must take some getting used to! Going from Animal House to the nerdiest, most uptight school in town." It turned out the boy and the first girl went to Greenwood, so they started talking about the reputations of all the schools in town, which meant they didn't ask me any personal questions.
The second girl was pretty quiet, so I didn't find out until weeks later that she was the only other kid there who didn't go to Greenwood. Her name was Amy and she went to Hollingsworth, West High's big rival, not that I cared about that stupid rivalry. Once I got to know her, I discovered we had a lot in common: we liked the same music, we thought the same things were funny. We even liked the same pizza toppings: anchovies and onions. But that was a long time later.
After pizza, there was some discussion of a planned camping trip, then a game that involved people getting up and running around, then some discussion of the topic. Some people had guitars and we sang some songs. We finished up with mutual shoulder massages and lots of hugs. It didn't seem so bad.
I was doing pretty well in my advanced math class, so the teacher suggested I try tutoring people in math after school. I started doing it one day a week, but after a few weeks, I went up to twice a week. I would hang out in the study hall, and if people needed help, I would help them, and if not, I would work on my homework. Except that there were always people who wanted help. They were almost always girls, maybe because the boys didn't want to admit that a girl might be better than them. Most of them were just confused about something, and after I walked them through some problems once or twice, they usually got it. But there was one girl who had real trouble: Sylvia Reynolds.
Each time I would show her how to do something, she would act like she understood, but then when she tried to do it herself, she would end up doing the craziest things. It took a couple of weeks, but I started to suspect that she really didn't understand much of anything about math. Her class was beginning algebra, but I started throwing in problems in arithmetic, and she couldn't do them, either. The only problems she could do halfway reliably were ones with arithmetic with positive, whole numbers. And that only if we hadn't done any harder ones. I wondered what she had actually been learning in all those math classes. How was it that no one noticed? I found out she was failing algebra miserably and they were threatening to kick her out of Gabriel. I got the feeling she was in a panic whenever she had to do any math and in a double panic because she was afraid of getting kicked out.
I started talking this over with my teacher. She didn't have any suggestions except to work on what she could do and go from there. Except that it probably wouldn't be in time for her to pass algebra. I felt really bad for her, so I talked it over with my aunt. Then I went to Ms. Ellis. She wasn't sure I should involve myself, but I said I just couldn't stand around and do nothing. I finally went to Mr. Wright, the guidance counsellor. They were all surprised that I was making a fuss for another student, but I said I knew what it was like to feel like the whole system is against you.
Meanwhile, I spent our time together just trying to get her to relax. I gave her little problems and puzzles that used basic arithmetic. A teacher from the younger grades gave me some problems that might get her into negative numbers and fractions without looking like it. Finally, they decided to let her drop algebra, since she wasn't learning anything and just getting depressed. She would need to take algebra or pre-algebra in summer school and pass it to stay in Gabriel. They reshuffled her schedule so she had study hall the same time as me, so I helped her during study hall and after school, too. So much for my free time. But it made me feel good that I could do something for someone else. The past six months or so, I'd been constantly needing help, so now I was paying it forward.
The tutoring helped with the friend situation, too. The students I helped in math got to see that I wasn't as weird as they'd thought from hearing about me. I guess they had thought I must have two heads or something. And Sylvia had quite a few friends, and they appreciated that I was working so hard to help her. She introduced me to a bunch of people at lunch. With all the people I was getting to know, I only ate with Teresa once or twice a week.
Sylvia also invited me out with her friends on weekends. They were different from Teresa's friends. They liked to go to the malls and hang out, which I wasn't wild about, but they were also into music. Making music. Most of them played some instrument. They also knew some boys who made music, so they'd all get together and some of them would jam together and the others would listen or bang on a trash can or something. They also went to a lot of movies, which Teresa and her family didn't do much. Sylvia liked to draw and could draw the most amazing pictures. When she wanted to, she could draw very lifelike pictures, but she also liked to draw caricatures. One time, she drew a picture of Ms. Williams and Mr. Wright on a nude beach together. She got all the body parts right, as far as I could tell. We all got a kick out of it.
About this time, my parents asked if I could visit them. I felt bad, because I hadn't really thought about my family, I'd been so busy with settling in to my new life. I had called them every few weeks when my aunt or uncle reminded me. So one Sunday afternoon, my uncle drove me over to my old home.
I was wearing a casual skirt and blouse and tights, and my hair was growing out of the boy/girl cut. When my parents opened the door, at first they didn't recognize me. They knew it had to be me, of course.
My mother said, "Martin, is that you?" I said "hi, mom," and reached out and hugged her, but she still didn't seem convinced. My uncle said goodbye, and I went in the house. She asked, "would you like me to get you something to drink?" in a nervous tone. I said, "you don't have to, I'll get it myself," and walked into the kitchen.
When I came out, she said, "you don't look at all like my son, but I know you're my son because you walk the same and you talk the same." She took me in her arms and gave me a hug and cried on my shoulder.
I could see that both my parents were having a hard time with my being even more like a girl than when I left, so I told them an edited version of what was going on with me. I told them about math, about tutoring, and about having to study all the time. "The nice thing is, everybody is nice to me. Nobody picks on anybody else. But we do study a lot." I didn't talk about school uniforms, or church dresses or anything to remind them of my sex change.
Biff asked if Gabriel had any sports teams. I told him they had some after-school sports clubs, mainly soccer and track, but no official school teams. Then he told me about West High. Things had settled down after I left, mainly because he didn't have any reason to fight with his old friends, but he didn't feel the same way about them. "I'll be glad to graduate and leave. The way they treated you, I saw a side of them that really grossed me out. I act friendly with them, mostly because I don't want to have any trouble, but I don't spend a lot of time with them any more. I tell them I'm busy with schoolwork. It's kind of lonely." He looked sad. Then he asked, "Martin, are you going to come to my graduation?"
"Why not?"
"You might not want to be around West High people."
"I don't think anyone will recognize me. Hey, my mom didn't. I can't see Tom Prescott succeeding where my mom didn't. Besides, they'll all be busy graduating."
Pete was just looking at me the whole time. I'd never known him to talk about deep stuff before, but when Biff finished, he said, "you know, you make a pretty good little sister." My mom sighed. "What do they call you now?"
"Melanie." I knew this kind of talk bothered my parents, but I couldn't figure out how to change the subject.
"Well, Melanie or Martin, brother or sister, I think you make a pretty good -- what's the word?"
"Sibling."
"Yeah, that. It's great to hear you're doing well. I'm proud to have you as my, uh, sibling. Put it there, sib." He grabbed my hand and shook it, then pulled me over and gave me a big hug.
My dad started talking about how things were at work. My mom brought in some brownies she'd baked in honor of my visit. We talked about the neighbors and about their summer plans. We didn't talk about mine. Finally, Mom and Pete went into the kitchen and made dinner. Biff and Dad talked about sports, especially the West High baskeball season. Then they talked about cars. I joined in a little then.
Dinner was -- polite. My mother kept looking at me. Sometimes I saw tears. I felt really bad for her. Finally, as we were just finishing, she heaved a big sigh and said, "I guess Pete is right. I have a daughter now instead of a son, but you're still the same person. You're still my child, even though you look so different." I could see how hard it was for her. I got up and put my arms around her and said, "and you're still my mom. And I love you." After a while, I went over to my dad, who was still sitting, watching us, and I put my arms around him and held him and said, "and you're still my dad. And I love you, too."
Later, after we'd cleared the table, Biff came over and said, "hey, what about me?" So I gave him a long hug and said, "you're still my brother, and I love you." Pete said he'd already gotten a hug and he didn't want to be greedy.
After we'd had dessert and washed all the dishes, it was time for me to go back home, as I now thought of it, but I didn't say that out loud. I gave everyone a big hug again, and then my dad drove me back. We didn't have much to say on the drive. I was mostly thinking how far my life had gone away from their lives. I didn't know what would happen in the future, but I didn't think we'd ever get any closer.
One day around the beginning of April, something happened that really upset me. When I got to school, people were buzzing about something, but I didn't pay much attention. When I got to my English class, though, I saw that some of the boys were wearing girls' uniforms, and I started to get nervous. Nobody said anything about it, and I sat down. When the class started, the teacher started calling the boys that were wearing girls' uniforms Miss So-and-so instead of Mister So-and-so. Some of the students would look at those boys and then look at me. I couldn't imagine what this was all about, but I was sure it had something to do with me -- after all, I was the only boy who normally dressed like a girl. I noticed that the other kids picked up on the "Miss So-and-so" thing and did it, too. I kept getting more and more nervous, waiting for something awful to happen. I had trouble concentrating in class. Finally, I asked the teacher if I could go see Ms. Ellis, the psychologist. My voice was pretty shaky, maybe that's why the teacher didn't ask me why. She did remind me to take my books with me "in case you don't come back before class is over."
Ms. Ellis didn't seem surprised to see me and she already knew about the boys in girls' uniforms. Word had gotten around about the boys before the first class, and they'd decided that if they were going to dress as girls, they would be treated as girls in every way. They'd have to use the girls' bathrooms and go to girls' phys ed. This made me feel worse. I told her how upset I was and how it brought back all the experiences I'd had at West High. I was sure it was a way to make fun of me and tell me I didn't belong here. I was kind of hysterical. She told me I could stay in the office as long as I needed to and could even go home. She kept talking to me and telling me that no one would let anyone make fun of me and they were fine with me just as I was. I finally settled down and went to math class late.
When I got out of math class one or two of the girls told me they'd heard I was upset, but I shouldn't worry, they had my back. I saw a teacher directing one of those boys away from the boys' bathroom. Later, when I used the bathroom, I saw one come in. He didn't look too cocky, mostly nervous, and he tried to sort of sneak into a stall and sneak out again, but one of the girls reminded him to wash his hands. There were two boys in our gym class. We were outside that day, and they were late coming out because they'd had to borrow gym suits from the school and then had trouble figuring out how to put them on. We all acted like they were girls but not our friends. By this time, I was still upset but not freaking out. After school I had my appointment with Dr. Gordon and talked about how upset I was. She said it was a productive session, though I was still upset at the end.
The next day, the boys were back in their usual uniforms: plaid pants, white shirt and plaid tie, and plaid jacket. I started to calm down. At lunch, though, I was sitting with Teresa and her friends when one of the boys who'd dressed as a girl came over. I tensed up and muttered to the girl next to me, "what's he going to do to me now?"
"I'm Dennis Lambert, from your English class, remember? I just wanted to apologize for getting you so upset yesterday," he said. "If I'd known how you would take it, I wouldn't have dressed that way and I'd have tried to talk the other boys into not dressing, too."
"If you weren't doing it to get me worked up, why did you do it?" I honestly couldn't think of any other reason.
"I think a lot of the guys just did it to be doing something different. But actually, I wanted to know what it was like to be a boy that suddenly had to dress and act like a girl. I guess I thought I'd understand what you were going through." He did sound contrite.
"And what did you find out? What was it like for you?" I asked like I was sure it would be something stupid. I was mad at all of them, but he was the only one coming over so I could yell at him.
"It was weird. It felt really weird."
"You have no idea. You have no idea!" I was shaking. "You think it's weird? That's what I feel like when I'm feeling 'normal.' Think what it's like when I'm reminded that I'm not normal, that I'm some kind of freak! You got to satisfy your curiosity and then change back the next day. I'm stuck here, neither boy nor girl. I came to this school trying to forget my nightmare at West High. I hoped that since I couldn't live as a boy, at least I could try to live as a girl and feel sort of normal. And then you and your buddies come along and remind me that I'm not. I thought people here would be better than at West High, but I guess I was wrong. I hope you had lots of fun, because I paid a high price for your fun."
He looked stunned. He muttered "I'm sorry. I'm really sorry," over and over again as he backed away from our table.
I spent the next few minutes concentrating on my breathing, like Dr. Gordon had taught me, and managed to settle down. I apologized to the other girls for making a scene, but they all said they were glad I told him off, they'd have done it if I hadn't.
I started to feel better after that. By the time Respect class came along, I was feeling pretty okay. Like a lot of the classes, today's class talked a lot about understanding how other people might see things differently and I got to thinking about Dennis. He wasn't a mean kid, and it was unfair of me to compare him to the kids at West High. That night, at dinner, I talked it over with Teresa and my aunt and uncle. Teresa thought he had it coming to him, but I said I thought I kind of overreacted. I was also thinking that I needed friends and I wasn't going to have any if I cut people out of my life every time they pushed one of my buttons, but I didn't say that.
Next day, at lunch, I put my lunch down at Teresa's table and then walked over to Dennis's table. I felt a hole in the bottom of my stomach and I thought about how a prisoner who was going to his execution must feel. There were mostly boys at the table and they all looked nervous when they saw me.
"Dennis," I said, "I want to apologize for yelling at you yesterday. I still think you weren't very considerate, but you didn't deserve all the stuff I said. Especially the part about being like West High. That was really unfair. It's just that I've had a lot of stuff going on in my life the past six months or so and I guess I just dumped it all on you. I'm sorry. I did wrong. Can we be friends? Or at least, not enemies?" I put out my hand.
He stood up and shook my hand. "Friends." Then he took a deep breath and tried to smile. "If you want to eat with us some time, feel free. Any time."
"Thanks. Maybe another day. Right now, I'd better get back before my lunch is cold."
Teresa thought I'd been too generous, but I said, "you know how your father says, you can never have too many friends or too few enemies. He seems like a nice boy. I mean, at least he tried to apologize, which is more than anyone else did."
The next day, I told Teresa and her friends I was going to eat with Dennis and his friends. "Sort of a peace offering," I said nervously. Dennis's friends had already made a space for me next to Dennis. I don't remember what we talked about. I remember feeling that if I wasn't careful, I'd start talking and acting like I was a boy and I was confused enough as it was.
I ended up eating with them once or twice a week and got to know Dennis better. He really was a nice boy, always trying to do the right thing. He wanted to become a doctor so he could help people, and he liked Gabriel because it was about studying hard, which you need to do if you want to go to med school. He asked if we could get together some weekend. I didn't want to go to his place, but Teresa usually had her friends over at our place. I was also a little nervous about being alone with him without someone like Teresa around. We worked it out that he would come over, but Teresa and her friends would be in the basement while Dennis and I hung out in the living room.
When he was over, we talked about a lot of things. I told him something of what I'd gone through. One thing was nice: because he knew what it was like to be a boy, he could understand a part of me that Teresa and her friends couldn't. He talked about people seeing him as too nerdy and feeling pressure to be a little more, I don't know, macho maybe. Even at Gabriel, the other boys thought he could act a little tougher and a little rowdier. Part of the reason he went along with the cross-dressing was that it might make the other boys see him as more willing to break the rules.
Teresa and her friends would wander by every now and then on the way to and from the kitchen or our bedroom. One time Teresa sat down with us and talked with Dennis for a while, and later Bethany did, too. "It's almost like they want to check me out and see if it's okay for you to be around me," he said.
"I think it's because we know that guys can be pretty mean, even when they don't intend to. Being mean, even to your friends, seems to be a guy thing. We girls" -- I was trying to make sure he knew I considered myself one of them -- "have to look out for one another. And I still don't have a lot of experience as a girl. They have my back." I suddenly realized this was the first time in my life I could honestly say that someone had my back. It felt nice.
Content note: discussion of sex (chapter 28)
Easter was coming up, and Teresa had been after me to get an Easter dress. That's a nice simple dress in spring colors that is supposed to make you think of flowers and spring and, I guess, Easter eggs. So one Saturday, Teresa and Carol and my aunt took me out to get one. Dennis was coming over in the afternoon, so we tried to get done before he came, but things always take longer than you think. We went to a store that seemed to be for people who wanted to pretend they were in a Victorian novel. It had pictures of people in 19th century clothes promenading with parasols on the walls and old-style dolls on little shelves. They even had a line of dolls with outfits like the ones they sold for girls, so girls could dress just like their dolls. They also had outfits for grown-ups, which I noticed because Aunt Edith was looking interested in some of them.
Anyway, they settled on a jumper with a pink top and a light green skirt with little pink flowers embroidered on it which came with a combined blouse and slip that you were supposed to wear under it. It was actually like wearing a jumper over a dress, and the hem of the dress was supposed to show. They also got me white knee socks knit in a diamond pattern, black patent leather shoes, and a broad-brimmed straw hat with a pink and green ribbon. Even a month earlier I might have objected, but by now, I just thought, whatever. Actually, when I looked at myself in the mirror, I liked it. When we left, I kept the outfit on, minus the hat. On the way home, they took me by a beauty salon and got my hair trimmed, too. It was almost shoulder length and it didn't look like a boy's cut at all.
Dennis was already there when we got home. Uncle Boris had been entertaining him with stories about the crazy things some of the students at his college did while he made lunch for us. Then I walked in, all done up, and Dennis just stared for a minute, speechless.
"Wow," he said, once he recovered his voice, "that is really nice. You look really pretty." Then he remembered how I was having trouble with the idea of being pretty and added, "I mean, if you wanted to be pretty," and then I guess he realized he was just going to sound stupid and stopped. Dennis had never been good at small talk, but he was even more tongue-tied than usual. While we were eating lunch, I caught him just looking at me like he couldn't take his eyes off of me. My uncle seemed to appreciate how I looked, but he was more subtle. I was still a little torn -- I felt like I wasn't supposed to be attractive like that, being really a boy and all, but most of me liked it. I'd never had people just want to look at me. Maybe the word is "admire."
After lunch, I changed back into more normal clothes and spent some time talking with Dennis.
"You know," he said, "I know you are, or were a boy, or something like that, but you make a really great girl. I keep thinking about how you said you feel like a freak" -- he looked at me to see if I was upset by the word -- "but I think you're the opposite of a freak. I really like you as a girl, and I think maybe I would have liked you if I'd gotten to know you as a boy, too. Like there's a part of you that's you, whether you're a boy or a girl, and that's pretty fine."
I couldn't exactly follow what he said, but it felt good and without even thinking I reached over and gave him a big hug. He looked surprised at first, but then he hugged me back. I explained, "at Youth Group we hug all the time. It's nice."
Carol and Teresa came in just as we were finishing our hug. They teased us a little. They didn't quite call us lovebirds, but that was what they were hinting at. But then they said it was great that I had another friend. We all got to talking about random stuff and just enjoying being together. Dennis and I had stopped hugging, but we sat next to each other on the sofa. I had this sudden thought: I could hold his hand, or at least put my hand on top of his. But I didn't do it.
Some of the people at the church were going to hike to the top of a nearby mountain -- it was more like a hill, but everyone called it a mountain -- to watch the sun rise for Easter, and the youth group had decided to join them. I was now a regular with the youth group, and had even started to open up a tiny bit about my life. Anyway, there was a dirt road to the top, so it wasn't like a wilderness hike. I decided to wear my Easter dress, but with white tights and some substantial shoes instead the patent leather ones. Teresa decided to wear her Easter dress, too. Then Aunt Edith decided to go along, and she wore a spring-like dress. Uncle Boris came along, too, to keep us out of trouble, he said, but he wouldn't wear a dress, even though we voted that he ought to. We got up real early and went over to the mountain. It was still dark, but by the time we got started up the mountain, it was beginning to get light. We walked up in little groups, whispering because it didn't seem right to be too loud. At the top, we just stood there, and nobody said anything. When we first saw a bit of the sun peek out over the hills on the horizon, Reverend Jen gave a short sort of sermon, something like, "As the sun rises, so did Our Lord. And so will we all." Then we said the Lord's Prayer, waited for the sun to be completely above the horizon, and then we went back down.
We went home, had breakfast, and changed to go to church. The youth group hid eggs for the little kids' Easter egg hunt and then we went to the service. I was going to take my Easter hat off, but my aunt instructed me that women didn't take hats off in church. It made me think how funny people are: we think taking your hat off is a sign of respect (at least if you're male), but if you're a woman, or an Orthodox Jew, or a muslim, you leave it on to show respect.
After church, as I was talking with the other kids in the Youth Group, I realized how much I was thinking of myself as just a girl. It wasn't bothering me as much as it did even a month ago. But I still didn't want to forget my old life entirely. That was me, too.
If you know anything about teen-agers, you know that one big topic for them is: sex.
By this point, I'd learned about masturbating in my new body, although I usually thought of it simply as "doing what feels good." I generally did it every couple of days. To be honest, it was one of the few things that made me feel good about my changed body, and I not only didn't feel like stopping, I couldn't see any reason why I should. Not only did it feel good, it was a good way to calm me down when I was upset or worried. I talked it over with Dr. Gordon, and she agreed with me.
When I moved into Teresa's room, I was worried that I wouldn't be able to do it. After a week, I couldn't stand it any longer and I started doing it after I thought Teresa was asleep, but I tried to be real quiet about it. Then one night, when I was lying awake wondering if she was asleep enough, I felt the bed shake a little and heard quiet little moans from below, and I realized I wasn't the only one who needed to "do what feels good." I don't know if she knew I heard her, and I still tried to be discrete, but I stopped worrying that she'd think I was some kind of pervert if she heard me doing it. Actually, I kind of hoped we would catch each other doing it at the same time, so we could talk about it and not pretend that we didn't both do it, even though I was pretty sure we both knew the other did.
About this time, our Respect class started a sex education unit. It was a lot more instruction than the class usually was and covered a lot of stuff I already knew, but there was some new stuff, too. I think that because ours was a beginners' class, they couldn't be sure we knew anything at all. We went over sex organs, menstruation, masturbation, reproduction, basic kinds of sex, including gay and lesbian, birth control, and STDs. They also touched on transgenderism; I thought it would make me uncomfortable, but somehow they did it so I didn't feel weird. We did some of it with the boys and girls separate and some together. I didn't say much, but other kids did. I listened a lot.
All that was just background information. They even gave us some quizzes on what they'd taught. Then they had us talk about sex. To each other. Sometimes with boys and girls together. Talk about awkward! They had us talk about how to deal with feeling attracted to someone. And how to deal with someone who's attracted to you, if you're attracted to them and if you're not. We brainstormed things like if you both decide to make love and then one of you decides you don't want to go through with it. And a lot of stuff about feelings.
One day after class, I asked the teacher, "one thing I don't understand: I got the impression Ms. Williams is kind of old-fashioned. I'd think she didn't believe in students having sex. But here we have this real explicit course on how to do it."
"You're right. She doesn't believe in it. But she's also aware that some students are going to do it anyway, and if they're going to do it, she wants them to do it with Respect. She's just being realistic. Besides, the state requires sex education, and this wasn't something she thought was worth fighting over."
I talked all this stuff over with Teresa and her friends. They'd all already had the course, so they talked about some of the questions and discussions they'd had in their classes. They ended up talking about which girls they thought were lesbians. We knew that lesbians often tried to get into Gabriel because Gabriel had a reputation for being safe for LGBTQ kids. There were some kids who we thought got in mainly because Gabriel was worried about what was happening to them in their home schools. I wondered if that was the real reason I got in. I was the only transgender kid they knew of this year, but there had been others in the past. Then they got into what they would do if a lesbian student came on to them. Most said they'd say no, but Ellen said she might consider it if the girl was nice enough. "Besides," she said, "who knows better what turns a girl on than another girl?" But she said she'd still rather do it with a boy. "They're so intriguing. They're so -- different." I didn't say anything.
I also talked about it with Dennis. I liked talking with him because he could talk about almost anything without getting all weird, even though I was a girl and he was a boy and, even worse, we really liked each other. For instance, I was worried about being attracted to either boys or girls.
"If I feel attracted to a boy, does that mean I'm gay because I'm really a boy, or am I straight because I'm a girl?" I asked one day. "And how about me being attracted to a girl? I mean, I used to be attracted to girls, generally, and I don't feel all that different now. Does that make me a lesbian?"
I always felt like I was crazy when I said these things, but Dennis took them seriously. He seemed to understand how I felt like I was really a boy, but also I was a girl, and it didn't seem to bother him like it did me.
"Does it really matter? I mean, if you're attracted to them, you're attracted to them. Who cares what you call it? And if you do have sex with a boy, it's going to look like straight sex, because you do sex with your body, and your body is female. And if you have sex with a girl, it'll look like lesbian sex, for the same reason."
He's going to make a great doctor someday, I thought. I was sitting next to him on the couch, holding his hand and leaning against him. I'd started holding his hand if I felt like it and he didn't seem to mind. And leaning up against him was nice and warm. Teresa and I would snuggle on the couch, too, especially if we were watching a movie together, but she didn't sit still as much as Dennis. With Dennis, I would pretend I was a cat finding a warm spot to get warm.
I started wondering what it would be like to have sex with him. Not that I was planning to, but I was sure that someday I'd want to have sex, and I thought I'd want it to be with someone like him. It still felt gay, though.
And if it was a woman I'd someday have sex with? Would it feel lesbian? Dennis's explanation made a lot of sense, but my feelings still felt mixed up.
May is prom season. I don't think Ms. Williams approved of proms, but she probably realized she wasn't going to get away with nothing at all. However, the school does what it can to cool down Prom Fever. They don't call it a prom, but a High School Spring Dance, it's for all three grades, you can't invite guests, other than close family, and you don't go as couples. But students do what they can to make it prom-like. Girls get fancy dresses, most of the boys really dress up, sometimes renting tuxes, and both girls and boys stretch the definition of "close family" to cover people who you'd have to go back to the stone age to find where they're related.
This was Teresa and Carol's first prom -- I mean, High School Spring Dance -- and they wanted to get suitable dresses. Meanwhile, Aunt Edith and Teresa both thought I needed some summer clothes. I thought my blue church dress would do just fine for the dance, but Teresa and Carol wanted to at least get me to try on something.
So, one Saturday in early May, we went on a clothes shopping expedition. Again. I swear, I'd been clothes shopping more times since I started turning female than in my whole life up to that time. On the other hand, it was something to do that wasn't studying. They got me a white blouse with really short sleeves in some really light cotton that you could almost see through. I didn't see the point, since I'd have to wear something underneath so people wouldn't see the bra. Carol and Teresa explained with exasperated patience that seeing the bra was the point. They also got me a light teal sleeveless blouse. I got a short summer skirt and a flower-print sundress and some sandals. And a bathing suit. They wanted me to get a pink bikini, but I wanted a tank suit in a dark color. We compromised on a tank suit in light green. Finally, they insisted on getting me a miniskirt. It was like six inches above my knees and it felt like it barely covered my crotch. It was going to take all summer for me to get used to wearing them all.
Then we went to a store that had prom dresses. We met Ellen there. Ellen had what we call a lot in front and wanted a dress that would show it off without getting her kicked out of the dance. Teresa and Carol just wanted something showy. They each tried on a half-dozen dresses and picked out some for me to try on. There were one or two that I said I would consider -- for next year. Teresa picked a calf-length green taffeta dress with organza sleeves, and Carol, who has fairly dark skin, picked a knee-length sleeveless pink and black satiny dress. Ellen, though, got a long black gown in some slinky shimmery fabric that clung to her body and was open in front down to her breasts with a sort of slit down between them. There wasn't any way to hide a bra under it, so I guess the dress was designed to work without one. "Do you think the boys will like it?" she asked me.
"They'll be too busy trying to find their eyeballs after they jump out of their heads and fall on the floor when they see you," I said. She took that as a "yes."
I went out that evening with Sylvia and her friends to a church basement where some of her musician friends were hanging out. I met a friend of hers named Doris Spelman. She was an eleventh-grader from Gabriel. Sylvia's friends were talking about what they were going to wear to the prom. Doris said she was going to wear a tux, she'd made a reservation already.
"But you're a girl," I said, "aren't girls supposed to wear dresses to the dance? Will they let you in?"
"They just said formal attire. If a tux isn't formal, I don't know what is."
"You don't like wearing dresses?" I had a feeling I was making a fool of myself, but I wanted to understand.
"I don't like having to wear a dress," she insisted. "I think girls should be able to choose. If nobody's willing to be different, it's as if we couldn't. This year, I'm the one being different. Besides, I've heard that you say you're 'really a boy,' and you're wearing a dress, aren't you."
"Everyone acts like I'm a girl, so I might as well be one. And if you know about me once being a boy, you also know why I just want to fit in and not make waves."
I changed the subject. "So, will you dance with the boys or with the girls."
"Both. But that's not unusual at our dances. Girls dance with girls, and with boys, and with their parents and brothers and sisters. The boys won't dance with other boys though, which I think is stupid."
It was about this time that I learned a new word: street harrassment. (Well, two words.) Things like: one warm Sunday afternoon, one of the girls from the youth group was over, and we decided to walk down to the ice cream store for some ice cream. I was wearing my summer skirt and the sheer blouse and sandals, just to get used to it, and Teresa and the other girl were also dressed sort of summery. Anyway, we'd only crossed the first street when a car came by with the windows down and some boys in it. When they saw us, they honked and slowed down so they could stay next to us. They started shouting things at us about how they thought we were sexy and we ought to go riding with them. We tried to ignore them. Then they started telling us what they thought of our breasts and butts. We kept walking. There were people out on their lawns who saw us and those boys, but nobody said or did anything. Fortunately, they decided to drive off.
I told Teresa and the other girl that I was really scared of those boys. They told me they were a little scared, but this sort of thing happened all the time, and usually they'd just drive off like this time. Anyway, there was nothing they could do. "Just don't ever get in the car with them. Or even get close to their car," they told me.
Anyway, the night of the prom, Teresa's parents came with us. I found out that although we weren't supposed to have dates, some of the boys brought flowers for pinning on for the girls they liked. It was a little like having a date, except that sometimes a boy would bring flowers for several girls. Dennis was there, and he'd brought flowers for both Teresa and me. I thought that was a good way for him to guarrantee he'd get at least two dances with a girl.
The band played all kinds of music. There was some swing music and some music for ballroom dances and some rock and roll. We'd had some lessons after school in basic dancing to get us ready, but I still wasn't very good at it. Uncle Boris danced with Teresa while Aunt Edith danced with me, then my uncle danced with me. They were pretty good at it, I mostly tried not to step on anybody's feet.
Then Dennis asked me to dance. He was a pretty good dancer. I asked him where he'd learned to dance so well, and he said his parents had sent him for dance lessons after school for the past year. I don't know what kind of dance it was, I was just trying to sort of move in time with the music and not hurt anyone. I stared at his face so I wouldn't get dizzy or confused. I don't know if he thought I was in love with him or just hypnotized.
One of Dennis's friends asked me to dance while Dennis danced with Teresa. The friend wasn't much better than me, so we mostly just walked around in time to the music. He was trying to act grown up and manly and impressive, but not really succeeding. It was weird, because I could see myself doing exactly the same thing if I hadn't gotten turned into a girl. So even though he was kind of annoying, I couldn't get mad at him.
About that time, I saw Ellen in her super-sexy dress. I was really surprised because she was on the sidelines. I went over to her. "What's happening? I thought the guys would be lining up to dance with you?"
"I don't know, they look at me, but they don't talk to me. Even the boys I usually talk to at school. Maybe you were right about them trying to find their eyeballs."
"Well, I'll dance with you," I said. The band was playing a slow dance, so we just walked in time to the music. I wanted to take her mind off of not being asked to dance, so I asked her about what she was doing for the summer. After that dance, I got Dennis and another one of his friends to promise to ask her to dance. I couldn't help wondering: why couldn't Ellen just ask a boy to dance? But I knew she was afraid they'd think it was weird. Sometimes the world is just so weird.
Doris was there, and she was wearing a tux, just like she'd said. She'd cut her hair shorter than usual, so she looked like a girl trying to pass as a boy, but not really. I saw her dancing, sometimes with a boy, and sometimes with a girl. I was getting some punch when the music stopped, and she came over and asked me to dance. She was as good as Dennis, maybe even as good as Uncle Boris. She had me doing turns and one time even a twirl. I felt like I almost knew what I was doing.
"Who's that girl you were dancing with?" she asked. "The one with that risque' dress?"
"Ellen. I think she was hoping the dress would make the boys want to dance with her more, but I think she just scared them off. It's too bad, because she's a nice girl and fun to be with."
"She's not the only one," she said, giving me a knowing smile.
"What do you mean?"
"I mean you," she explained, like I was slow. "You are a nice girl and fun to be with." I couldn't figure out why she was saying it. She looked exasperated. "I'm flirting with you, you dope. C'mon, flirt back. You've got to get practice sometime."
"You dance very well," I said. She gave me a sort of "and?" look. "I'd say you've swept me off my feet -- but really, you've kept me on my feet."
"There you go. We'll have you flirting like a pro before long."
I suddenly started feeling that dissociation feeling again, plus feeling hot and cold at the same time. "I'm sorry, I'm getting a little confused." I didn't know why I said it. "It's like, um, I don't know if I'm a boy dancing with a girl, or a girl dancing with a girl, or a girl dancing with a boy, or--." I stopped. "I don't know what I'm saying," I finished.
"You think too much. Just go with it. Do what feels good." This made me think of what I liked to do in my bed at night, and I almost lost it. She had to hold me firmly until I got my feet to work right again. I looked around and saw Dennis dancing with Ellen and Teresa dancing with another boy. Sylvia was by the punchbowl, talking with a boy and a girl. I noticed she had a flower pinned to her.
"Hey, am I so ugly you don't want to look at me?" I was afraid she was mad at me, but when I looked at her, she was grinning. "Got your attention, didn't I?"
"No, you're not ugly at all." I tried to think of a word that wasn't just for boys or just for girls. "I think you're very good-looking. Attractive. I was just looking around to see how my friends were doing. I was worried about Ellen...."
"Yeah, we need to take care of Ellen. I'll dance with her and get some of the older boys to ask her. It'd be a shame for her to have gone to all that trouble to wear a 'fuck me' dress and then have it go to waste." I looked around nervously to see if a teacher had heard her. "Relax, I looked before I said it." When the music stopped, she pulled me a little closer and gave me a kiss. On the mouth. It wasn't a big passionate kiss, but I was still blown away. She gave me a sly smile and then went off, probably to find Ellen.
Dennis asked me to dance again. It went a little better now that I'd had more practice. I wondered if I should try flirting with Dennis. He always seemed so serious, though. "You dance very well." Repeating myself, I thought. "I'm really enjoying it. And you look so handsome. I've talked with you so much, but I guess I never really looked at you. Until now." I think he blushed, but the lights were low, so it was hard to tell.
I don't remember all the people I danced with. There were people I knew and people I didn't. I do remember that Teresa asked me for the last dance. She looked happy. "Isn't this a lot of fun? I think I've danced with half the boys here and with some of the girls. I think some of them were smitten with me." She repeated the word: "smitten," like she enjoyed the taste. "And I'm so glad you're here. It's like I have a sister to share it with." When the music stopped, she gave me a long hug.
I saw Dennis, and reached out for a hug. I don't think it had occurred to him to ask for a hug, but he seemed to like it when I asked him. It was one of those it-could-be-a-brother-sister-hug-or-maybe-more type hugs. Then we said good-bye.
I saw Ellen then. "It's funny," she said, "right after you danced with me, boys started coming up to ask me to dance. Some I didn't know, too. And a girl, at least I think it was a girl. She was wearing a tux. I think you were a lucky charm for me."
I went and said good-bye to some of the other girls I knew, but they were chasing us out by them, so it was time to go home. Doris just gave me a wave and a smile as she went past.
A couple more things happened before the end of school. The Saturday after the Prom, I was hanging out with Teresa and Carol and Ellen, and Ellen looked upset.
"Some people have been telling me that some people are saying that my prom dress was slutty and that I was a slut! They said other things that were too upsetting to repeat."
We were all indignant. "Who's calling you a slut?" Carol demanded.
"I don't know. Nobody will mention any names. They just look at me funny and say 'some people.'"
"What a bunch of cowards! Can't even insult you to your face!" Carol said.
"Do you all think I'm a slut?" Ellen asked.
"Gosh, no!" I said. You'll notice I was trying to keep my language clean -- I didn't want the wrong word to slip out at school and earn me another paddling. Everyone else said more or less the same.
"Were they boys or girls who were saying this?" Teresa asked.
"I don't know. It was girls who were telling me, though."
"I'll bet it was girls and they were just jealous, because they didn't have the nerve to wear something like that."
"Are you all jealous?"
"No. It's not something I would wear, but I don't think there's anything wrong with it. Although -- if you were hoping you'd get more boys asking you to dance, I'd say it didn't work very well."
Ellen looked at me. "Melanie, you used to be a boy. What did you think of my dress? Was it slutty?"
"Slutty? No. Maybe a bit more, uh, explicit than anybody else's. Actually, I liked it. I thought it looked cool. I'll admit, I had a hard time not staring at your breasts the whole time. They looked really nice." Everyone laughed at this except Ellen.
"So if you'd been a boy, you'd have asked me to dance? You wouldn't have thought I was a -- a -- whore?"
"A what? Is that what they called you? I would never think that! If anything, I'd have thought you were out of my league. Like, why would this beautiful, hot girl want to dance with a loser like me? And if you'd asked me to dance, I'd have been tongue-tied the whole time."
"You didn't look tongue-tied when we danced."
I shrugged. "I guess, now that I know you, I'm not so intimidated by you. And I know how nice you are."
"You don't think it was, uh, indecent the way I showed off my boobs?"
"All our dresses showed off our boobs. I don't think there was a male in the room who wasn't aware of our boobs. Your dress was just a little more explicit."
Carol interrupted. "The question is, what do we do about this -- gossip!? This isn't West High, we can't have people at our school talking about other people this way."
"We could talk to our friends and get them to talk about how disgusting they think talk like that is," I suggested. "You know, social pressure. I'm sure Sylvia and Dennis and their friends would think this is awful."
"We should talk to the Respect teachers and get them to bring it up in class," suggested Teresa. "See, Ellen, we've got your back." And, sure enough, next week, the topic of gossip and insults came up in class.
The next thing that happened was my birthday. That Saturday, Teresa and her parents and I went to my parents' house, and we had a little party with ice cream and cake. But Teresa gave me her present to me before we went: it was a light blue lacy summer nightgown. "I've got one like it, so we'll match!"
I decided to dress up for the party, so I put on my Easter outfit. I was beginning to get used to dressing like a girl, and I wanted to look nice. And I didn't think that there was any way I could dress that would make it any easier on my parents. When I got there, they seemed okay with how I looked. We all sat around the table and had lunch and then my parents brought out the cake and all. My dad gave me a bookbag that I could wear on my back, my mom gave me a shawl that one of her patients had given her a few years back. I guess it was her way of showing that she accepted what I'd become. Biff gave me a book of jokes, and Pete gave me a book on repairing motorcycles -- sort of a joke, since I'd given him "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" for Christmas.
Afterwards, Teresa took me out to the ice cream shop where a bunch of her friends and mine were waiting to wish me a happy birthday. They gave me little presents, like a hair band and a floppy hat and dark glasses. Someone asked if I'd ever "really" kissed anyone. I said I didn't think so. This was my sixteenth birthday, so they started saying, "sweet sixteen and never been kissed." Dennis was there, so they started saying Dennis should kiss me. At first I didn't want to, but they all insisted, and I thought, why not? Besides, it wasn't like it was some gross guy, this was Dennis. Dennis was saying, no, no, too, but he gave in, too.
Anyway, we turned to face each other, and he held my shoulders, but gently, and we looked at each other. I think I was blushing and I had a nervous smile. He was a little taller, so I had to look up a little. Everyone got real quiet. He bent over and rubbed his lips on mine and then kissed me. I was afraid he'd stick his tongue in my mouth, like some boys do, but he didn't. He just moistened my lips with his tongue and rubbed my lips a little, then kissed me again. There was something magical about it. I couldn't move. I just stood there looking stupid. Then he took me in his arms and hugged me, and everyone cheered. I buried my face in his shoulder so I wouldn't have to look at anyone. It wasn't anything I'd have ever wanted to do, but now that it was over, I was glad I did it. If by "did it," you mean "stand there looking stupid while this really, really nice boy gives you the most magical kiss you can imagine."
