The Challenge

Comments

Most of these stories proceed

Most of these stories proceed under the premise that guys are stupid. That they would just let women roll over them. That they wouldn't know what female hormones would do. Apparently all guys would fall under the spell of female clothing. Don't get me wrong I like the suspense of the stories but the suspense is over long before the story is. I hope everyone knows that the actions in most of these stories that the women take are tantamount to assualt. That's right! A REAL CRIME! Not only that but essentially it equates to rape. Taking something that can't be replaced! Using estrogen as a rape drug. The mentality of the women reflected in these stories scares the hell out of me. I hope women do not actually think this way.

Abuse

Maren Sorensen's picture

I very belatedly agree with your comment. Whilst I don’t understand why the girls wanted to feminize their boyfriends, I can give them a pass for being young and clueless. The mother and doctor should be charged with child abuse and locked up. There is nothing either moral or ethical in their actions. I have enjoyed most of Nina’s stories but this made me cringe...

Your offensive comments

Valcyte's picture

Wow Guest Reader, your comments are really out of place on this website. Although I cannot speak for every reader and contributor on this website it should be clear that most of us come here for relaxation and a little bit of fantasy. I found your comments both intrusive and a bit bizarre, as if you have no experience with the issues common to the TG experience. Your initial sentence regarding the premise of "most of these stories" completely misses the point of a transgendered fiction site. I am assuming that you knew what sort of site this is when you wandered on to it late one Friday night and posted in the wee hours of Saturday morning. Unless you are completely ignorant of TG Fiction you will have noticed that much of it addresses the fantasies of its audience. One major theme in all sites is that we identify with the protagonist and that we admire and indeed wish we could experience being a woman. For many of us this is only a dream. Reality and responsibility and plausibility are sacrificed so that we can dream a little. I doubt that most readers and supporters of this site agree with any of your points. Do you honestly think that anything on television or in the movies is plausible? I am not sure what you were looking for Guest Reader when you stumbled on this site but it is clear it is not for you. If you took the time necessary to read a broad cross section of stories, in order to inform yourself, before painting us all with your broad brush, you would find a rainbow of ideas and styles, ranging from obvious fantasy to semi or even autobiographical writing. If you are truly interested in TG Literature I encourage you to spend some more time here or at the sister sites. I am certain that you will find a story or two that meets your exacting criteria. If not then perhaps you could grace this site with a short example of what you deem to be the essential universal TG short story that appeals to all of us and insults none.
Val
P.S. In keeping with Erin's rule #1 and #2 I tried to keep this friendly and give you the benefit of the doubt.
P.P.S. Try "Becoming Christina Chase" by Admiral Krunch.

Guest Reader

ninatg1's picture

I really loved your comment on my story. That was a first effort story that clearly had room for improvement, but I was a little shocked by that previous comment that equated my premise with Rape. I write stories that in a strange way I wish were my reality. I assume many other writers feel the same way. We push the bounds of reality and often do things that frankly are unthinkable. The only person abused in my story is the central character in the fantasy and he/she is ultimately happier for it, and that is why people (not everyone) enjoy reading it. My favorite stories are all ones where the central character is given an initial push down the road to their destiny. Maybe that helps relieve the misguided guilt one might feel following an unconventional path. The story obviously hit a chord with the reader and I do not want to deny that persons feelings. It may have hit to close to home or possible was to similar to other tram that the person felt first hand. Either way, my story was not meant to be cruel or suggestive of abuse and was merely a little TG escapism. I hope to publish another story in the next few days and unfortunately this reader may have an issue with that one as well.