I couldn't help thinking that nothing like this would have ever happened if I'd stayed a boy. I'd have had a little celebration with my family and that would have been it. I'd have never had so many people show that they liked me.
The last thing was Biff's graduation. I was a little afraid I'd run into people who would harrass me again, but I decided to be brave. I'd go dressed as a girl, which is how I always dressed now, and if anyone gave me any hassle, I'd just give them a raspberry.
So I sat in the bleachers with my mom and dad and Pete and we watched Biff go up for his diploma. I also saw Tom Prescott go up and get his, and I was afraid he'd see me, which was ridiculous. Biff was going to the state university next year to study engineering. He told me Tom had gotten a football scholarship at a school in Texas, so I wouldn't have to worry about seeing him around town in the fall.
After the ceremony, we wandered around and took pictures of Biff and his friends -- his new friends, the ones he made after the jock clique kicked him out. I was glad he'd made new friends. He introduced me to them, and they were nice to me, even impressed that I'd done so well after all I'd been through. "See, there are decent people at West Hell," Biff said. One or two said things like, "Biff, you've got a cute sister," and, sort of joking, "hey, Melanie, are you doing anything next Saturday night?"
I did see two of the guys who had held me down in the empty classroom in January and I thought my heart would stop, but they just looked at me a little funny and then went on by.
People didn't call Gabriel students nerds for nothing. At West High, kids spent the summer lifeguarding or working at fast food places or just hanging out and getting into trouble. Gabriel students went to summer school. If anybody was doing something else, I didn't hear about it. Most of the people I knew were taking classes at Greenwood High, because the classes were free, but I heard that some kids were taking intensive music classes at the conservatory downtown.
Teresa was taking conversational French in the morning and a computer course in the afternoon. She'd gotten Bethany and another girl, Judy Klemp, to agree to go with her so she wouldn't be the only girl in the class. I decided to take a morning class in Spanish, so I could get to Spanish III or maybe IV by graduation. I thought it would look good when applying to college. Dennis was taking an advanced chemistry class in the morning, I guess to help him get into a good pre-med program. He seemed to have his life planned out. Sylvia was taking remedial algebra, and counting on my help.
The morning classes let out at 12:30, but my appointments with Dr. Gordon were still at 4:30, the way they were during the school year, and it took about an hour to walk to them from Greenwood High, so I had something like two or three hours to kill on Tuesday and Friday. Dennis's condo complex was almost on the way from Greenwood to Dr. Gordon's, so I got in the habit of walking home with Dennis and hanging out with him until it was time to go to Dr. Gordon. His complex had a pool, which made it even better. Sometimes he'd tease me: "do you love me for myself, or for my pool?" Sometimes I came over even when I didn't have an appointment with Dr. Gordon.
The summer school classes were a lot easier than the ones at Gabriel. I could get all my homework done in maybe a half hour each day. The other kids, though, kept complaining about how hard the class was. I hadn't thought of my Gabriel classes as so hard, maybe because we were all doing the same amount of studying, so it seemed normal.
One thing I didn't like about summer was the street harrassment. I never had any problems when I was walking with Dennis, but twice on the way to Dr. Gordon, I had cars slow down and somebody shout something out the window. The second time it was an older guy, which was really creepy. I finally asked Dennis to walk me to Dr. Gordon. He was happy to do it, but I felt bad making him waste an hour walking around. Coming home, I'd take the bus, which wasn't so bad.
On Saturdays, if I was hanging out with Teresa and her friends, we'd sometimes have trouble walking down to the ice cream shop, like in the Spring. I didn't feel so scared since there were a bunch of us, but it made summer less fun.
One time, though, I had a really bad experience. We were about to walk into the ice cream shop and three big guys, like football players, were going in at the same time. They started talking to us, saying something about how nice it was to meet up with a bunch of pretty girls and pretending it was a date. I was already feeling like, get me away from here. One of them said to me, "hey, girlie, what's with the long face? Lemme brighten up your day," and then pulled me over and tried to kiss me. I was so mad I punched him in the stomach as hard as I could.
"Hey, what was that for? I just wanted to give you a kiss," he said.
"And I just wanted to give you a black eye!" I yelled. "I guess neither one of us are going to get what we want." I added. Suddenly I was afraid they were going to beat me up, but the guy's friends just laughed and said, "she's got you there," but I was already starting to shake. I was suddenly remembering the time Tom Prescott and his gang dragged me into the classroom. I thought I was going to fall down or faint. I dimly heard one of the boys say, "hey, what's the matter with her?"
Somebody helped me onto a bench, but I hardly noticed. I was having some sort of double vision, or maybe more like double feeling. I could feel my shirt being pulled up, I could feel Tom's hands on my breast, I could feel my pants being pulled down. I saw Teresa and Carol looking at me, and I managed to croak out, "flashback." I couldn't stop the memories. I could feel Tom's hand on my crotch. I felt ashamed of being undressed and exposed, like I wanted to die. I felt even worse than when it actually happened.
I could hear Carol talking to me. She was sitting next to me and saying, "Melanie, it's okay. You're at the ice cream shop. You're not at West High. Nobody's going to hurt you." She was saying it over and over again. I nodded and started taking deep breaths. I couldn't remember telling her about the almost-rape, but I guess Teresa told her that something awful had happened to me there.
The boys came out of the ice cream shop and gave us all ice cream cones. The one who tried to kiss me came over and said, "Jeez, I'm really sorry, if I'd known you'd get so upset...." I realized he wasn't a mean kid, he just thought it was normal to kiss a girl without asking. I thought that, too, back when I was a boy. Teresa explained, "she had some really awful experiences at her old school."
My afternoons with Dennis were the opposite of this. We'd come to his house and change into our bathing suits and swim for an hour, and then come in and change and eat something and talk. Mostly, he'd talk about his plans for the future. I didn't say all that much because I hadn't thought about the future, and I thought he'd be bored if I talked about Sylvia and the street harrassment. When the weather was hot, we wouldn't bother to change after swimming, we'd just eat in our suits and then sit on a towel and talk and cuddle. I'd bring my sundress and just put it on over my suit when it was time to leave. We were always alone there, because his parents both worked, and his older brother was a lifeguard at a city pool and away all day.
One time, Dennis asked if he could touch my breast. He sounded kind of embarrassed about it, so I wanted to make him feel okay about it, so I said, "I'd love it." At first, he just touched me real lightly, through the bathing suit. I had to show him how to hold my breast. I told him I liked it, mostly to encourage him, but it took a few times before he felt comfortable really holding and, well, fondling it so it felt good. I started sliding the strap down on the bathing suit so he could touch my bare breast. It felt really good, like I wanted more. I also started unbuttoning his shirt, or, if he had a T-shirt, pushing it up, and stroking and tickling his chest.
At night, when I was in bed and playing with myself, or just thinking about it, I started imagining it was Dennis stroking my crotch and my thighs, and I'd get really turned on. Actually, it was more like I was getting swept away. I'd get cold chills, and I felt like I wanted Dennis to do this to me in real life more than anything in the world. It was wonderful and scary at the same time. I talked it over with Dr. Gordon, and she said it was pretty common for teen-agers to feel real strong urges like this. People usually called it "hormones." I guess I must not have had many hormones when I was a boy, because I never felt anything this strong until now. She thought that maybe the sex-change thing made these "hormone" feelings even stronger in me than in most girls. She suggested I not worry about it, and she didn't think it would be too bad if Dennis did end up doing what I wanted, but I should be sure to listen to how he felt about things and not push him into anything.
I wasn't spending all my free time with Dennis. Sylvia needed my help, so on the afternoons when I wasn't with Dennis, I would go over to Sylvia's to go over her class and help her with her homework. She could actually do the math, but she still panicked a lot and needed me to calm her down and walk her through everything. On the days when I saw Dr. Gordon, or if I was at Dennis's, I would go over to her house before dinner, eat with her family, and spend the evening helping her. Her mom or dad would then drive me home. I felt a little guilty mooching off of them, but they told me it was the least they could do for me helping Sylvia.
On Saturdays when I wasn't with Teresa and her friends, I would hang out with Sylvia and her friends. They had an above-ground pool in the back yard, so I'd bring my bathing suit and we'd paddle around or just sit and cool off. Usually Sylvia and Doris were there and Judy Klemp, the girl in Teresa's computer class. Sometimes her friend Nick, who she insisted wasn't her boyfriend and who played guitar, was there, too, and once or twice his guitar-player friend Jeff came. On days when there weren't any boys, we would sometimes just go naked in the yard and the pool. Sylvia and I thought it was a little naughty, which we liked, but Doris thought it was stupid to get so hung up on whether somebody else could see our bodies. "We all know what everyone looks like under their clothes." But actually, I didn't really. I'd try to see what the other girls looked like to see if the sex change really made me look just like them. I couldn't see much of their crotches, what with the pubic hair, but I did notice that Doris and Sylvia had bigger breasts than mine and Judy just had sort of bumps. Judy had kind of a boy's figure, anyway. I'd thought of Doris as some sort of butch lesbian because of how she looked at the prom, but now she was growing her hair back and wearing summer dresses.
"You know, Melanie," said Sylvia one time when we were hanging out all naked and naughty. "When you first started coming to Gabriel, and everyone knew you used to be a boy, a lot of people were wondering if you still looked like a boy under your clothes."
"Ugh," said Doris. "That's so disrespectful! Didn't they ask themselves how Melanie would feel?"
"Yeah, I thought it was pretty gross, too, and I didn't even know Melanie back then. Anyway, I heard that some of the girls in your gym class said they knew for a fact that you looked just like all the other girls, and after that, the talk died out."
"Yeah, I remember on my first day, one of the girls was looking at me, and she said she hadn't expected me to look normal. But she apologized. I guess she told everyone else, or maybe some of the other girls were looking, too. I didn't think about it too much, because I was expecting it to be a lot worse. It was so bad in the boy's gym back at West Hell -- that's West High, ha, ha -- I refused to go any more."
"I wasn't sure whether to tell you. I hope it's long enough ago that it doesn't bother you. And I hope you know now that when stuff like this comes up, we'll defend you. We have your back."
I shrugged. "It wouldn't have done me any good to be bothered by it. But I guess you're right, I had enough to worry about back then without worrying about that, too." It did make me feel a little less weird about checking out the other girls' bodies, though.
Saturday evenings, if I was at Sylvia's, we'd go over to that church basement where the youth minister had what they called a coffee house, which didn't have coffee, but did have pizza and pop and fruit and juice, and Nick and his musician friends would play and we would talk. Doris was really interesting to talk to. She thought for herself a lot and had her own ideas about everything. She said she was a radical feminist and had read all the big authors like Simone de Beauvoir and Andrea Dworkin and Naomi Wolf. When I asked her if she was a lesbian like everyone said, she said that was a stupid question. When she saw how I shut right up, she said she didn't mean I was stupid, just that I needed to think about it. She said the right question was were we being with people we liked and were we making love with people we enjoyed making love to. She didn't see anything wrong with her making love to boys or to girls, as long as she was treating them with respect -- the Gabriel girl was showing, I thought. And she didn't see why I shouldn't make love to a boy or a girl, either, if I wanted to and he or she wanted to and we weren't disrespecting anybody. It made me think of my feelings about Dennis. Then sometimes she'd sing a song called "R-E-S-P-E-C-T." Nick and Jeff knew all about how she liked it, so when she started, they'd switch to playing along with her singing and try go get her to go up on the stage, which was just a platform in the corner with a mic. Doris made me think of Ellen, who liked to talk about sex a lot, but I had the feeling Doris had done more than she talked about, while Ellen talked more than she did.
I decided that I would ask Dennis if he wanted to do more than just fondle my breasts. He was holding my back against his bare chest and playing with my breast one day, and I was really getting turned on. I had changed back into my skirt and blouse, but had left my underwear off so I'd dry out a little. I pulled all my courage together and said, "Dennis, would you be willing to, you know, touch me down there?"
He pulled back and looked at me. "I don't know if I should. It doesn't feel like I'd be respecting you."
"Why is it disrespecting me if I ask you to do something and you do it? I mean, it wouldn't be disrespecting me if you didn't, either. And you've been so nice and so -- decent -- to me, I can't imagine anything you did being not respectful. But if it's too weird, let's just forget I said it, okay?" We slowly got back to cuddling, but he didn't touch my breast. I've queered it, I thought.
The next time I was over, it was raining, so we didn't swim. We sat and talked about school, about what we'd do in August. Then Dennis said, "I thought about what you said last time, and I think I'd like to try it, if you still want to."
"Sure," I said. "But let's cuddle first." I unbuttoned my blouse and let him fondle my breast for a while. He started kissing me on the cheek and then lightly on my lips. He had one arm behind my back and one on my breast and I was feeling safe and really turned on. Finally I whispered, "whenever you want." He reached down under my skirt and started stroking my crotch with one finger, through my underwear. I reached down and showed him to be firmer and to stroke the insides of my thighs. I was getting more and more turned on. I pulled my underwear down some, using just one hand. Now he was stroking my bare crotch. I guess those sex education classes were good for something, because he found my clitoris by himself. 'Clitoris.' I could see the National Enquirer headline in my mind: "I was a boy and now I have a clitoris." He kept stroking and kissing me and in a few minutes I came. It was as good as when I did it myself, but even better because I wasn't alone. I was with someone who understood me and cared about me, and who I cared about. I took his hand out and raised it to my lips and kissed it. Then I snuggled up against him and said, "that was wonderful." He was looking at me, kind of thoughtfully.
I was turned so I was half facing him, and I was stroking his chest and all the way down to his shorts. I thought, I want to make him feel good, too. I sort of ran my fingers over the zipper of his shorts and I asked him, "would it be all right if I, well, go inside your shorts?"
"Do you want to?"
"I do want to," and I meant it. Suddenly getting him turned on and maybe coming was something I really wanted to do, I don't know why. "But I don't want to do anything you don't want."
I kept running my fingers over his zipper, and he didn't say anything. I wondered if I should stop, since I didn't know if it bothered him. After a few minutes, he reached down and unzipped and unbuttoned his shorts and slid them down a little, so his penis was uncovered. It was already hard, and when I stroked it, it got even harder and sort of stood out. I had an idea of what he might like, what with having been a boy, so I stroked his abdomen and his penis. I slid the shorts down further so I could tickle his balls. All the time, I was kissing his cheek. I alternated using my hand on his penis and stroking and tickling him. I could tell from his breathing and how he was stretching and tensing his legs and moving that he was really getting turned on. Pretty soon, he started coming and shooting semen all over his stomach and up to his chest, so I got a lot gentler with my stroking. When he finished and relaxed, I kissed him all over his face and told him it was wonderful. It wasn't a lie. I felt like by letting me jack him off, he'd given me something very special, and I was afraid he'd feel weird about what we'd done.
We talked for a little while. I think he was still afraid he'd done something wrong to me, and I kept telling him how right it felt to me and how much I enjoyed being with him. I didn't tell him about how I'd imagined him doing this to me for weeks already. I tried to imagine how Doris would talk to him, except I didn't think he would go for Doris. I offered to get him a paper towel or washcloth to clean up the semen. "There's a washcloth in the bathroom," he said. I cleaned him up, and we got dressed. He was still looking a little distant, so I hugged him, and he hugged me back.
That's how it started. By the second time, he was eager to do it. We'd undress and start making out and fondling as soon as we got to his house. If the weather was hot, we'd bring each other off and then go in swimming. Then we'd hang around in the house until it was time for me to leave.
But that wasn't enough for me. At night, in bed, I wasn't imagining him putting his hands on me. I was imagining him putting his penis into me. I knew what it looked like, I knew how it felt, and when I put my fingers inside me, it felt like it was just a taste of what I really wanted. I didn't know if I should say anything to Dennis. Maybe he'd think I was some kind of slut.
One time, when I was around Doris, I asked her about whether wanting intercourse with a boy meant you were a slut. I think she was going to say something about that being stupid, but she could see I was really serious. I'm pretty sure she could tell right away that this wasn't just idle curiousity. She sat me down and looked directly at me.
"Is this something you really want to do?"
"Yes," I said quietly, looking down at my hands.
"Melanie, please look at me. Does the boy you're thinking of want to?"
"I don't know. I haven't asked him. I'm afraid he'll think I'm a slut and won't want to be around me."
"Do you care about him?"
"Yes."
"Is he a decent guy? Does he care about you?"
"Yes, he's very decent. Maybe too decent. But I'm pretty sure he does care about me."
"Then ask him. He can say yes or he can say no. I don't think he'll call you a slut, but if he does, then you'll know he wasn't really decent. No decent guy calls someone who he cares about and who cares about him a slut."
That night, I had a dream of Dennis making love to me. I could feel him inside me. I could feel him holding me tenderly. I could feel him thrusting and each thrust turned me on more and more, until I kind of exploded with ecstasy. I woke up sweaty and throbbing. I wondered if I had orgasmed in my sleep. I couldn't get the feeling from the dream out of my mind.
The next time Dennis and I were alone together and he was holding my breast, I asked him. "How do you feel about, uh, going all the way?"
"You mean, with you?"
"Yeah. It was just, you know, this idea that kind of popped into my head." Talk about back-pedaling.
"Is that something you want to do? Is that what you're telling me?"
"Yeah, kind of. If it isn't too weird."
He let go of my breast and just held me. He was quiet for a long time. I weirded him out, I thought. "I guess it's pretty weird, huh?"
"No, I don't think it's weird at all. But I don't know if I'm ready for it. See, I like you a lot. And I like holding you, and, well, the other stuff we've been doing. But sometimes I feel like we've been going way too fast. Like my body's on a plane halfway to Tahiti, and my mind's still at home."
"Is it all right if I say I'd like to try it, but I'm fine if you don't want to?" I wanted to say, will you think I'm a slut, but I thought I'd just sound stupid.
"It's okay if you tell me what you like. The problem is, I feel like I'm supposed to want to, too. Like, if I were the big strong man you seem to think I am, I'd be making strong, tender love to you right now. But I'm not. I'm just a boy who wants to be a doctor someday and hopes like hell he'll learn enough so he won't kill too many patients. I guess I'm afraid I'll do the wrong thing and kill you. Emotionally, I mean."
I twisted around and reached around him and held him in my arms. It sounds like a cheap romance novel, but I felt like I loved him. I mean, I haven't actually read any romance novels, but it's like I imagine they sound like. "You won't kill me. Even if you hurt me, and I know you won't intentionally, I'll survive. I mean, I survived West High." I actually believed it at the time. "Whatever you want to do is fine with me. I just like being with you."
Well, the next time I was over, he said, "I've thought about it, and if you still want to, we could, you know, go all the way." We cuddled, took our clothes off, played with each others bodies for a while, and then he got out a condom. "See, I came prepared." I thought, I can't get pregnant, we don't really need this, but I didn't want to say anything to discourage him.
Just as he was about to push it in, I felt this spasm of anxiety and I felt my vagina cramp. I couldn't help gasping.
"I'm hurting you," he said.
"I just got a little scared and tightened up. Maybe if you can just gently stroke me down there for a while, I'll loosen up. I still want to."
He held me and stroked me and kissed me over and over again and after a while I started to feel like I was going to float away. He put a finger in, then two. I concentrated on feeling how nice it was to hold him and have him hold me. I felt his fingers sliding back and forth, and then I realized they weren't fingers any more. It didn't hurt at all. I started to relax and feel him in me. I felt him sliding up and down on me and how our sweat made it easy to slide. I could feel his chest squeezing my breasts and his legs on my thighs and I was beyond turned on. It just felt so good. I started to come, and I kept on as he kept thrusting, just like in my dream. I couldn't help moaning. I couldn't really think, I was just feeling how good it felt. I finally realized he'd stopped, but I didn't want to move. I just wanted to lie there in the glow and feel him in me and on me.
"Did you like it?" he asked.
I started to laugh. "Is the Pope Catholic?" I managed to get out and then nodded. When I'd recovered, I asked, "did you?"
He nodded. I gently stroked his lips with my finger, then kissed him. We lay there for a long time, just stroking and caressing one another. Then he reached down to hold the condom as he pulled out. He went into the bathroom and covered the condom in toilet paper and buried it in the kitchen trash. We got on our bathing suits and went to the pool, but before we went out the door, I took him in my arms and held him tight for a while.
That night, as I was in bed, I thought of the nightmare I'd had where I was going to be sacrificed at West High. "They can't sacrifice me now, because I'm not a virgin any more!" I thought. And I did stop having dreams (nightmares, really) about West High.
While all this was going on, I was spending most of my evenings with Sylvia. One evening when I came home, Teresa told me Dennis had come by.
"He thought he'd find you here, but then we hung out and talked for a while. You don't mind, do you?"
"No, of course not. He's very nice and, well, you're like my sister. Did you like being with him?"
"Yes. It took a little while, but I think we hit it off." She looked at me like she was afraid I'd be mad.
"That's great."
So by the time Dennis and I were making love, he was also coming over to see Teresa several times a week. I thought it was too bad we couldn't all three get together sometimes.
Anyway, it was after that that Dennis and I made love. We made love the next time we were together, and then the next time. Each time, we didn't really know if it would happen. We'd cuddle and caress and fondle a bit, and then it would seem like making love was a great idea.
The end of summer school was coming. I was helping Sylvia get ready for her final exam, which was taking a lot of time, and I was getting ready for my own. Teresa and I hadn't seen all that much of each other, but I think she had a pretty good idea that Dennis and me were a lot more than just buddies. Whenever she'd mention his name, I'd sort of smile.
One night she asked: "are you and Dennis having sex?" I hadn't expected her to ask. Actually, I hadn't been thinking much about her at all. I said, yes. I wasn't going to lie.
"Is it good?" she asked.
"Yes," I smiled.
"I'm glad," she said. Then she got more serious. "Would you be upset if Dennis and I, well, made out?"
I thought for a minute or two. "No, not really. I mean, I don't own him, and besides, it's you, not some stranger. Just be gentle with him. I think he's a little afraid of girls. And I'm glad you told me. It's not something I'd want to be surprised with."
About a week later, when we were going to bed, she said, "I have to tell you something. Dennis and I made out a few times, and, well, we went a little further."
"You all made love?" I was startled. I didn't think Dennis would go all the way that quickly.
"Not exactly, but we went most of the way. I hadn't planned on it, but, well, we were both enjoying making out, and one thing led to another." I couldn't help giggling at the idea of Teresa just letting "one thing lead to another." She always seemed so in control. "You aren't mad at me, are you?" she asked.
"No, not mad, just surprised. He sounded like he wasn't sure he wanted to, uh, get physical with anyone. But I'm glad for you. I was afraid you'd be feeling left out. And it kind of gives us something in common now, doesn't it?"
That night, I dreamed Dennis had a heart attack while we were making love, and I was trying to save him, but I didn't know CPR.
The next time Dennis and I were walking from school, he stopped me at a bench.
"Melanie. I should have told you before this, but: your cousin and I made love a few days ago."
"You did? She told me you all didn't go all the way."
"Well, that's true. But we might as well have, as far as I'm concerned."
"Was it good? I mean, did you enjoy it?"
"I did, at the time. I mean, it was fun. But then I got to thinking, and I just don't think I can handle this any more. One girlfriend was hard enough, but two -- I can't wrap my mind around it."
"So you want to stop making love to me?"
"I need to back off for a while. From both of you. I don't think you should be coming over any more, and I shouldn't be going over to your place, either." It sounded like he'd rehearsed this in his mind.
"Will we still be friends, at least? Will I be able to talk to you? I mean, I'd be okay with you not making love to me and stuff like that if I could still talk to you. And listen to you talk. I need a friend a lot more than I need a boyfriend."
He looked really miserable. He finally said, "I don't think we can be friends right now, either." He looked like he wanted to say more, but then he just sort of stopped and sat there.
"But you'll still be seeing Teresa, won't you?"
"No, not her, either. I'm sorry." We sat there for a while, not saying anything. Then he added, "I know you need someone to walk you over to your psychiatrist's, I'll see if one of my friends will go with you." Even while breaking up with me, he still thinks about my needs. For some reason, that made me want to cry more than anything else. And I did. I didn't make any noise, but I noticed tears running off my nose and dripping onto my skirt.
I don't remember the rest of the day. I don't know how I got home. That evening, I came into the bedroom while Teresa was getting ready for bed. "Dennis talked to me today. He says he can't deal with two girlfriends. He doesn't want to see either of us now. He doesn't even want to be friends. I asked if he would keep seeing you, but he won't. I'm sorry."
"You aren't mad at me? It's kind of my fault that he broke up with you."
"How could I be mad at you? I owe you my life."
"You what? What kind of crap is that?"
"Well, you did save my life."
She looked aghast. "So all this time, when I thought you enjoyed being with me, like, sharing a room and all, you were just, I don't know, pretending to be happy with everything because you felt you owed me? Oh my God!" She looked like she was going to be sick.
"No, no, that's not true! That's not true at all, I swear! I mean, it hasn't been perfect, but it has been really great to live with you and to share a room with you and to hang out with you. That's the honest truth. I've never lied to you and I'm not lying now."
She looked skeptical.
"It's more like I trust you," I continued. "You've never done anything to hurt me. I mean, of course you like to make out with him and maybe you'd have even liked go all the way. But you didn't do it to hurt me. You didn't do it to make him stop being friends. That was his idea. And I think it's stupid. I think he's missing out, not wanting to be friends with you."
"I'm not sure I didn't do it to hurt you. I was a little jealous, seeing how well you got along with him. I'm not as perfect as you say. Sometimes I'm mean. I don't want to be perfect. I want to be able to be mad at you or mean and I want you to be able to be mad and unreasonable and we can fight and then make up and love each other again. Like normal people."
"Well, anyway, I'm not mad at you. I'm just sad that it didn't work out."
We sat in the bedroom together, not saying anything. I kept thinking of Dennis and the idea of him fucking Teresa and me both. "You know," I said, "it's too bad it didn't work out with him fucking both of us." I reveled in using the forbidden word. "I'm imagining us kind of training him, like Pavlov and his dog, so whenever we wanted somebody to fuck us, we'd just call and he'd rush over. And if we both wanted, he'd do both of us, however we wanted." I started to laugh. "We'd tell him what we wanted him to do, and he'd say, 'Yes, mistress, your wish is my command.'" I said the last bit in the deepest voice I could manage.
Teresa started getting into it. "Why would he have to come over? We could just tie him to the bed in here. We'd have to tie him up and keep him in the closet when we weren't here, in case Mom came in." We were both rolling on the floor laughing. It wasn't really funny, but we both wanted to laugh. I think Teresa was kind of upset at Dennis breaking up with me, too.
The next day was Friday. Dennis's friend Zeke walked me to Dr. Gordon's. He was the boy that danced with me at the Prom, and he still kept trying to act more mature than he was. I gave him a little kiss when he dropped me off, and he turned bright red. My little revenge, I guess. It felt really funny not to have Dennis walking with me.
I hadn't talked to Dr. Gordon before about our love-making, and she scolded me a little when I told her about it. "You have to be open with me if I'm to help you." But she didn't stay mad long. I talked about how I'd felt with Dennis, and about Teresa and him and the breakup. By the end of the session, I was seeing that I hadn't treated Dennis like a person, either. I'd been only thinking about what I wanted out of him, not how he might feel about it. I tried to imagine how I would have felt if I'd had a girlfriend like me when I was a boy, but all I could think of was that I'd have been thrilled to death to be getting laid. I guess Dennis was different, or maybe I would have felt differently if it actually happened. But I couldn't ignore how he was kind of reluctant the whole time. And how broken up he seemed to be about breaking up with me. I guess I didn't understand him at all. Maybe I wasn't grown up enough for sex after all. Dennis kept worrying that when he was a doctor, he wouldn't know enough not to kill someone. Well, I didn't know enough not to kind of kill him. I felt like something you'd scrape off your shoe. She tried to tell me that everyone makes mistakes and even hurts people sometimes, but I still felt bad.
I kept expecting to feel really awful about losing Dennis, but it hadn't happened yet. I just felt kind of like a zombie. I went to Sylvia's on Saturday and Doris was there, so I talked to her about it. She gave me her number and told me I should have called her earlier, but I should still call if I needed someone to talk to. "We experienced girls have to stick together." Anyway, she kind of clucked sympathetically, but said, all things come to an end, and this was, after all, my first.
My aunt noticed how down I was, and asked me about it. "Dennis doesn't want to be friends with me any more." No way I was going to mention sex.
She put her arm around me and stroked my shoulder. "Yes, I know it's tough. You feel really close to someone, and then they turn their back on you." I was getting the funny feeling my aunt knew more than she was letting on. "I know it doesn't make you feel any better, but the only cure for a broken heart is time. And not being surrounded with reminders. Soon we'll be at the cabin in the woods, maybe you can get some heart-ease there." Being a social worker, she must have comforted people who'd had much worse things happen to them.
The next week was finals. I spend Monday afternoon at Sylvia's. Tuesday, when I would have gone to Dennis's, I told Zeke I didn't need him. I took the bus downtown and sat on a bench in City Square. I bought a coke and sipped it while I watched the pigeons and felt miserable. I expected someone to creep on me, but no one did. I took the bus to Dr. Gordon's and cried a lot.
I spent a lot of time with Sylvia, prepping her for the exam. It kept my mind off of Dennis, which was good. On Friday, we had finals. After class, Sylvia said she thought she passed. I walked over to her place and we went skinny-dipping and I tried to feel naughty, but I didn't feel too much. I ended up telling Sylvia that Dennis had dumped me, but I had deserved it, because I was too clingy. I think she must have been reading romance novels, because she started talking about how "faithless, fickle" boys were. After a while, she got me to start saying it. We took sticks and made little pretend ex-boyfriends and started throwing pebbles at those "faithless, fickle boys." But then I got on the bus to Dr. Gordon's and felt the yawning hole in my heart.
My aunt and uncle rented a cabin for two weeks each year up in the woods, on a small lake, and they took me with them this year. We packed up and left the day after the finals.
The cabin was a little one-story house with a kitchen, living and dining room, and two bedrooms. Teresa and I shared the room with two twin beds. The cabin came with a canoe and a dock. There was a kind of village on the opposite side of the lake, with a general store and a pizza place and such. So if any of us wanted to get some pizza or shop or just hang out, we'd paddle over in the canoe. There were other cabins like ours, but there were trees between us so we didn't see them.
Teresa kept me busy during the day. She insisted that her mom shouldn't have to cook because it was vacation, so Teresa and I would trade off cooking and washing up. The cabin came with some bamboo fishing poles, so we'd go dig up worms and fish off the dock. Some days we caught nothing, but other days we'd catch enough for dinner for everyone. Or we'd swim in the lake, or canoe over to town and hang out and buy ice cream cones at the general store.
But in the evening, I'd feel a big hole inside me. I'd lie in bed and keep remembering how it felt to have Dennis inside me or fondling my breasts and it would hit me that I'd probably never do any of that with him again, and my body would ache with wanting him. Other times, I would remember listening to him and him listening to my ravings about feeling like a freak and talking me out of it. I'd realize I'd probably never get to talk to him or listen to him like that again, and it would feel like a punch in the stomach. I'd start crying and feeling like I lost the only friend I ever had. I thought I'd never stop crying and hurting. Sometimes Teresa would come over and lie next to me and put her arm around me. It didn't make it hurt less, but it made me feel less lonely.
There were other kids of all ages who'd come into the village. We met two boys, Ned and Robert, who lived in some of the cabins on the other lake, the one on the other side of the village. They lived in the city where the state university is, which is maybe 200 miles from us. Anyway, we were sitting on a cinderblock wall outside the general store eating ice cream cones and talking and, after a while, the boys and Teresa started kind of flirting, just as something to do. I just slumped down and concentrated on my ice cream. Robert was nearest me, and he said to me, "hey, what's with the frown? It's a nice day, you've got ice cream and two boys who'd love to give you some male attention."
"No thanks," I said. "I don't need any 'male attention.'" I went back to making sure that every drop of ice cream went into my mouth and not onto the ground.
"What's with her?" he asked Teresa.
"Her boyfriend broke up with her just before we came up here."
"He was not my 'boyfriend'," I complained. "He was just a friend."
"You could have fooled us. You guys walked together, talked together, you were over at his place practically every day, if he wasn't over at ours. And --" I glared at her, daring her to say what she knew. "Well, you sure acted like boyfriend and girlfriend. Whatever he was, he stopped being it two weeks ago."
"Just give me some space, will ya?" I grumbled.
The breakup was a good excuse not to flirt back, but another reason was that I was a little weirded out by the idea of me flirting with a boy. I wasn't any good flirting with girls back when I was a boy, and besides, I still felt funny about acting like I was attracted to boys or with boys being attracted to me. I guess I was still thinking like a boy. The thing with Dennis had been different. There wasn't any of that romantic stuff. We were just friends who trusted each other and, well, liked giving each other pleasure.
Ned was speaking to me. "What?" I said.
"I was saying, we have a boat over on our lake and would you like to go out for a cruise? Your cousin wants to come, but she won't come without you. You can come with or without frown." I couldn't help smiling at that "with or without frown" business.
"Okay," I said. I'd finished my ice cream, anyway.
Their boat was basically like a large rowboat with an outboard motor. We all got lifejackets on and Ned started us up while Robert cast off. This lake was a lot bigger than ours, and there were lots of boats on it: little one-person sailboats, canoes, kayaks, other motorboats, even a windsurfer. He drove us around and pointed out the cabins and boathouses. They'd been coming for years and knew a lot of people.
There was a strong breeze on my face, so I shut my eyes and just felt the sun on my back and the wind blowing my hair around. Robert was sitting next to me and put his arm around my shoulder. I wasn't sure at first if I liked it or not, but then I decided I did. It was sort of comforting. My sun dress was sweaty and my legs were bare, so what with the wind, I was getting chilly, so I sort of snuggled up against him. It didn't feel gay, just friendly.
After that, we hung out together pretty much every day. Sometimes they'd come over and swim in our lake, or we'd swim at the beach on their lake. I didn't talk about all the stuff that had gone on since last September, so I didn't say much about myself. They boys seemed to accept that I didn't flirt or act all girly around them. One time we were all sitting on the dock and Teresa was sitting in on Ned's lap kind of snuggling and kissing, and Robert asked if I'd like to sit on his lap. "You don't have to kiss or anything if you don't want to." So I sat across his lap and he held me and stroked my back. Sometimes he'd kiss my cheek or my forehead. I didn't mind. It felt good and kind of restful.
"You don't mind me kissing you, do you?" he asked.
"No, it's okay. What you're doing is nice. I like it. Especially since I don't have to do anything. I've had a tough year, and it's nice to sit next to someone and feel good and not have to do anything. Or think about anything."
"What happened?"
"It's more like, what didn't? Anyway, I don't want to think about it. The best part of vacation is not being reminded of it." I was getting upset just remembering that there was a past year. "Can you just hold me and talk about your life and stroke all the bad stuff away?"
So he held me against his chest and stroked my head and back and arm and told me about his friends and being in the school band and the drama club and going to see rock bands when they performed at the university. I dozed off, lying in his arms and listening to the sound of his voice.
A little while later, Teresa shook me awake. "Time to go home and make dinner." I realized I was lying down on the dock and Robert was lying next to me and his jacket was laid on top of me.
"You looked so peaceful, I didn't want to wake you," he said. We said goodbye, and Teresa and I paddled home.
The next day was the last day before we had to go home. We swam across the lake and met the boys at the village dock, and we all swam back to our cabin and had lunch. It turned out Uncle Boris knew Ned's parents from the university, but he hadn't met Ned. In the afternoon, we lay on the grass near the lake and enjoyed the sun. Robert and I lay next to each other and after a while we held each other and started stroking each other's sides and kissing in a lazy way, like it was just something happening to us. It felt good and was relaxing, having his body pressed up against mine and him stroking my back and my head and playing with my hair. I thought, I wish I could just stay like this forever.
Chapters 35--52
Melanie makes peace with being a girl (who was a boy, but isn't any more.)
When we got back, we still had a week before school started. I thought I'd gotten over Dennis while we were on vacation, but now that I was back, I missed him as much as before, though I wasn't crying myself to sleep any more. I remembered that Doris had said I should call her, so I did, and she told me to come on over.
When I got to her place, she was in the back yard wearing a bikini and lying on a towel sunning herself while reading a book. I was wearing the miniskirt and a halter top and feeling very exposed even though I was a lot more covered than she was. When she saw me, she sat up and got me to sit next to her.
"So what's up?" she asked.
"I'm still hung up on Dennis. I know it's stupid, but I feel like I'll never be happy again. And I'll be seeing him around every day when school starts. I'd talk it over with Dr. Gordon, but she's still on vacation."
"Did you talk to her before you left?"
"Yeah, but it didn't help much. I kind of felt like it was my fault he broke up with me."
"Why?"
"I'd been pushing him harder than he was comfortable with. I thought he was okay with what we were doing, but then he wasn't."
"What did you do exactly? Pester him until he finally did what you wanted?"
"I don't think so, at least, I didn't keep asking him. We started out just hugging and kissing, mostly hugging. Then he wanted to touch my breast and that was fine, but then I asked him to, you know, down there."
"Finger-fucking?"
"I guess. Anyway, he wasn't sure, but then the next time he said he wanted to. Then after a while I wanted him to, you know, fuck me. Make love, I called it. He thought about it, and then the next time, he said yes. We did it a couple of times, and then he said he didn't want to see me any more."
"So you asked him to do things, and each time, he thought about it and then said yes. I don't see how that's 'pushing' him. I mean, if he really wasn't comfortable with it, why did he say yes? How are you supposed to know that he doesn't want to if he says yes the first time you ask? You're not a mind reader!" She sounded indignant.
She went on. "I don't think you did anything wrong, and I don't think it's right that Dr. Gordon got you to think you did. It's the same old story: whatever happens, it's the woman's fault. It's your fault for asking. It's your fault for not understanding him better than he understands himself. That is just so sexist!"
I noticed the book she'd been reading: "Yes Means Yes." I guess that's what Doris was telling me: Dennis's "yes" meant "yes."
She continued, "I mean, you can't do anything about him breaking up with you. If he doesn't want to be with you any more, he should. But it doesn't make it your fault. Sometimes it's nobody's fault."
I sat on the ground with my arms around my knees. "I still miss him, though. I miss the sex, but I also miss him as a friend."
"He was really good?"
"Yeah. He listened to me raving about not knowing if I'm a boy or a girl and got me to feel better about it. I felt like I could talk to him about anything. He wants to be a doctor and I admired him so much because I think he will really try to help people. And when we were hugging and, well, you know, he was so gentle and considerate. I knew he'd never hurt me." I started to cry. It seemed like ever since I got turned into a girl, I was crying a lot more.
Doris had her arm around my shoulders and was stroking my cheek. After I stopped crying, she said, "I know it's tough, losing a friend. But if you want someone to listen to you 'raving' about, well, anything, I'd be willing to."
"You wouldn't think I was a freak?"
"Hell, no. You're you. Like I said at the prom, whether you're a boy or a girl or whatever, you're nice and you're fun to be with. Besides, I've never been a boy, and I'd love to hear from someone who knows what it's like to be a boy and a girl."
"I'm not sure I know what it's like to be a girl, I just know what it's like to be me."
"That's interesting enough." She found another towel and put it next to hers and got me to lie down next to her. My skirt rode up, so I pulled it down again. She started stroking my cheek again and said in a low, gentle voice, "so tell me, what did people call you when you were a boy?"
"Martin. My parents still do, when I call them or visit them. But I don't visit them much, they still have a hard time with me being a girl."
"Do you mind when people call you Martin? Would you like it if I sometimes called you Martin?"
"I don't know. When someone calls me Martin, it reminds me of my past, and sometimes it hurts, because I feel like it's a piece of me that I've lost forever. And sometimes it's nice, because I don't want to forget where I came from. It's like I'm one of those immigrants long ago who came here knowing they'd never see their homeland or their family or friends again."
She got me to talking about my life before the motorcycle accident. I hadn't really thought about it since my metamorphosis. I talked about hanging out with friends, about being with my brothers, even stuff like my underwear and shaving. It's funny, but when I told it to her, my life as a boy sounded kind of boring. She even got me to talk about jerking off. She said she'd seen boys do it and she'd done it to boys, but she didn't know what it felt like. I said it wasn't as intense as when I did it as a girl, but I didn't know whether that was because girls were different or because the sex-change treatment kind of overdid it. I had to admit, though, if they did overdo it, I wasn't going to complain.
Talking to Doris got me thinking: the doctors had said that if I really didn't like being a girl, in a few years I get an old-fashioned sex-change operation, but I wouldn't really be like a boy: I wouldn't be able to have normal sex or father a child. Sex as a girl wasn't bad, maybe better than as a boy. I already couldn't have a child, I wasn't sure I wanted to give up sex, too. Maybe I would rather spend the rest of my life as a girl. Lots of people lived their whole lives as girls and they seemed happy enough, maybe I'd be happy with it, too.
She talked about her life, too. She didn't have any brothers or sisters. She always seemed to know what she wanted to do and insisted on doing it, even if other people didn't understand. Her parents didn't really understand her, but they realized they couldn't change her and they seemed kind of proud of her. She was interested in all kinds of social justice things, not just feminism. She thought she might want to be an activist someday. She'd had run-ins with the school, though they seemed to respect her, too, because they never threatened to kick her out.
One time I told her, "you always seem so sure of yourself and full of energy. I'm always unsure of myself and never seem to know anything. I wonder why you want to be around me."
"Don't put yourself down. You've had an interesting life. Yeah, I know, it's been tough, but it's interesting to hear about. And you're real. Not fakey. And I like that you aren't full of energy. It's restful being around you. Besides, I really appreciate what you've done for Sylvia."
I went over to her place a couple of times that week. Teresa teased me about it. "You know she's a lesbian, right? Better watch out, she might seduce you!" she laughed.
"Would that be so bad?" I said.
"No, not really. It might be fun. You'll have to tell me what it was like if you all do do it; I've never done it with a girl."
I didn't mention to her that each time I left Doris's place, she would give me a kiss on the mouth. Nothing passionate, just a gentle kiss.
One time it was raining when I went over and we hung out in her room. She was getting me to tell about what it was like the last few months at West High.
"What finally got you to leave?"
"I didn't know I could leave. But I got suspended over -- over an -- incident. A really horrible one. And then I, uh, tried to kill myself. And then my aunt and uncle let me live with them and they got me into Gabriel."
"If you don't mind telling, why did you--"
"Try to kill myself? Things had gotten so bad, especially with that, uh, incident, that I thought dying would be better than going back. And I was sure they'd make me go back."
"What kind of incident?"
I couldn't speak for a few minutes. "A couple of guys -- the football stars and their friends -- they dragged me into a classroom." I started to shake just from thinking about it, but I couldn't stop talking. "They pulled my clothes off -- I mean, partway. And then Tom, Tom Prescott, he put his hand on--" I started to cry and my voice got shaky. "On my b-breast, and he said --- he said, 'it's got tits like a girl.'"
"'It'"?
"Yeah, all month they called me 'it'. Not 'you' or even 'he' or 'she'."
"That's awful!" she said and just held me and waited.
"Then he said, 'let's see if it's got a -- a cunt -- like a girl' and pulled down my underpants and put his hands all over. Then he pulled his pants down and --" I was wailing by this time. "And that's when the teacher came in and they said I'd pulled my clothes off myself and the principal believed them and not me." I was bawling like a little kid.
Then Doris's father knocked on the door and came in. "What's the matter? Why is she crying?" He looked really upset and concerned.
"Melanie was telling me about a really horrible incident at her old school."
"Is that true, Melanie?" he asked me.
I nodded. "I'm sorry to bother you," I added. "I didn't mean to make so much noise, but it was really awful. I hope I'm not getting Doris in trouble."
"Maybe I shouldn't have asked," Doris said.
"No, it's good. I can't talk about it to most people, it's too horrible. I've only ever told the whole story to my shrink. But I feel safe with you." I put my head on her shoulder. I was still sobbing a little. "I'm okay," I told her father, "but I appreciate that you -- you were concerned."
He looked a little dubious, but he left us. I put my face on Doris's shoulder and quietly sobbed and cried for a while, while she held me and patted my back. Then she got me to lie down on her bed and she stroked my back and my head and pretty much everything. After I was pretty relaxed, she got on top of me and massaged me all the way from my shoulders down to my feet.
"I don't think I can move," I said when she was done. "My muscles don't want to do anything."
"You don't have to. At dinner time I'll bring up some food and spoon feed you." I couldn't help laughing, which kind of hurt, because my stomach was sore from crying.
I did stay, though, and her parents gave me dinner, but at the dinner table. I explained that I'd been at West High and things were really awful for me for months, and that's why I'd transferred to Gabriel. I didn't tell them the details or that I'd tried to kill myself.
School was starting next week, so Aunt Edith took me on yet another shopping trip. She said I'd filled out and needed new bras, plus my tights were wearing out, plus she thought I needed some dressier skirts and blouses. So we went to the bra store and Teresa got me to get some racier bras as well as plain ones. Well, they seemed racy to me: mostly they were just lacy and one was sort of see-through, and one was black. Then we went to the mall and they got me more tights and underwear and a frilly white blouse and a long black wool skirt and another plain skirt and dress, since I still couldn't wear pants. I spent the rest of the weekend hanging out with Teresa and her friends.
When school started, I felt like an old lag. I knew where everything was, at least once I got my schedule, and I knew what to do everywhere. The first day, I ate lunch with Sylvia and her friends, so I could congratulate her on passing algebra. I saw Dennis there, too. Actually, he was in my English class again. He saw me, but he acted like he didn't know me. I didn't want to make a scene the first day back, but it bugged me. I mean, even Zeke said hi.
Finally, on Friday, I said something. I went over to Dennis's table. Everyone turned to look at me, and Dennis was looking nervous. Good, I thought. I looked straight at Dennis, like no one else was there, and I said, "Dennis, you don't have to be friends with me if you don't want. But at least admit I exist. At least look at me and say hi when I walk by. That's just respect." Then I walked back to Teresa's table and ate my lunch. Later, Dennis walked over and said he was sorry and we shook hands.
Homework, of course, started up the first day, so Teresa and I were pretty busy every evening, but Doris asked me to come down to the coffee house Saturday night with her and her friends and then spend the night at her place. "Sort of a pyjama party," she said, except that it would be just us two. We could go to her church the next day if I didn't want to rush home to go to ours.
So I packed a bag and a sleeping bag and took the bus down to the coffee house. I decided to dress nice, so I put on the navy skirt and a white blouse and some white knee socks. When I got there, I saw that the other girls had decided to dress up, too. Sort of. Everyone was from a different century. Judy was dressed like someone from the 1940's, Sylvia was wearing a dress from a Jane Austen movie, and Doris looked like someone from a Renaissance festival, with a long skirt and peasant blouse and lace-up bodice that showed off her breasts, only we were supposed to call it her "bosom." Her hair was by now over her shoulders and she tied it back with a thong. I was still thinking of her as a butch lesbian, but she sure didn't look like it now. More like a "wench." I told her that and she thought it was hysterical. The boys wore their usual bo-o-oring torn jeans and heavy metal T-shirts.
Sylvia, Doris, Judy, and I ended up squeezing together onto one of the ratty couches and got Jeff to bring us drinks. Nick and Jeff and us played musical couch for the rest of the evening, except that whoever didn't find a spot just kind of sprawled on top of the others. Nick insisted that we each sing a song, so Doris sang R-E-S-P-E-C-T, and Sylvia sang Material Girl, and I don't remember what Judy sang. I was last and didn't really want to get up in front of everybody, but they all insisted, so I sang Yesterday, except that I said "he" instead of "she" everywhere.
Around closing time, Sylvia's dad picked us up and dropped me and Doris off at her place. We got ready for bed. I was wearing the nightgown Teresa gave me, and Doris was wearing a long T-shirt. I started to unroll my sleeping bag, but Doris said it would be more comfortable on her bed, and there was room because it was a double bed. So I joined her. I'd hadn't shared a bed in I don't know how long and I didn't know how I was supposed to act.
"Do you mind if we snuggle?" she said. I was okay with it, so we hugged and held each other and she covered my face with little kisses. I wasn't surprised. I'd been kind of expecting something like this, since I knew she liked me and I knew she was a lesbian. But she was so nice to me and I felt so safe with her and I knew she wouldn't make me do anything I didn't want to. After a while, we were getting sleepy, so I turned over and she cuddled up to my back and put her hand on my breast. I put my hand on hers and then lifted it to my mouth and kissed it. Then I put it back on my breast and fell asleep.
Some time in the night, I got up to pee, and when I came back, Doris was awake. I lay down next to her and we started hugging and kissing and then stroking each other all over. She put her hand on my breast and started kind of playing with it. I put my hand on hers, too, but after a while, what she was doing started to turn me on and I couldn't think of anything but what she was doing to me. I was on my back and she was on her side and every now and then I would lift my head and kiss her because she seemed so wonderful. "I think I'm in love with you," I said. I don't know why, it seemed like it was just what I wanted to say.
She smiled and leaned over and kissed me. Then she moved her hand down under my nightgown and asked, "do you mind if I...?"
I whispered, "you don't have to ask. I'm sure I'll love whatever you do." It sounds a little stupid to say it now, but I was pretty far gone. She got a funny grin and gave me a long kiss on the mouth and then kind of sucked and kissed one of my nipples, which turned me on even more. She lifted my nightgown until she could reach my crotch and put her knee over one of my legs. She had one arm under my head and was kissing me on the face, over and over, while she gently stroked my crotch. I was really turned on, so I don't remember too many details, just her stroking me harder and harder, but never too much, and feeling her body pressed against mine and her kisses on my face, and then I was coming and trying not to be too loud and wake her parents. When it was over and I could notice anything, I noticed that Doris was on top of me, hugging me and kissing me and holding her legs on either side of mine. I stroked her back and noticed that her nightshirt had come up to her waist, so her butt was bare. I couldn't help giggling and rubbing her butt, it was just so cute, feeling her bare butt sticking out. I got this feeling that she was the most wonderful person in the whole world, so I gave her a big, tight hug and said, "I love you so much," and I nuzzled her cheek.
Then I asked her, "do you mind if I, you know, try to make you feel good? You did such a good job of making me feel good."
"I think the word you're looking for is 'masturbate,'" she replied.
"I dunno. That word sounds too scientific for what we've been doing. Like something that belongs in a chem lab or something. You know, 'mix the reagents in a beaker and masturbate for two and a half minutes.'"
Doris lost it completely.
She had to cover her mouth so she wouldn't wake up the whole house with her laughing. When she'd recovered enough to say anything, she said, "I almost peed myself! 'Masturbate for two and a--'." She fell over laughing again. Every time it looked like she'd gotten a grip, she'd say it again and crack up again. She finally gasped out, "where do you come up with these things?"
"I'm sorry, it was just what came into my head."
"Don't be sorry, there was nothing wrong with it, exactly. But it did sort of blow the mood."
"I'm sorry I blew the mood. You did such nice things to me, and now I won't be able to do it for you."
"That's okay, I wasn't ready for that, anyway. It takes me a while in a relationship before I can relax enough to let someone else make love to me." She looked at me carefully. "You don't mind me calling it 'making love'?"
"No, no, it's a beautiful word. Can I at least cuddle you and kiss you?"
She slid closer to me, and I put my arms around her and tried kissing her gently, the way she'd done to me. After a while, her eyes closed and her breathing slowed, so I figured she was asleep. I soon fell asleep, too.
In the morning, after breakfast, we went to Doris's church. It was a lot more laid back than Teresa's, and I think they were more liberal, too, because I saw what I thought were some gay and some lesbian couples. They had chairs instead of pews, and nobody dressed up. I was the most dressed up person there with my navy skirt and white blouse. The minister had nice pants and a short-sleeved shirt, and they had a guitar instead of an organ or piano. At the end, we all held hands in a circle and gave the people around us a hug and sometimes a kiss on the cheek.
It was time for youth group to start up. I was looking forward to hanging out with Amy. But when she arrived, it turned out she'd brought a friend.
"Melanie, this is my friend Eric. Eric, this is Melanie."
"Hi, Eric."
He grinned at me and said, "hi, Mel."
I forced myself to be polite. "Uh, my name is Melanie."
"But I like Mel better."
This got my back up. "Well, I don't. Please call me Melanie."
I got ready to walk off, when Amy said, "hey, chill out. What's the big deal with what he calls you?"
"That he can't be bothered to call me by my name. If it's really no big deal, why doesn't he just call me Melanie." Eric was still grinning as I walked off.
I hoped if I ignored him, he'd find somebody else to pester. I went off to the people putting together the pizza order to lobby for my favorite toppings. A few minutes later, I hear, "hey, Mel!" behind me. I ignore it and kept talking about toppings. A few minutes later, I see his head stuck right in front of my face.
"Hey, why didn't you answer?"
"I heard you calling for someone named 'Mel', so I figured you were talking to someone else."
"Come on, I'm just trying to be friendly."
"Well, you're not succeeding. Go be 'friendly' with someone else. Like they say, don't go away mad, just go away." He was getting on my nerves.
I wandered over to one of the couches to hang out with some Greenwooders and wait for the opening circle. I sat down and a second later, Eric plunked himself down next to me and put his arm around my shoulders. I hissed, "get your hands off of me!" and then grabbed his arm and pulled it out from behind me. I couldn't stand being that close to him, so I got up and walked away, and tried to figure out where I was going to go.
About then, it was time for opening circle. I made a point of sitting as far away from Eric as possible, which meant being way away from Amy and even from Teresa.
We did our usual check-in. Amy introduced Eric. When it was my turn, I couldn't think of anything to say, so I just gave my name and passed. Reverend Jen introduced the topic: what our real values are. We talked about it for a few minutes and then broke up into small groups. As I was heading to my group (which Eric was not in, I was glad to see), Eric came up and tried to talk to me.
"Mel, why can't you be friendlier?"
"Why can't you stop being a jerk? Just leave me alone, okay?" We went off to our groups. I was having trouble even remembering what we were talking about. Damn him! I thought.
The discussions in our group were interesting enough that I forgot about Eric, so when we went to go back into the big circle, it came as a shock when he came up behind me and grabbed my arm.
"Let go of me!" I screamed and tried to pull away. He held on. With my free hand I punched him in the stomach as hard as I could, which wasn't very since only my left arm was free and I wasn't at a good angle. But it was enough to make him let go. I was thinking, OMG, what did I just do? What is going on with me? We stood for a few seconds staring at each other. He looked surprised, and I was freaking out. He reached his hand out again, and I took off, screaming, "get away from me!" I ran down the hall to the bathrooms. This floor of the church had one-person bathrooms, so I ran inside one, locked the door and put my back against it, since I was sure he'd try to break in. I heard some loud voices. I slid down the door and ended up sitting on the floor with my back against the door. There was no window and nothing to look at but the side of the toilet and the toilet paper roll in the background. Somebody knocked on the door and said, "Melanie!" It didn't sound like Eric, but I still didn't answer, and they went away.
By now, I wasn't freaking out so much about Eric as about how I was freaking out. I don't think I'd ever really punched anyone until this summer, and now I'd done it twice. God, I'm a nut case. I'm a violent criminal. I can't be allowed to run around loose. I wasn't exactly crying, but I felt something wet dripping down my cheek.
About then, the light went out. It seems there was a motion detector switch, and you had to move around or it would think no one was there. I waved my hand and the light went back on.
Another knock at the door. "Melanie? It's Teresa. The pizza is here. Do you want any?"
"No, I'm not hungry. Hey, can you get me when it's time to go? Like, when our ride is here?"
"Okay," she said and went away.
After a while, I just stopped thinking. I felt like a robot someone had put in the closet and turned off. Every now and then, the light would go out, and I'd wave my hand to turn it back on. I was just blank.
Teresa knocked on the door. "My Dad is here." I dragged myself to my feet and opened the door. As we were walking out the door, Reverend Jen came up to me. "Can we find a time to talk this week? I'd really like to talk with you about what happened."
I shrugged a 'whatever.' "I'm pretty busy with schoolwork all week."
"Then ask your parents to call me."
I was like a zombie the whole way home, but when we got inside, I went over to my uncle and he put his arms around me and I started bawling. He got me over to the couch and my aunt came in. I put my face on his chest and cried and shook for the longest time. When I'd cried myself out, I leaned back in the sofa. My aunt brought a big handkerchief for me to dry my face with. Teresa said, "do you want to eat something?" She explained, "she didn't have anything to eat." I nodded, and my aunt went into the kitchen.
"Do you want to tell me what happened?" my uncle asked.
I nodded, but it took a few minutes for me to be able to talk, and I still kept having to stop. "This new kid. Eric. He started by calling me 'Mel' and refused to call me Melanie. Then he kept bugging me even when I asked him to stop. He kept trying to put his arm around me and asking me why I wasn't 'friendly.' I couldn't get him to leave me alone! Then he grabbed me and wouldn't let go and I freaked out and punched him and then ran off and hid in the bathroom until you came.
"It was so weird. I never hit people. Wait, there was that time this summer, at the ice cream shop. A guy tried to kiss me without asking. A big guy. I punched him hard, and then had a flashback. To the rape. Well, the attempted rape. I didn't have a flashback this time, though. I just feel like I can't go back to youth group."
My aunt was standing in the doorway listening.
Teresa said, "the youth pastor asked Melanie to call her, or at least for you all to call her." Then she said to me, "after you hid in the bathroom, we had a long discussion. You weren't there to tell your side, but we pieced it together from what people saw, and I think we had a good idea, anyway. It took a while, but I think Eric finally got it, and when he did, he looked pretty shook up. I didn't tell them your whole story, but I did tell them you'd had some pretty awful experiences at your old school. We're on your side, Melanie."
I started crying again. My aunt brought in a tray with some tea and some leftover fried chicken. I was still sobbing a little when I started eating. When I was done, I settled back on the couch. I noticed I was feeling better. Maybe I was just hungry.
"I don't know why I freaked out like that. I feel so stupid. It's not like he did anything really awful. He was just annoying."
My aunt spoke. "Melanie, he wasn't just being annoying. He was violating your boundaries. Every time you tried to set a limit, he ignored it, starting with your name. That's predator behavior. Not that I'm saying he is a predator, but it was threatening, and you had every reason to feel threatened."
"So I'm not crazy?"
"No, you've been through a traumatic experience. Your experiences at West High School taught you where that kind of behavior can lead, so you're more sensitive to it. Your reaction is not at all irrational."
I tried to laugh. "I'm lucky to be living with a social worker."
I felt like I'd been run through a wringer. I could hardly stand up. Teresa and my aunt helped me upstairs and got me dressed for bed. I suppose I could have managed by myself, but it was nice to have people take care of me.
The next day, school filled my mind and I didn't think about what I'd been through. But later in the week, my uncle told me that they'd talked to Reverend Jen and she wanted to come by that night after I'd finished studying. That night, I rushed through my studies. Reverend Jen came in and Teresa and I went down to the living room.
"I wanted to talk about what happened Sunday night. I'm really sorry I wasn't paying enough attention to notice what you were going through. It was my job to keep an eye on things, and I fell down there. I'm sorry."
It made me feel funny to hear a grown-up admit to a kid that she'd messed up. "It's okay. You did your best."
"Anyway, we had a long discussion about how we treat one another and especially about what Eric did. Eric had -- maybe still has -- some messed-up ideas about how to relate to girls. He thought he was supposed to take charge, and that girls are supposed to act like they don't like it even when they do. I think until you punched him and ran away, he honestly thought you were just playing hard to get." She shook her head, it looked like a shudder. "I think we need to spend the next few meetings talking about how we relate to one another, especially as men and women.
"But there's one thing we need to resolve before the next time. Melanie -- I don't know how to put this. Is there any way you can feel like coming if Eric is there? Or do we need to ask Eric not to come back? What would it take for you to feel safe again at our youth group?"
"Tell him not to come back? Oh my God, no. That would be so awful, seeing somebody kicked out, and knowing how awful that feels. I mean, everybody's a jerk sometimes. If he can just leave me alone and keep away from me, I think I would be okay with him being there."
She looked at me carefully, like she was trying to see something. Then she went on. "Would it help if he apologized?"
I thought briefly. "No, I don't want to talk to him at all. Just get him to not talk to me and avoid me. I'll avoid him, too. If he really changes, I'll know it sooner or later." I tried to imagine what it would be like. "It will be weird. But I think I need that, to feel safe."
I continued, "I really appreciate all you're doing for me. I don't feel like I deserve so much special attention."
"Melanie, you do deserve it. You're one of God's children, and you deserve love and respect and consideration as much as anyone. As one of God's servants, it's my job to see to it that you get it."
"Did you know our school has a class called 'respect'? Everyone spends an hour a day learning about and talking about how to show respect for one another."
"That sounds interesting. I'll ask you about it, since I might want to incorporate some of that in our program. But not tonight. I think you need to go to bed. And so do I."
We said our goodbyes, and then I went to bed.
Dr. Gordon was finally back from her vacation. I went in and talked about what Doris had said about Dennis. I was kind of mad at her for making me feel so guilty. She said she hadn't been trying to make me feel guilty and she didn't think I'd done anything wrong, either. It was just that I shouldn't be too surprised that sex was more than most kids my age could handle. I told her about Doris and how nice she was, but I didn't tell her about how Doris masturbated me. (I still don't like that word.)
She also said that things were going so well that I didn't need to come twice a week. From now on, I would just see her on Tuesdays. I wasn't sure I liked it, but I also seemed to be getting mad at her a lot, so maybe it was for the best.
That was the week that Teresa got her learner's permit. I talked to my aunt and uncle about me getting one, but they said they'd need to find out what was involved, my sex-change might make it complicated. We might have to get a lawyer and get all my official records changed to list me as 'female.' I wasn't sure how I felt about that.
I talked to Doris practically every day, though not for very long. We both had lots of schoolwork, plus she was starting to apply to colleges. She didn't think I could spend the night every weekend, because her parents or my aunt and uncle might think something was up. Maybe they would have been okay with it, but neither of us wanted to find out. Besides, she wanted some time with her other friends and she thought I should hang out with my other friends, too. She was a little like she was my mom, being so sensible. I did get her to agree to come over Sunday afternoon.
Teresa didn't ask me what I was doing with Doris, and I didn't tell her everything, but I'm sure she guessed. She'd say how nice it was that I had a new friend and give me a knowing smile. Meanwhile, almost every night I'd remember everything about my sleepover with Doris.
Doris came over a little after lunch on Sunday. Teresa and I were still dressed from church, and I noticed that Doris was also more dressed up than usual. Somehow she'd figured out that we'd all be dressed up and wanted to make a good impression. It's funny, but I was more nervous about Doris coming than I was about Dennis the first time. Anyway, she made polite conversation with my aunt and uncle when she got there, and then the three of us went upstairs to hang out in our room. We sat on the floor and talked. Doris spent more time talking to Teresa than me, and at first I was miffed -- wasn't she my friend? Then I figured out that she was trying to make a good impression on Teresa, just like she'd tried to make a good impression on Aunt Edith and Uncle Boris. Since I wasn't saying much, I had time to think, and I thought: she's really smart. This way, they'll want her over here and they'll be happy that I'm spending time with her. Especially since Teresa kind of knows what we're doing together, it's smart to get on her good side.
I noticed they'd started talking about political stuff like racism and feminism. I hadn't thought about what Teresa believed, it had just never come up, but it sounded like Teresa wasn't anywhere near as radical as Doris. I was afraid they'd start arguing, but whenever they got to a real disagreement, one of them would back off. I guess I'm not very smart, because I couldn't get all that interested in it. I lay down on my stomach sort of between them and listened to the sound of their voices and ignored the words. It was nice that way. Just listening to two people who really mattered to me. I was thinking of nothing in particular when I realized that someone was stroking my back. I made contented noises, and then I noticed that they were both kind of stroking me, sort of like how you pet a cat. It kind of blew me away, but I didn't want it to stop, either. I started making purring noises, and I heard someone laugh. Then Doris said, "I didn't know you had a pet cat," and Teresa said, "I didn't know, either." I kind of went, "mrow?" Doris started laughing and stopped petting me, so I got up on my hands and knees and rubbed my head against her, the way cats do. Then I rubbed my head against Teresa and said "mrow" again.
Uncle Boris shouted up the stairs that it was a nice day and we should take advantage of it, so we got our shoes on and went for a walk in the nature preserve. It was fun. There were places where it was wide enough for us all three to walk side by side, and then we'd hold hands. One time, we started singing "we're off to see the Wizard" and swinging our arms and laughing. So when the path got narrow, so we had to walk single file, we each held onto the person in front of us and started saying "lions! and tigers! and bears! Oh, my!" It's a good thing no one from the psych ward at the hospital saw us, or they'd have locked us up for sure.
When we got back, my aunt and uncle invited Doris to dinner. Doris was kind of careful at first, but Teresa and I just kept looking at each other and smiling and cracking up, and I mouthed "lions" and "tigers" and I'd crack up before I could get to "bears." Aunt Edith and Uncle Boris looked at us like we were crazy and then looked at Doris.
Doris rolled her eyes. "When we were in the park, they got into singing 'we're off to see the Wizard,' and then the lions and tigers and bears thing --"
"You did it, too!" I interrupted.
"Quiet. I'm trying to act mature. I'm going off to college next year, so I've got to get in practice."
Teresa was facing her, so she started mouthing "lions" and so on until Doris couldn't keep a straight face. Meanwhile, my aunt and uncle were smiling and not looking like they thought we were crazy any more. Or at least, not crazy in a bad way. "It does my heart good to see you children having so much fun together," said my aunt. It looked like Doris's visit was a success.
I'd gotten to the point that I wanted to spend every minute of every day with Doris. Teresa said I was "smitten" with her. But Doris didn't want to. She said she liked me a lot, and did want to spend time together, but she needed her own life and thought I needed one, too. It was like Chinese water torture.
Meanwhile, I'd gone back to doing math tutoring and singing in the chorus. Sylvia still needed help, but she mostly needed me to help her calm down when she got anxious. She could do the work when she wasn't anxious. I got to know some of the other girls better, now that Sylvia wasn't taking all of my time. There were even a few boys that came over for help now. One or two of them I didn't think really needed my help. I wondered if they were doing it just so they could spend time with me. It took me a while to think that, and when I did, it blew me away. I'd never been popular before, and I couldn't imagine why people would want to be with me so much they'd pretend to be dumb.
I got paddled again. Just like before, I was having trouble remembering not to use curse words. But this time I wasn't so scared or shocked. It was just like, oh fudge, here we go again. It still hurt and I was still upset about it. I talked it over with Doris that evening.
"I don't blame you for being upset," she said. "It is pretty obnoxious. I usually get paddled several times a year, and I never really get used to it. But I tell myself, at least you know the score. Being paddled helps me remember that there's a power structure here, and they can do what they want with us and we can't stop them, and if we want to have any say about what happens to us, we're going to have to be smart and organized and figure out how to game the system."
I wasn't sure it made me feel any better, but at least she was willing to listen. She's going to make a good activist someday, I thought.
The next weekend, the youth group was having a camping trip. We all brought sleeping bags and spare clothes and the church supplied tents and food. We left Saturday morning and got dropped off at the trailhead which was a few miles from the campsite. So we had to carry all the stuff to the campsite We complained the whole way, even though it wasn't really that bad. We set up our tents and then walked around looking for toads and salamanders until lunch time. I had to learn how to pee in the woods as a girl. I was still wearing skirts, so it was kind of neat to just wander off, lift the skirt a little and then just pee. For supper we roasted hot dogs on sticks and cooked potatos in the coals. And of course we roasted marshmallows for desert. Yes, Eric was there, too, but we acted like we didn't see each other, and it didn't bother me.
I was sharing a tent with two other girls who I didn't know very well. It turned out they had lots of friends, and they all decided to hang out in our tent. They started out talking about boys they had crushes on who I didn't know. Finally, one of them moaned, "sometimes I feel so horny I could just die!"
Everybody laughed sort of nervously, and then they got quiet. Another girl said, really quietly, "I know what you mean. We try to look pretty, but what is it for? Nobody talks about that. I mean, isn't it so some boy will want us and want to do, you know, stuff that makes us happy? Like kissing and holding and, well, you know. I used to think girls who got married right out of high school were crazy, but now I kind of get where they're coming from. Not that I'm planning to, myself."
I probably should have kept my mouth shut, but I couldn't help asking, "there are boys, you know. Couldn't they, uh, help you out?"
I heard people making disgusted noises. "Have you tried talking to them? They're nice enough if you keep telling them that you don't want to be their girlfriend -- and if the pastor is watching. But if a girl lets one of them sleep with her, or even lets him get to second base, it's all over town the next day, what a 'slut' she is. Or they think they own you." Someone else said, "they're like Eric was to you, only in a different way. I wish we could 're-educate' them all."
It was dark and we hadn't bothered with flashlights. It was getting cold, too, but nobody wanted to leave, because it was warmer in the tent with all the people. I had alread gotten into my sleeping bag because the skirt and socks weren't all that warm. Somebody fetched some more eleeping bags, and we decided to double up in the bags and kind of pile together to stay warm. I ended up sharing my bag with a girl I didn't know who was feeling pretty cold by then. I was afraid it would be weird, but it was just cozy. Especially the part where I was warming her up. I wondered what the boys were doing. The boys' tents were on the other side of the fire, so we couldn't hear. I'll bet they weren't snuggling up together to stay warm, though.
Doris finally agreed to have me stay over the next Saturday. Teresa and I went over to Sylvia's, and the usual gang was there. We talked about what we were planning to do after we graduated. I was trying to act like we were just friends hanging out, but finally I leaned over to Doris and asked her if I could put my arm around her or something. I thought everyone would be too busy talking to notice, but just when I started talking, everyone was between sentences and they all heard.
"Hey, Dor, I see you have a new admirer," said Sylvia. I felt horribly embarrassed and tried to slink away, but Doris put her arm around me and pulled me over to her and said something like, "only the best!" I buried my face in her side.
Sylvia said, "Melanie, we're not making fun of you. We think it's great that you and Doris are together. We just like giving Doris a hard time."
Teresa added, "you can come out now." So I unburied my head and tried to act normal. And everyone seemed to be trying to be extra nice to me.
I didn't say much after that. Mostly, I was just enjoying watching and listening and feeling Doris's body next to mine and her arm around my shoulder. Teresa got in a long conversation with Jeff. It looked like they were hitting it off. It made me happy because I thought Teresa was a little sad that she hadn't had a boyfriend yet. I don't think Dennis really counted.
Sylvia's parents ordered us pizza and then took us to see a movie. Afterwards, we all went home, except me, I went to Doris's.
It still wasn't bedtime when we got there. Her family has this thing where before they go to bed, they sit in the living room and each have a little glass of wine and maybe say something about the day or maybe just relax. They had the windows open so you could hear the crickets and the birds and the wind in the leaves. I said I'd never drunk wine, so they gave me some sparkling cider instead. Even though it didn't have any alcohol, I felt sort of sleepy, maybe because the lights were low. They got me to talk about West High and switching to Gabriel. I wasn't going to tell them about having been a boy, but it kind of came up anyway, because it was hard to tell the story without it. Her mother said she'd heard something about it on the news. "Was that you?" She asked. They sounded very sympathetic.
Doris and I went up to her room and went to bed. We kind of lay next to each other, looking at each other and kind of feeling each other.
"Doris?" I said.
"What?"
"Am I too, you know, clingy?" I felt embarrassed to say it.
"What do you mean, 'too clingy'?"
"I'm afraid I'll make you not like me because I'm always wanting to be with you." And to make love to you, I thought. But I wasn't going to say it. "Your friends were making fun of you because I wanted to snuggle with you while they were there. DPDA."
"It's fine. It's kind of cute, actually. I kind of like it. It's nice to feel wanted. By the way, what you were doing wasn't 'DPDA,' you weren't, like feeling me up, or even kissing me while everyone was around. I've had guys do that. No, you were just right."
She leaned over and gave me a kiss. "Do you mind if I call you Martin?" she whispered.
"No, but--why?"
"I don't know. Maybe the idea that you used to be a boy. And maybe still have some boy in you. It makes you interesting." She was saying this in a sort of flirtatious way. Maybe turned on. She kissed me again, a long kiss, and started caressing my breast.
"Do you feel like having me do nice things to you this time?" I said. "You know, mas-tur-bate." I still had trouble saying the word.
She started laughing, but not as bad as last time. Then she said, "you're so cute" and grabbed my nose between her knuckles. Then she put her arms around me and hugged me and rolled me back and forth, saying "Martin. Melanie. Melanie-Martin." When she was done, we were lying side by side on our backs. Then she got sort of serious. "Sure. I'd love to have you 'do nice things' to me."
I turned to her and started kissing her face and shoulder. She slipped off her nightshirt and let me play with her breast. She had to show me how to do it so it felt good for her, because it was a little different from what I liked. After a while, she took my hand and put it down on her lower belly and had me tickle her for a while. I was giving her little kisses the whole time. She had to show me when and how to stroke her labia and her clitoris. I felt kind of stupid. When she was about to come, she had me hold her very tight with my arms and hold one of her legs with mine as she thrashed and strained, but it was all very controlled and quiet. When she came, she got real stiff and sort of whimpered. Afterwards, she lay there and breathed hard. When she'd caught her breath she pulled me to her and kissed my head and shoulders all over.
When she'd settled down, I said, "I'm sorry I wasn't very good at it. I guess I'm not really like a real girl yet, since you have to show me everything."
"No, 'real girls' don't always know what other girls like exactly without being shown. There's always some awkwardness the first few times. You're doing fine."
"But you did so well on me the first time."
"I've had more practice. Also -- now don't take it the wrong way -- but you're a lot simpler than a lot of girls. I do a few motions and bang! you're hot to trot."
"Well, the doctor did say 'an approximation of female sexuality,'" I said, sort of embarrassed. "I guess they figured, Keep It Simple, See."
"Don't put yourself down. You're just right." Then sort of dreamily, she chanted, "Melanie-Martin, Martin-Melanie,...." She kept chanting it as she put her arms around me and started kissing me. When she was done 'doing nice things' to me, we snuggled. Doris went right to sleep, but I lay awake a while thinking. The sex was fun and hit the spot, but it was the snuggling and lying next to Doris and feeling her body that really felt good. It was like there was a hunger or a need that I didn't know I had, but suddenly it was filled. I wondered if I might have felt the same way with Dennis, if we'd ever had the chance to spend the night together.
The next weekend, I visited my family. I stayed in my old room and my parents called me "Martin," but I continued to dress as a girl and mostly act like a girl. Biff was away at school, but Pete was around, and he called me Melanie. It was surreal.
We mostly hung around the house or ran errands. I didn't try to contact anyone I'd known before because, well -- what would I say? Besides, there were a lot of people I didn't want to remind of my existence. I wasn't sure they wouldn't follow me to the east side if they knew.
Anyway, we ended up going out for pizza Saturday night. We were sitting at the table waiting for our pizza to be done when I saw Ursula walk in. I'd had a crush on Ursula back in ninth grade, or as much a of a crush as I could have with things as they were, me being a "loser" and she being an "ugly." I never went anywhere with it, because the only thing I knew about boy-girl stuff was how my brothers talked about taking girls out and seeing how far they could go with them. I couldn't see treating Ursula that way. Or any girl. So when I saw her, I couldn't help calling out to her.
"Ursula!" I said. She gave me a puzzled look, like, who are you?
"Ursula, it's me, Martin. Remember?" I added. She walked over to us with a really confused look on her face.
"Who?" She shook her head, still confused.
"Martin Rawlings. From West High. Ninth grade. And part of tenth. You know, the vampire at your Hallowe'en party? Who pretended to bite your neck? The guy who got the involuntary sex-change?"
"Martin ?! Is that you? I can't hardly believe it. They said you'd killed yourself, that's why you weren't around any more. And you look so different. You really look like a girl now, nothing like the old Martin."
"Well, I'm not dead. But I'm going to a different school now, and I figured I might as well live as a girl, since living as a boy wasn't working out."
"Do they still call you Martin?"
"I'm called Melanie now. But I'm okay with Martin, from people who knew me back then. How are you doing? Surviving West High?"
She suddenly looked miserable. "They haven't killed me. Yet."
"Do you want to join us?" I looked at my mom and dad, a little late, but they seemed to like the idea.
She glanced nervously around the room. Her face twitched. "I don't think I'd better." She kept looking around.
"Do you want to talk sometime? Give me your number? Or I'll give you mine." I pulled a pencil out of my purse and jotted my cell number on a napkin and pushed it into her hand. She looked at it, then suddenly tore off a piece, took my pencil and wrote a number down and gave it to me. Then she sidled off.
"God, she looked afraid to be seen with us," I muttered. "It's like we're Jews in Nazi Germany or something." Nobody else said anything. Our pizza came and we went back to talking about Pete and Biff and the neighbors.
On Sunday, I talked to my parents about me going to church, but they decided it would be too complicated trying to explain who I was. Some of the people there knew about my metamorphosis, but I hadn't been around long enough then for them to get used to me as a girl. So they went and I stayed home. Surreal.
At dinner, at my aunt and uncle's, I told them about how Ursula had acted. "I'm worried about her. She didn't used to be so afraid. It looked like she was afraid of someone seeing her. I was wondering if I could invite her here sometime. Maybe she'd feel safer about talking to me. And Aunt Edith -- I hope this isn't asking to do work in your free time -- you might have a take on what's going on."
I called Ursula that night and invited her over for next Sunday afternoon. She sounded real depressed, but after I talked to her a while and told her about my situation, she agreed. She'd take the bus over -- I told her how -- and Uncle Boris would drive her home.
Teresa and I met her at the bus stop. She did a double-take seeing Teresa, so I introduced them. "Ursula, this is my cousin Teresa. She's real nice. She was my friend last year when nobody else would be."
Teresa simply said, "any friend of Melanie's -- Martin's -- is a friend of mine," and opened her arms for a hug. Ursula stood there for a moment, looking anxious, then let Teresa hug her.
As we walked back, I got a better look at Ursula. Her eyes had always looked sunken, but it used to be because of make-up. Now it wasn't. She used to look defiant, now she looked defeated. Her black nail polish was chipped and worn, like she'd put it on a week ago and hadn't done anything since. She was wearing black sweats instead of a black blouse and skirt.
At lunch, she was very quiet. She didn't join in any conversations, and gave one- or two-word answers to questions. After lunch, we went up to the guest room. Teresa poked her head in and said she'd be in our bedroom if anybody needed anything. Instead of sitting on the couch-bed, Ursula sat on the floor in a corner where she could see the door and put her arms around her knees.
"So, how's it going?" I started off.
"Martin -- Melanie -- can we talk about something less depressing? Why don't you tell me about what's been up with you since you left West High?"
I glossed over my suicide attempt and told her about moving to my aunt and uncle's to get away from the harassment. I told her in great detail what it was like being at Gabriel.
"God, it sounds like you died and went to heaven," she said when I was done. "What it's like at West High? Same old, same old, I guess. No, that's not true. It's gotten worse. All we want to do now, we 'uglies' and your 'loser' friends, is to get out. Evelyne has been taking lots of summer courses and hopes to graduate early. Even if they don't let her, she plans to apply to college for next year, anyway. Toshi -- well, she tried to kill herself right before school started, and her parents sent her to a Catholic school, and they won't let her see or talk to any of her old friends. Seth and Kurt and some of the other 'losers' have started smoking weed each morning and lunch time just to get through the day."
"How about you?" I asked.
She started to tear up. "You don't have to say if you don't want to," I said.
"No, I need to tell someone. But you've got to promise not to tell anyone."
I wasn't sure if I should, but she looked so miserable, I couldn't say no. "I promise."
"Okay." She didn't say anything for a while. Then she started talking, like she was talking to herself. "Did you know Kevin? On the basketball team? Last spring, he started coming on to me. He kept asking me out and wouldn't take no for an answer. I was able to avoid him in the summer, but this fall, he started up again, only real polite and considerate. One day, he offered me a ride home, and stupid me, I accepted. He drove me out into the country and told me how hot he thought I was and how he couldn't help coming on to me and how if I had any decency, I'd 'help him' with it. I kept asking him to take me home, but he ignored me. I realized I wasn't going to get home until I agreed to go all the way with him. I thought of getting out and running away, but we were miles away from anywhere and anybody and he could outrun me easily. So I finally gave in.
"It was awful. It hurt, but worst of all, I felt like I was a thing. Like a -- a dirty kotex. He wouldn't even use a condom. He took me home and I sat on the toilet for an hour and then took a shower for like an hour -- well, you know. I was scared I would get pregnant, too.
"After that, I didn't care. It was like it was happening to someone else. He'd take me off in his truck and fuck me and then bring me home or to school or wherever. I'd just go, whatever. I'm amazed I never got pregnant. But then he stopped and went back to calling me ugly. And people started saying I was a slut. An ugly slut. He must have told people, or maybe they saw.
"And I can't talk to any of my friends. We don't talk. We don't do stuff together any more. There's no solidarity. Just staying alive takes everything we've got. I don't know what the others are going through. I don't know what Toshi went through, to try to kill herself like that, but it must have been bad.
"So now I just go to school and back and spend the rest of my time in my room. I can't get interested in school work, I'm flunking courses and I don't care. I'd probably spend every day stoned like Seth and Kurt, except that I don't want to get to school any earlier than I have to, and besides, my parents would have a cow if they smelled it on me. When you saw me, it was like the first time in weeks I'd been out. I was afraid the whole time somebody from school would be there and start picking on me, that's why I ran off."
She stopped talking and sat there, looking lost and miserable. It really hurt to see her like that. Finally I said, "would it help if I put my arm around you? I mean, I know you know me as a boy, and it might remind you of, well...."
"It's okay," she said, and I could see tears in her eyes and on her cheek. "I know you'd never be like Kevin, even if you were still a boy." I slid over to her and put my arm around her shoulder. She buried her face in my chest and sobbed silently for the longest time.
Teresa peeked in the door, then tiptoed over to the desk and got something out of the drawer. Ursula looked up, tried to smile at her, but then buried her face again.
"Would you like Teresa to stay?" I asked. She shrugged. Teresa sat down on the other side of her. I looked at Teresa and just said, "West High." She nodded.
When she'd stopped sobbing and was just sitting there rubbing her thumb idly over her knee, Teresa suggested, "would you like some hot chocolate? My dad likes to make some about now."
Ursula half laughed and said, "sure, why not?"
When Teresa went out, I said to Ursula, "you know, you could talk to my aunt and uncle. My aunt's a social worker, so she's probably heard stuff like that and might have some ideas. And she'd have to keep it confidential if you asked. My uncle's pretty smart. If nothing else, they'd give you a sympathetic ear."
While we were drinking our hot chocolate in the living room, Ursula saw some paper and a pencil on the coffee table and started doodling. I didn't pay any attention, Ursula had always doodled, but after a while, Teresa noticed and said, "hey, that's pretty good."
"Naw, it's just some doodling."
"I wish I could draw half as good as your 'doodles'."
Now I looked over, and I had to admit, it was pretty good. A picture of a tree with fairies on the branches and wolves stalking around in the grass. My aunt and uncle took a look. My aunt gave my uncle a look I couldn't figure out. I said, "you know, I have a friend, Sylvia, who likes to draw. I should introduce you to her. Maybe if you come back again...."
I looked around, suddenly wondering if it was okay to invite her without checking with them, but my uncle said, "sure, we'd love to see you again."
My life was getting really complicated. What with school, romancing Doris, and trying to do something for Ursula, not to mention finding ways for Teresa and Jeff to have time together, and seeing our friends, well, it's like I had to have an appointment book to keep track of what was when.
One time, Doris came over for a sleep-over. At first, we thought she'd sleep in the guest room, but she said, no, she was happy to sleep in a sleeping bag on the floor. Then I couldn't bear to see her all alone on the floor, so I got out my sleeping bag and we snuggled on the floor. We didn't go any further, what with Teresa being there. Sometime in the night, Teresa got in with us, too, so I had Doris on one side and Teresa on the other. In a way, it was too much of a good thing, but it also felt really, really nice to have two people really liking me. Like having them next to me and snuggling made me feel liked in a way that just hanging out and talking didn't. It felt so nice and natural but different from anything, for a while, I thought I was dreaming it. Then, after I was sure it was real, I thought about Teresa wanting to be next to us. I thought: maybe Teresa is as hungry for snuggles as I sometimes am.
I was talking to Aunt Edith about what I could do for Ursula. She looked so miserable and beaten down, I wanted to cry. I wished there was a way to get her out of West High, but I didn't think her parents could afford private school, and I didn't think my Aunt and Uncle would want to take in another kid. All I could think of was to offer her a place where people would be nice to her and she wouldn't have to be afraid all the time. So I talked to my friends and we found Saturdays and Sundays when we thought she could come over and hang out with us. I called her up and asked her.
Ursula had bad news. "Martin -- I mean, Melanie -- my parents say I can't go hanging out. My teachers say I'm flunking everything. I have to stay home and study until I get my grades up. But when I try, I just feel like, what's the use? I can't even look at my homework."
I thought for a minute. "You know, I could help you with your homework. I'm tutoring people in math at Gabriel. Maybe some of my friends would help you, too. Do you think you'd have an easier time if you had people there encouraging you?"
She perked up a little. "I don't know. I could ask my parents, though."
"Gabriel School seems to have a reputation for being super-nerdy, maybe they'd believe that we'd spend an afternoon hanging out doing schoolwork. I mean, it would be true, we won't lie about it. But it's always easier when you're not alone. I don't think I'd have done as well if it weren't for Teresa doing her homework at the same time."
She said she'd talk to her parents. They might want to talk to my aunt and uncle, though. So I told Teresa and her parents. Teresa rolled her eyes and said, "what are you getting me into now?" But she said she was down with helping Ursula study. She'd seen how awful Ursula looked.
I'd told Doris and Sylvia and their friends about Ursula and they were sympathetic. When I told them about the homework situation, they were less happy, but said they'd try to spare some time. Sylvia spoke for everyone when she said, "It's not like we don't already spend most of our waking hours just on our own schoolwork."
The next evening, Ursula's parents called up and talked to my aunt and uncle. It seems her parents weren't mean, but they were really worried and didn't know what to do. I think hearing from my aunt and uncle that we were the kind of kids to actually focus on schoolwork and not screw around and that they'd keep an eye on things made them willing to give it a try.
So Ursula came over the next Saturday with a bunch of books and a list of assignments to work on. I helped her with math, Teresa helped her with English and writing. Ursula turned out to not need much help. She knew how to do the stuff, she just needed to not be so depressed before she could do it. A lot of the time she was just working by herself while we did our own thing and sometimes brought her hot chocolate and snacks. I actually saw here smile once or twice. By dinner time, she'd gotten them all done. She looked really depressed at the idea of having to go home. I'd hoped to spend the evening with Doris, but I thought Ursula deserved some fun time, since she'd worked so hard. We got the okay from her parents and Teresa and Ursula and I went over to the church basement to hang out with Sylvia and Doris and them. I got Ursula to do some drawings for Sylvia, and Sylvia did some, and they got along great. And I got some time with Doris. Ursula's parents picked her up around 10:00 and dropped me and Doris at Doris's and Teresa at home. So it all worked out.
Ursula's parents were impressed that she'd gotten everything done, so they were happy to have her come over again. She came over for a Sunday afternoon, and Sylvia dropped by. Ursula rushed through her work so she could do drawings with Sylvia. The third time she came, I noticed she'd gotten her Goth look together. She said she'd gotten "dressed up" just to come over. She'd dyed her hair red and green and put fresh nail polish on. Doris came by that time. Sylvia had her over one time for studying and a sleepover. But she still looked miserable when it was time for her to go home.
On the lighter side, Teresa's friends had been after me to go to school wearing Teresa's petticoat, but in a friendly way. After they promised they would have my back if I had any trouble, I wore it to school. I felt really conspicuous, the way my skirt stuck out, and I was sure everyone was looking at it, but nobody said anything, not even the teachers. Well, some of my friends said stuff at lunch, but they were all saying how cute it looked. I think some of the boys were sneaking peeks, but they didn't say anything. It took some getting used to sitting down and getting up, though, because I had to arrange the skirt and petticoat so it wouldn't show. I tried to make it look like I'd been doing it all my life and I was doing it without thinking. In the afternoon I realized I'd need to undress for gym and then everyone would see it, but by now I was feeling braver. I hadn't gotten into trouble yet. So I just took it off like I did anything else and put it in my locker, and after gym I put it on and acted like it was normal. Two of the girls did come over and say they thought it was pretty, but they weren't sure they'd have the courage to do it themselves. All in all, it was pretty positive. In fact, when I got home, I didn't want to take it off.
The church basement coffee house had a Hallowe'en party the Saturday before Hallowe'en. Ursula came dressed as Morticia, from the Addams Family. She even had some really wilted roses with lots of thorns; she said the guy at the flower shop had just given them to her 'cause he couldn't sell them. Teresa's friends scrounged up a short light blue peasant dress and a bonnet and had me go as Little Bo Peep. They insisted on putting make-up on me, including ridiculously rosy cheeks. It was my first time wearing make-up and while it did look cool, I didn't like the feel of it on my skin. They talked Carol into dressing up as one of my sheep. Teresa decided to be the Snow Queen. Jeff and Nick came as zombies. I told them it wasn't much of a stretch. Ellen was a mermaid, with a green sequined hobble skirt that looked sort of like a tail and a skimpy green sequined bra. Doris came as Abe Lincoln and Sylvia as a pirate. Even Dennis and his friends came: I guess he'd gotten over being so upset with me. Dennis came as Dracula and Zeke as a knight.
Yeah, Zeke. That night, Zeke spent a lot of time hanging around Doris and me. He really hammed up the knight stuff, saying a lot of thees and thous and fetching us drinks and stuff pretending he was slaying a dragon. As we were about to go home, he came over and awkwardly asked us if he could hang out with our crowd. Doris and Teresa said, "sure." On the way home, we talked about it.
"You know," said Doris, "I don't think I've ever asked somebody about hanging out, we just kind of did it. You know, you say, let's go to so-and-so's."
"Well, you asked me to hang out with you," I said.
"Well, you were a special case. You were too clueless to just show up, so we had to kind of give you a shove."
"Thanks -- I think," I said, sort of insulted, but not really.
"That's all right, we love just the way you are," said Doris. Teresa was sitting next to me, and she leaned over and gave me a hug, or as much of a hug as you can give someone when you're both belted into your seat. Then she started singing the song; you know, "I love you just the way you are."
I continued. "Anyway, maybe Zeke's the same. He seems to think he has to put on some kind of act for anyone to like him. Anyway, I think I'll make a point of letting him know when we're doing something."
"I guess that makes you his social secretary," said Teresa.
"More like his social worker," I said. "Or the clueless leading the clueless." Even more for my plate. Ursula, now Zeke. God! What's a loser from West High like me doing here, anyway?
I couldn't help thinking every now and then about how I was feeling so different about things now. A year ago, I would have thought wearing a dress was a fate worse than death, and as for looking pretty? Ugh. As for the sex change, it was like my life was over. But now I was dressing like a girl and (mostly) acting like a girl, and enjoying it. I even wanted to be pretty sometimes. I mean, some of it was a pain, like the harrassment, or having to be "ladylike" sometimes, but mostly it was fun. Maybe even better than being a boy.
It was a dark and stormy night.
I've always wanted to start a story with that line. I guess starting a chapter that way is sort of like that. Anyway, it was a dark and stormy night in early November, and I was once again having a "sleepover" at Doris's house. Doris had somehow gotten a vibrator, so after we went to bed and turned out the light, she got it out. We knew how you were supposed to use it, but it was more fun to pretend we didn't. We'd tried it on ears, necks, breasts, and we'd even held it in our mouths while it was running. The storm was so loud, we figured we didn't have to be all that quiet, and we were giggling and laughing like crazy. We'd thrown our nightgowns on the floor, and Doris was about to try it on my clitoris, when suddenly there was this huge crash over by her desk and a blast of cold, wet wind started coming in. Doris fumbled for the bedside lamp. When she turned it on, we saw a huge branch, as big around as my leg, sticking in the window and lying on her desk, and there were bits of glass and wood and leaves and papers everywhere. Including on her nightshirt and my nightgown, the pretty one Teresa had given me.
I was about to get off the bed and walk over there, but Doris yelled, "stay on the bed. Do you want to get glass in your feet and have to go to the emergency room? Let me get my slippers on, you stay here."
About then, the door burst open, and Doris's father turned on the light and looked in. Her mother was right behind. They looked at us and then at the tree branch. I was so embarrassed. There we were, stark naked on the bed. I was sure they'd throw me out, maybe both of us. I mean, not just sex, but lesbian sex!
Her father said, "you girls stay on the bed. Wait for us to clean up the glass. We don't want you getting splinters. Tabby, you wait here, I'll go fetch a broom and the vacuum."
As we sat their waiting, I thought about pulling the top sheet over me, but then thought I would just draw attention to myself. I guess Doris was embarrassed, too, because she said, "mom, it isn't what you think."
Her mother shook her head with a funny smile and gently said, "Dor, you don't have to lie to us. It's okay."
About then, I noticed the vibrator -- on the bed, in plain view. The jig is up, I thought. Doris sounded confused: "what do you mean?"
"I mean, if you and Melanie want to have sex together, or not to, or do something else, it's fine. I know you care about each other and wouldn't hurt anyone." She gave another one of those funny smiles. "You've always done what you thought best, and it's worked out pretty well. You're seventeen, so we thought you might start, well, experimenting. We'd glad that if you are, you're doing it where we know where you are and know you're safe --" she glanced at the hole where the window used to be "-- well, mostly safe -- and not in the back of a car or some other awful place."
"But -- why didn't you say something?" she gasped.
"We assumed you'd tell us when you were ready. We didn't want to invade your privacy."
I don't know where the conversation would have gone, but her father showed up with a broom with a rag on it, a brush and dustpan, a big trash can, and the vacuum cleaner. He must have had five hands to hold it all. He started pushing the glass and everything else on the floor away from the door and the bed, while her mom reached over and carefully picked up the bigger pieces of glass and wood. Once they'd cleaned and vacuumed a path to the dresser, her mom asked, "which drawer are your nightshirts in?"
"The bottom one. Oh, and please get a second one for Melanie. She looks chilly." I was shaking, but I think it was more because I was scared and blown away by the whole thing. After we both had gotten something on, I noticed that the vibrator was still on the bed. I saw her mom pull open the drawer in the bedside table and casually put the vibrator in, like it was perfectly normal for your teen-aged daughter to have a vibrator, but she should put it away when she's not using it.
"Come on downstairs, I'll make up the sofa for you. You can't sleep in here tonight. Melanie, we'll get the glass out of your nightgown tomorrow, I know you'll want to keep it."
By the time Doris and I had opened out the couch for a bed, her mom showed up with sheets and a whole pile of blankets and pillows. We made up the bed while her mom went into the kitchen and put something on the stove. "I'll make a nice pot of herb tea to settle you down," she said from the kitchen.
When we were done, we sat on the edge of the sofa bed. I was still shivering, but Doris looked stunned, like someone had hit her with a baseball bat. Her mom came over and took her in her arms and held her. I saw tears dripping from Doris's eye, but she didn't make a sound. Her mom must have seen how scared I was, because she said, "don't worry, Melanie, no one's going to do anything to you. You're fine. Come here," and she reached out to me and hugged me together with Doris. We stayed that way until the tea kettle started whistling.
Her dad came down about the time her mom brought out the tray with the teapot and the cups. "I got the worst of it cleaned up," he said, "and I pulled the desk away from the window so Doris's books and papers won't get ruined any more than they already are. I rescued Melanie's bag, too. I assume her clothes are inside. We'll work on it some more in the morning." We sat around the coffee table and drank our tea and didn't say anything.
Her mom said, "I think you two should get to bed." Her dad came over and gave each of us a hug. A man hug, but it was nice, all the same. Then her mom put her arms around Doris again and held her and stroked her back and head and murmered, "It's all right," over and over. Then her parents turned out the lights and went upstairs to bed.
I put my arms around Doris and pulled her into bed and tossed the covers over her. She was crying silently, but then started to sob. "What is it?" I asked.
"I don't know. It's like, I don't know, to think that all this time they've known what's been going on with me and all my boyfriends and girlfriends. It's like I've been walking around naked all this time and didn't even know it." She went back to crying on my chest while I held her.
We must have fallen asleep, because the next thing I knew, the sun was coming in the window and I could hear her mom bustling around in the kitchen. Doris was still asleep with her head on my chest.
Doris was in a better mood, especially after she'd eaten something. She and her dad worked on cutting the tree branch off that was sticking in the window and putting plastic sheeting over the window opening. I wanted to help, but they didn't want me messing up my nice clothes, which is all I had brought to wear. So her mom and I worked on getting glass splinters out of my nightgown, Doris's night shirt, and the other random clothes and rugs that had been on the floor and gotten broken glass rained on them.
Things were never the same between Doris and me after that. She didn't want to have me over for sleep-overs, because she couldn't stand knowing her parents knew what was happening.
"I don't understand," I said, talking to her on the phone one evening. "Isn't it great that they aren't getting all weird about you having sex? Lots of kids would die for parents who were cool about it." I kind of whispered, so nobody at our place could hear me.
"I don't know, it makes me feel like a little kid again. Having to have my parents' permission. And it's kind of weird thinking of them being mixed up in, well, what we were doing together. I mean, what are they going to do next, give me a dildo for Christmas?"
"You'd rather they were mad at you?"
"Yeah, I guess."
"Does this mean you don't want to make love any more?"
"Look, Mel, it's not personal, okay? I like you a lot, and I want to, but -- I don't want to do it with anyone if my parents -- well, I know it sounds stupid, but I can't relax knowing that they're, you know."
"Will you at least keep being my friend?" I was suddenly afraid it would turn out like it did with Dennis.
"I'll always be your friend, Melanie. More than a friend. I've stayed more than a friend with all the girls I've, you know, been intimate with."
I couldn't help teasing her. "Have there been so many?" I sort of giggled, so she wouldn't think I was really putting her down.
"That's gross," she said. After a pause, she continued, "only three. A girl named Alice, who kind of introduced me to doing it with girls. She's in college now. There's you. And one other."
"Sylvia?" I guessed.
"How did you know?"
"I didn't, really. But you all seem to be more than just like, people who hang out together. Anyway, I won't tell anyone." I continued, "would you at least be willing to come over to our place sometimes? I think Teresa likes you, and she'd miss you if she didn't see you."
"I don't know. Not right now." She sounded really down.
After dinner the next day, I made a point of washing up in the kitchen with Aunt Edith, so it was just us two. I asked her, "you work with a lot of teenagers. If they're having sex, do their parents usually know about it?"
"Why do you ask?"
"I have a friend -- yeah, it really is a friend, not me -- and she was having sex with --" I tried to come up with something that would make it less obvious that it was me and Doris. "-- with her boyfriend regularly, and then she found out her parents had figured it out, and even though they were okay with it, she was really weirded out just because they knew. She thought parents never know unless they catch them."
She looked at me for a few minutes. I always had the feeling she knew more than she let on. "I think most parents don't want to know. But if they are willing to accept the idea, I think they can usually guess."
I went back to washing, and she went back to drying. "You know," she added, sounding like she was being very careful with what she said, "if you want to talk to me about any sexual relationships you might be having or thinking of having, my door is always open."
"You wouldn't get mad if Teresa or I told you we were thinking of having sex?"
"No, I wouldn't. I'm not going to encourage you, I think it's the kind of thing you need to decide for yourself. But if you need advice or help, or, for instance, birth control, or just a shoulder to cry on, I'm there for you. You and Teresa. Maybe you can let her know that."
That weekend, we were all over at Sylvia's, and Doris was really different. She didn't say much, and when I tried to snuggle up next to her, she didn't exactly push me away, but she didn't put her arm around me like she usually did.
"What's up, Doris?" I asked. "You aren't giving your opinion about stuff, or talking about feminism or capitalism or the environment or power or anything, like you usually do. You sound really depressed."
"I just feel like, who wants to hear the opinions of some stupid kid? I don't know anything, I just like to think I do."
We all started talking at once.
"What do you mean, 'stupid kid'?" said Sylvia. "You're really smart and you've read a lot of stuff. And you do know a lot of stuff."
"I don't. I just kid myself that I know anything, and I've fooled you all into believing it."
"That's the biggest load of bullshit I've ever heard," said Sylvia.
"You know a lot more than I do," added Judy.
"Is this some kind of, 'I'm a girl, so I must be dumb' BS?" said Jeff. "Don't tell me you buy into that sexist crap." I'd never thought of Jeff as a feminist, so this was quite a surprise to me.
"Dor, what's going on?" said Teresa. "Why are you suddenly so down on yourself?"
She turned away from us. She looked like she was trying not to cry. Finally, she said, "I don't want to talk about it."
Suddenly she reminded me of some of the guys at West High who thought they were hot stuff. If something happened that punctured their image, they'd get morose and say stuff like, "I don't want to talk about it." Even some of the other "losers" would get like that.
"Let's leave her alone," I said. "I think we're just making her feel worse." We went back to talking about stuff like movies, or what we wanted for Christmas, or what we'd like to do for vacation, and of course griping about teachers. Sylvia told us about how the library was going to show some of her drawings. Jeff talked about the latest drama with his band, which was always on the edge of breaking up. I sat next to Doris and put my arm around her. I didn't want to bug her, but I didn't want her to feel all left alone, either.
We decided to go out for pizza, we figured Sylvia's parents had paid for our pizza too many times already. Everyone else was walking ahead of us, Doris and I were straggling behind. I stopped and look straight at Doris.
"I don't know if this will help, but I want to be honest. I think you're amazing, and someday you're going to do great things, and when I read about you or hear about you on TV, I'll be able to say to my friends, I knew her way back when. Even if you don't believe in yourself right now, we believe in you. I believe in you."
Doris got sort of a lopsided smile and said, "I guess I really do have an admirer. And, hey, you never know, maybe you won't be saying that because you'll be with me." We hugged each other and kissed.
I said, "I'm proud to be one of your admirers." Then, hand in hand, we double-timed it to catch up with the rest of them.
Things were going okay with Eric. Eric kept his side of the truce -- he didn't try to get near me, or talk to me, or even talk about me. I tried to act like I was ignoring him, but I kept catching myself trying to see what he was doing or hear what he was saying. I couldn't hear the words, but I could tell that he was getting along great some of the time, but sometimes I'd hear, "Eric, no!" or "That wasn't okay!" and there'd be some serious sounding conversation and he would look dejected for a while.
Teresa told me some of it. "Basically, he's a nice guy, but sometimes he comes out with some really sexist stuff or he does something that's not okay, and we have to yell at him and then explain things to him. It's like no one ever taught him how to act, or they taught him the wrong things. But he is getting better. Slowly."
"I wonder if we should try talking to each other again. You know, me admitting he exists, and vice versa. On a trial basis. I mean, we can't pretend each other doesn't exist forever." Teresa agreed, so I called Reverend Jen and we worked it out for the next youth group night.
I thought Eric would come over as soon as I got there, but he just stayed with other people. Finally, I went over and said, "hi."
"The pastor told me we didn't have to avoid each other, but I thought you hated me so much, you wouldn't want to have anything to do with me."
"I never hated you. I hated how you were treating me. If you can, like, not touch me without asking first, and give me space when I ask, and, yeah, call me by my name, I'll be okay with you. And I'd rather not have to avoid you. It was getting really weird."
We didn't say anything for a little bit. Eric was looking down at the floor. Then he said, still looking down, "I'm sorry about how I treated you that first night. I think I understand how it felt to you. I just didn't think. And it was weird. I don't know why I acted like that. I don't usually act like that with anybody. I think I was nervous or something. I was a real jerk."
"Forgiven," I said. I hated seeing him so down on himself. "Why don't we try talking like normal people? You know, talk about school, or what we do for fun, or rag on our least favorite teachers. Or argue about pizza toppings. You know, 'anchovie lovers unite! You have nothing to lose but your pepperoni!'" That got a little smile out of him.
Over the next couple of youth groups, we talked a lot. Part of it was that he was new, but part of it was that except for the four of us, everyone went to Greenwood. It's not that they were exactly unfriendly, but they had all that school stuff in common and got tired of having to explain stuff that everybody except us knew all about. So a lot of the time we ended up together.
I talked about Gabriel School, which he thought was fascinating, it was so different from anything he'd ever seen in school. He talked about Hollingsworth, which seemed like a nicer version of West High. I found out that he had an old truck which he repaired himself. He'd even rebuilt the engine by himself. He lived with just his mom, his parents had gotten divorced when he was around five and his father didn't go to much trouble to see him. His mom did her best, but she worked long hours to support them, and she was trying to find a boyfriend who might be a half-decent stepdad for Eric, which took up a lot of whatever free time she had. He worked after school every day to bring in some more money. It sounded like a tough life.
Once we ran out of school and home stuff to talk about, we'd talk about how we saw things, or how people relate. I would talk to him about stuff we'd learned in Respect class, and it would always blow him away. For instance, all he knew about relating to girls was acting macho and trying to impress them.
"Isn't it a drag to have to pretend to be something you aren't all the time?" I asked. "And what good is it if they like what you pretend to be, but you don't know if they like who you really are?"
"Yeah, when you put it that way, it sounds stupid, but what else is there? I mean, if you like a girl, what do you do? I just hang around them and try to act cool, but they don't seem to get the message."
"You could try just telling them you're interested."
"You mean, just say it?"
"Yeah, you could say, Suzy so-and-so, I like you. If she acts like it's okay, you could go on to suggest some things to do together."
"You mean, like, 'Melanie, I like you'?"
"That's it." Typical Eric, to use my name.
"Melanie, I like you," he repeated.
"Yeah, that's pretty good."
"Melanie." He looked me in the eye. "I like you. I mean it." I just stared at him. It didn't compute at first.
"Aw, jeez, I guess I did it wrong again."
"No, ..." I felt really tongue-tied. "No, you did it just right. It's just that -- I don't know, I don't know what. I feel so confused."
He looked dejected again. "I shouldn't have said it."
"No, if that's how you feel, you should say it. It's a really nice thing to say. It's just that, well, I need some time to figure out how I feel about it. It's sort of unexpected."
We had opening circle, but I was too distracted to say anything. Then we had the topic, and I was busy thinking about that. But then we broke up into small groups. Eric was in my group and we ended up sitting next to each other. I kept remembering how he put his arm around me that first time, and I felt like I really wanted him to do it now. I don't know why, I just did. It was all I could think of. When we were done, I got up my courage.
"Eric, I don't know how you feel about it, but I was just thinking -- well, I'd like it if you put your arm around me."
"I thought it really bothered you if I touched you."
"Only if you do it without asking. That's all I wanted, for you to respect how I feel." When we got back into the circle, Eric sat down in front of a couch and I sat next to him and he put his arm around my shoulders. It felt so nice. I leaned my head on his shoulder and it felt even nicer. He leaned his head on top of mine. I whispered into his ear, "Eric: I think I like you, too." Reverend Jen and some of the kids on the opposite side of the circle were looking at us, and Reverend Jen kind of smiled but didn't say anything. I think word got around by mental telepathy or something, because other people would turn around and secretly look at us. Eric had a few things to say about the topic, but I didn't. I think I was distracted. Actually, I don't remember what the topic was. It didn't make much of an impression, I guess. At least, not compared with snuggling with Eric.
When pizza came, Eric and I sat at the same table. Teresa joined us, and then Amy.
"You know we're going to tease you unmercifully," said Teresa.
"I don't know about teasing, but I think you all looked so cute together," said Amy. "Eric and Melanie in love. We could make a movie about it."
"We're only in like," I insisted. Then I looked at Eric and he looked kind of hurt, so I added, "So far, anyway."
"Keep us posted," said Teresa. "Weekly progress reports."
Eric and I found a spot on a couch and he put his arm around me again and I leaned on him again, too. He started playing with my hair. Amy came over and sat next to me and leaned onto me, so I put my arm around her. Then one of the Greenwood boys came over and tried to lie on our laps. I don't know who else would have tried to pile on or how, but Reverend Jen picked that moment to call us together.
When it was time to go, Eric kind of awkwardly said, "are we 'in like' enough that we can trade phone numbers? And maybe ask you out sometime?"
"Sure," I said. But he still looked nervous even after we'd put the numbers in our phones.
"Would you get upset if I happened to ask if I could, uh, kiss you?"
I couldn't resist teasing him. "Why? Is that something you might just happen to say?" But then he looked so sad, I couldn't keep it up. "Yes, I'd love it if you kissed me. If you'll give me a hug, too. But -- well, I'm not a very good kisser."
He didn't say anything, he just put his arms around me and looked me in the eye, real close. He was a few inches taller than me, and I suddenly thought, I'd probably be his same size if I hadn't gotten that treatment. Maybe like him in other ways, too.
He gently kissed me on the mouth, pulled back, then did it again. Then I squeezed him to me. Teresa came by to tell me her dad was here to pick us up, so I said goodbye to Eric.
In the car, Teresa said to me, "you are definitely smitten with him. I see he's got your number."
"My phone number. He wants to get together again. A date, I guess. I don't know when I'm going to squeeze it in, though."
I was busy with schoolwork that week, so I sort of forgot about Eric, but not really. So when he called me Wednesday night, it was a surprise, but it's not like I wasn't kind of hoping for it, too.
"Do you want to see a movie tomorrow night?"
"Thanks for asking, but weeknights I have to study. It'd have to be a weekend."
"You study every weeknight?"
"That's a Gabriel School thing, I guess. They don't want idle hands, or something."
"How about Saturday?"
"I already agreed to go out with a bunch of my friends. I might be able to manage Friday night, though. I could do my Friday night homework on Saturday morning. What movie?"
"I could manage Friday night, I'm not working then. I was thinking of 'District 99.' It's a sci-fi movie about a future where the rich control everything and keep everybody practically like slaves, and this guy who's trying to start a revolution."
"Sounds violent and depressing. I'm not sure I'm up for that. Is there anything playing that's a little more, uh, upbeat?"
We went through the movie listings and settled on one called 'Who?,' about two guys who aren't related but look exactly alike and end up in the same vacation town and everyone mixes them up.
On Friday, Eric came by to pick me up right after dinner. My aunt and uncle invited him in and kind of looked him over. They were friendly and welcoming, but they made sure they had his address and phone numbers and my uncle kind of surreptitiously got a look at Eric's truck. Once we were on our way, Eric asked, "are you parents always that suspicious of guys?"
"My aunt and uncle, not my parents. I think they're a little protective of me because I've had some bad experiences with high-school kids. This is the first time I've gone out with someone who wasn't from Gabriel School. And they don't know much about you. Well, actually, they do know about how you and I, let's say, didn't exactly get off on the best foot when we first met."
"I guess I'll have to be on my best behavior, then."
"What other kind of behavior were you thinking of being on?"
"Jeez, can't I do anything right?"
"I'm sorry, I shouldn't tease. Hey, this is the truck you fixed up, right? What kind of stuff did you have to do to it?" A nice safe topic. It turned out it was also one he could talk about for hours. I breathed a sigh of relief. But I was going to have to watch my smart-ass comments in the future.
The movie was better than I expected. I ended up laughing so hard I almost choked on some popcorn and Eric had to pound my back so I could breathe again. After the movie, we went to my local ice cream shop. I had hot chocolate and strawberry ice cream, and Eric had a coffee float.
"You know," I said, "I think this is the first real date I've ever been on."
"You've never been on a date before?"
"Oh, I've gone out with friends and hung out and seen movies and stuff, but this is the first time somebody's, like, asked me out and planned an evening together. You're my first." I kind batted my eyes at him. But then I suddenly felt a little weird. It was so girly and cutsy-dumb. I mean, I wanted to act like a girl and live like one, but this was getting kind of over the top. Was I going to turn into one of those girls I could never stand to be around?
Eric didn't seem bothered by it, though. He just said, "put it there!" and we high-fived.
Eric brought me back around 11:00. My aunt and uncle were still up and invited Eric in for coffee and cakes, but he said he had to get home, since he was working in the morning. He gave me a hug and a kiss on the porch, and then he left.
Doris called me up and asked if I was going to the Trangender Day of Remembrance service.
"Transgender what?"
She put on her most patient, explaining-to-idiots voice. "Transgender. Day. Of. Remembrance. It's a ceremony to commemorate the TG people who have been killed in the past year just for being TG. They're having one in town next Tuesday night. You should come."
"What's that got to do with you or me?"
"Uh, didn't you 'trans' from boy to girl about a year ago? I think that means you count as 'trans'gender. And I'm going because I know someone who is 'trans'-gender. You."
When she put it that way, I did sound pretty stupid. "Okay, I'll rush through my homework to get ready."
When Teresa heard about it, she wanted to go, too, and then her parents thought they'd go. So we had transportation.
The ceremony, or whatever it was, was in a Unitarian church. Someone had gotten the idea to put up posterboards, sort of like what you have at a science fair, for some of the people. Each one was for a different person. They had pictures, newspaper clippings or print-outs of on-line stories about the person who was killed, and sometimes things people had written or drawn. One had a hair ribbon that the victim used to wear. I noticed that a few were from around here. One was a 22-year-old TG prostitute who had been found downtown beaten and strangled with her bra. There was a police report on her board saying they never found the killer. They only knew her street name, so they couldn't look for next of kin. The writings on her poster were from other prostitutes. I wondered if she had a family. I wondered if they'd have admitted they were related to her. There was another for a trans man in the capital. I didn't know there even were women who got themselves turned into men. She was shot by some coworkers when they found out.
The ceremony was pretty simple. They'd read off a name, tell a little bit about him or her, and someone would light a little candle and take it back to where they were sitting or standing. Each time it was a different person. I ended up lighting one for a trans boy in Mexico. There were more victims than people attending, so most of us ended up with several candles. They had the lights out, just a couple of candles in front to see the words and to light our candles, so it started out dark and got lighter. When they'd read off all the names, we all stood in silence for a couple of minutes. Someone from the newspaper took some pictures. Then we walked out and blew out our candles and left them on tables by the posters. I started to think: I could have been one of them. Maybe in the future I might get murdered, and they'd read my name off next November. It felt creepy.
There were a bunch of people from the LGBTQ center in town who told me they were trans. Some looked like normal people and some looked a little funny. I didn't feel like talking to them, but Doris and Teresa told them my story. They thought I should come to their meetings, but I said I was pretty busy already. To be honest, I just wanted to live like a normal girl. I didn't want to think about any of that other stuff.
The next week was Thanksgiving. This year, my family came over. My brothers were pretty cool, they called me Melanie and treated me like their sister. My mom and Dad tried calling me Melanie, but you could tell it was hard for them. After dinner, we were all hanging out in the living room, when my mom asked me, "what do you think the future is going to be like for you?"
"I'll try to get into a college, if I can afford it. After that, get a job, I guess. Isn't that what everyone does?"
Then she asked, looking pretty uncomfortable, "do you think you'll have a family?"
"If I meet a nice guy, maybe." She sort of winced, but tried to smile. "Or, who knows, maybe a nice girl."
When she heard that, she turned away and said, "God forbid," and wrung her hands. I guess girl-on-girl action was too weird for her, even if one of the girls used to be her son. Then she put on a kind of fake smile and faced me and started asking me about school.
After my family had left, my uncle talked to me.
"I looked into what you'd need to do to get a learner's permit or a license. The problem is that your birth certificate says 'male', so DMV will only issue you a license that says 'male', but you look female, so they might not believe you're you when you try to get the license. And even if the picture looks like you, they may think it's a fake. Nobody really knows what will cause problems and what won't.
"As for changing your birth certificate, the problem is that you're under 18. They won't change the sex on a birth certificate before someone has SRS. We can argue that the gene therapy counts as SRS, but the guidelines say that you can't have SRS before you're 18. So they may kick up a fuss about your age.
"It may be complicated and we may need to go to court to straighten things out. Is this something you want to do? Are you ready to commit to what may be a long unpleasant slog?"
I thought for a while. "I'm not sure how I feel about it yet. Part of me wants to do it so I can live like a normal something, and part of me doesn't want to kill off my old self. And part of me is just afraid of doing anything that might, you know, mess up the situation I have now. Can I have some time to think about it some more?"
"Of course. Take as much time as you need."
On Saturday, Ursula came over and we hung out with Doris and Sylvia. And Dennis. It seems Ursula and Dennis had hit it off. I didn't ask her, but I wondered if Dennis not being ready for sex was part of what she liked about him. Maybe it made her feel safe. And I knew Dennis can be really nice and gentle. They spent a lot of time talking to each other and some time snuggling on the couch. It hurt a little, seeing Dennis doing with Ursula what I'd wished he'd kept doing with me, but then I told myself, Ursula needs this more than me. And I've got Doris and now Eric, sort of.
I mentioned to Doris that Eric and I were getting to be like boyfriend and girlfriend. But I told her she was still special to me. "Being with Eric doesn't mean I'm not willing to have sleepovers with you, if you ever feel like you want to." She told me she was glad I felt that way and I would always be special to her. Then she kissed me and we kind of hugged and snuggled. One time we were on the couch and Dennis and Ursula were there, too, so we all got squeezed together real tight.
Eric and I started going out together once a week or so. Sometimes we'd just go for a walk. One time, he took me skating. I'd never skated before, so he had to hold me up a lot, which was fun. And sometimes, if we were walking and no one was around, we'd stop and hug and kiss for a while. Sometimes he'd stroke my back. It seemed a little like he was feeling me up, but it felt good, and I'd stroke his back and the back of his head while we were kissing.
Sometimes, when it was almost time to go home, we would sit next to each other in the truck and put our arms around each other or kiss and stroke each other's face. One time, he started to stroke my front and touched my breast. Then he stopped. "I guess I should ask you first, shouldn't I?"
"Yes, you should ask, but it's okay if you want to -- touch my breast. Asking first makes it so much more --" I started to blush. "-- sexy, romantic, something like that."
Eric had one arm around my shoulder and went back to kissing me, while with his other hand he just lightly touched my breast through my clothes. I could see he was trying, but it wasn't doing anything for me, so I took his wrist. He pulled away.
"I'm doing it wrong, aren't I? I should stop." He sounded hurt.
"No. I mean, I want you to keep doing it, I just wanted to show you how you could do it so I'd like it more. Here." And I tried to get him to cup my breast with his hand and caress it, but he was stiff and hard to move. It was like he was taking it personally that anybody had to show him anything.
"Eric, can you just relax?" I gave him a long kiss, hoping it would get his mind off his pride, and I took his hand and caressed it and kissed it. I knew explaining it wouldn't work, I'd have to get him in the right mood to let me do it. Damn it, why do boys have to be so complicated? I finally got him to caress my breasts, but it was a struggle. And we had to go home right after that.
The next time we tried it, it went better, but it was still awkward. "Eric, I hate to say it, but the front seat of your truck isn't the most comfortable place to be, well, exploring each other's bodies."
"We could try doing it at my place. My mom is out most evenings, so we'd be alone." We decided we'd try it if things worked out sometime.
It was getting near Christmas, and Eric invited me to a Christmas party at one of his friends. It wasn't too bad, but I didn't know anybody and there was drinking. They had a mistletoe over a doorway and people were having fun catching other people under it and demanding a kiss. At least three guys got me to kiss them that way. They were nice about it, so I didn't mind. And Eric got a few kisses that way, too. But then some of the kids there started insisting I should drink something and I got afraid that they were trying to get me drunk, so I asked Eric if we could leave.
"We have an hour or two before you need to get home. Do you want to stop by my place and, well, mess around a little? Only if you want to, and only as much as you want to." I said yes, and next thing I knew, we were in his mom's bed and he was kissing me and caressing my breasts and back and everything.
Pretty soon I had my blouse and bra off and he had his shirt off and our hands were everywhere. By now, he seemed okay with me guiding him. I didn't need guidance because of course I'd been a boy and had an idea what he might like. I worried a little that he'd wonder why he didn't need to explain or show anything to me, but he didn't say anything. He started to slide his hand under my skirt, but I stopped him and said, "not tonight."
"You don't like it?"
"It's the kind of thing I think I'd like if I felt really, really comfortable with you. But we're not there yet."
We went back to cuddling and caressing and kissing, but I could tell he was disappointed. Pretty soon we had to leave, anyway. Why couldn't he just snuggle and kiss, anyway?
It sounds like all I was thinking about was sex. I mean, I was thinking about it a lot, but aren't teenagers supposed to be obsessed with sex? But I was doing other things. School. And friends. Doris was working on college applications and freaking out.
"I've applied to a dozen places, but I'm sure I won't get in. I know there are people with much better grades and test scores. And extra-curriculars! I haven't done anything! There are people who do a dozen sports, are in all the school plays, have been to Africa. How can I compete with them?"
She had her heart set on going to University of Chicago, and even though she'd applied other places, she was convinced that her life wouldn't be worth living if she didn't get in there. I tried to calm her down. I told her I thought she had a good chance and if they didn't accept her, it was their loss. It didn't seem to help. Mostly I just held her and caressed her and listened to her rave. I'd hold her for a while, then she'd work on an application until it got too much for her and I had to hold her again.
The church basement coffee house had a Christmas party, so our Gabriel gang went, including Urusula. Eric had to work so he couldn't come, which made me sad but also kind of relieved for some reason. Alice, Doris's friend who was at college now, showed up, and they and Sylvia spent a lot of time catching up. I hung around them and they tried to include me, but it was mostly about stuff from before I knew any of them. Zeke was there and he hung around me quite a bit. I told him I had a boyfriend, but he said he just liked being around me. Teresa and Jeff were hanging out with everyone and even though you could tell they were a couple, they were pretty laid back about it. I realized it somehow wasn't like that between Eric and me, but I couldn't say why.
Christmas was pleasant. There isn't a whole lot to say about it, which is kind of why it was so nice. My family came over for Christmas Day, but the rest of the time we just kind of hung out, saw movies and stuff. It snowed, so we made snow men and snow women, had snowball fights, and generally relaxed.
The youth group had a sleep-over for New Years. We had music and dancing and games and a talent show. Eric and I danced a lot together, but I also danced with other people, including Teresa and Amy. At midnight, we lowered a glitz ball and everybody shouted and hugged and then we all piled up in a pile. Since the pile kept falling over, we had to keep piling up again. Finally, we got out sleeping bags. The boys were on one half of the room and the girls on the other, but Eric and I arranged to be close enough that if we stretched our arms out we could just hold hands. I don't think we were supposed to be that close, but Reverend Jen sort of looked the other way.
One of the bands I liked -- Black Rose -- was going to play at the arena at the University in town, so Eric got hold of tickets for Saturday night. I insisted on paying for mine, since the tickets were expensive and I knew money was tight at his place, and he gave in. So that night, Eric picked me up in his truck and promised to have me home by midnight.
The warm-up band was pretty good, even though we'd never heard of them. I think they called themselves the Hot Potatoes or something. They played a lot of songs that were easy to sing along to even though we'd never heard them before and there was a lot of call and response and clapping and stomping on cue. So we were all really worked up when Black Rose came out.
They were awful. I mean, the songs were good, but they did a lousy job of playing them. I think they were drunk or high or something. The drummer and the guitarist couldn't keep in sync. The lead singer kept losing track of the words. At one point, he wandered so close to the edge of the stage, he would have fallen off if people in the mosh pit hadn't pushed him back. One of the roadies came up and led him back to the middle of the stage and then sat on a speaker on stage keeping an eye on him.
After about twenty minutes of this, Eric and I just looked at each other and started working our way to the exit. I could see that other people had the same idea. By the time we got to the truck and headed for the parking lot exit, there was starting to be a line.
We had something like three hours before I had to be home, so we went over to Eric's place. His mother was out for the evening, so we had the place to ourselves. I'd been going back and forth about whether I was ready to go all the way with Eric and finally decided I'd do it. I left my coat and purse in the living room and we both went to his mother's room -- with its big bed -- to make out. Bit by bit, he took off his shirt and I took off my blouse and camisole and bra. Finally, I said, "it would be okay with me if we got naked." I'd imagined something really romantic, but it ended up with him sitting on one side of the bed taking his pants and socks off and me on the other taking off my skirt, tights, slip, and underwear. We got under the sheets and started exploring each others' bodies.
"I gotta know," said Eric. "Are we going to, you know, do it tonight? I mean, I'm cool with it if you don't want to, but I'd like to know one way or another."
I was starting to have a sort of out-of-body experience, but I managed to say, "yes, I'd like to. But let's take it slow and gentle. And -- do you have a condom?" I felt kind of stupid. I'd been thinking of making love, I could have perfectly well gotten one myself.
He looked sort of sheepish. "I've had a pack for a while."
We went back to feeling each other up. He felt up my breasts and ran his hand down my crotch. I felt up his chest and his butt. When I got to his penis, it was hard. He started to push it into my crotch.
"Please, take it a little slower." He went back to fondling me, but I could tell he was more interested in putting it in. I wanted it too, why couldn't he just be patient and wait for me to be ready? I could sort of feel my vagina clench up.
"Can you just gently stroke me? I need to relax down there." He tried, but I had to use my hand to show him and say "gentler, please" a few times. Once he had the hang of it, I stopped paying so much attention to him and started paying attention to how it felt. At one point, he got up and got a condom and went back to stroking me. Then he stopped to put it on. He tried to put his penis in, but I had to say, not yet. He seemed a little frustrated, but once he started fondling and stroking me I forgot about it. Finally, somehow I was ready and he got it in. And it felt good, almost as good as with Dennis. Feeling his body on me, his arms around me, hearing him moaning, it all felt good, and that was all I could think about, how good it was.
After I came, and I guess he came, too but I wasn't really paying attention, I just felt this glow. I couldn't help thinking how this would never have happened if that mix-up at the hospital hadn't happened. I couldn't help just blurting out how I felt.
"This was so nice. It's times like this when I'm glad I'm a girl. I'd never have had anything like this if I'd stayed a boy." It shows how high I was that I didn't think anything of saying it, even after I said it.
"What? What was that?" Eric asked. He sounded mostly puzzled. I suddenly got nervous about what I had said.
"What was what?"
"What you were saying. Something about staying a boy."
"I was just babbling."
"That's some weird babbling. Like, I don't know, you used to, what, pretend to be a boy?"
"It didn't mean anything, I just get these weird ideas," I protested.
"You're a lousy liar." It's true, I can't lie to save my life.
"What if I told you that I used to be a boy, but through some sort of medical mixup, I got turned from a boy into a girl?"
"I'd say that you were bullshitting me. Or maybe needed to see a shrink." He didn't say anything for a while. "Okay, I'll bite. Tell me your delusion. I want to hear it." He tried to make it sound like he was acting like it was a joke, but he sounded pretty tense.
"What if I said there was this gene-therapy lab at the university hospital and one of the things they were working on was something for guys that want to be, you know, women?"
"Go on." It sounded like an order.
"And I was in for a concussion, and they were going to give me this gene therapy thing to fix the concussion, only they got me mixed up with one of those--" I couldn't continue.
"You're -- you're not joking, are you?" His voice sounded kind of hollow. He suddenly sat up, pushed my legs apart, and stuck his head down by my crotch. "Oh, what's the use, I wouldn't know what to look for," he muttered. He stared at me from where he was sitting between my legs. "You're not making it up?"
I wanted to say, yeah, I made it up, but he'd already said I was a lousy liar. "I thought everyone knew." A lie. I knew he'd never heard about this. "I was even shown on television."
"Oh, yeah, I think I remember seeing something like that. Was that the news story where this boy was standing in front of the hospital and they were saying they'd given him this weird sex-change treatment?" He was sounding pretty upset. "That was you?" I hoped he would give up, but he didn't. I finally squeeked a tiny "yeah?" and gave him a don't-hit-me smile.
"You're really a guy!?" He started looking horrified. "The 'girl' I just fucked is really a guy!?" He started out slow and kind of dead, but was almost screaming when he finished. "A -- a she-male." He started backing away from me off the bed.
"Eric, please!" I pleaded.
"You mean all this time I've been going out with a guy? You pretended you were a girl to get me to fall for you? You made me think I was kissing a girl and making out with a girl and -- and fucking a girl, and all this time you were really a guy?"
"Eric, no!" I was crying, but he wasn't listening.
"You think I'm some kind of fag? You think I want to fuck guys? You think I want to kiss and hug and make out with guys?" He was screaming, "get away from me! Jesus, what have you done to me?" I rolled away from him, but kept looking at him over my shoulder in case he tried to do something to me.
I was afraid he'd kill me, but he went into the bathroom, still saying, "I've been fucking a guy. Oh, God!" I heard the water running. Next Day of Remembrance, they'll be saying my name, I thought.
I tried to get my clothes on as fast as I could. I wanted to be ready to run. But it was hard. First, I got my underpants on backwards and had to take them off and put them on again. When I tried to put my bra on, I couldn't feel the hooks, so it took forever. I gave up after I got two hooks on (I think.) I started to put my tights on, but realized they were inside out. My toe caught somewhere when I was putting the second leg on and I had to pull it off and redo it. How long do I have before he comes out and kills me? Camisole. Blouse -- half the buttons, and not the cuffs. Fumbling for the hook on the back of the skirt. Dragging the slip on under it. I could hear Eric taking a shower and still moaning, "oh, God! Oh God." I located my shoes and shoved my feet into them, then ran for the living room to collect my coat and purse. I tried to be quiet going out the door so maybe he wouldn't follow me right away. Down the front steps, onto the sidewalk, and into the darkness.
I didn't know where I was going, I just knew I wanted to be far away from Eric whenever he decided to come after me. I saw the moon low in the sky and figured that must be West. I knew Teresa's house was west of here, so I found a street that was going that way and started walking.
At first, all I could think of was how upset I felt. I'd think about the sex and then Eric's reaction and I'd feel like my feelings were bouncing like a ping-pong ball. I just wanted to jump out of my body. I wanted to be anywhere but here and anybody but me. I started feeling tears on my face. "Hurt." That was the word. I felt so, so hurt. I kept walking and feeling humiliated and ashamed. And hurt.
After a while, I started feeling like, this isn't fair. What was I supposed to do? I didn't choose to get turned into a girl. Or to be born a boy, either. I just wanted to feel normal. Some kind of normal. Was I supposed to tell everyone I met, hey, I'm a tranny? Wear a scarlet "T"? I started feeling self-righteous indignation. That went on for a while.
Then I started feeling guilty. You should have told him. It was a lie. A lie of omission. And then you seduced him. Just a slut, I'm a tranny slut. I was feeling miserable and kind of sorry for myself. I'm the lowest form of life, I deserve to die. I thought, I want to kill myself. Except if I do, Teresa will kill me.
About this time, I noticed that my legs were cold. I started noticing where I was. I was on a country road in the middle of nowhere. I couldn't remember when I'd last seen a house. There'd been woods, I remembered, but now there were open fields on both sides of the road with stubble from harvested corn or something, all covered with dry snow. The wind was blowing across the fields and under my skirt and it was really cold, especially when it would pick up some loose snow and blow it onto my legs. I kept walking, hoping I'd see a house, or at least some woods. I was starting to worry that I'd freeze to death.
You know, you should call your uncle and ask them to pick you up. Maybe they can figure out where you are. The moon was about to set, if I waited any longer it would be too dark to see anything. I opened my purse and felt around for my phone, but couldn't find it. I squatted down by the side of the road. It was really awkward because my shoes were sort of high heels, and even though they weren't real high, they weren't real steady on the dirt and gravel by the side of the road. I dug through the purse again. Still no phone. I tried dumping everything out on the edge of the road. Tampons, address book, envelopes, a red ribbon, hairbrush, even a compact. But no phone. Then I remembered: I'd taken it out to charge it. I must have forgotten to put it back in. I'll bet it's still on my dresser.
Now I started to get scared. I was feeling really cold, not just my legs. My coat was cute, but not really warm enough for spending hours in the cold. I gathered all the stuff and put it back in the purse. I looked around in what was left of the moonlight to make sure I hadn't left anything. Then I started walking again. I told myself, if I saw a car, I'd flag them down. But I didn't remember seeing any cars or any traffic at all.
I don't know how long I walked. I couldn't see any houses. Keep walking, I thought, maybe something will turn up. The fields turned into woods, so the wind was less, but I was still freezing. I couldn't feel my legs or my feet. Or my crotch. I was shivering. I kept stumbling because I couldn't tell whether my foot was on the ground or not. I kept thinking about how freezing to death is supposed to be a comfortable way to die. This must be God granting my wish to die, only now I wasn't so sure. If I do die, will Teresa figure it counts as suicide? Or just a tragic accident? If she decides it was suicide, will she follow me into wherever it is we go after death and beat me up for all eternity?
I noticed a light on the road. I turned around, almost falling, and saw headlights coming my way. I tried to walk into the road, but my legs weren't working right, so I just waved my arms. The lights came to a stop beside me and I saw the outline of a pickup truck. I heard "need a ride" in a familiar voice. A voice from my nightmares: Eric.
I shouted, "no, thanks!" and tried to hobble away. I'd rather die, I thought.
Eric got out of the truck and walked over to me. I felt like a zombie or some movie monster was coming over to eat my brains or something and tried to walk as fast as I could, but I ended up stumbling and falling onto my hands and knees. I'll bet I tore my tights. Great, not only will I die, but I'll die with ragged tights, like the stories where you get taken to the ER with ratty underpants and die of embarrassment. I couldn't feel my hands, I must have torn them up, too, but somehow the tights bothered me more.
I felt Eric lift me to my feet. "Don't be an idiot. You're going to freeze to death out here. Let me take you home." When he let go, I started to fall, so he put his arms under my back and my knees and carried me across the road to the truck. "Hell, you're half-dead already," he muttered. He opened the door, but I couldn't climb up into the seat, so he had to kind of heave my butt onto the seat and push my legs inside, like I was a crash-test dummy. He buckled the seat belt around me. I would have been mortified if I hadn't been so out of it. He closed the door, then disappeared. When he came back, he tossed my shoes inside.
"Do you have your purse?" he asked. I opened my coat and showed it to him. He got in and turned the truck around.
"What were you doing out here, anyway?"
"Walking home," I mumbled.
"You wouldn't have gotten home this way, it's like fifty miles before the next town." He turned on the heater full blast. I just lay there, soaking in the warmth.
"I wish you'd stayed. I settled down after a while and went to find you, but you were gone. I've spent the past hour or so going down every road out of town trying to find you."
"I thought ... kill me." I was having trouble speaking. The heat had stopped the shivering, but now I was so limp I could hardly move.
He didn't say anything for a while. I saw lights, he made a few turns, and drove on.
"I'm sorry I yelled at you like that. It just, well, hit me somewhere. I felt awful, but I shouldn't have said those things." He might have said some more stuff, but I was getting too drowsy to hear anything.
The next thing I knew, he was shaking me. "You're home. You gotta go in now." He had to put on my shoes and help me walk up to the front door. My uncle opened the door before we had a chance to ring.
He took one look at me and asked, "what happened to you?" He and Eric walked me into the living room. My aunt and Teresa were standing around watching. "You're freezing!" he said. "What happened? Why are you so cold?"
"Eric and I, well, we had a fight, and I ran off and tried to walk home. He found me before I froze to death." My uncle looked skeptical, but asked Eric if he wanted something to eat or drink.
"No, I'd better be going. But -- Melanie, we have to talk. Can we talk tomorrow after Church?" I nodded, and he left.
Teresa and Aunt Edith got me upstairs and undressed me and gave me a bath. The water felt scalding, but they said it was just warm. When they decided I was thawed out enough, they wrapped me in a terry-cloth bathrobe and Uncle Boris brought me some hot herb tea. I felt like a baby they'd given a bath to.
"Do you want to talk about it?" my aunt asked after I'd had some tea.
I shook my head. "Maybe tomorrow, after I talk with Eric."
Eric was at church the next day, but didn't try to talk to me until after the service. He told my uncle he'd drive me home and then he led me into a corner of the library.
"I'm sorry I said all that stuff. It was really uncalled for." He sounded kind of stiff, like he was reading a script. He didn't really look at me.
I wanted to say, "it's okay," but I couldn't make myself do it. Actually, it's not that I wanted to, it was more that I thought I ought to.
After a few really awkward minutes, he asked, "were you serious about what you said last night? Saying you used to be -- a guy? You're not just messing with me?"
I shrugged. "I know it sounds weird, but it's true."
He looked like he was struggling with something. "I don't get it. What is that all about? I mean if you did somehow, like, change, what happened? You said some stuff last night, but I didn't really take it all in."
I took a deep breath. "A year, well, a year and a half ago, I tried driving my brother's motorcycle --"
"You know how to drive a motorcycle?" he interrupted.
"Well, no, that was the problem. I kind of wrecked the motorcycle and almost killed myself. I don't actually remember. I got a real bad concussion, they thought I'd die or at least have brain damage. They took me down to the University hospital for this experimental gene-therapy treatment. Only they were also doing some experimental sex-change treatment on someone and they mixed us up."
I expected Eric to interrupt, but he was just staring at me. A little like last night. "Nobody noticed until a few months later, when my parents took me to the doctor to find out why my body was, well, changing. They started investigating and finally figured out what had happened, but it was way too late.
"Anyway, the kids at West High were making my life hell. I started feeling like I'd rather be dead. My parents finally took me out and my aunt and uncle arranged for me to go to Gabriel. I decided to start living as a girl then. And here I am!" I tried to sound upbeat and chipper. He was just staring at me. I waited.
"Do you think there's any chance we can still be, well, friends, at least?" I was still hoping we could somehow patch things up.
"I don't know. I gotta figure out if I'm okay with it."
"Okay with what?"
"With you being, uh, trans-, you know, a boy turned into a girl. It's -- well, it's not right. Guys are supposed to be guys. Girls are supposed to be girls."
"It's not like I can do anything about it, about what I am."
"I guess not. I still don't know if I'm okay with it."
I couldn't help asking. "And if you're not okay with it?"
He didn't say anything, but the way he looked at me, it was like I wasn't human. I felt a cold hole in my stomach. We sat in silence for a few more minutes.
"Guess I gotta go. I promised you a ride home, you coming?"
"No, I need some time to think." He didn't seem too heartbroken. Me, I couldn't imagine sitting next to him for the 15 minutes or so it would take to get home. I wandered in the direction of the sanctuary. Once I was safely out of Eric's sight, I tried calling my uncle, but there was no answer. Probably still on the road.
Eric's words rattled around in my brain: "I don't know if I'm okay with it." They felt like a knife in my gut, but I couldn't put my finger on why. I was still standing around in the hall when Reverend Jen came out of a room. Her office, I guess.
"What's wrong?" My face must have been showing how I felt.
I tried to put some words together, but nothing came out. She put her arms around me and I put my arms around her like a little kid and just started bawling. She didn't say anything, just held me and acted like this was something that happened every day. After a little bit, she led me back into her office and onto a little couch. I leaned on her shoulder and cried some more while she stroked my head and shoulders. I noticed she left the door open, maybe so no one would think anything funny was going on.
"Do you want to tell me?" she asked after I had mostly stopped crying.
"I don't know if you know, but, uh, I used to be a boy." I was almost getting used to saying it.
"I know, Teresa told me back when you moved in with her. I didn't say anything because I thought it was for you to decide when you wanted to talk about it."
"Anyway, Eric and I were boyfriend and girlfriend, but last night, when we were, you know, messing around, I let it slip that I used to be a boy and he flipped out. I thought he was going to kill me. I ran out and tried to walk home and almost froze to death before he found me and brought me home." TMI, I thought.
"Anyway, we talked today and he said, I don't know if I'm okay with you being a girl who used to be a boy. And he looked at me like, I don't know, like I was a stranger. I felt so hurt, like he stuck a knife in me. I don't know why."
"Do you love him?"
At first I didn't know what to say. I'd never thought about "love."
"I like him. I like it when he holds me and caresses me and all. I don't know about love. But I do want to be close to him and I want him to want me. At least, I did."
"It must be pretty awful when someone you care about says they don't accept who you are. It's like they get to decide whether it's okay for you to be what you don't have any choice about being."
"Yeah, it's like he still kinda thinks I'm a freak. That's one of the nicer things they called me at West High. But, oh God, it still hurts." I leaned against her again. I cried silent tears onto her sweater until they wouldn't come any more. She called my aunt and uncle and they came and picked me up. When we got home, I told my aunt the same story I told Reverend Jen, but I had the feeling maybe she guessed I'd been doing more than just "messing around." I spent the afternoon on my bed feeling miserable. Teresa came over every now and then to give me a hug, or as much of one as you can give someone lying face down on a bed feeling sorry for herself.
That evening, when we got to youth group, I told Reverend Jen I might need more than the usual amount of time at check-in and she just nodded. Eric showed up, but looked sort of uncomfortable and sat on the other side of the room. I didn't know if that was because he felt bad about how he'd treated me or if he was bothered being so close to a tranny she-male. I told myself I didn't care, but I did.
Before I knew it, it was my turn to talk. It took me what seemed like hours before I could find my voice.
"Guys, there's something I need to tell you all." I saw Teresa stare at me, looking concerned. "I look like a girl now, I even feel like a girl, but I used to be a boy. A year or so ago, I got a bad concussion and was in University Hospital. I was supposed to get this experimental concussion treatment from their gene therapy lab, but they got me mixed up with someone who wanted their experimental sex-change treatment." How many times was I going to have to tell this stupid story? Every time I told it, I felt more like a moron. Pretty soon I won't have any brain cells left.
"I started gradually turning into a girl. My, ah, you know, genitals started shrinking and turning into girl's ones and I started growing breasts. I tried to hide it, but pretty soon everyone could tell I had a girl's body. The kids at West High -- you all know how bad they can be. They were worse. About when I thought I'd rather be dead than spend another day there, Teresa's mom and dad agreed to take me in and try to get me into Gabriel School, where they don't let kids pick on each other. I decided that since I looked like a girl and not anything like a boy, I'd just start living as a girl.
"Maybe I should have told you all in the beginning, but, honestly, I just wanted not to have to think about it any more. Well, now I've told you. If you all decide you don't want a tranny freak in your group" -- Reverend Jen winced when I said this -- "just let me know and I'll leave."
I was sitting between Amy and a Greenwood girl and they both told me, "no, we want you to stay" and "you're not a freak." They both tried to hug me at the same time, which didn't really work, but I appreciated it anyway. I heard other voices saying the same thing. I couldn't help looking at Eric. I think he looked a little ashamed, even though I hadn't said anything about him. "Good," I thought.
Reverend Jen stepped in before anyone else could say anything.
"Melanie, is there anything you want from us? What would you like?"
I don't know where the words came from, but I heard myself wailing, "I just want to be normal! I want to feel normal! I'm tired of being a freak!" Not really an answer.
Nobody said anything for a while. Then one of the boys said, "can we ask you some questions?" Reverend Jen looked like she was going to say no, but I just shrugged and said, "might as well get it over with."
"Are you like a real girl all the way? I mean, even under your clothes?" I heard some groans and some people say, "come on!" I answered anyway.
"I'm not an expert on how girls look naked, but as far as I know, I look like any other girl. I don't have a dick. I can't have a baby, but otherwise, I've got all the girl equipment." They want TMI, I'll give 'em TMI. "Oh, and the breasts are real, too. No boob job." Periods, too, I thought but didn't say.
"Did you have any trouble with which bathroom to use?" somebody else asked.
"Only at West High. The girls made a fuss so I couldn't use their bathroom and the guys -- well you can guess what they did when I used the boy's bathroom."
"Was it hard to get used to wearing girl clothes and doing girl stuff?" That was a guy asking.
"It was weird at first, but I got used to it. Now I kind of like it."
It went on like this for a while, then Reverend Jen said it was getting time to order dinner and did we want to continue check-in or break. They voted for break. When we got up, a lot of the girls came by to hug me and tell me they wanted me there. Some told me how brave I was, which I didn't really understand. What choice did I have? Most of the boys told me they wanted me to stay, too. Some made a point of saying that, as far as they were concerned, I was a girl and my past didn't matter. Some even told me they thought I was cute or sexy. Eric didn't say anything. Some people gave him funny looks, but nobody said anything about how the guy who was practically joined at the hip with me for months was suddenly acting like I didn't exist. Fine with me, though.
As we were getting ready to go home, Eric came over and said, "you know, you didn't have to tell them."
I cut him off. "What's it to you? You're don't even think I have a right to exist." He tried to answer, but I just walked out. My uncle was there, so I could get right into the car without listening to whatever Eric had to say.
I spent the next week wrapping my head around what had happened. I realized that whatever Eric and I had had going was dead. Stone-cold dead. I might have been able to get over what he did Saturday. I could imagine finding out was a shock and he didn't handle it well. It was his "I don't know if I'm okay with it" that killed it for me. He wasn't in shock any more. But he still honestly thought it was up to him to decide whether I had a right to exist or something. I couldn't stand that. It was too much like West High. I'd never be able to forget it or forgive him, any more than I'd ever be able to forgive Tom Prescott. I'd practice being civil, but we'd never be closer than strangers.
"You should have dumped him long ago," Doris advised me.
Doris had finished her college applications and had more time on her hands, so we were hanging out more. She seemed a lot less stressed out than last fall. I'd told her all about me and Eric.
"Back when he wouldn't let you show him how to fondle you. That was a bad sign already. He was showing you that he cared more about his pride than how you felt. You should have told him about being trans right at the beginning. If he's not going to accept it, better to know right away so you don't waste any more time with him."
"You're right, I guess. But I was tired of telling everyone the freak show of my life. And I wanted him. Maybe I still do, even though now I could never stand to be with him. At the time, it seemed worth it. And it felt nice. At least, when I wasn't having to train him how to treat me. I liked having him want me. I liked having him hold me. I really liked the fucking while it was happening. Before he flipped out."
"Sounds like we need to introduce you to a better class of fuck-buddy. You need to get laid by someone who isn't a jerk."
We were hanging out in her living room, kind of draped over each other. It looked like Doris had gotten over her embarrassment about her parents knowing she was making love. I mean, we weren't exactly doing foreplay on the couch, but we were being pretty affectionate. My hair was down past my shoulders and she was making braids in the hair that she could reach from the front. There was a fire in the fireplace and her parents were sitting around reading. Sometimes they'd look up at us and they'd have a sort of "aw, aren't they cute!" smile. We'd all had some wine and I was feeling pretty mellow. I wondered if she'd go for the idea of me spending the night. I wondered if there was any way we could spend the night together at my aunt and uncle's. It would mean admitting to them that I was, well, fucking. I was pretty sure that they knew it was happening, but I wasn't sure I was ready to talk about it out loud with them. But they had told me they were relieved I wasn't going out with Eric and they mentioned Doris and Dennis as people they felt better about, so they probably knew about everything. If I waited until they "caught" me at it the way Doris got caught before talking about it, I wouldn't just feel embarrassed, I'd feel stupid.
"You know, maybe it's time for you to stop hiding your head in the sand."
"What do you mean?" I asked.
"You've been trying to pretend you've always been a girl. But you haven't. Maybe you should try talking with some other boy-turned-girl people. Maybe you would get more comfortable with your -- history."
"You mean go to some trans group down at the LGB-whatever center?"
"Yeah, something like that. It doesn't have to be that, but I can't think of anything else offhand. Oh, by the way, it's getting late. Do you want to stay here tonight?" She leaned over close to me and whispered, in a stage whisper and like it was really naughty: "in my bed with me." I giggled and nodded. I think it was the wine, I felt like giggling about everything.
I'd talked about it with Dr. Gordon, too. I'd told her the whole sorry story. Anyway, she'd asked me how I was feeling.
"Hurt. Really hurt. I mean, he acted like he loved me. And I kind of loved him, too. And to have him suddenly act like I'd betrayed him or something. I mean, I couldn't help being what I am. I wasn't doing it to hurt him. I wasn't doing anything at all, it got done to me!" I was sobbing.
"Of course you were hurt. That was very hurtful. And unfair." She gave me a few minutes -- and some tissues -- to settle down. "I'm more concerned about whether it hurt your sense of yourself as a person. Do you feel like you aren't worth as much?"
"Well, I feel like I blew it by not telling him right away. From now on, I'm not going to go out or even be friends with someone who doesn't know I used to be a boy. If they're going to reject me, I want them to do it before I have a chance to care about them."
"When I first started seeing you, you kept saying you felt abnormal, like a freak. I wondered if this might have made you feel like you were abnormal, or weren't really a girl."
"No, this didn't make me feel that way. I mean, I know I'm different from the other girls because I used to be a boy and they didn't. But I don't feel like being different that way makes me all that different from the girls who are different in some other way. I guess it helps that pretty much everyone knows about my past and they still think I'm a normal girl. Like, Doris thinks it's interesting that I used to be a boy, but it's interesting the way it would be interesting if I'd lived in England.
"I guess that's why I didn't really think about saying what I did to Eric. I'd gotten used to everyone knowing about me being a boy until not too long ago and nobody caring. That's why it hurt so much, what Eric did. Since I left West High, nobody'd ever treated me like that. And right after I'd opened myself up to him like that. You know, when I make love with someone, it's like I take down all of my protection. It's like my soul is naked. I can't imagine doing it any other way."
"It's that way for most women, I think. And many men, too."
The next Youth Group, Eric wasn't there. I asked Amy about it.
"He said he didn't want to come. He's -- well, he's being a real jerk about you being trans and all. Says he doesn't --" She looked at me: "do you really want to hear this?" she said dubiously. I nodded. She sighed. "He says he doesn't want to be around queers. Says we had the choice between a normal guy and a -- pervert -- and we chose the pervert." She added, "I slapped him." "I mean, what can you do about it?" she continued. "Wave your magic wand and turn back into a boy?"
"Isn't he your friend?" I asked.
"Was. I could be okay with it, sort of, if he just didn't like you. But he's being such a bigot about it. I won't be friends with bigots."
Youth group started, so we didn't talk any more about it. I kind of wanted to think of him as a total jerk. But I couldn't help thinking how, even when he was so mad at me that night, he still worried enough about me that he drove all over the place to find me. He's a jerk, but he did save my life. I shouldn't have blown him off like I did at the end of the last youth group.
The whole youth group, I felt bad about it. I felt like I'd been unfair to him. And I had not only driven him away from me, I'd screwed things up between Amy and him. I had trouble focussing on what was going on and I didn't have the heart to sing.
When it was over, I went over to Reverend Jen. "Amy says Eric won't come any more because I'm here. And she won't be friends with him any more because of how he's acting. I feel like it's my fault. I don't want him to feel like he can't come. I don't want him and Amy not talking to each other because of me. It was me, I don't know, me surprising him with my being trans and all that made him so mad and upset. Maybe I should leave so he can come."
"Melanie, it's not your fault. You have every right to be here and so does he. You're not keeping him away, he is. If he's upset by finding out something about you at an inopportune moment, he can talk about it. If he's bothered by being around someone who is trans, he can talk about it and work through it. He's choosing to run away instead. As for Amy, you didn't make her do anything, that was her decision. If that's anyone's fault, it's Eric's. I can't tell you what to do, but I think you should stay."
"I still feel bad about it."
"That's because you care about him as a person. It speaks well of you. But you can't work through his anger for him. He has to do that. Now, go home, your ride's here. If you need to talk some more, give me a call."
I didn't have a chance to bring up him saving my life and how I wished I hadn't just blown him off the last time I saw him.
A couple of days later, I wrote a letter apologizing for blowing him off and saying I was grateful that he'd driven around looking for me and saved me from freezing to death. I even said I was sad not to see him at youth group. A week later, it came back -- unopened. He'd scribbled "return to sender" and slapped another stamp on it, just to be sure, I guess.
Doris kept bugging me til I looked up the trans groups in town. Basically, there was one, which met every second and fourth Thursday. I agreed to go, but only if she'd come with me.
"But I'm not trans," she protested. "Oh, well, we can go together, and if they don't allow non-trans people, they can throw me out."
"Then I'll leave, too."
The group met in a room at a Methodist church sort of downtown. My uncle and I picked up Doris and he drove us over to the church. We found the parish house, where only one room had a light on, which we figured must be the place. There were about twenty people milling around. Someone pointed us to a table with name tags and told us to write our names and preferred pronouns.
"Maybe I should put down 'male pronouns'", Doris whispered to me.
"Do it and I'll tell everyone at school you're planning a sex change," I hissed. But she was already writing "Pronoun: she, her, etc." on her tag. We stood around feeling awkward for a few minutes until someone said they were starting. We found two chairs next to each other in a circle of chairs.
We started off by saying our names and pronouns and, if we felt like it, something about ourselves. Well, I thought I could handle the name part. But I was still nervous. When it got to me, I said, "I'm Melanie. I use female pronouns, but you can use whatever you want." Verbal diarrhea, I thought. I couldn't help adding, even though I felt stupid doing it, "and this is my friend Doris. She's just here to give me moral support. I hope it's okay." Doris rolled her eyes.
Somebody said, "of course. Welcome to both of you." And the person next to Doris said their name. Her name, since she said "female pronouns."
Now that I'd said my bit and wasn't so nervous, I could look around at the people. There were all ages. I think we were the youngest. Some looked like regular men and women, and I'd have assumed that's what they were if we were anyplace else. I mean, they came in all shapes and sizes, but that's like normal people. Some looked like guys trying to look like women, some looked like butch women. And some I wasn't sure about. I could see why they asked us to say what pronouns we wanted. I was a little weirded out just by being there, and a little more by the people who didn't look like regular people. But then I thought about how Eric had been with me and I didn't want to be like that, so I told my weird-out to get lost.
After the intros, they explained the rules, like how you weren't supposed to tell anybody outside what people had said here and you were supposed to let people say their piece without interrupting and not answer back or argue with them. Some of the people talked about the stuff they were dealing with. Sometimes it had to do with transition, sometimes it was just life. I was feeling like maybe I wouldn't have to do anything and feeling glad about it when the person who seemed to be leading the group asked me, "Melanie, do you want to say anything about yourself? You don't have to."
"I guess I don't mind, but -- I don't know what to say. I think I'm pretty boring," and sort of laughed. Nervous. Doris muttered, "you are not boring!" so everyone could hear it.
"Do you want to say how you came to realize you were female? Or how you managed to do your transition? You look like you're about --"
"Sixteen."
"You look like you've been on hormones for several years. I didn't know they were giving hormones to children that young."
"It's a little complicated. Kind of a weird story. Actually, I didn't, like, realize I was female and ask for a sex change. I didn't actually want to be a girl at all. And I didn't exactly take hormones, either. I mean, I guess I have hormones in me, but--." This was sounding pretty stupid. "I guess I have to tell the whole stupid story. You see, I was a boy until about, what, two years ago. I got a real bad concussion, they thought I'd die or have permanent brain damage, so they sent me down to the University Hospital for this experimental gene-therapy treatment that was supposed to repair the brain damage. Only the people who do the gene-therapy stuff were also testing this gene-therapy sex-change treatment and they mixed me up with the guy who wanted the sex change, and nobody realized it. My brain recovered anyway--"
"Sometimes I wonder...." Doris interrupted.
I gave her a dirty look. "-- but then my body started changing. It wasn't until I'd mostly changed into a girl that they figured out the mix-up."
"You mean, your body just started growing and shrinking in various places, all by itself?" someone asked. "No surgery?"
"Yeah. My, uh, penis and all just kind of gradually shrank into my body and when it was done, I had a, well, a vagina. And I started growing breasts. And my body shape changed a little, too. It was weird. After six months or so you wouldn't have believed I'd ever been a boy, even if you saw me naked."
"Weren't you upset?" someone else asked.
"I don't know. I kind of didn't have a chance. The people at school were so awful about it, picking on me, calling me names, stuff like that, that I was too busy worrying about just kind of staying alive. The school didn't do anything because it was the popular kids who were doing it and I was one of the losers who nobody cared about. Then some guys tried to rape me, and then I tried to commit suicide, and, well, my aunt and uncle arranged to get me out of that school and into this school where they don't allow kids to bully other kids. By then, I looked completely like a girl, so I figured it was easier to just say I was a girl. I've been living as a girl ever since. My cousin helped me a lot. And my friends." I looked at Doris.
I looked around. I thought maybe they thought I was making it all up. "If you don't believe me, you can ask the people at the gene-therapy department. Dr. Newcomb is the guy who runs it."
The leader said, "I've heard of Dr. Newcomb. We've asked him to give us a talk about his research. I didn't know he'd gotten to the point of actually treating people."
"Do you feel any dysphoria?" someone asked.
"Maybe we shouldn't be interrogating her," someone else said.
"It's okay. What was that word?"
"Dysphoria. When you feel like you're in the wrong body. Like you're really a boy, just stuck in a girl's body. And unhappy about it."
"Well, it was hard at first. Life as a boy wasn't all that great, but it was what I was used to. And all your life, everyone acts like being like a girl is the worst thing in the world. But once I started living as a girl, it wasn't so bad. I've gotten to like it, actually. Some of the girl stuff is pretty fun. Once I got past my 'boys aren't supposed to like girl stuff' attitude. And I've got some really nice friends. Like Doris." I put my arm around her and she tried to look proud and humble at the same time.
"But what do you feel like inside? Is your essence male or female? Do you identify as a boy or a girl?"
I was having some trouble understanding what she wanted. "I dunno. I guess I feel like me inside. I don't feel like I'm any different from what I was before. Inside, I mean. Is that what you're asking?"
Fortunately, they stopped asking me stuff I couldn't answer and went on to somebody else. I heard a lot about families that wouldn't have anything to do with someone after they said they were trans, or wouldn't let them see their kids any more. And legal problems. Like when their driver's license and stuff say they're one thing, but they've changed themselves into the other sex. I'm pretty lucky, I thought.
After all the discussion, we had a break where we milled around and had juice and coffee and cookies and stuff. This guy came over to us and told us how they were glad we came and we should be sure to come back. He was really nice, not macho like some guys. Then he asked me, "I can't help wondering, though. Your experience is so different from most of us. What do you think you could get out of coming here? Is there some sort of support we can give you?"
I said, "I mostly came because Doris said I should."
"Melanie," she said, with this long-suffering look. "I said you should because you keep telling me you feel like a freak. All this 'am I really a boy or a girl?' stuff. Maybe the people here can help you. Or at least show you you're not a freak."
The guy -- his name was John, by the way -- laughed and said, "we all feel like freaks some of the time. You get used to it. It's nice getting together like this because here, being trans is normal. And people understand what you're going through. It's normal, when you've switched genders, to be a little confused about what you 'really' are."
Some other people came up and talked with us. They were all pretty nice, and they didn't ask me questions I couldn't understand. One of the women asked if she could give me a hug, and I said, yes, but I wasn't sure if I liked it.
On our way back from the support group, I told my uncle I'd like to change my legal name and gender. I don't know why, except that I couldn't see any reason not to any more. It wouldn't change who I was, I'd still be a girl who used to be a boy, but it would make things like getting a driver's license easier. I wouldn't have to be explaining my history to every cop and bureaucrat.
A few days later, Zeke came up to me at lunch and asked me out.
I guess I should say, it didn't happen out of the blue. Zeke had been trying to be friends with me since maybe the fall. I'd been letting him know when we were hanging out, like I'd said, so he'd been around. My friends all kind of looked at him like the puppy that follows you home. The biggest problem was that he was still trying to seem all grown-up and like he had it all together. A little before Thanksgiving, I'd finally kind of told him off.
"Zeke, you're a nice guy, I think we all feel that way about you. But when you make like you're so mature and cool, it drives us up a wall. Well, me, anyway. I mean, we're not grown-ups and we are immature. Even when we're trying, we do stupid stuff. So when you pretend you don't, first of all, we don't believe it, and second, it means we can't talk with you about stuff. About all the stupid-feeling stuff that's going on with us. And when we do silly or dopey stuff, it feels like you're thinking we're stupid." Then I thought, that's a little harsh. When he didn't say anything, I added, "Oh jeez, I didn't mean to be that mean about it. We still like you. It's just that you'd be easier to take if you could lighten up and be yourself."
He didn't say anything. He kind of slumped down. After a while, I took his hand and held it. I kept wanting to say something, but I remembered how my Aunt kept saying sometimes you have to just let people sit with something. Finally, in a choked-up voice, he said, "It's kind of hard. I have to keep reminding myself that you -- you wouldn't do anything to be mean and try to listen to you and not get mad. If anyone else had said that -- Well, I guess I have some thinking to do." He got up to go. We were in the cafeteria and it was about time for class.
"Just remember," I said as we were leaving, "we do like you, however you are." He got a half-smile and then we went off to our next class.
It took a little while, but he started to act more like a kid. He got more puppy-like, but in a cute way, and we made a point of saying how he was more fun to be around now. And he was, we weren't lying. He started coming up with crazy fun ideas. Some of them were just crazy, but some were pretty good.
He did especially like hanging out with me. A lot of the time, it would be me and Doris and Zeke kind of all together and sometimes Teresa and Jeff, too. I asked Doris if she minded that he seemed to have a crush on me and she said as long as I wasn't planning to dump her, she didn't mind me and Zeke hanging out. Actually, she seemed to think he was a pet. If he was lying down, she'd come over and start petting him like a cat.
Speaking of his crazy ideas: one day, a little before Christmas, he said, "we ought to do a MST3K."
"A what?" I asked.
"Mystery Science Theater 3000," he patiently explained. "You watch some cheezy sci-fi movie and make fun of it. I could download a movie and show it on your wide screen TV." So one Saturday afternoon, that's what we did. Zeke and Doris and I, and Teresa and Jeff and Dennis and Ursula, we all made popcorn and hung out in the basement while Zeke hooked his laptop to the TV and played a movie about some alien tomatoes that would grow in someone's garden and then come in and kill and eat them and then leave their seeds in the next garden. When the US army came, they shot the soldiers and the tanks with seeds. We got to snuggle and laugh and eat popcorn and snark at the movie.
So, anyway, he asked if I wanted to go to a movie with him and I said yes. There's a movie theater in town that shows old movies and it was having a "Star Wars" festival. The movie he wanted us to see was one I'd never heard of and he hadn't heard much either, but he said, "if it's good, we can enjoy it together and if it's bad, we can make fun of it together."
He asked Doris if she wanted to come, too. I think we knew he was just being nice because Doris and I were something of a thing, but Doris said she'd pass. She also said, "don't do anything I wouldn't do." To which I said, "what exactly is there that you wouldn't do?" One good snark deserves another. I guess she thought so, too, because she just laughed.
Anyway, we decided to make an Occasion of it by dressing nice. I wore a pale pink blouse with a kind of scarf tied around the collar and a royal blue over-the-knee skirt with pale pink tights and black Mary Janes. I'd washed my hair (!) and put it back with a hair band. I thought it looked nice. His dad was going to take us there and my uncle was going to pick us up.
So Friday night, Zeke and his dad came in. Zeke had on navy blue pants, black shoes, a light blue shirt, and a scarf tied sort of like an ascot. "You look like a movie producer!" I said. I think he took it as a compliment.
"You look pretty nice, too," he said. "Quite the lady."
His dad and my aunt and uncle talked a bit. We'd both been over to each other's houses, so it's not like they didn't know who we were, but they sort of pretended they wanted to know who their kids were going to be going out with.
We got dropped off at the movie theater. Zeke insisted on buying the tickets. "Can I just this once play the mature, masterful guy?" he'd pleaded and I said okay. The previous showing hadn't quite ended, so we sat on a bench in the foyer.
"Can I put my arm around you?" Zeke asked.
"Only if you give me a kiss," I said. I was feeling pretty daring. So we turned towards each other and he put both arms around me and slowly pulled my face to his. He gave me one very light kiss on the lips, then waited a second or two and gave me another, deeper one.
"I hope this is okay. I'm not a very good kisser. I mean, I haven't done it much -- except with relatives, like my mom. Okay, she's not a relative, she's my--" I shut him up by planting my lips on his and gently rubbing them and then giving him a long kiss.
"I think you kiss just fine. You take your time so you don't mash my lips and so I have a chance to get prepared. It's really, uh--" I realized I was sounding too practical, not romantic enough. "Really sweet. Really romantic." I should have shut up then, but I went on. "Like the first kiss I got from Dennis." As soon as I said it, I knew I'd blown the mood again. "Oh my God, I'm sorry, I'm so stupid, I shouldn't compare you to--"
"Come on, Melanie, you're not stupid. And I don't mind if you compare me to Dennis. Hey, if I'm half as good as Dennis, I figure I'm doing pretty well. Let's try again. Make sure it wasn't just an accident." We both laughed nervously. Then he gently pulled my shoulders until our lips were touching and he gave me another one of those light kisses and then a deeper one and rubbing lips and a long kiss. It was good the first time we did it, but even better the second time.
"Can I just put my head on your shoulder?" I asked.
"Uh, sure," he replied. I scrunched up next to him and leaned my head over.
"It's not that I don't like kissing you, it's just that I'm really feeling like being close to you. Can you just hold me?" I asked.
"No problem."
He sounded kind of not sure of himself, so I said, "mmm, that's really nice." It was, too. I felt like I was floating away.
After a while, I don't know how long because I was in heaven, the people started coming out of the theater, so we stood up and waited to go in. Zeke put his arm around my waist and I put my hand on top of his shoulder. "You know," he said, "this is how you stand for some kinds of dances. You know, waltz, cha-cha, that kind of thing. Maybe we should take dance lessons together. Maybe, next prom, we could actually know what we're doing!"
"What a concept!" We both laughed.
We sat together in the middle of the theater and we snuggled through the movie. Well, as much as you can when you're in separate movie theater seats. Considering how much people like to neck in theaters, I'm surprised they don't make them so you can get rid of the stupid barrier between the seats. The movie turned out to be not so bad, so we just watched it and didn't try to make fun of it.
I called my uncle after we got out since he was driving us home. We waited on the same bench as before. I was feeling a little sleepy, so I laid my head on his shoulder and he put his arm around me. It was even nicer than before. He started stroking my back and I just went, "mmmm," like before.
"I wish we could stay like this forever," I said. "Except I'm afraid it might not be too comfortable for you."
"I'm fine with it. Really."
"I think I should try holding you while you lean on me. Come on, let's at least try it." So we shifted around and I put my arm around him. After a while, I took my other hand and stroked his hair and gently brushed his face with my fingertips. It was nice, too. I felt like I wanted to do nice things for him and give him some taking-care-of. I rubbed my check against his head, since I couldn't turn my head enough to actually kiss him.
About then, my uncle came in. He looked at us and got a sort of indulgent smile, but told us it was time to go. We dropped Zeke off at his house. I walked him to the door and we had a last hug and kiss, more of a brother-sister kind of kiss, but still.
That night, I kept thinking how nice it was to hug him and kiss him. I thought it would be real nice to lie next to each other and hold him or have him hold me. It was weird. Just a month earlier, I'd made love to Eric. I'll still call it "making love," even if it did turn out badly. And here I was mooning over another guy and he was about as opposite of Eric as I could imagine. With Eric, there was always some problem or other. With Zeke, I just did what I felt like and it was always fine. I didn't know if I wanted to make love to Zeke, or ever would, but I was sure if we did do it, it would feel right.
I also thought about how I really liked him, but I also liked Doris, only in different ways. I couldn't say I liked one more than the other, it was just too different. It's like when you like chocolate ice cream, but you also like orange sherbet, and you think: is there some way I could have both?
There's not much more to tell. I mean, life went on, but it would be pretty boring to tell. Just the sort of stuff that I guess any teenage girl does.
Doris got into University of Chicago, just like I said she would. Now I'm studying like crazy, so maybe I'll have a chance to get into University of Chicago, too. I'm missing her already. She thinks I'll be okay with Zeke to comfort me and I can't get her to see that I need her, too. The hospital finally settled for enough to put me through any college I want, so at least I don't have to worry about paying for it.
Ursula's family decided to move so she could go somewhere else besides West High. They rented a place in Greenwood's district and rented out their own house and she started there in the fall. I don't know if she ever told anyone but me about what Kevin did to her, but at least she's a lot more cheerful now. She's still together with Dennis, but she also has friends from school. And the art teacher raves about her drawings, she says Ursula has real talent.
Getting my legal name and gender changed is turning out to be more of a problem than I thought. Every couple of weeks, my uncle's lawyer fills us in on the latest stupid excuses the state bureaucrats have found to not recognize that I'm not a boy any more. Teresa already has her license and I still haven't gotten my learner's permit.
I ran into Eric and his mother in the mall that summer. It was kind of awkward. It seems he'd told her that I'd dumped him, so she was mad at me. Also, he hadn't mentioned I was trans. We got all that straightened out, but she looked like he was going to get an earful later on. I sort of felt bad for him, but sort of not. Anyway, I guess that's sort of settled.
It's sad about my family, though. It's more like they're my aunt and uncle and Aunt Edith and Uncle Boris are my real parents. We see each other at Thanksgiving and Christmas, but that's about it. My life has changed in so many ways and they can't relate to the way I am now. And honestly, I can't really relate to the way they are, either.
Actually, I'm having trouble these days even relating to how I used to be. When I think of what happened back when I was Martin, it feels like it happened to somebody else.
I talked about that with Dr. Gordon in one of our last sessions ever. She asked if I thought it was more because I was a girl instead of a boy or more because of all the other changes. I couldn't answer her then, and even though I've thought about it ever since, I still don't have a good answer. For a while, I was sure that it was all because I got out of that Hell of a school and into a place where people were on my side helping me. But then I thought: if I'd moved in with my Aunt and Uncle but stayed a boy, I don't think I'd have ever been such good friends with Teresa. I don't think I'd have gotten friends I could tell everything to, people like Doris and Sylvia and Carol. Or even Dennis. I think I'd have been like Zeke, only like he was before I lectured him. Trying to be what I thought a guy was supposed to be like and not even trying to figure out who I really am. I'd have looked cool on the outside, but inside I'd have known something was missing.
But now I think: I don't really need an answer. Maybe it's like when you have a mom and a dad. You don't have to decide who did more to make you you. You're just glad they were both there. I'm glad I got out of West Hell and into Gabriel School. I'm glad I have a family that knows how to support me, even if it isn't the one I was born into. I'm glad I've got friends who have my back. And, last but not least, I'm glad I'm a girl.
(The End)
This story came to me yesterday morning as I was waking up.
Sept. 23, 2015
It was a bad one.
When the ambulance drove up, there were two cars, a pickup, and an SUV piled and tossed around like a child's blocks. Two police cars and a fire truck were already there and the firemen had already cut a few bodies out of the wreckage. People were standing around with dazed expressions, some with blood on their faces or arms.
"Those over there are already dead. This one's still breathing," one of the firefighters told the EMTs as they got out and walked over. "We've got a few maybes that we're still trying to extract."
Colin and Beth opened the back and pulled out the gurney and it over while Jack knelt over the man and checked him over. "The damage seems to be confined to the legs and lower abdomen. Probably internal organ damage. Let's get him on the gurney and we'll patch him up on the way."
The man was a big guy, with a neatly trimmed full white beard and short white hair around the edges of a mostly bald head. Beth lifted his head while Jack and Colin got his body and legs up and onto the gurney. Together, they got the gurney into the ambulance. Colin headed back to the driver's seat while Jack and Beth got in the back.
The siren seemed to wake the man up. Jack was around the man's lower body trying to control the bleeding as best he could while Beth was putting an IV into his arm and keeping an eye on his breathing, so it was Beth who saw him open his eyes.
"Dying..." he got out. He was obviously having trouble breathing, and his voice was high and almost child-like. She wasn't sure if it was a statement or a question.
"Scared.... So -- scared." He was looking at the ceiling, then noticed Beth. He became more animated.
"Hold me," he gasped, and she noticed his hand moving. She finished setting up the IV, then reached over to his hand and held it.
"Allison," he continued. With the next breath, "call me All--."
Beth managed to restrain herself from saying, "what?" She couldn't imagine why a big man like him would be called Allison. "Allison?" she replied, finally. "Your name is Allison?"
"Inner ... me."
"The inner you is named 'Allison'?" He nodded.
"Allison," she forced herself to say. "We're fighting for you. We'll be at the ER soon."
He shook his head. "Dying." She had to admit that he was probably right, but said nothing. The next labored breath was "hold." She was already holding his hand, so she shook it slightly. His face, already deathly pale, was turning paler, almost grey.
He looked at her, as if really seeing her for the first time. His eyes bored into her, then his face fell. "Tell me ... good."
After a few seconds, Beth filled in the missing words in her mind: 'tell me I'm good.' "You're good, Allison," she said. She couldn't imagine why he was thinking of this at a time like this. The name came a little easier this time.
He looked relieved, even as he labored for breath. "Always wanted ... never...was."
"You always wanted to be good, but never were?" He nodded. She saw tears in his eyes.
As the ambulance took corners, accelerated and decelerated, she silently took it all in. She wanted to pick him up and hold him, that was probably what he actually wished, but he was strapped down. Even holding his head would crimp his trachea and make it impossible to draw even the little breath he was now. Instead, she stroked his head. "Allison, you are good. You were always good." She added, "a good girl."
He smiled at that last. "Thank..."
"You're welcome." She continued to stroke his head and hold his hand and call him "Allison" and tell him how good he was. It felt strange and unprofessional to be talking to a man who must be old enough to be her father as if he were a little girl, but she couldn't bring herself to deny what was in all likelihood his last request.
Suddenly, he looked at her, distressed. "Remember ..." "Rememb ... Allison. Alli ..."
"Remember you as Allison? Yes, I won't forget you, Allison." She added, "Allison, it's going to be all right." She felt bad saying what was probably a lie. She rationalized that if he was religious, maybe "all right" could include dying and going to heaven.
He nodded and relaxed, still laboring to breathe, but looking into her eyes. She continued to look at him and stroke his head and hold his hand and murmur his "inner name" to him and tell him he was good. He was having a harder and harder time drawing a breath. She set up the ventilator with her free hand and pulled out the mask where she could grab it in a hurry.
"I've stopped all the obvious bleeding," said Jack. "But it looks like he might have some internal bleeding. If he can hold out until we get to the ER, they might pull him through."
"Colin, how close are we?" Beth shouted through the window into the cab.
"A few more blocks. I've radioed ahead. They're waiting."
"Tell them he's in shock. Possible internal bleeding. He may arrest at any moment."
Beth noticed that her patient was staring past her. He mumbled something. "What?" she asked. He said something that sounded like a name, but she couldn't make it out.
"We're losing him, Jack."
"Put him on the ventilator." Beth put the mask over his face and held it while Jack checked the man's wrist for a pulse. His chest rose and fell from the pressure of the ventilator, but then he shuddered weakly and was still, except for the rise and fall of his chest from the air forced by the ventilator.
"I think we lost him," said Beth.
"No pulse," said Jack. "So close." The ambulance made another turn and then swerved, stopped, and reversed.
"Tough break," said Jack. "He almost made it."
"I wonder what his name was," mused Beth.
"I guess we'll never know, will we?"
Beth wondered about the unknown man. Had anyone known about "Allison" while he was alive? What was that business about "good"? Who was he inside? She'd never know. Maybe no one would.
They got the gurney out of the ambulance and wheeled it over to the waiting orderlies. A man in scrubs followed them. They stopped briefly while Jack explained things to the doctor. While Jack was busy talking, she reached over and grasped the man's lifeless hand.
"You're good, Allison," she whispered. "I won't forget you."
When I first found BigCloset, it seems like it was full of stories I wanted to read and that -- to be candid -- made me feel more whole.
Nowadays, when I come here, I scan the list of stories, and half the time none of them make me even want to look at them. And I leave with a sense of restlessness, that there's something I'm looking for that I'm not finding, but I don't know what it is.
So I ask myself: has BigCloset changed? Or have I?
As always, I've been compulsively examining myself. Sometimes I think it's to figure out how to make it not hurt so much, or at least so I'll know what hurts. Other times I think it's just so I won't find myself so frighteningly confusing. Sometimes I think I've found something that makes it all make sense. Unfortunately, by the next day, it turns out to be -- or at least seems to be -- gibberish. Like the kid who tries to build towers out of blocks, but it always falls down sooner or later.
Maybe I've changed, but if so, I don't know in what way; I don't ever have a clear enough picture of who I used to be to tell.
There I was, standing on her front porch, a half-hour drive from home, for my first piano lesson. Not my first piano lesson ever, but my first in a long time -- and my first with the woman whose music I had fallen in love with.
I knew her from her playing for services at our church. Our church has many accomplished musicians -- singers, violinists, flute, trumpet -- but none of them seem to put their heart and soul into the music they play the way she does. I remember my first few visits to the church, and I remember how when she would play pieces as preludes to the service or for the offering, I felt almost seduced by her playing. It felt like she was putting her whole self into her playing, holding nothing back, so the she and the music were one. It felt like her spirit was speaking directly to my heart.
This is what I'd always wanted from music. Ever since I was a child, I was fascinated by the way music could take me in and play the strings of my heart and make me want to merge with it. It started with hearing my mother play, and even when she played poorly, I would hear it the way I imagined it wanted to be played. I started piano lessons in second grade and quickly gravitated towards the more emotional classical composers: Beethoven, Chopin, Brahms. I remember one of my favorite pieces was Beethoven's "Fairwell to the Piano." This was at the time when the hell of my childhood was at its most hellish, and I think I thought of Beethoven and myself as kindred spirits: encroaching deafness was slowly depriving him of what was most essential to him, the way the hell of my life was slowly depriving me of some essential part of my self.
I survived, I made it through college, got decent jobs, got a marriage and lost it, and in the process had children. But I always knew something was missing, though I didn't know what, and when I realized that the lack of that something was slowly killing me, I began the journey that led me to that church.
When I went up after the service to express my appreciation, she turned out to be kind, generous of spirit, but also a little shy and earnest, as if she were only ever fully herself in her playing. Ah, to have even only a tenth of that spirit -- and skill! I wanted it so much, I was afraid of showing it and seeming creepy, especially since she was married to a very nice man. I finally decided that the safest approach was to ask her for lessons, since I knew she taught piano for a living. So I dug out the piano music I'd accumulated over the years and spent a few weeks practicing a half-dozen pieces to the point that I wouldn't embarrass myself too much, and, with my heart in my mouth, asked her if she would give me lessons.
Wonder of wonders, she agreed, and, even more miraculously, I made it to her house without getting lost too much or forgetting my music or my driver's license. Here, in her home, she was if anything more considerate and empathic than at church. She led me to the bench and sat me down, then looked through the pile of music I'd brought.
"Play something you're familiar with," she asked. I felt relieved that she hadn't pulled out something I'd never played before, though if I were thinking halfway straight I would have realized that that would have made no sense from her point of view. I pulled out a book of Chopin etudes. I thought about number one, but then changed my mind and went to number two -- a real workout for the last three fingers of the right hand.
The bench was more of a chair, and she was sitting in another chair next to me, in the usual piano teacher position, but my feelings for her made it feel almost unbearable. I hoped she would interpret my awkwardness as the normal nervousness of a new student hoping not to make a bad first impression. It took me two tries to get started, and it was all I could do to not swear every few measures when I missed a note or got confused about an accidental.
I finally limped to the end. I felt disappointed -- partly because I was so far from impressing her, but partly because my actual playing was so miserable in comparison with how I heard the music in my head. It plunked, it didn't sing, let alone let my spirit run free. I would have cried, if crying hadn't been one of the things that got burned out of me during the hell years. I could still feel her next to me, but my disappointment made me feel miles away from her.
"That sounds good. You seem to have the idea. Now, why don't we work on getting it to flow more. Try just doing the top line, and concentrating on getting the 3-4-5 fingering to feel easy and fluid. That's actually the point of the etude."
We spent a good fifteen minutes working on that. My fingers would start to cramp up and she would have me stop and practice relaxing my fingers, the goal being to play with relaxed fingers. One time she massaged my fingers and hand, and the sudden sense of intimacy from feeling her touch me was a shock, almost like a blow. Afterwards, I relaxed by playing Brahms' Waltz in A-flat, one of those pieces I remember my mother playing, and we worked on getting it to "sing." I got frustrated because it wasn't coming out the way I heard it, and she noticed.
"It looks like you feel like something is wrong with how you're playing. I think you're doing pretty well, so what is upsetting you?"
I realized that the feeling was the sort of thing I usually try to hide, and then I thought, if I don't show this part of me now, when will I? "When I play it, it doesn't sound like I hear it in my head."
"Well, how do you hear it in your head? Try singing or humming it."
Now I really felt embarrassed, but I tried: "dum-m dah dah dah dum-m dah dah dah dum deedle dum dum dum," and so on. As I sang, I started going up into the music. She sat quietly while I went through it, repeats and all. Then we worked on getting my playing to sound a little more like that.
It wasn't until I had said goodbye and was walking down the steps and heading towards my car that I realized just how intense it had been for me. I felt like I was coming back to the ordinary Earth after having been in some higher plane for an hour.
I took lessons from her for half a year this way, once a week. My technique did improve, she was on top of everything else a gifted teacher. And it felt good to be with her; I would sometimes get goosebumps from listening to her. I wanted to please her, I wanted her to think I was doing well. At times, I felt more like a small child with her mother. But I was still no closer to putting my soul into it the way she could. Finally, I straight out asked her.
"I've always loved the way you seem to put your heart and soul into your playing. Actually, I've envied you a little. Is this something you could teach me?"
"I don't know if I know how to teach it. It's just always been the way I've played. But -- we can try."
So the next few lessons, she had me focus on the feeling and not worry about the notes. It mostly felt awful. Each wrong note was like chalk screeching on a blackboard. But every now and then, I'd get most of them right, half by accident, and would feel some part of myself flowing along with the notes.
Finally, she suggested that she play, and I stand behind her and put my hands on top of hers, so that perhaps I could feel how she played and get a sense of it that way. It sounded logical, but when it came time for me to actually put my hands on top of hers, I realized how close I would have to be to her and I suddenly thought of the legend of Semele.
I was starting to wonder if this was such a good idea, but I couldn't think of a good reason not to. It was intense. I had to stand front-to-back with her to be able to reach her hands, which was overwhelming enough, but laying my hands on top of hers felt, if anything, even more intimate.
Then she started to play. I'm not sure how much I picked up from feeling her fingers and hands move, as listening to her play was an experience. I think it must have been something she loved to play, because I felt myself being swept along and barely aware of where I was.
And then it was over. I stood up and we both looked around a bit and saw that her husband was home. He looked at us and I thought I was going to die. He finally said, "hey, you never let me get that close when you're playing."
She looked right back and said, "hey, you've never asked me for piano lessons, either!" And they both laughed.
He kind of slapped me on the back and asked how the lessons were going. I couldn't manage a word. After a few awkward minutes, I gathered up my music. "I guess I'd better get home," I said.
"See you next week," she said. We said goodbye and I left. All the way home, I argued in my head as to whether I would actually come back. In the end, though, I made some excuse, I can't remember what, and said I couldn't make it and never scheduled another lesson.
I still attend church, sometimes, but I sit in the back row when I do, and I keep quiet, the way I tried to do when I was small, and when it's time to sing the hymns, I sing quietly, so no one can really hear my voice. If I were more of a man, I suppose I would face up to the awkwardness and work something out with her and her husband. If I were more of a man, I would sing bass clef and sing so I could be heard. But I'm not.
My friends had all decided to go to the diner, the one we always go to, and I was tagging along. We found a wide booth and squeezed in, three to a side, even though it was really only supposed to hold two. It was cozy with Ben and Jenny on one side and the wall on the other. It felt nice to be included. I sat there and listened as Ben and Jenny flirted with one another and the guys on the other side talked about sports, a topic I didn't know much about and wasn't all that interested in anyway.
We saw what we thought was the waitress come over to our table, but instead it was a woman about my height in a white pants suit, and instead of dealing out menus and asking us what we wanted to drink, she said, "Adam? Please come with me." She looked right at me, so she knew who I was. Ben and Jenny silently slid out to let me out of the booth and then slid back in.
Once I was out of the booth, I got a better look at her. She had thick black hair that billowed out around her face and short bangs that left most of her forehead exposed. The suit jacket had really wide lapels, in sort of an exaggerated disco style, and the pants had big hips. She had tiny silvery things in her ears, probably studs, and a thin silver bracelet on her left wrist.
"Am I in trouble?" I asked.
She gave me a tired smile and said, "no, if anything, the opposite. Please come along, we don't have time to waste." She turned and walked away from the table and I had to hustle to catch up.
I wondered what this was all about. As far as I could remember, my life was quite unremarkable and unmemorable. I'd never done anything particularly bad, but I hadn't done anything particularly good, either. I didn't think I'd made much of an impression on anyone and sometimes wondered if anyone would notice if I simply vanished. Indeed, none of the friends I'd come to the diner with had seemed to pay any attention to my being led off by some strange woman, leaving me with the suspicion that by now they no longer even remembered me coming in the first place.
As I finished thinking this, I looked around and saw we weren't in the diner any more. Indeed, I wasn't sure we were anywhere at all. We were walking side by side through an endless grayness. It didn't seem like a grayness that was hiding anything so much of an absence of anything. I tried to see if I could see anything through the grayness and I started to see vague outlines of houses, trees, lampposts. But when I relaxed, they faded back into the uniform gray. As an experiment, I tried to see mountains and chalets and after a while I thought I could see them, instead.
"Where are you taking me?" I asked.
"It's hard to explain. You'll see." She said nothing more and I had the distinct impression that that was as much of an explanation as I was going to get.
I remembered a story I'd read recently where a kind of 'enforcer' finds a lost girl and comforts her and holds her and gets her to feel safe and relaxed. And then breaks her neck. I had the impression you were supposed to see it as a mercy killing, but instead it had if anything simply reinforced my fear and distrust of the kindness of strangers. I felt like crying.
"Am I -- am I going to die? Is that where you're taking me?"
"We all die, sooner or later," she said, not breaking her stride or even turning her head. "But that's not where I'm taking you. Don't worry." I wasn't exactly reassured, but I couldn't think of anything to say to that. We continued walking.
After a while, I began to feel a little uncomfortable about the silence. I thought I should try to strike up a conversation.
"What's your name?" I asked. "What should I call you?"
She stopped and faced me. "What would you like to call me?" She was looking at me like she was seeing me more than anyone ever had before. It was unsettling. It took me a while to find an answer.
"You remind me of Diane Keaton in Annie Hall. Could I call you Annie?"
She gave me the first full-hearted smile I'd seen so far. "I would like that," she said and stroked the back of my head. I noticed that she was at least a head taller than me now and I had to look sharply upward to see her face. She took my hand and we resumed walking.
"My mother's name was Anne. Not Annie, though."
"I know. But I'm not your mother."
The featureless gray void around us and the featureless gray floor, or ground, or whatever it was, never changed. It began to get to me. I looked at where we were going and even turned around to see where we'd come from. It all looked alike wherever I looked. I started to worry that we were walking in circles, or perhaps walking in place, like Marcel Marceau.
"I can't see where we're going. Are you sure this is the right way? I'm afraid we're lost."
"No, we're not lost. I know the way. You don't need to see it, you just need to come with me."
"But how will we get back to the diner? Do you know the way back?"
"I don't need to. We won't be going back."
"I'm scared," I said. I hadn't planned to say anything, it just popped out. My voice sounded high and whiny.
She turned to me and pulled me to her. I buried my face in her stomach and sniffled. She caressed my head and shoulders and toussled my thin, wispy hair. "I understand you're scared. But, really, it's going to be all right. It's going to be all right. I'll be with you the whole time."
It took me a while, but I stopped crying and we went on, her holding my hand. Her steps were shorter than before, more like strolling than the purposeful strides we'd made when we started, but I was still having to hustle to keep up with her, and when I couldn't, she'd look down and slow down for me to catch up. My legs looked awfully short to me and my hands were sort of pudgy. I'd wondered whether she was getting bigger or I was getting smaller, but it now looked like it was me getting smaller. I looked over at her and saw that my face was even with her hips.
"Am I getting smaller? Or growing younger? I think I am."
I had stopped, so she had to stop, too. "Yes, you're growing younger, honey."
"But -- why?"
"It's necessary," she said gently. "You'll see." She started walking and I had to trot to catch up.
"Will I -- will I keep getting younger? Will I keep getting younger until I'm the way I was before I was born?"
"No, it won't go that far. We're almost where we need to go. When we get there, it will stop. It will be all right."
By now, just walking was difficult, even if I wasn't trying to keep up. I gave up and stood still and started to cry.
"Why am I like this? What is going on? What is happening to me?" My voice sounded funny and I had trouble making the words sound right.
She stopped walking and looked down at me. "You can't keep going?" she asked.
I shook my head. I plopped down on my butt. It didn't hurt like it would have when I was full size. "I'm sorry," I sobbed. "I know I'm supposed to, but I can't."
She squatted down in front of me. She was still taller than me, but at least she wasn't so much taller and I could look her in the face without hurting my neck. She gave me a penetrating look, but then sighed and looked more sympathetic.
"Come here, little one," she said and picked me up like a toddler and held me to her chest with one hand under my butt and the other stroking my back, so I was looking over her shoulder. I kept thinking it was silly, but it did make me feel better.
"How old am I?" I asked after she started walking again.
"You look like you're maybe two or three, and your emotional maturity is not much older. But your awareness isn't much younger than when we started." I could feel her voice vibrating her chest where I was pressed against her. Her voice was low and soothing. I was still scared, but I felt a lot safer now that she was carrying me.
She started talking as if to herself. "Sometimes, to make things right, you have to go all the way back to where they went wrong. Sometimes that means you have to go pretty far back."
I started to feel bad about having to be handled like a baby. "I'm sorry to be so much trouble," I said.
"It's no trouble. You're doing the best you can. Just relax, we'll be there in no time. We're pretty close."
I wasn't sure that being there soon was all that comforting, I was pretty anxious about what would happen there, but it didn't seem like I had any alternative.
It did seem like the gray around me was getting brighter. I couldn't look all the way around me, but as far as I could tell, the brightness was all around us. I still had no clue what she was seeing to tell her where to go. She kept walking. I had no sense of time, but it did get brighter and brighter until it was as bright as a beach on a sunny day and I had to bury my eyes in her shoulder to protect them from the light.
At last, she stopped and put me down. I turned around and saw sort of a pond, about the size of a duck pond. There was no shore. It looked like it was just a depression in the featureless gray floor we'd been walking on which had collected rain water, like a bird bath.
"You need to go in there. Let's get your clothes off." I felt embarrassed that she would see me naked, but it wasn't like I could do anything about it. I tried to help, but my chubby fingers weren't able to handle the buttons or to pull myself out of my shirt and pants.
"Is that water going to change me?" I asked as she was getting my underwear off. I noticed that my belly and genitals looked like a baby boy's.
"No, it won't change anything. It's more like a ceremony. A symbol of what is going to happen."
"So why do I have to do it?" I whined.
"What has to happen won't happen if you don't."
Now naked, I sat down on the edge of the pond. The floor or ground or whatever it was felt neither warm nor cold. I put my feet in the water. It felt like tepid water. It splashed like water. I didn't feel like it was changing me in any way.
I turned and saw that she had just finished taking off her shoes and socks and was starting on rolling up her pants. "I'll walk you in in just a minute." I went back to looking at the water. My feet had made little ripples which reflected the diffuse light surrounding us into little lines across the water.
I felt her come up beside me and take my hand. I stood up without her asking and we took slow steps into the pond. Other than the splashing of our feet in the water, there was no sound. Once we got to where the water was up to my chest, we stopped.
"Dunk yourself in the water. Just hold your breath and squat down. Once you're wet all over, stand back up."
I took a deep breath and dropped down on my haunches. I opened my eyes. I could see her bare legs through the watery blue. Otherwise, there was nothing to see. I looked a little longer, remembering how long I used to be able to swim underwater. I felt her tug on my arm, so I stood back up.
"I don't feel any different," I said. "Maybe wetter."
"That you are," she said with a chuckle, somehow sounding more relaxed and cheerful than she had before. "Let's get you back out and dressed." We splashed back to the spot on the shore where my toddler-sized clothing lay in a heap.
"Do you have a towel? I'm still wet."
"We'll just wait here until you're dry."
"Is this what we came here for? Can you tell me now what's going on?" My words sounded funny coming out in a little baby voice.
She found a spot where there weren't any puddles from our drip-drying and sat down cross-legged on the ground. "Honey: didn't you ever have the feeling you didn't really fit? Like you weren't really there?"
"Yes. Sometimes I thought I was a ghost. Like, how come none of my friends wanted to know why you were there, or why I went off with you?" I felt so lonely, so empty, so afraid.
"Somehow, when you were very young, something went -- off. You got lost and nobody saw or came to find you. You never got the chance to become who you were meant to be."
I was a little distracted. I was looking at my naked toddler body and the little drops of water and wondering how long it would take for them to evaporate. I would have expected to feel chilly, but somehow the air felt as lukewarm as the water. It took a while for her words to sink in, I don't know how long. Time didn't seem to have its usual meaning.
"Nobody came to find me?" I suddenly felt very, very sad. Then the word 'nobody' struck me. "But -- didn't you come?"
A warm smile filled her face and she nodded.
I thought some more. My toddler brain wasn't having an easy time of it. "So -- does that mean I have that chance now?"
She nodded again.
"Do I have to do something? To become, I mean."
"You'll know what to do. Just listen to your heart."
"I think I'm dry now," I said after a while. Annie came over and helped me back into my toddler-size clothes, or rather, she put them on me while I tried to move my limbs into whatever position made the job easiest for her.
"What do we do now?" I asked once I was dressed.
"We go," she said.
"But which way?"
"You tell me. I led you here, now it's your turn to lead."
"Oh, thanks a lot!" It sounded funny, hearing adult words spoken in a toddler voice. "How do I do that?"
"Pick a direction. You'll know the way. If you listen to your heart, that is."
"New age religion now. You're being very helpful." Annie laughed gently. I turned around a few times slowly. No direction seemed better than any other. Finally, I just picked one at random. "That way," I pointed. I took her hand and we started walking.
"Now that I'm leading, do you have to go away? Can you stay with me?"
"Of course. I'll stay with you for as long as you need me. You don't have to go it alone. Just remember you're leading, not me."
As we walked, I tried to figure out how to listen to my heart. I mean, if I tried, I could hear a 'lub-lub, lub-lub,' but I don't think that's what she meant.
I closed my eyes and had a vision of a kindergarden girl dressed for ballet, in pink leotard and tights and a pink child's tutu, the kind you make with a length of nylon net folded over some elastic, and with her wispy yellow hair held out of the way with green and blue plastic barrettes with bas reliefs of frogs on them. I got a warm feeling all the way down to my groin. I opened my eyes and saw that I was dressed the same way. I'd grown back to kindergardener size and I looked exactly like the girl in my vision. I glanced over to Annie, who was giving me an indulgent smile. I stopped and looked at myself. Then I got afraid of my daring and when I did, I faded back into a drab little boy. When I saw that, all the joy drained out of me and I started to cry.
"You'll get better at it," Annie reassured me.
I looked up at her through teary eyes. "Can I have a hug?"
"Of course," she said and picked me up and held me tight until I felt better. It didn't erase my disappointment, but it did make me feel better. "Uff! You're a lot heavier that you were the last time I carried you," she laughed as she put me back down.
"I'm sorry."
"Don't be. It was my privilege," she said cheerfully. She seemed a lot more carefree than she had been on the way in. Like she'd been carrying a weight and she wasn't any more.
I started walking again and so did she. I didn't know if I was going the right way, or even the same way as before, but I didn't worry about it any more. The gray had gotten dimmer, back to the way it had been before.
I tried to recall the vision of the kindergardener in the tutu, but it was hard, and when I finally could see it, it felt unhappy and reluctant, like it had felt hurt and pushed away when I'd gotten scared.
"I want to bring the girl back, but I can't," I said.
"Don't push it. Just listen. Your heart will speak to you again when it's ready. It's very forgiving."
I tried to imagine myself as a Disney prince. I sort of got the picture in my mind. But then a Disney princess appeared, in my mind, and he went off with her. Yeah, pushing it wasn't working.
We were walking together, holding hands. I was gently swinging our joined arms back and forth. "I know you're not my mommy," I said. "But I kind of wish you were."
As soon as I said it, I was afraid she'd vanish, like in a fairy tale. But when I looked over at her, she was smiling. "How about a favorite aunt?"
"Aunt Annie...." I recited and got a good feeling all the way down to my toes. On an impulse, I turned to her and said, "I love you, Aunt Annie." I reached out to hug her.
She stopped and hugged me back, a long loving hug where we melted into each other. I was a little taller, up to the height of her chest. She said, "I love you, too. You know -- I don't know what I should call you. I somehow think you aren't an Adam any more."
"I better let my heart answer." We hugged a little longer, and the warmth of that hug kept flowing into me. I had a vision of myself as a seedling that was being warmed by the sun. I felt my hair brushing my shoulders. She stroked my back and I was aware of my body, my back and front and all, very aware that it was real and it was my body.
"We'll have to break this up sooner or later if you ever want to get home." I wasn't sure where 'home' was any more, but I let go of her anyway and we went back to walking. We were walking hand in hand, a little like a child with their mother and a little like two BFFs. I was thinking of Marcel Marceau walking and drawing a box with his hands. I looked at my free hand. It looked exactly the same as before. But it felt different. I had this strong feeling, like: wow, it's my hand!
"Eve!" I blurted out without thinking. Did I say that? I mused on this. "I guess my heart wants me to be called Eve. Like Adam and Eve. But I'm not a girl."
"Would you like to be?"
"I don't know. I never really wanted to be, not before. I never really wanted to be much of anything, I guess. Except maybe real. But -- maybe my heart.... It's so weird. Isn't it?" I looked to her for an answer.
"You're leading, it's for you to answer."
"I guess I was lost a long time, so being found is going to feel weird for a while." I thought about it for a while. "So I guess I'm not what -- or who -- I thought I was. I guess I'm going to be Eve now. And different in a lot of other ways, too.... It still feels weird, but not quite so weird as before."
I glanced down at myself as I walked. I was taller now, almost teenager size, and I could almost see a gauzy peasant dress superimposed over my drab dungarees. I had a feeling the dungarees were my past and the dress was my future. I wasn't sure how I felt about that, but it didn't seem like how I felt would make any difference.
I still couldn't tell which way was the right one. All directions still looked exactly the same. No matter where I looked, everything was the same featureless gray. From somewhere came the thought: maybe it doesn't matter so much which direction we walk in as that I chose it. I wondered where we'd end up, though.
"Do you think we'll get back to the diner, and my friends will still be there?"
"What do you think?"
I thought for a moment. Words came into my mind from somewhere. "I think when I get back, we won't be at the diner at all. And if I do go to the diner someday, it won't be anything like it was when you fetched me." I waited for more words to come to me. "I'll be different. I'll want different things. No, I'll actually want things. I'll like some things and I'll hate some things. I won't be able to hide any more. People will see me. I'll have different friends, and the people who used to be my friends, if we're still friends, I'll be a different kind of friend to them." I felt a little sad, but just a little. Maybe a little lost. "I won't be able to be Adam any more, will I? I'll be Eve, instead," I said wistfully. "But I'll be me."
As I was saying it, the formless gray we were walking through seemed to be ending and there was something more distinct ahead of us. I stopped and peered into the distance. A home? A school? A church parish hall? I couldn't tell for sure, but it felt welcoming. Challenging, too. Indistinct as it was, though, it felt more solid, more real than anywhere I'd been back before Annie fetched me from the diner. I felt afraid. Was I ready to face a new, more real world as the new, more real me? I looked at my new aunt. "Am I ready for this?" I asked.
She smiled at me. "Ask your heart."
"I don't know. But I'm not sure it matters. I have to go ahead whether I feel ready or not." I swallowed nervously. "If I fall, will you be there to help me back up?"
"Of course. But I don't think you will."
I slowly felt a smile starting in my chest and spreading out all through me. "I'm going to do this right," I said. As I took my first steps forward into my future, my heart pounding with fear, I picked up my courage and shouted, "ready or not, here I come!"
I spent some time binge-reading Dorothy Colleen's stuff this morning, and it inspired me to write something like her stories, but it didn't turn out that way. I guess the muse had other ideas. Oh, well, what can you expect for 3 hours' work?
Once upon a time, I was a young man, rather like you (well, some of you.) But not much of one. I had a dead-end job in some office, doing meaningless work for some clanking machine of a corporation. I had no friends to speak of, merely people who knew my name from work or local hangouts. I always felt something vital was missing from my life, that I was an empty shell. And so on weekends and vacations I would travel, hoping I'd find that missing something.
On one of those vacations, I was hiking in the mountains and chanced upon a round valley enclosed by mountains, with peasant farms and a rather medievalish town by the meandering river, and, on a rise in the very center of the valley, an almost cartoonish castle.
I wandered along dirt paths connecting fields to the cottages and barns and cottages to one another, enjoying the day and watching the peasants hard at work in their fields. I could tell they saw me, but none seemed to think I was all that remarkable. When I got tired, I sat down on a convenient log and ate the sandwiches from my backpack. Later, I found my way to a wagon track running along side the willow-lined river. By the time I got to the town, the sun was getting lower and my stomach was telling me it was dinner time, so I went into the local tavern and sat at one of the long tables which already had a fair number of people dressed in various types of old-fashioned working dress and asked for some dinner. I showed the innkeeper my collection of coins from all over and he picked one out, saying that it was enough to pay for dinner and even a night's lodging.
As I ate, I asked the people around me about the castle.
"Been there since I was small," shrugged one, more interested in his neighbor's tale of an uncooperative cow.
"Nope, never been inside. Don't know anyone who has," went the next. Everyone I spoke to showed a strange lack of curiosity about it.
The next morning, I headed for the castle. None of the paths led towards it, I had to zig-zag and finally simply bushwhack through the underbrush and weeds until I reached the flagstones in front of the heavy wooden door. From up close, I could see that the turrets were too small and delicate to be more than mere decorations. The partly open door sported a thick collection of cobwebs, but otherwise the castle was remarkably clear of vines or moss or any other signs of age. I pushed open the door and walked through a stone-walled passage to a large, brightly-lit room with an empty banquet table in the middle, surrounded by chairs, and around the edge, a comfortable-looking bed with a brocaded bedspread and a thick rug in front of it, a writing desk with a huge ancient-looking book opened on it, a long wardrobe, and on the wall near the passage into the room, a large full-length mirror. The light came from the high ceiling, which had large windows around the edge and white globes hanging like chandeliers.
By now I was more than a little hungry. I had seen no doors other than the one I came in by, and no evidence of a kitchen, so where would a banquet come to fill the banquet table? At that point, I didn't need a banquet, I would have been happy just to have more sandwiches like the ones I'd had yesterday. I sat down at the table and looked around the room. When I looked back at the table, I saw in front of me a china plate with sandwiches exactly like what I'd thought of, and next to it a crystal goblet full of water. No silverware, I noticed, but then one doesn't need silverware to eat a sandwich. I looked around the room again, then back at the table. The sandwiches and the goblet were still there. I said a silent thank you to whoever or whatever had provided the sandwiches and tucked in.
After lunch, I wandered over to the book. It was written in a crabbed script that resembled no alphabet I had ever seen, and there were odd diagrams sprinked about that I could make no sense of. I tried to turn the page, but it wouldn't move. When I tried harder, I ended up turning a whole packet of pages. They weren't stuck together like a book that has gotten wet, because they slid smoothly and lay flat when I turned them.
As I leafed through the pages that would consent to be laid open, I noticed that some of the other pages had yet another script, written in a different ink. Some were elaborately illuminated, others looked like scrawled lab notes.
By this time, I was tired and sleepy, so I took off my boots and lay down on the bed. It was the most comfortable bed I'd ever slept on and I was asleep in moments.
When I awoke, I could see from the light in the windows that it was getting to be evening. I didn't fancy dragging myself back down to the tavern, so I tried sitting at the table, closing my eyes, and wishing for a dinner like the one from last night. When I opened them, it lay before me, except far better cooked, and the goblet had red wine in it.
After I'd eaten, I realized that I was dirty and stinky, not having washed in several days, and, more urgently, I needed to find a toilet. When I looked around, I saw an opening that I somehow hadn't seen before in the wall opposite the entrance. Going through the opening, I saw on the left a remarkably clean toilet with a full roll of toilet paper and a sink with a fluffy white towel on the towel bar. On the right was a large bathtub with steaming water. I used the toilet, washed my hands, then took off my clothes and got in the tub. There were bottles of bath oils and shampoos and such arranged on the side of the tub and I tried them all out. By now it didn't surprise me to find a huge bath towel, which got me quite dry, a bathrobe, and fuzzy slippers. By now it was dark and the white globes were lighting the room like moonlight. On the bed was a silky nightgown. I dressed for bed and crawled in. The moonlight dimmed and I fell asleep.
The next morning, I wished for bacon and eggs and pancakes and there they were, including a caraffe of real maple syrup. After breakfast, I looked in the wardrobe and found not only my own clothes, now clean and smelling like they'd been line-dried, but two sets of clothes in the style of what the men in town wore, and on a shelf a leather purse with coins like the one the innkeeper had taken. And when I looked out the door, I saw that there was now a flagstone path leading down to one of the wagon roads.
I spent the day wandering the valley, enjoying the sights. In the afternoon, while I sat on the edge of a well, a pretty country girl came up to me to fetch water. I'd never had any luck with the fair sex, but she seemed to find whatever I said fascinating. We talked for a while, until we found ourselves in each others arms. I helped her bring water back to her family's cottage and then she led me to the barn, where, hidden among the piles of hay, we made love.
Over the next few weeks, I found that things seemed to always arrange themselves as I wished. Farmers' wagons came by going my way whenever I was tired of walking, when I wanted a beer in the tavern, someone was always standing a round of drinks. And whenever I took a fancy to a pretty girl, she seemed to be as interested as I. I suspected all this had to do with my living in the castle, so I made a point of always spending some time there. I did find out that I could stay away for a few days and still have use of its magic.
But I found that all this didn't appease the hunger I'd always felt. I came to realize that I envied the girls I bedded. I didn't so much want to have them as be like them. And so, one night, as I went to bed, I laid out my wish on my mind: I thought of a few of the young women I'd been with and put together an image that wasn't exactly like any of them but was a little like them all.
Next morning, I awoke to find blond hair halfway down my back, two largish breasts on my chest, and of course a pretty little crack at my crotch. The wardrobe contained typical young women's clothes for the area. I dressed and went down to the town, where all manner of young men flirted with me. When the innkeeper saw me, he wanted to know why I was socializing with the boys instead of serving in the tavern, so I went in and to work and he settled down. The work turned out not to be hard, the customers treated me kindly, so I didn't mind.
But when I got back to the castle, late at night, I glanced at the mirror and saw -- me, as I'd always been, but dressed in women's clothes, and the clothes, which looked pretty on a curvaceous young girl, simply looked ridiculous on that scrawny man. I found a towel and covered the mirror up.
Days turned to weeks, weeks turned to months, until I lost track of the time. When I got bored with being a tavern girl, I tried being a milkmaid, and then, when that palled, a wealthy lady with servants. I made love to young men, to old men, and to women.
But every few weeks, my curiosity would take over and I'd look at the mirror. And each time, the man in the mirror would look a little more grotesque. He became fat, with a beer belly. His hair receded and became thinner. And his face and body began to look less human and more like some orc or goblin or troll from a Tolkien movie. I tried to put it out of my mind, but I kept finding that in my happiest moments as a woman, the image of the ever more troll-like person that the mirror had shown me would intrude on my thoughts and spoil my pleasure.
Finally, I could stand it no longer. One night, when I looked in the mirror and saw a monster with a gray-green wrinkled, wart-covered face, randomly placed tufts of hair, hulking body, clawed hands on scaly arms, I took a chair and smashed the mirror. It took several tries, but eventually the frame was empty and the floor covered with shards.
Then darkness filled the room, lit only by sparkling light from the shards. The room dissolved into a kaleidescope of colors until I didn't know which way was up. I started to get dizzy and closed my eyes and eventually felt my bum hit the floor -- hard. I clutched my knees until it stopped feeling like everything was spinning around me.
When I opened my eyes, I saw that I was sitting on the floor in my drab studio apartment, my butt was hurting, and the first light of dawn was shining in my window. I turned on the radio and when they eventually said the date, I realized it was the first day of work after my vacation.
Over the next few weeks, I kept trying to replay the adventure in my mind. In my spare time, I tried to figure out exactly where I'd gone and how I might get back to that hidden valley. But I came to also realize that I now knew what it was that had always been missing. I eventually found a transgender support group, but the first few times were really hard. I would look at the 'women' there and think, they look like what I saw in that mirror, I can't come back, it's too awful. But then I'd come again, and by the fourth or fifth visit, I saw people, not monsters, and by the tenth when I looked at the people transitioning to be women I saw -- women.
I began to see that this was a path that I might be able to travel. It would be hard, and I wouldn't ever look or feel like what the magic in that magical valley gave me. I'd always see hints of the orc in the mirror.
But it would be real.
Admin Note: Originally published on BigCloset TopShelf on Friday 07-31-2015 at 08:29:08 -0400 am, this retro classic was pulled out of the closet, and re-presented for our newer readers. ~Sephrena
2015-07-31 08:29:08 -0400
This story was inspired by KT Leone's story "The Christmas Conversation." I found the story charming, but couldn't really believe the pastor's instant conversion from seeing the trans girl's desire to be a girl as a sin to accepting her. This is my attempt to imagine how a pastor from a conservative Christian tradition might come to see that it was not only not a sin, but how God wanted her to be.
Reverend Warren Hanley prepared himself for his next appointment. Marisa Taylor, Gary Taylor's wife, wanted to talk about her son, Jesse. Although she hadn't said what it was about, he could guess. Hopewell was a small enough town that pretty much everybody knew everybody's business, and a boy who showed no interest in the usual boyish activities and had a delicate manner more like a girl was going to get talked about. Reverend Hanley considered himself a servant of the God of Love rather than of the stern judging God, so he had a feeling this was going to be a difficult talk.
"Come in, Miz Taylor," he said as he opened the door and gestured for her to sit in an overstuffed chair near his desk.
"It's about my son, Reverend," said Marisa nervously. "I've tried to bring him up right, and Gary did what he could, at least until he was deployed, but --"
Reverend Hanley waited patiently. He gave her a smile to indicate she could take as long as she needed.
"Well, you know he doesn't like sports or roughhousing. I mean, he's been trying to play baseball, but his heart isn't in it. And I've noticed he has this sad look. I'd say: haunted. Like there was something real heavy on his mind. Well, I told him if he had something he needed to say, he could talk to me any time. I've said it a few times, especially since Gary left. One day, he sat me down in the kitchen." Reverend Hanley couldn't help smiling at the image of this shy, slender seven-year-old telling his mother to sit down. "And he asked me to promise not to get mad, but he had to tell me something. And I said, did you do something bad? And he said, kinda, but it's not what you think. And I said, spit it out, son. And he said, I think I'm a girl. Well, I didn't know what to say at first. But I could see he was really upset, so I put him on my lap and hugged him. And then I asked why he thought so, and he said, I don't know, I just know it. I keep trying to be a boy like I'm supposed to, but inside I know it's a lie."
She gave the pastor a supplicating look. The pastor asked, "and what did you do then?"
"I didn't know what to do. The next time I got to talk to Gary, a week later, I asked him, and he said to talk to the doctor. And the doctor told me to take him to see Dr. Hancock, who's a child psychologist, over in Milburn. The Army insurance is paying for it. I hoped she could help him get straightened out."
The pastor wasn't sure a psychologist was such a good idea. While he wasn't opposed to them on principle, he thought they sometimes gave bad advice that conflicted with the Lord's law. But he didn't want to distress her, so he said, "I can see you're trying to do your best for your son."
"Anyway, after a few weeks, she -- Dr. Hancock -- told me Jesse was probably 'transgender.' That means that even though he's a boy on the outside, he's a girl on the inside. And whether he is or not, we'd best let him spend some time being a girl. If he's not transgender, he'll get bored with it. Well, I got him some girl clothes -- a dress and some tights and some, you know, and I let him dress up in the evening. I was worried I was hurting him, but the minute he got dressed up, that sad look vanished and he looked happier than he'd been in months. But when he had to get back into his boy clothes, he got sad again. I've been letting him do it most evenings, when we don't have company or anything, and we close the curtains. I even got him a girl's nightgown, so he's happy all night. He decided he'd like to be called Jessica, at least when he's being a girl."
Marisa began to cry. Reverend Hanley reached her a box of tissues.
"I feel so torn, Reverend. On the one hand, I know the Lord says he should accept the body the Good Lord gave him and be happy being a boy. On the other hand -- on the other hand, I just want my boy to be happy, and this is what makes him happy. When he's trying to be a boy, I feel like I'm losing my son, but when he's being a girl, I feel like I have my boy -- I mean my child -- back. Tell me: what should I do?"
"Miz Taylor, I know you love your boy and you don't want to do anything to hurt him. He's got the best mother a boy could have. But sometimes -- well, sometimes the Lord gives us hard things to do. Sometimes He lays heavy burdens on us, and we just have to carry them. Miz Carrington lost her husband and her son to cancer, and they suffered mightily for a long time. I can't tell her why the Lord made them suffer like that, and I can't tell your Jesse why the Lord put this burden on him. The Lord made him a boy, and he needs to pray to the Lord for strength to resist this temptation."
"What should I do about the -- the dresses and such?"
"I'd suggest you give them to the church clothing drive. There are always poor families that could use them. Just remember: the Lord knows we stumble, and He doesn't hold it against us when we do. But it's our job to stand back up again and sin no more."
Marisa thanked the pastor and went out, but he could see from the way her shoulders slumped that she wasn't comforted. He sighed to himself. Yes, sometimes the Lord gives us heavy burdens. As the door closed he bowed his head and said a prayer for Mrs. Taylor and her son.
(To be continued)
Reverend Hanley loved Advent. It held all the joy of Christmas but without the crass commercialism that had consumed Christmas, even in Hopewell, Alabama. The younger children were in the front of the church, in front of the pews, sitting on the floor. One of the more responsible six-year-old girls had been chosen for the honor of lighting this Sunday's one Advent candle. Then the congregation sang a children's hymn and then one of the older boys came up and read the Scripture passage. As soon as the boy started to speak, Reverend Hanley realized he should perhaps have left it for after the children had left. It was the passage which includes Jesus saying, if you have lusted after a woman in your heart, you have already committed adultery. He was worried about what the children would make of it, and so decided to scrap the children's sermon he had planned and make up one that would shift the emphasis away from sex.
"Have any of you had your parents say, stop hitting your brother or sister on the head, and then you hit him or her on the foot so you can say, well I didn't hit him on the head?"
The children all laughed at that. Reverend Hanley glanced up at the pews and saw Mrs. Taylor sitting a few rows back and Jesse sitting on her lap. He suddenly realized what Mrs. Taylor meant by a "haunted look." His look reminded him of those refugee children, orphans who had seen their family killed in war. All through the sermon, that look troubled him.
"So Jesus is saying, it's not enough to just not do the things God tells you not to do," he concluded. "You also have to not even think of doing them." On that note, he signaled to the organist to begin the hymn for the children to go out to the Sunday School wing.
As the last of the parishoners shook his hand at the end of the service, Reverend Hanley saw Jesse come over to him, followed by his mother. He still had that bleak look on his face.
"Reverend, can I talk to you for a minute?" Jesse asked.
"Certainly, my son," replied the pastor.
"Uh, somewhere a little private? I don't want everyone to hear."
They walked to the edge of the porch, on the opposite side from the playground.
"Reverend, my Ma told you about me thinking I was, well, you know." The pastor nodded. "Well, if me being a girl is a sin, and thinking of sinning is as bad as doing it, don't that mean--"
"Doesn't" the pastor automatically corrected him.
"Doesn't that mean I'm gonna go to Hell? I can't stop thinking of how much I want to." His voice started to break up. "I pray to God to help me not want to, but I do, all the time. I don't want to go to Hell. Please, can you talk to God and ask him to help me?"
The pastor didn't know what to say. On the one hand, he wanted to say something to make Jesse feel less afraid. On the other, he couldn't contradict what he'd said in the Children's sermon or to his mother. The logic of the Lord's law and the Lord's word said he was going to go to Hell, and he couldn't see any way around it.
"Son, I think the Lord knows the burdens we carry. I can't see Him sending you to Hell if you're doing the best you can." But Jesse didn't look very comforted.
The pastor couldn't shake the memory of Jesse's bleak look or the conversation on Sunday from his mind. It followed him home, it intruded as he drove in on Monday and again during the planning of the Altar Guild supper. As he planned the program for Wednesday night Bible study, after each item on the program, the memory would intrude.
Finally, on Thursday, he left a message for Dr. Hancock to call him.
"I'm calling about Jesse Taylor, one of your patients," he explained when she called him back.
"You know I'm not allowed to talk about one of my patients without their permission, or, in Jesse's case, his mother's."
"I'm not asking about him in particular. But his mother said you thought he was -- transgender, and I thought I should find out a little more about trangender children. Have you had a lot of them?"
"I've treated a few. And I've spoken with colleagues on occasion. I'd say I know about maybe twenty, either from my practice or my colleagues. I've also attended talks about transgender children and adults at conferences."
"How successful are you at curing them?"
"Reverend Hanley, I haven't tried, but people have tried in the past. The success rate is so low and the outcomes so bad, it's no longer considered ethical. We now simply support the child in whatever he or she--"
"She?"
"Transgender children come in both genders. Trans girls are children who are assigned male at birth but transition to female. Trans boys are children who are assigned female--"
"I get the picture." The idea of girls wanting to be boys was, for reasons the pastor wasn't sure he wanted to think about, even more distressing than the other way around.
"As I was saying, we support the child. Some change their mind on their own. Most don't. In those cases, we help their families and communities learn to accept it."
"And if they don't?"
She sighed. "When they don't -- it's not good. Some run away, or leave as soon as they're able to make it on their own. Others -- the ones I know about, at least -- most of them die. Usually suicide, but sometimes they become alcoholic or drug addicts and die in alcohol or drug-related accidents. Or they engage in risky behavior. Many of the colored trans people end up murdered. The suicide and murder rates -- being murdered, I mean -- are really high."
"And how do you see Jesse turning out?"
"I told you, I can't talk about him with you. You, of all people, should understand that."
"I'm sorry, ma'am, you did explain that. Thank you for speaking with me, you've been very helpful. And you've been very generous with your time. I won't take any more of it. Goodbye."
"Doesn't that mean, 'God be with you'?"
"That it does, ma'am, that it does."
"Well, may God be with you, sir," she said and hung up.
The conversation with the psychologist stuck in the back of the pastor's mind for the rest of the week, but faded into the background as he worked on Sunday's sermons. The adult sermon was to be about advent as a time of anticipation of the Lord's gift of His only son. The children's sermon would be on a similar theme, but using the children's anticipation of gifts from Santa to make it clearer to them.
On Sunday, as he started telling his sermon to the children, once again he noticed Jesse on his mother's lap and his bleak, haunted look. The part of the his mind that was not occupied with his performance jumped back to the conversation with the psychologist, especially the part where she said, "most of them die." He suddenly had a vision of that bleak face staring out of the corpse of a child. He'd had to see dead children on occasion, especially when he worked as a hospital chaplain, and the sight had always given him an un-Christian sense of despair. He knew that this was simply the Lord bringing His Own home, but he couldn't help feeling like each dead child was a precious gift of God destroyed before it had even been opened. The idea that his position on Jesse's belief that he was a girl, however Biblically and doctrinally correct, might be even partly responsible for Jesse becoming another one of them disturbed him.
After church, he asked Mrs. Taylor if she could come in at her convenience. She said she'd have to check her schedule for work at the WalMart. The next day, she called and said that she was free Wednesday afternoon.
"Miz Taylor," said the pastor after Marisa was seated in the overstuffed chair in his office, "you and your son have been very much in my thoughts and my prayers. I'd much appreciate it if you could tell me how you all are doing. Only what you feel comfortable telling me, of course. It's perhaps selfish of me, but I'd like to settle my mind a little."
Marisa sighed. "It's not much different from what I told you two weeks ago. Jesse is a very obedient little boy, always has been, but he looks so sad and, like I said, haunted. Except when he gets to be Jessica, like he says."
"You haven't gotten rid of his dresses?"
Marisa looked a little guilty. "No, I haven't. I haven't had the heart to. You see, Reverend, it's like this. I grew up on a farm, and we had barn cats. Now, the way it is when they have kittens, if their eyes don't open after a day or so, you figure they'll be blind and it's a kindness not to make them live.
"Well one day, I think I was about Jesse's age, one of the momma cats had had kittens, and my Pa said that three of them hadn't opened their eyes, and he told me to drown them. Now I wasn't keen on drowning helpless little kittens, but what Pa said, you did. He told me to get a barrel and half fill it with water and drop them in, and if they didn't sink fast enough, to hold them down. Well, I did like he told me and filled up the barrel and fetched the kittens. I saw them roll around with their eyes closed and looking so helpless and I couldn't help it, I knew they were just animals, but I said a little prayer for each of them. Then I dropped them in. Two drowned right away, but the third somehow kept his head up and I had to push him down and hold him under. I could feel his heart beating and his thrashing around and I could just imagine being him and him wondering, why? why? When I was done, I went to my Pa crying and told him I didn't care what he did, I wasn't never going to drown a kitten again. I thought he'd get mad, but he just looked kind of sad at me and told me he wouldn't."
Marisa's eyes were wet, and she began crying as she continued. "This is all to say, when I think of taking those dresses and girl clothes away from him, and taking those hours of being Jessica away, I feel like I'd be drowning my own kittens. I just can't do it. The Lord may send me to Hell, He may send us both to Hell, but I just can't do it."
The pastor couldn't speak for the longest time. Marisa's sobs had ceased by the time he had an idea of what to say. "The Lord knows best what burdens we bear and how well we can bear them. You and I know what the Lord wants you to do --" Saying this last sentence was somehow like swallowing razor blades. "But He also knows you can only do what you can do. I'd say, do what you can, don't do what you can't, and pray to the Lord for strength and forgiveness."
"Well, Reverend, we both pray. I pray for strength and for the Lord to ease Jesse's load. And Jesse? Well, he's started praying for the Lord to call him home and send him back as a girl next time, so he won't feel torn apart all the time. I tell you, it's like a knife in my heart every time he says things like that. But I can't say as I blame him. His nature and his body being at war against one another like that."
The pastor knew he should say something, but he couldn't think of anything. The psychologist's comment about how "most of them die" was ringing in his ears again. Finally he said, "Miz Taylor, I much appreciate your coming in. I'm sorry I don't have -- I don't yet have -- anything to comfort you with. But you've given me a lot to think about. I'll be praying for both of you." With that, they both stood up and the pastor escorted Marisa to the door.
Friday was the pastor's lunch with Reverend Ken Jackson, pastor of the Carrington African church. It was his turn to bring lunch. One time, he'd invited Reverend Jackson to the luncheonette in Hopewell, and while nobody said or did anything that was less than perfectly polite, the way they looked at them, especially Reverend Jackson -- well, the pastor didn't want to put Reverend Jackson through that again. Today he'd brought turkey salad he'd made himself, ham biscuits, and corn bread.
They sat down at one of the tables in the parish hall, where someone had set two places, complete with a water jug. The pastor unpacked the lunch.
"Is that your home-made turkey salad?" asked Reverend Jackson. "You do make a fine salad, Reverend Hanley."
"You're very kind to say so, Reverend Jackson," replied the pastor. "But it's not as good as your fried chicken. If you ever get tired of preaching, your chicken could give KFC a run for their money."
"But I'd never make a dime if you started selling your turkey salad, my customers would all eat turkey salad instead of my chicken." They both laughed.
Having satisfied the demands of courtesy, they got down to telling each other of the trials and triumphs they'd encountered in their ministries since the last time they'd met. They tried to respect confidentiality, but since pretty much everything they dealt with was known to pretty much everyone in the community, for most of what they discussed, confidentiality was a moot point.
The pastor finally got to the matter that was sticking in his conscience like a thorn. "Do you ever have find times when it seems like the Word of the Lord from the Bible just -- just doesn't seem to answer the questions you face in your ministry?"
"What are you thinking of, Reverend?" asked Reverend Jackson.
"We are all created by the Lord, that I believe, and I don't believe the Lord makes mistakes, either. But sometimes, I just can't reconcile what the Lord says and what the Lord does."
"You wouldn't be thinking of a certain seven-year-old boy, would you?"
The pastor started. "Who said anything about a boy?"
"I don't think there's anyone in Hopewell that doesn't know that there's a boy who acts more like a girl than a boy and wears dresses in the privacy of his home. And since white folks never seem to realize that black folks have perfectly good ears and will talk like they weren't there, everyone here knows it, too."
The pastor calmed himself. "I'm torn. The boy says he can't stop feeling like he is really a girl. He's convinced he's going to Hell for it. Every time I see him, he looks so hopeless. And his mother says he's started praying for the Good Lord to call him home and send him back with either his body or his nature changed, so he won't feel so torn apart. I spoke to the psychologist in Milburn, and she won't talk about him, but she says boys like him mostly never change. Either they live as girls, maybe even getting operations so they'll look more like girls. Or they commit suicide or destroy themselves with drugs or drink. I can't tell him that the Lord says what he's doing is right. But I don't have the heart to keep telling him and his mother that it's a sin, either. Not when I see how much it's hurting him."
The two men sat in silence for a while.
"You know," said Reverend Jackson in a thoughtful voice. "I think sometimes the Lord sends us conundrums. Things where we don't know the answers. Maybe it's to test us. Or maybe -- maybe it's to challenge us. To get us out of the rut where we know all the answers. Or where we think we know all the answers."
"What are you suggesting, Reverend Jackson?"
"I don't know, Reverend Hanley. Maybe we just need to pray. Pray and trust that if we have faith and allow the Lord to lead us, He will lead us down the path He has appointed for us."
The two men sat up, closed their eyes, and bowed their heads. Reverend Jackson began. "Lord, look down upon thy servant Warren. Give him, we pray, guidance, that he may follow thy Divine will in ministering to thy child Jesse. For his sake, for Jesse's sake, may thy will be done. Amen."
The pastor hadn't ever been prayed over by a colored preacher. At first, he wasn't sure he liked it, but he quickly reminded himself that the Lord asks us to be humble and remember that we are all His children.
"Maybe not the most elegant prayer I've ever said, but I always say, it's more important what you have in your heart than the wording you use. I do hope the Lord will give you guidance." The pastor looked at Reverend Hanley and Reverend Hanley looked back, and for the first time in all the years they'd known each other, he felt a love that was not tainted by their history.
The moment passed, they shook hands, and went their separate ways.
The next Sunday, as the pastor was checking over his notes for the sermon and getting himself in the right frame of mind for the service, the choir director, Randall Collins, knocked. Mr. Collins was a nervous and awkward man who lived for music. The pastor sometimes got the idea that he had a hard time distinguishing between the Lord and His music. But the music he was able to coax out of the untrained children and adults in the choir was truly angelic, and if Mr. Collins felt that in their song he got a glimpse of Heaven, well, maybe he wasn't entirely wrong.
"I'm sorry to disturb you, reverend, but I've been preparing the children's choir for the Christmas Eve service and, well, we're having a problem."
Mr. Collins shifted from one foot to the other and back. The pastor nodded to encourage him to continue.
"It's Jesse. You know what an angelic voice he has. We had him down for a few solos, including 'What Child is This.' He was singing so beautifully until -- until three weeks ago when he started having trouble singing. Sometimes he would stop singing and say he couldn't go on. And when he did sing, it didn't have any joy. I asked him what was the matter, and he said he just didn't have the heart to sing, but he wouldn't tell me why. He just said that Christmas made him sad. His mother couldn't figure it out, either. I'm afraid by Christmas, he won't be able to sing at all, and then where will we be?"
The pastor tried to console Mr. Collins. "I'll talk to Jesse and his mother and see if we can find out what's bothering him and help him find Christmas joy." Mr. Collins looked visibly relieved as he left, but the pastor had the uncomfortable feeling that every word he'd said was a lie.
In the service, the children's choir sang "Come, Thou Long Expected Jesus." Jesse didn't have a solo part, but the pastor could see that Jesse's heart wasn't in his singing, and right after they were done, rather than staying in the sanctuary with the rest of the choir, he snuck down to join his mother in the pew. He spent the rest of the time with his face buried in his mother's chest.
After the service was over and everyone had gone home, the pastor sat in his office and tried to pray. He quickly realized that he couldn't really pray surrounded with all the evidence of of his knowledge and accomplishments, at least not the way he needed to, so he went back into the church to kneel before the altar. But even that seemed too prideful, and he ended up in a pew. It wasn't until his knees were on the cushion that he realized that this was the same one Jesse and his mother usually sat in.
He prayed for guidance, over and over again. Finally, Bible verses where Jesus forgave sinners started coming to mind, and he imagined how he might paraphrase them to fit Jesse's situation. He felt relieved, feeling that he knew what to do, but after he'd locked up, gotten in the car and gotten onto the road, he suddenly felt like he was just like the prideful pharisees in the Bible. In forgiving Jesse's "sins", was he not setting himself up as the one without sin?
Mondays were his day off, when he usually did chores and relaxed, but he found time to sneak off into the back yard, behind some bushes, to pray some more. It didn't help.
On Wednesday, he went to the monthly ministers' meeting. About two dozen ministers from churches in the area gathered at one of the churches, this time one in Tennesee, to hear talks about ministry and to mingle and chat. The pastor used the opportunity to ask if anyone had had in his church a boy who thought he was a girl.
"No, but Chuck Rogers, from over Coleburg way, had a girl who thought she was a boy," someone said. The pastor looked around until he found him.
"I've got a boy in my church who feels he is a girl inside. He's convinced he's going to Hell for it, and I'm trying to help him with it."
Reverend Rogers answered, "well, as you may have heard, I had a girl who believed she was really a boy. Let me tell you, it was pretty strange. I'd never heard such a thing."
"What did you do?"
"We had several long talks, and I talked with her Momma and Daddy. I explained what Scripture says, and said that every time she had those thoughts, she should pray. I told her I was sure the Lord would forgive her, but she should try to sin no more."
"How did that turn out?"
"She seemed to be better for a while. She did a lot of praying and smiled more. But then one day, she went and lay down on the railroad tracks when a train was coming, and that was that."
"That sounds terrible!" The pastor had horrible visions of Jesse lying dismembered on a railroad track and having to tell his mother.
"Believe you me, we were all pretty shook up. Such a pretty girl, and such an ugly end! But then I got to thinking, maybe it was best this way. She was saying she was always feeling like she was being pulled apart and couldn't be happy. As it is, she went back to the Lord, who I hope forgave her, and I truly believe she's happier this way."
The pastor was still seeing visions of Jesse and the girl lying on the tracks, so it took a few minutes for Reverend Rogers' words to register. When they did, all he could manage to say was, "so it was all for the best? That's what you're saying?"
"That's putting it a little too harshly. I'd have said, she is in a better place. That's pretty much what I preached at her funeral."
The pastor was still in a state of shock when he got in the car. On the way home, he realized two things: first, what Reverend Rogers said was basically in agreement with what the Bible said, at least as the church saw it. And second, he could not go along with it. Even if it meant giving up the ministry or even the church, he could not accept what Reverend Rogers had said. If that meant that Jesse was going to Hell for being who and what he was, well, then the pastor would go to Hell along with him. Or her.
For some reason, the pastor found himself driving to his office rather than home. Once he was sitting at his desk, the thoughts he'd had on the way there suddenly seemed crazy. How could he turn his back on a lifetime of belief? He looked at the books on their shelves. Was he supposed to somehow believe that the feelings of one seven-year-old disproved the conclusions of hundreds or even thousands of people who'd spent their lives trying to understand the Lord and His Word?
Suddenly his office, with its tightly closed windows, seemed stifling. He unlocked the church and knelt down in a pew: once again, the one that Jesse and his mother sat in. It no longer seemed like a coincidence. He tried to pray, but words wouldn't come. He just knelt there with his face on the back of the pew in front of him.
He heard his wife's voice calling. He looked up and saw that it was already dark. "What's going on Warren? You didn't come home."
"I -- I was praying. I have something I'm trying to work out. Something with my -- my pastoral responsibilities. I guess I may as well come home, though, I'm not going to work it out tonight."
Mary reached out her arms to him and when he came to her, she hugged him. They walked hand in hand out to their cars. On the way home, the pastor thought about what would happen to Mary and the children if he openly sided with Jesse and preached that what he -- or was it she? -- was doing was no sin. Would he lose his job? Would the congregation and the town ostracize them? He'd spent his life getting along with everyone, would he make enemies, even assuming he kept his job? He thought of all the forces that would be arrayed against him. And not just him. They might take it out on his family, too. And then he thought: this is what Jesse is facing. Jesse and his momma. The town, the church, maybe even the entire Baptist Convention, maybe the demagogues in Montgomery, all lined up against one seven-year-old.
When the pastor woke up, he had no clearer idea of what to do about Jesse. It was peaceful, lying next to Mary, and when he'd get up, he'd have to face his responsibilities -- preparing for Sunday's church service, the questions of his staff and his flock. He had a bit of a notion to ask Mary what she thought, but a part of him was reluctant, too. For one thing, pastoral business was confidential, and it wasn't for him to gossip about what he heard, even if it seemed like everybody knew all about this one. For another, well, Mary was a woman, and discerning the word of the Lord was really men's business.
"Penny for your thoughts, Warren. You seem -- more thoughtful than usual."
He sighed. "I could never put one past you, could I? Yes, I'm troubled. The word of the Lord is telling me one thing, but my heart is telling me something different. Usually, when that happens, my heart is telling me to go the easy way, and the Lord is telling me to take the harder way. But this time, it's the other way around."
"You know I don't know the Bible the way you do, but I do know your heart as much as anyone on this Earth, and I'd trust your heart anywhere."
"Even if it might cause trouble for you? Even if people might disapprove? Even if I lost my -- my pastorate?"
She sighed. "It might be hard. But -- when I married you, I promised to trust you and stay with you in good times and bad. And even if we suffer, it's better to suffer for doing the right thing than to live a life of ease by doing the wrong thing. And Warren?"
"Yes?"
"I know it's not my place to pry, but -- I think you'll find that more people in the church will trust you than you think. You've always acted out of love, and people respond to that."
Warren always had a suspicion that Mary knew more about what went on in his work world than she let on, and never more so than now. Sometimes in rankled, but not this time. He couldn't figure out why, though. And hearing how she trusted him made him feel better. He could feel that he wasn't alone in this.
That immediately made him think: how is it for Jesse? How alone does he -- or is it she? -- feel? WWJD -- what would Jesus do? Well, what would he do?
He spent the morning alternately dealing with all the little things that come up and wracking his brain for an approach to Sunday's sermon. He usually tried in his Fourth Advent sermon to tell about the imminent arrival of The Savior in a way that made it seem like it was happening this year right here in little Hopewell Alabama. But nothing would come. WWJD. That silly cliche kept popping into his mind.
Finally, in the middle of the afternoon, it felt like he couldn't stand it and he dialed the number. It wasn't until he'd finished that he realized it was Ms. Taylor's number he'd called. He hadn't realized he knew it.
"Hello?" said a child's voice.
"Jesse? This is Reverend Hanley. Is your momma home?"
"She's at work. Can I have her call you?"
"If it's not too much trouble."
"Oh, no. I'm sure she'd be happy to call you. But she gets home kind of late. Around nine or ten."
"That's fine, let me give you my home number. Or she can call me tomorrow at the church, if that's better for her. Or whenever is good for her."
"Let me get a pencil and paper." The pastor dictated the number and Jesse read it back. He was impressed by how responsible and well-mannered Jesse was, and the idea that the Lord might have in mind for him any sort of punishment, let alone Hellfire, seemed too horrible to imagine.
When he was done, the Pastor thanked Jesse. "Oh, it was no trouble," said Jesse. "It was a pleasure. And I know my momma will be happy to talk to you."
The pastor had thought that he'd be able to concentrate better now that he'd taken a step towards -- towards something he wasn't quite ready to admit to himself. But instead, he felt on edge. After the third unsuccessful attempt to focus on Sunday's sermon, he realized that his and Ms. Taylor's positions had reversed. At first, it was she who was seeking his approval and support. But now, it seemed like it was he that was seeking her blessing for something he didn't quite want to think about too clearly.
That evening, when he got home, he warned Mary there might be a call late that evening. "A parishioner," was all he said.
"Is it anything to do with what's been worrying you?" she asked tentatively. He just nodded.
At dinner, he kept losing track of what Mary and his children were saying. When he had to ask Bonnie, his seven-year-old, for the second time to repeat what she'd said about their class Christmas party the next day, she said, "Daddy, aren't you even listening to me?" It suddenly struck him that Jesse was the same age as Bonnie.
That evening, he read Bonnie a bedtime story. It wasn't exactly the sort of thing you'd think a preacher would read, as it was about mice and rats and chipmunks fighting for freedom from the tyranny of the cats, but it took his mind off of everything else and got him to put all his attention on his daughter.
It was about 10:30, as they were just getting Jeff into bed, that Ms. Taylor called.
"Reverend Hanley, Jesse told me you'd asked if I might call you. I hope it's not too late, I was working at the Walmart until after 9 and then Jesse had made a wonderful dinner for us."
"No, it's not too late, and I'm much obliged that you were so kind as to call me back. I know you have a lot on your plate, what with working and providing for your -- child."
"Oh, it was no trouble. But I must say, I'm a little mystified as to what you might be calling about. I hope there's nothing wrong."
"No, nothing. It's just that -- well, I've been ponderin' a lot about Jesse and -- how can I say this? Sometimes I think the Lord puts things -- well, people too -- that -- well, sometimes we're forced to realize that all our wisdom is nothing in the face of the Lord's glory. And being as Jesse is one of the Lord's children and creations, I thought I'd like to meet Jesse. Well, actually, to meet Jessica. If that's not too much of an inconvenience for you all."
He heard a sharp intake of breath. "Jessica?"
"Yes, Jessica. The girl that Jesse believes he -- she -- really is. I'll understand if you don't feel comfortable with it. And I'm not asking you as your pastor. You know, your shepherd. I'm just asking as one sinner to another -- well, I'm not saying you're a sinner, but you know. It might just ease my mind, that's all."
She was silent for a few minutes. "I -- I don't quite know what to say. May I think about it for a bit? I'd have to talk to Jesse about it, too."
"Take whatever time you want. And if you don't feel right about it, I'll understand. But -- if you do decide to, might I ask if my wife Mary could come along? I haven't talked with her about Jesse, as you haven't said it was okay, but she's got a mother's touch and I'd feel better knowing she was beside me. But I understand you can't answer right away. And whatever you decide, I appreciate your talking with me."
"I'd like to say yes, that is, if Jesse doesn't mind, but I'm afraid. You know, some people have said some mighty unkind things to him. And he's so easily hurt. I mean, I don't really think you'd want to hurt him, but -- as a mother, I want to protect him. I want to make sure he comes to no harm."
"I assure you, Ma'am, I don't intend to say anything unkind. And if Mary is along, I know she won't let me say anything even unintentionally unkind. I just want to get to know Jessica. I want to let her know that I, at least, think it's just fine for her to be Jessica." The pastor hadn't intended to go that far, especially before even meeting the girl inside Jesse -- well, the girl Jesse thought was inside him -- but the talk of people being unkind -- and he could well imagine what sorts of things Ms. Taylor was talking about -- pushed him to reassure her.
"May I talk to Jesse tomorrow morning and let you know before I go to work?"
"That's fine. I'll be in the office by 9:00 or so, but if you have to go to work before then, please feel free to call me at home."
The next morning, as the pastor was finishing breakfast, they got a call. Mary handed him the phone. It was Mrs. Taylor.
"I just sent Jesse off to school. He said he'd like to meet you as Jessica. Would Saturday morning work for you? I don't have to be at the store until 11:00. And Jessica would be very happy to have Mary there, but she wants to know what she should wear?"
"I think that would work fine for us. Bonnie has ballet at 9:00 and Jeff has basketball at 9:30. I think Jessica should wear whatever she likes best. I'm sure whatever she picks will be pretty." They said their goodbyes, and the pastor hung up.
"Mary," he said, "I have a favor to ask of you. It's about this -- pastoral issue I've been wrestling with."
"Warren, you know I'm ready to help you with anything I can. But what is it?"
"You know that little boy Jesse and his momma? Well, it seems he believes he's really a little girl inside. His momma has been giving him girls' clothes and letting him pretend to be a girl named Jessica when they're alone. They've been talking to me, but I haven't been able to help them. I asked if I could meet 'Jessica' tomorrow morning, while Bonnie's at ballet and Jeff is at basketball. And I was wondering if you might be willing to go along, so he doesn't feel so much like I'm coming to judge him."
"Of course I'll come."
"I really appreciate it, Mary," he said as he got up and headed towards the door. Mary came up behind him and put her arms around him.
"Warren, I'm really -- I'm really touched that you would trust me with something like this. There's a big part of your life that you usually shut me out of, and I feel like I'm the Martha in your life. It's nice to be your Mary sometimes."
The pastor went to his office with a heart that was lighter than it had been in weeks. He still wondered if what he was doing was doctrinally correct, but he knew, whatever the answer might be, he could do no other than to accept Jesse as he or she was and stand with her.
But once he was sitting in his office, surrounded by his books and responsibilities, doubts began to creep in. Was he not committing the sin of pride, imagining that his feeling of right and wrong were wiser than the theologians of the church? He knew he was an indifferent scholar, good enough to write sermons for a small town like Hopewell, but he had no hope of refuting the arguments of those who had taught him the proper way of understanding the Word of the Lord. It was his little heart against the wisdom of the Church.
Yet when he thought of Jesse's sad face at church last Sunday, and of the polite and mannerly way he spoke on the phone, he knew he could not follow the Church's teachings in this. He thought of the German pastor who, when the children were being sent to the concentration camps, went with them and died along side them, so they at least would not be alone. If Jesse's going to Hell, I'll be there with him. But then he thought: and if he's going to Heaven? "... for of such is the Kingdom of Heaven."
* - * - * - *
The next morning, the pastor and Mary decided to walk to the Taylors' house. It was one of those crisp December days when winter seems almost kind, and parsonage and the house where Jesse and his mother rented the second floor were near the middle of town. Mary had on a silver cross on a necklace, but the pastor had chosen not to wear any of the signs of his office. Mary had brought a bag of her home-baked Christmas cookies, because of course it wouldn't do to come empty-handed. (It couldn't possibly be because she was proud of her baking!)
Mrs. Taylor answered the door.
"Marisa!" "Mary! What a surprise!" The two women hugged and exchanged pleasantries like they were long-lost cousins. "And Reverend Hanley, it's an honor. Come on upstairs, Jesse" -- here she got a little more sober -- "that is, Jessica, is waiting to meet you."
Mrs. Taylor led them up the stairs to the apartment, where they found themselves in the kitchen. "Set yourselves down, I'll get Jesse." The pastor had said not one word, and wasn't sure he could have even if he'd wanted to. A few minutes later, Jesse -- no, Jessica -- came shyly into the room, gently pushed by her mother.
She was wearing a knee-length light blue dress -- the same light blue that the Virgin Mary is often depicted as wearing. It had a white Peter Pan collar, a smocked bodice, puffed sleeves that came down just past her elbows, and a gathered skirt with a ruffle at the bottom. She had white cable-knit knee socks and black patent-leather shoes with a strap, and on her head was a broad-brimmed hat in the same blue as the dress. She was holding her hands behind her back and had a nervous smile.
"Oh, aren't you just adorable!" gushed Mary as she got up and approached Jessica. "May I have a hug?" Jessica put her arms around Mary's waist and Mary put her arms around Jessica's shoulders. The pastor got up, too, but wasn't quite sure where he belonged in the love-fest.
"Let me look at you again," said Mary, disengaging from Jessica. "That dress is just so pretty. And the hat! Jessica, please give it a whirl so we can see the whole thing." She obligingly twirled, and the skirt flew up just enough to see the hem of a simple eyelet-trimmed cotton petticoat.
The pastor finally found his voice. "That's mighty pretty, indeed, Jess--ica." He hadn't yet found his eloquence.
Jessica's face turned somber. "You mean, I won't go to Hell?"
"No, Jessica. I mean, the Lord doesn't consult with me before rendering His judgements, but I can't believe that He'd send you to Hell. I can believe that He made you to be just as you are, like the lilies of the field."
Hearing that, Jessica got a huge smile on her face and ran over to the pastor and threw her arms around him and gave him a big hug. "Do you mean that?" she asked.
"Yes. When I said it was a sin, I was wrong. I can see that now. I can see that this is who you are, and it is not wrong. God doesn't make mistakes."
"Ooh, I'm so happy," squealed Jessica as she hugged herself and danced and twirled around the kitchen. She grabbed her mother's hands and they sashayed around in a circle.
Eventually, she settled down and they all sat down. Marisa put the cookies on a plate and served them drinks. Jessica had milk, Marisa chose apple juice, while the pastor and Mary went with water.
Midway through her third cookie, Jessica got a serious expression on her face. "Reverend, do you think Jesus would like it if I wore a dress to church tomorrow?"
"Well, that's up to your momma, but if she says it's okay, it's fine with me. And if anyone gives you grief, let me know and I'll have a little talk with them." When Marisa and Mary both gave him a questioning look, he added serenely, "judge not, that ye be not judged."
The pastor couldn't help noticing that Jesse's -- Jessica's face was filled with a smile that he didn't recall having seen in ages. And she was filled with more life than could possibly fit into her seven-year-old body. He wasn't quite sure what he would do if -- more likely, when -- Jessica showed up in church, but he was determined that he would take her side somehow.
When the cookies were gone, Marisa sent Jessica off to wash her hands. "Mrs. Taylor," said the pastor. "I can see you were right. It would have been like drowning kittens. I'll do whatever I can to help her, and you both."
"I will, too," said Mary. "Maybe we can invite her over to play with Bonnie during Christmas vacation."
"We'll have to see," said Marisa. "To be honest, this is quite a shock. It'll take me some time to adjust to it. Both of us, I think."
Jessica came back in, with clean hands, and they said their goodbyes. As Marisa was showing them out, Mary said, "we'll be in touch. Don't hesitate to call me."
The pastor was lost in his thoughts. But as he pondered, he had a sense of a Gentle Shepherd looking down from Heaven and smiling at him for the first time since he was a little boy.
Sunday morning found the pastor in his study. He was still struggling with the sermon he'd have to deliver in about two hours. He knew he wanted to say something about Jesus having come into the world a nobody born to two nobodies, but he hadn't been able to get any further. He heard a knock on the door.
"Come on in." It wasn't like he had any train of thought that they'd be interrupting.
The door opened to show Ms. Taylor and Jesse -- no, Jessica. Jessica had on a long red velour dress with what looked like a taffeta bodice in a Christmas plaid, a hairband holding back her hair, and a smile that was so big it barely fit on her face.
"Mrs. Hanley was so nice, she found me this pretty, Christmas-y dress to wear. Isn't it pretty?" she gushed. She was playing with her hands and shifting from one foot to the other.
He couldn't help smiling in return. "Yes, it's really pretty. It's so pretty, I'll bet all the girls will be jealous," he teased.
"Momma says nobody will be able to see it under my choir robes. But I'll know I'm wearing it, and Momma will know, and now you will know," she giggled as she hung on her mother's wrist and wiggled around. Her mother whispered something to her. "Oh, Reverend, this is for you." She took something from her mother's hand and solemnly walked up to his desk and handed it to him.
It was a little angel Christmas ornament, with a cone made out of red construction paper for a robe, a styrofoam ball with a painted face for a head, yellow yarn for hair, and pipe-cleaner arms holding sheet music made of a scrap of white paper, and another pipe-cleaner for a halo.
"You can put it on your Christmas tree," she informed him.
"Thank you," he said to her and she beamed.
"Time for choir practice," said her mother. Jessica turned and skipped towards the door. When she reached it, she turned around and gave a little wave and said "goodbye!" before disappearing down the hall, singing "Oh Little Town of Bethlehem" in a high voice. Her mother shrugged and trotted after her. The pastor closed the door and went back to his sermon writing.
Later on, as he stood in church watching the children's choir process up to their seats, followed by the adult choir, he could see a little bit of red below the hem of Jesse's -- no, Jessica's -- robe, and he -- she still had the hairband on. He wondered if he'd have to deal with some pointed remarks later. But he could see Jessica's angelic face and hear her singing her heart out, and he could almost hear a voice saying, "well done," though he wasn't sure if the voice was talking to him or to Jessica.
He still hadn't written a sermon, so he was going to have to wing it for the first time in his life. He said a silent prayer to the Lord to give him the right words -- actually, any words at all -- when the time came.
The sermon hymn finished, and he still didn't know what he was going to say. He stood at the pulpit, no notes on the lecturn. He turned, saw Jesse's -- no, Jessica's -- smiling face looking at him. He opened his mouth and began to speak.
Later, the pastor couldn't exactly remember what he'd said. He had the idea he'd tied in a dozen Bible verses about how to treat the poor, the outcasts, the lepers, the lowliest of the low. He might have preached about "of such is the Kingdom of Heaven." But it was fuzzy in his mind. The only think he remembered clearly was seeing Jessica's -- yes, Jessica's face -- looking at him as he spoke. And when he sat down and the choir sang, among all the children and all the grownups, he could somehow clearly hear Jessica's sweet voice, singing like an angel from Heaven.
The End
When I was in elementary school, there was a girl in my class who I idolized. Her name was Amelia Jennings and she was not only the same size as me, but her first name was next to mine in the alphabet, so when we were lined up by name or by height, we would be next to each other.
There the similarities ended. She had yellow blond hair which reached down to the middle of her back, she was graceful -- she took ballet -- she was self-assured and smart and popular and got good grades. And she was cute and dressed to bring that cuteness out. I on the other hand was a boy. I had very short hair because my father believed boys should have crew cuts and laughed off my objections as a child's foolishness. My clothes were dull khaki and navy blue from J.C. Penney's boys' department. I was gawky and a social and physical klutz -- I couldn't catch a ball if it was dropped in my hands and if I threw a ball, I was lucky to get it into the same time zone as my target. I counted myself lucky when I was ignored by the other kids, which I managed most of the time except for Joe, Fred, and Kelly, three class clowns and part-time bullies who I called "the three stooges" (but not to their faces.)
Even our politics differed -- my family was staunch Republican, while Amelia was a Democrat: she'd worn a black armband for a month after Kennedy was assassinated. She normally preferred to ignore my presence even when we were next to one another in line, but when I came to class wearing my "Goldwater for President" button, she finally took notice of me, but only to shower me with withering contempt.
So things went until shortly after Christmas vacation. Mrs. Murphy, the art teacher, decided what we needed to spice up the winter months was a school play. We had all seen The Wizard of Oz on television, so an adaptation for the elementary school stage was the obvious choice. The first and second graders were munchkins and winkies, and the three stooges were given the part of -- no surprise -- flying monkeys. The lead parts were assigned based in large part on who was most likely to remember their lines, with Amelia getting the part of Glinda. There was no way Glinda could be floated in in a giant bubble, so it was decided to have a herald, with a toy trumpet and a suitably grand speech to announce her. I don't know why, but I was given the part of the herald.
At the first rehearsal we were given our scripts and measured for costumes. Mrs. Murphy, some of the mothers, and some of Mrs. Murphy's friends from the days before she was a teacher were going to find or make our costumes.
Rehearsals went on for six weeks. I eventually learned to deliver my few lines to Mrs. Murphy's satisfaction and Amelia eventually learned to not show her distaste for her herald while on stage. All went well, or at least as well as could be expected, until a week before the performance, when we had to try on our costumes. Instead of taking the time to have try them on in school where she could check the fit herself and incidentally make sure nothing got lost, Mrs. Murphy gave each of us a bag with our costume and asked our mothers to check the fit. If it fit well, she invited us to wear them to school. For some reason, she also saw fit to warn me that I shouldn't worry if my costume seemed a little fancy and frilly, because back in the day when there were heralds, that was how the manliest of men dressed.
So off I went to catch my bus, carrying a bookbag and a huge bag stuffed with a costume with a lot of white in it. I sat by myself as usual and practiced my speech the whole way home, at least until the other kids told me to shut up.
When I got home, my Mom was in the kitchen dealing with my baby brother. "Hi, Mom, Mrs. Murphy sent my costume home with me, you're supposed to check it."
"Okay, honey, why don't you go to your room and put it on. When you're done, give me a shout."
I emptied the bag on my bed, and saw that it was all white. The pile contained a pair of white tights, a sort of dress like an undershirt with a lot of poufy netting on the bottom, which I now know is called a petticoat, and a white satin thing with some kind of see-through outer layer which I assumed must be the tunic but which looked an awful lot like a dress. Actually, exactly like a dress. The manliest of men, I reminded myself. I took off my clothes except for my underpants and put on the tights and the petticoat. It felt completely different from anything I had ever worn. It took a few minutes for me to realize that I liked it. I then put on the dress. It zipped up the back, which I couldn't figure out how to do, so I just left it unzipped. I noticed some white ballet slippers had fallen out of the bag, too, so I put them on.
It felt heavenly. I guess those manly men back then knew something guys these days just don't understand, I thought. If this is what 'manly' felt like, I was all for it. I went out into the hall and looked at myself in the full length mirror at the end. The petticoat made the skirt of the dress stick out in a really pretty way. I twirled and watched the skirt stick out a little bit more. I loved how it looked. I loved how it felt. It was like I was looking at some me and feeling like some me that I had never known existed. I felt like I was in a dream.
"Ambrose! Are you ready for me to check your costume?" my mother called up the stairs.
"I guess so." Actually, I would have been happy to stay looking at myself in the mirror all night. I heard her come up.
"Ambrose! What on earth are you wearing?" my mother exclaimed when she saw me.
"It's my costume! This is what Mrs. Murphy made for me."
"But it's a dress!"
"It's a tunic. Mrs. Murphy said that's how manly men dressed in those days."
"Are you sure there hasn't been a mixup? Might you have gotten someone else's costume by mistake?"
"But this is what Mrs. Murphy gave me!" I argued.
We went back and forth a few times until my mother gave up arguing with me.
"There's no point trying to talk sense into you when you get an idea in your head. Okay, but I'm going to call up Mrs. Murphy tomorrow to make sure there hasn't been a mistake."
She then zipped it up, looked it over a few times, and rather resignedly pronounced it a good fit. She helped me out of the costume and I put it away and went off to do my homework, or at least as much of it as I had remembered to write down in my notebook.
The next morning, after rushing through breakfast, I went back upstairs and changed into my costume. My father had left and my mother had her hands full with my little sister and my baby brother, so she didn't see me go out the door to the bus stop in my costume. It didn't occur to me to bring clothes to change into. I'm amazed it occurred to me to bring my bookbag.
Danny and Angela were already at the bus stop. "Why are you dressed like a girl?" asked Danny.
"I'm not dressed like a girl, I'm dressed like a herald," I insisted.
"More like a princess," said Angela.
"This is the costume Mrs. Murphy made for me. She says that this is how heralds dressed. Kings and all wore really fancy clothes, so their heralds had to dress fancy, too." They gave up talking to me, but they kept looking at me and giggling.
When I got on the bus, everybody stared at me and a few asked why I was wearing a dress. "It's my costume for the school play!" I insisted. I sat in my usual seat near the back, alone as usual, but I could hear the whispering all the way to school.
When I got off the bus at school, the three stooges were there, and that's when the heckling started in earnest. "Oh look at what Ambrose is wearing. I always knew he was a girl!"
"No, he can't be Ambrose, he must be Ambrosia!"
"You're going to have to start using the girls' toilet!"
I kept insisting, "it's my costume! It's what heralds wear!" but I was having a harder and harder time believing it myself.
When I got into the classroom, Mrs. Taylor, our teacher, looked startled, but before she could say anything, Amelia came over to me and punched me. "That's my costume! Take it off! Take it off right now!"
"Mrs. Murphy told me it was the herald costume!" I whimpered.
"She did not! You took my costume! Give it back!" She started pulling on the sleeves and probably would have punched me again, but Mrs. Taylor pushed us apart.
"Don't pull on the costume, you'll tear it. You don't want that, Amelia, do you?" Mrs. Taylor sat us in opposite corners at the front of the classroom and wrote a note for me to take to the office. This was in the days before hall monitors, when they assumed that ten-year-olds would do as they were told, so I was sent by myself. As I walked down the hall, children were still getting into their classrooms, so there was plenty of opportunity for them to point and stare and giggle at me.
Mrs. Hedges in the office gave me a funny look but said nothing as she read the note. She then went and spoke with the principal and then fetched Mrs. Murphy, who I guess didn't have a class at that time. By this time it was beginning to percolate into my brain that it was pretty likely that I had actually gotten the wrong costume and was actually wearing the Glinda costume, not the herald costume, and I was feeling very, very stupid.
"Why are you wearing the Glinda costume?" asked Mrs. Murphy.
"That's what you gave me yesterday," I protested.
"No, I told you to pick up the bag with your name on it. Did you look at the name?"
"I thought I saw 'Ambrose' on it."
"Fine. Just please change out of it into your regular clothes."
"Uh, my regular clothes are at home. I guess I forgot to bring them."
The grown-ups didn't sound too happy about this, but they didn't say anything. Mrs. Hedges called home and fortunately got my mother, who, as it happens, hadn't gotten around to calling the school yet. My Mom got there about twenty minutes later, carrying my baby brother Warren on one arm and the costume bag, which now had my school clothes, in the other, and the bag was clearly marked 'Amelia.'
"That's so typical for Ambrose," said my mother. "He probably didn't bother to read past the first two letters." I was sent off to the nurse's office to change and, once the nurse had confirmed that I did indeed have all the proper clothes on in the proper places and orientation, she sent me back to my classroom. To my surprise, the school never punished me; they probably had no idea what would be appropriate, or else they were convinced I was hopeless.
My classmates were not so forgiving. Amelia tripped me when I had to go up to the board, and at recess she yelled at me about how much she hated me for getting 'boy cooties' all over her costume. By this point, everyone in the school knew about my wearing the dress, so it wasn't just the three stooges who were calling me "girl" and "sissy" and "queer." I didn't have to worry about losing any friends though, since I hadn't had any to begin with.
Just before my last class was over, Mrs. Murphy showed up in our room. I'd had this idea I'd skip the rehearsal and go straight home, but she must have guessed what I was thinking. She took me by the hand and led me to the cafetorium.
"I don't want to be in the play any more," I whined as we were walking.
"Nonsense! Don't you know, 'the show must go on'?"
"But they'll all laugh at me! I'll feel so stupid."
"You didn't worry about that this morning. If you had enough guts to wear Amelia's costume to school, you have enough to get up on stage and say your lines. It's like what they say about getting back up on the horse after you've fallen."
I didn't have an answer for that, but I was pretty sure that if I fell off a horse, wild horses couldn't drag me back onto one. Come to think of it, I wasn't going to ever fall since I wasn't ever going to get on a horse in the first place.
"Besides, the best way to get the other kids to stop teasing you is to act like what you did is the coolest thing anyone could do. After all, how many other boys would have the courage to wear a Glinda costume to school? Act like you're proud of it, not embarrassed."
"But I am embarrassed," I said, starting to cry. "I feel so stupid!"
She stopped and pulled me into the alcove in front of a door to a classroom. She squatted down so she was the same height as me and looked at me with concern. "Ambrose," she said gently. "Can you tell me: how did you feel when you put on the costume? I promise I won't tell anyone else."
I had never had anyone look like they actually cared what I felt, at least not unless they planned to use what I said to 'improve' me. I just stared at her.
"I've known a few men and even boys who would have loved to wear such a pretty costume. I don't think there's anything wrong with it. I wonder if ... maybe ... you enjoyed wearing it. Maybe you took it by mistake, but once you tried it on, maybe it felt ... really nice. And maybe ... it felt so nice you didn't think of asking yourself why I would have picked out a costume like that for you. But you don't have to tell me unless you want to."
"Why do you want to know? I don't get it." After I said it, I realized that by not denying enjoying it, I'd kind of admitted she was right. I realized I somehow couldn't say I hated it. Not to her.
"Ambrose: I'm an art teacher. That means I get to see sides of kids that the other teachers don't see. And I see a child in front of me who has many good qualities and strengths, but is in a place that only seems to care about his weaknesses. I don't know how much I can do to change that, but I want you to at least know that I see you and I care. I gave you the role of herald -- which I think you do pretty well, by the way -- because I wanted to give you a chance to shine a little bit. That's why I want you to go ahead and play that part anyway."
"But everyone is going to think I'm a sissy." I was crying pretty hard. Any second, one of the other kids was going to come by and see me and really know I was a sissy.
"I don't think you're a sissy. And even if you were, I don't think there's anything wrong with it. Besides, how many other kids would have had the guts to do what you did."
"I wasn't having guts. I was just being stupid. I wasn't thinking."
"But they don't have to know that," she said with a conspiratorial grin. "Just act like they're too chicken to do anything like that. Hey, I know! Pretend you are a secret agent and that was part of a secret mission, but since it's secret, you can't let anyone know. Yes, lives depended upon you wearing that dress and never letting anyone know why."
My face was still wet, but I couldn't help giggling at the idea. "It's so secret, even I don't know why!" I said.
"That's right. Need to know and all that. Now come on, Mr. Secret Agent, let's get down to the rehearsal before any of those enemy agents figure out that something is up, okay?"
The rehearsal went remarkably smoothly. To my surprise, Amelia didn't do anything to me during the rehearsals or even the performance. I later heard that it had been explained to her that if she tried to sabotage my performance, it would make her look worse. It didn't stop her from shoving me when the teachers weren't looking, or calling me names. And there were plenty of other kids who called me names. But I kept telling myself "lives depended upon me" and held my head up high and, except for Amelia, they soon got bored and quit.
After that rehearsal, Mrs. Murphy took me aside. "Ambrose, if you ever need to talk to someone about things you don't feel comfortable talking to anyone else about, I'd be glad to listen."
I didn't know what to say except "thanks." After the show was over, she invited me to join an after-school drawing class, so I spent many happy afternoons with her and a few other kids making all kinds of drawings: good, bad, and ugly, as they say. I never talked to her about what I felt when I wore the dress, but I got a sense that she knew and accepted me. It was the one bright spot in an otherwise miserable childhood.
Unfortunately, the school decided not to renew her contract at the end of the year, probably because she wasn't conventional enough for them. She moved and I lost track of her. When I was in my thirties and finally got the courage to deal with the part of me that wearing the dress had awakened, I tried to find her again, and I tried again several years later when I changed my name to Heather, but there was no one left at my old school from when she'd been there, and anyway they wouldn't have seen any reason to keep track of where a teacher who had lasted only a year might have gone. I couldn't even find out her first name.
But I never forgot the sense of understanding and acceptance that I got from her. All my life, through all the times when the world seem dedicated to convincing me how worthless and what a failure I was, I remembered how she thought I was worth something and I took heart. Mrs. Murphy, if you're still alive, and maybe even if you aren't, I wish there were some way to let you know how much of a difference you made in one child's life.
This isn’t your usual BigCloset story. It started out as an oral story, a tale to tell on a story-telling evening. So you have to imagine that you’re hearing me tell this story to a group of people at night by the fireside.
Sit back, and imagine a retreat center in the country, where a bunch of families are gathered for the weekend for some sort of program. And imagine we’re all snowed in, the power is out, it is night and everyone is huddled in sleeping bags and blankets in the common room in front of the fireplace, the only source of warmth and light. All the activities the organizers had planned have gone out the window, so we’ve decided to tell stories while waiting for the roads to get cleared and the power to come back on, and it’s my turn. I’m sitting on the raised hearth, next to the fire, and I begin.
“I’ll warn you in advance,” I say, “I’m transgender, and since they say: write about what you know, all my stories are about transgender people and being transgender. So this story, about a brother and sister named Billy and Suzie, is as well. It goes: Once upon a time…”
Once upon a time a woman gave birth to twins. The first one had, as we may delicately put it, an “innie,” so they said, “it’s a girl” and named her Suzie. The second one had an, ah, “outie,” so they said, “it’s a boy” and named him Billy.
The two of them were alike as two peas, and if they hadn’t always put Suzie in pink diapers and Billy in blue diapers, no one would have been able to tell one from the other. Both had hazel eyes that drank in the world when they were awake. Both were born nearly bald, but in time grew the same fine blond hair that it was a shame to cut.
From their earliest days, clumsily rolling and squirming in the crib, they wanted to be together, and if they were separated, they would cry and pine until they were reunited. And when they were older and had their own rooms, they were always together. If Billy was in his room playing with his balls and trucks and blocks, Suzie would be there, too, happily making truck noises or piling blocks. If Suzie was in her room with its dolls and stuffed animals and dollhouse, Billy was right there with Suzie, making up stories about the dolls and the stuffed animals and giving the baby dolls their bottles and rocking them to sleep. If one of them got a bump or a scrape, the other would be right there, hugging them and kissing the boo-boo. And if one or the other had a hard day and went to bed crying, as likely as not they would be found the next morning cuddled together in one bed.
One morning, when they were five, Suzie got an idea for a marvelous prank. Suzie put on Billy’s blue jean overalls and NY Jets T-shirt, and Billy put on one of Suzie’s play dresses, so each could pretend to be the other. Their parents were none the wiser and spent the day actually believing that the child in the dress was Suzie and the one in the overalls was Billy. It was not until dinner time, when the children could not contain their laughter any more, that the deception was discovered.
The adults all agreed that it was a very funny prank, but the next day, they consulted with a child psychiatrist who, as it happens, had trained at Johns Hopkins and spent several years working with Dr. Kenneth Zucker. Soon after, their lives suddenly got busier and they never seemed to have time to play together. Billy spent most of his free time at play dates with other boys, and his father started playing ball and wrestling with him and taking him to ball games, and later, he was signed up for T-ball and soccer and, later still, started little league. Suzie’s mother started keeping her busy cooking and having her watch My Little Pony and taking ballet and had her join the Girl Scouts. Billy was given a crew cut, which left him inconsolable for days, but Suzie’s hair was allowed to grow out and soon she had bangs and wore barrettes and hair bands. Suzie no longer wore trousers, only skirts and dresses, while Billy had only jeans and T-shirts and sweat clothes, except for church when he wore a little suit and tie. They loved their parents and tried their best to go along and be happy, but they rarely smiled, and when they did, it always seemed a little empty.
Suzie rebelled first. At the beginning of ninth grade, she quit Girl Scouts and ballet and joined the girls’ basketball team, and though she wasn’t the best on the team, she was the most spirited. The girls’ teams didn’t have cheerleaders, but Suzie’s enthusiasm and drive gave them more ‘spirit’ than any team of cheerleaders could, and by her senior year, their team was state champion two years in a row. She spent her allowance on Tae Kwon Doh lessons, and did so well that when she could no longer pay, the dojang let her attend for free. When she graduated, her parents wanted her to go to the community college and study to be a nurse, but she won an athletic scholarship to study at the big state university, majored in politics and pre-law, and after college she worked her way through law school and got a job at a big law firm in the state capital.
Billy dutifully went out for football, but he wasn’t very good at it, perhaps because his heart wasn’t in it. He mostly warmed the bench and only got put in when it didn’t make any difference. The other boys would regularly call him ‘wuss’ and ‘pansy,’ despite his being on the football team, and one time a few boys ganged up on him, but Suzie happened by and together they drove the boys away.
His dad got him into his dad’s old university, but he didn’t join his father’s old fraternity, and he quit the pre-med program his parents talked him into going into and majored in psychology instead. After college, he wanted to train to be a child psychologist, but his parents convinced him no parents would bring their child to a male psychologist, so he got a job in human resources at a large corporation.
Suzie married Sebastian, a handsome and sexy lawyer in the firm, and together they “made beautiful music,” not to mention two beautiful children: David and Penelope. Suzie eventually realized that the firm would never make a woman partner, no matter how good she was, so she quit and joined an all-woman firm founded by some friends from law school. Sebastian was an engaged father and a wonderful lover, but he had expected her to quit her job and stay home and involve herself with the children and with the social activities that were so necessary for him to rise in the firm. So they divorced and he married Meg, a woman whose husband had dumped her for a trophy wife. Sebastian moved into Meg’s three-bedroom condo and had the children on weekends.
Billy also married, a few years later than Suzie. He met an elementary school teacher, Arabella, through a book group and they eventually married and also had two children: May and Evan. Billy was a dutiful and responsible husband and father, but Arabella complained that he always kept the real Billy, the part she loved the best, locked away, and after many unsuccessful years of marriage counselling, they separated. “I will never love anyone but you,” she said tearfully, “but I can’t stand living with you and not having you.”
December rolled around. Sebastian and Meg took the children to their chalet in Aspen for the holidays, while Arabella took their children to her mother’s for Christmas, leaving Suzie and Billy to spend their end-of-year vacation on their own. Suzie invited Billy to stay with her so the house wouldn’t feel so empty. The first night, as they ate take-out Chinese before a fire in the fireplace, they reminisced.
Billy asked, “remember how happy we were just being together, back when we were kids? I’ve missed you.”
And Suzie said, “I’ve missed you, too.” Then she said, “Remember when we swapped clothes, and fooled our parents? Wasn’t that fun?”
Billy: “After that, we never got to play together again. I don’t think we ever had much fun after that.”
Suzie: “Why don’t we try swapping clothes now? We look like we’re both still the same size.”
So Billy tried to put on one of Suzie’s dresses, and with the help of something called a waist-cincher and some chunks of foam in the bra, he managed to fit into it. Meanwhile, Suzie wrapped her chest in really tight Ace bandages and managed to get into one of Billy’s shirts. The pants were a bit tight, but she got them on. And when they looked in the mirror (after a bit of make-up and fiddling with the hair), they looked sort of like each other.
They looked at each other and they both said, “that was fun!”
Then Suzie said, “now we have to go out and fool the rest of the world.”
The next day, they dressed more carefully and went out to eat at a restaurant. They could barely manage a straight face, but nobody seemed to notice.
They decided Billy would be called “Barbara” and Suzie would be “Sean.” All week, “Barbara” and “Sean” did everything together as sister and brother, just like when they were small. They couldn’t remember ever being so happy just to be alive.
New Years was coming, and when they found out that there was a fancy party at one of the hotels with a band and a dance floor, they decided they’d go. Billy helped “Sean” rent a tux, and Suzie helped “Barbara” buy a nice evening gown.
(Notice how being a girl is a lot more expensive than being a guy?)
And off they went to the party. They got a table in sight of the bar and the dance floor, and Sean went off to get food and drink for them both from the bar. At the bar, there were a bunch of men hanging around, and Sean soon got to talking with them about the usual man stuff — cars, Super Bowl, dirty jokes. She was just another guy with the guys.
And she loved it.
Meanwhile, Barbara was sitting at the table, nibbling the hors d’oeuvres and drinking her ginger ale, when a tall, dark, handsome man came up and asked her to dance.
(I mean, aren’t they always tall, dark, and handsome?)
Well, Barbara isn’t any better at saying no than Billy, so off she goes. She doesn’t know one dance from another, but that doesn’t matter. He’s trying to tell her how enchanting and beautiful she is while he sweeps her around, but she isn’t paying any attention to what he’s saying, she’s just doing her best to stay on her feet, and sometimes she says stuff like “oh, my!” and “help.” To her amazement, she manages not to fall or to knock anyone over. When the music stops, she gets him to help her back to the table, she is so dizzy and discombobulated.
Well, Sean comes to her rescue and brings her some more to eat and drink and helps her settle down, and before you know it, another tall, dark, handsome man comes over and asks her to dance.
The next dance is a slow dance, so he’s holding her in a ballroom hold — you know, one hand holding her right hand up, the other behind her back. It’s kind of dreamy, but when the music stops, she notices that the dress is about to fall off her shoulders. She dashes off to the toilets, and fortunately just in time remembers not to go into the men’s room. Anyway, in the ladies’ room, she realizes that the zipper is pulled down and she doesn’t know how to pull it up. Another woman is there, and she pulls it up for her.
(that’s why if your a woman, you try to go to the ladies’ with someone)
And when Barbara wonders aloud what was wrong with the zipper, the woman makes a face and says, “probably your dance partner. Guys like to do that kind of thing. They think it’s funny. Men!”
She finds Sean among the guys at the bar, and he ends up dancing with her and getting one or two of the men from the bar to dance with her, too.
And then the band announces it’s almost midnight. They go back to their table, where waiters bring them small glasses of champagne. They toast the New Year, they hug, and they give each other a brotherly/sisterly kiss. They dance together once, and then head home. They’re partied out — Barbara especially.
The morning comes, as mornings do, though in this case it’s more like afternoon. They’re sitting on the couch in front of the fireplace after a leisurely brunch, made from whatever they find in the refrigerator, and Suzie says, “you know, I really liked being Sean. Maybe not all the time, but it was really great being a guy with other guys.”
And Billy says, “I enjoyed being Barbara, too. I’m sure Mom and Dad would say I’m not supposed to, but — don’t tell anyone — but I liked wearing a beautiful gown and looking pretty and having people looking at me.” He looks kind of embarrassed. “And having people ask me to dance and saying nice things about me. But — okay, it was nice having those guys want to dance with me, but I kept wishing I could be doing it with Arabella instead. But I don’t know what Arabella would think. Maybe she’d hate me.”
Suzie says, “why don’t we just try it a few times? You don’t have to tell Arabella right away; I mean, you’re separated, you have a life of your own. Besides, I’d feel better going out as Sean if I have someone I know with me.”
So over the next few months, they find a few weekends to get together and a few friendly places where people are okay with them being Sean and Barbara.
Well, things move on. Sean ends up getting to know a few women in these places, and before you know it, she and a woman named Catherine get to be more than friends; sometimes it’s Sean and Catherine that are an item, and sometimes it’s Suzie and Catherine. Catherine says she gets the best of both worlds, and eventually she meets David and Penelope and moves in with Suzie.
Meanwhile, Billy likes being Barbara, but flirting with guys at bars and clubs leaves Barbara feeling empty. Whether as Billy or Barbara, she misses Arabella. He’d really like to introduce Arabella to Barbara, but how? “I’m afraid Arabella won’t want anything to do with me if she finds out.”
So Billy and Suzie — and Catherine — come up with a plan.
First, Billy introduces Arabella to Suzie and Catherine. Well, she already knew Suzie, but now she has to get used to Suzi having a woman as a partner. It takes a few months, but Catherine is so nice, she can’t help but be charmed. Then they let slip that Suzie sometimes goes out as Sean. That takes some getting used to, but eventually it doesn’t seem all that weird to Arabella. I mean, if you spend enough time with first graders, you have to get used to a lot.
Then Billy and Suzie tell about how they used to swap clothes when they were very young, and how much they liked it. Well, Arabella is no dummy, and by now, she’s beginning to get a clue as to which way this is going. She’s a bit tired of this beating-around-the-bush, so she asks right out (with a knowing smile), “you wouldn’t by any chance have ever tried it, now that you’re grown up ... would you?”
So of course, everyone laughs, and when they’ve settled down a bit, Arabella asks, “so what do you call yourself when you’re dressed up like Suzie?” And Suzie and Billy tell the whole story.
It takes a while, but Arabella and Billy work things out so that Barbara is a part of their lives, though not all that often, because of jobs and kids. But the most important thing is that Billy begins to open up and gradually show Arabella, and the rest of the family, the parts of himself that he’s had locked away for so long.
In fact, Billy gets up the courage to pursue his old dream of becoming a child psychologist. He takes the classes and does the training and gets certified, and when he’s done, he quits his job and starts practicing with another child psychologist.
And there ends my story, though of course, it’s not the end for Billy and Suzie and their friends and family. You’ll just have to imagine how they go on and grow old. But I think it’s going to be a much happier life for all of them.
And though it’s not part of my story, it wouldn’t surprise me if Billy starts seeing some “gender variant” (as we call them) kids in his practice. I hope so, because kids like that could really use someone who knows from experience what they’re going through. Suzie and Billy sure could have.